A Critical Assessment of Pattern Comparisons Between POD and Autoencoders in Intraventricular Flows Journal: Journal of L a T e X Templates

E. Lazpita, A. Bell-Navas, J. Garicano-Mena, P. Koumoutsakos, S. Le Clainche · 2025

Read A Critical Assessment of Pattern Comparisons Between POD and Autoencoders in Intraventricular Flows Journal: Journal of L a T e X Templates by E. Lazpita, A. Bell-Navas, J. Garicano-Mena, P. Koumoutsakos, S. Le Clainche (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19376.txt.

Introduction

Eneko Lazpita, Andrés Bell-Navas, Jesús Garicano-Mena, and Petros Koumoutsakos compare two ways of compressing blood flow inside the heart's left ventricle. Flow patterns there track heart health and can warn of decline early. Proper orthogonal decomposition is the classic linear tool; autoencoders are its neural, flexible cousins.

Both were fed flow fields from fluid simulations of the ventricle. At a well-chosen latent size, autoencoder modes came out nearly independent and looked much like the classic modes, capturing the same share of kinetic energy. Adding more latent modes, though, made the neural modes overlap and repeat each other. The study maps where each method earns its keep.

Catalog record

CREATORE. Lazpita, A. Bell-Navas, J. Garicano-Mena, P. Koumoutsakos, S. Le Clainche
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19376

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Critical Assessment of Pattern Comparisons Between POD and Autoencoders in Intraventricular Flows Journal: Journal of L a T e X Templates E. Lazpita, A. Bell-Navas, J. Garicano-Mena, P. Koumoutsakos, S. Le Clainche Abstract Understanding intraventricular hemodynamics requires compact and physically interpretable representations of the underlying flow structures, as characteristic flow patterns are closely associated with cardiovascular conditions and can support the early detection of cardiac deterioration. Conventional visualization of velocity or pressure fields, however, provides limited insight into the coherent mechanisms driving these dynamics. Reduced-order modeling techniques, such as Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) and Autoencoder (AE) architectures, offer powerful alternatives for extracting dominant flow features from complex datasets. This study systematically compares POD with several AE variants (Linear, Nonlinear, Convolutional, and Variational) using left ventricular flow fields obtained from computational fluid dynamics simulations. We show that, for a suitably chosen latent dimension, AEs produce modes that become nearly orthogonal and qualitatively resemble POD modes that capture a given percentage of kinetic energy. As the number of latent modes increases, AE modes progressively lose orthogonality, leading to linear dependence, spatial redundancy, and the appearance of repeated modes with substantial high-frequency content. This degradation reduces interpretability and introduces noise-like components into AE-based reduced-order models, potentially complicating their integration with physics-based formulations or neural-network surrogates. The extent of interpretability loss varies across AE architectures, with nonlinear, convolutional, and variational models exhibiting distinct behaviors in orthogonality preservation and feature localization. Overall, the results indicate that Autoencoders can reproduce POD-like coherent structures under specific latent-space configurations, while highlighting the need for careful mode selection to ensure physically meaningful representations of cardiac flow dynamics. 1 Introduction The accurate analysis of intraventricular flow is fundamental to understand the mechanisms that govern cardiac function. The flow inside the left ventricle (LV) is characterized by strong three-dimensionality, temporal variability, and the presence of large-scale vortical structures that evolve throughout the cardiac cycle. Among these, the incoming blood flow that fills the LV cavity during the diastole, and the posterior ejection through the aortic valve opening during systole play a crucial role, as this facilitates an efficient redirection of the inflow toward the outflow tract, minimizing energy losses and promoting effective ejection during systole. The formation, evolution, and eventual breakdown of this vortex ring are therefore considered key indicators of pumping efficiency and overall ventricular performance [ 28 , 34 ] . Cardiac flow data can be obtained from a wide range of sources, including medical imaging techniques such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) [ 32 ] or computed tomography (CT) [ 36 , 35 ] , experimental approaches such as particle image velocimetry (PIV) [ 20 , 37 ] and in vitro and in silico models [ 22 , 10 ] , and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations that numerically resolve the coupled fluid and structural dynamics of the ventricle [ 23 , 44 ] . Each of these modalities provides complementary information about the hemodynamic environment, typically expressed in terms of velocity fields, pressure distributions, wall shear stress distributions, or vorticity patterns. However, these visualization techniques only offer a qualitative perspective, and often fail to reveal the intrinsic mechanisms driving flow evolution, the characteristic frequencies associated with cardiac dynamics, and the onset of flow instabilities such as vortex breakdown [ 34 , 4 ] . To overcome these limitations, modal decomposition techniques have gained increasing attention. Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) [ 31 ] , Dynamic Mode Decomposition (DMD) [ 38 ] and its robust extension Higher Order DMD (HODMD) [ 29 ] allow a systematic extraction of coherent structures and dominant temporal patterns from complex flow fields. These methods have been successfully applied in various biomedical contexts, including arterial and venous flows [ 19 , 16 ] . However, applications to the heart cavity dynamics remain relatively limited, although some studies are starting to arise. For instance, Ref. [ 42 ] combined the Shake-the-Box algorithm—an advanced Lagrangian particle tracking method—with POD to analyze the three-dimensional and time-resolved nature of intraventricular flow. Similarly, Ref. [ 7 ] employed POD in patient-specific simulations, identifying characteristic flow patterns and quantifying the energy contribution of each mode. Recent research has extended these methods to incorporate temporal dynamics through DMD. Studies such as Ref. [ 8 ] and Ref. [ 33 ] extracted coherent modes associated with specific frequencies and proposed modal biomarkers to characterize cardiac performance and pathology. In a subsequent contribution, Ref. [ 11 ] combined POD and DMD to construct a reduced-order model of left ventricular flow under pathological conditions. These efforts demonstrate the potential of modal decomposition techniques to reveal the underlying physics of intraventricular hemodynamics and to develop compact representations of complex flow phenomena. In parallel, the advent of deep learning has introduced a new paradigm for analyzing high-dimensional biomedical and fluid dynamics data. In fluid mechanics, Convolutional and Autoencoder-based neural networks have been used to extract discriminating features represented in low-dimensional latent spaces, reconstruct flow fields, and predict their temporal evolution with remarkable accuracy [ 13 ] . We have used POD/DMD as data-driven approaches alternative to traditional reduced-order models, enabling the identification of nonlinear dynamics and subtle spatial correlations that linear methods may overlook. In the biomedical domain, deep learning has shown great promise for the analysis of cardiac imaging and hemodynamic data. For example, Ref. [ 14 ] applied HODMD to analyze echocardiography imaging and identify features associated with heart diseases. The resulting dynamic descriptors were subsequently integrated with deep learning frameworks for automatic heart disease recognition, achieving significantly higher accuracy than conventional image-based models [ 5 ] . These developments highlight the potential of combining modal decomposition and deep learning to uncover physiologically meaningful flow patterns and to enhance diagnostic and predictive tools in cardiovascular research. Building upon these advances, the present work explores data-driven methodologies for extracting, analyzing, and interpreting coherent flow structures in intraventricular CFD data. By bridging physics-based modal decomposition techniques with deep learning approaches, this study aims to deepen the understanding of the dynamic mechanisms governing left ventricular flow and to establish a foundation for efficient, interpretable, and predictive models of cardiac hemodynamics. In particular, this work addresses a gap in the current literature regarding the interpretability of Autoencoder-based modes when applied to cardiac flow fields. While Autoencoders have demonstrated remarkable capabilities for nonlinear dimensionality reduction, their ability to generate modal structures comparable to those produced by POD remains insufficiently understood. Here, we investigate under which conditions AE latent representations yield coherent structures that qualitatively resemble POD modes, and how this relationship evolves as the number of latent dimensions increases. A key aspect of this analysis is the observation that AE modes may lose orthogonality when the latent space grows, leading to spatial redundancy, mode repetition, and the appearance of high-frequency content that behaves similarly to noise. Such effects can obscure the underlying flow physics and raise important questions about the reliability of AE-based reduced-order models. Understanding these behaviors is essential for the future development of physics-aware data-driven models. Non-orthogonal and redundant AE modes can hinder the enforcement of physical constraints, limit the interpretability of learned representations, and introduce instability when coupling the reduced-order model with neural-network surrogates or hybrid physics–ML frameworks. By clarifying the circumstances under which AE

Read the complete text