Limitations of Entangled Two-Photon Absorption detection

R. Pollmann, F. Roeder, C. Silberhorn, B. Brecht · 2025

Read Limitations of Entangled Two-Photon Absorption detection by R. Pollmann, F. Roeder, C. Silberhorn, B. Brecht (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19261.txt.

Introduction

René Pollmann, Franz Roeder, Christine Silberhorn, and Benjamin Brecht set a hard limit test for a delicate light-matter effect. Entangled two-photon absorption promises imaging and sensing gains, yet claimed sightings are hard to judge across setups. Their method scores any experiment's sensitivity in one shared unit.

Every signal and noise source in the measurement enters the model. The result is a single number, in Göppert-Mayer units, that says whether the effect can be seen at all under stated conditions. Different designs become directly comparable. Builders can also test each change to an apparatus on paper first, and follow the clearest path to a detectable signal.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Pollmann, F. Roeder, C. Silberhorn, B. Brecht
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19261

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Limitations of Entangled Two-Photon Absorption detection R. Pollmann, F. Roeder, C. Silberhorn, B. Brecht Abstract We introduce a method for determining the sensitivity of any given Entangled Two-Photon Absorption (ETPA) measurement. By modeling all signal and noise contributions to the measurement, we derive a single numerical value that describes the sensitivity of the ETPA measurement in Göppert-Mayer units. This allows us to directly compare vastly different experimental approaches and, determine whether ETPA will be detectable under the given conditions. Therefore, we can quantify the effect of any change to a given experimental apparatus and identify the ideal optimization pathway. I Introduction Two-photon absorption (TPA) is a valuable tool for a variety of spectroscopy and imaging schemes, creating contrast and improving resolution via nonlinear processes 11 . However, since any TPA process requires two photons to interact simultaneously with one absorber, the overall interaction cross-sections are prohibitively small. This limitation is typically overcome by vastly increasing the photon flux with high-power pulsed lasers or high finesse cavities. Molecular TPA requires the simultaneous arrival of two photons and sets strict limits on their combined energy. Thus, time-frequency entangled photon pairs promise a significant advantage in absorption yield. Furthermore, it has been proposed, that the quantum correlations embedded in the photo pair provide access to molecular information inaccessible with classical light sources 19 ; 11 . However, these correlations could just as well decrease the TPA yields in an unfortunate experimental configuration 4 ; 16 . To measure the effect of quantum correlations on TPA yields, the high power laser is replaced by a parametric down conversion (PDC) source that produces time-frequency entangled photon pairs. However, the increase in absorption efficiency is now counteracted by the decrease in power driving the TPA. Therefore, observing molecular TPA driven by entangled pairs (ETPA) in the lab is very challenging, primarily due to the prohibitively low overall ETPA rate 20 ; 7 ; 9 ; 14 ; 13 ; 21 ; 12 ; 5 ; 6 . There are two approaches to detecting molecular absorption: Measuring attenuation of the transmitted field and measuring fluorescence emitted by the absorber. In this work, we focus on direct fluorescence detection as described in 20 ; 7 ; 9 ; 14 ; 13 . However, our approach can also be applied to the transmission approach, as presented in 5 ; 12 ; 22 ; 23 . Although a fluorescence event is always tied to a molecule reaching an excited state, any information about the excitation pathway is lost. Here, we will consider three excitation pathways: ETPA, TPA and single-photon or hot band absorption (HBA) 10 . Therefore, detecting only a fluorescence signal when exciting with PDC light is insufficient for measuring ETPA. Furthermore, technical imperfections, most notably detector dark counts, significantly contribute to any recorded signal. Since the overall goal is to investigate the effect of the quantum correlations on the absorption yield, only the strength of the quantum correlations must be varied in the experiment, while all other parameters have to remain constant. This modulation can be achieved by either separating the correlated photons 12 ; 21 ; 1 or by introducing losses 20 ; 7 ; 9 ; 14 ; 13 ; 5 . These different methods and the dependence of the ETPA signature on all properties of the excitation beam make comparisons between published (null-) results nontrivial. Therefore, we developed a unifying framework that allows us to directly compare different ETPA measurements. By treating the absorber as a black box and focusing on the measurement system, we developed an analytical model that enables us to predict whether observations are possible by calculating the expected signal and noise levels for any given set of experimental parameters. Furthermore, we can directly calculate the impact of each experimental parameter on the final sensitivity, thus providing a clear path for improvement of any given ETPA experiment. II Model Our model is based on calculating signal-to-noise ratios, analogous to the detection threshold derived in 23 . By modeling both the signal and the noise, and then comparing them, we obtain a lower bound for the detectable ETPA strength in a given experimental configuration. In the experiment, a total of N_{rec} potential ETPA fluorescence events will be recorded. As previously mentioned, this will be the sum of all possible excitation pathways \displaystyle N_{rec}=N_{ent}+N_{c}+N_{h}+N_{dark}, (1) the desired ETPA contribution N_{ent} , an unavoidable classical TPA contribution N_{c} caused by two uncorrelated photons getting absorbed, as well as direct single-photo absorption N_{h} 10 . In the experiment the recorded number of events N_{rec} will also include a non-fluorescence contribution consisting of detector dark counts N_{dark} . Thus, in any ETPA experiment, the amount of correlated pairs interacting with the absorber must be varied while keeping the total number of photons at the absorber - and therefore the resulting non ETPA contribution - constant. This results in at least two data points: one with maximal correlations of the light field and the largest total fluorescence yield, from now on called signal ( S ) and one background ( B ) measurement recorded with minimal (spoiled) correlations. An ETPA signature can then be detected if the difference between the two data points is greater than the measurement uncertainty: \displaystyle S-B\geq u(S)+u(B) (2) with u(S) ( u(B) ) being the measurement uncertainty of S\ (B) . Since we assume Poissonian statistics for all measured quantities: \displaystyle u(S)=n_{\sigma}\sqrt{S}\text{ and }u(B)=n_{\sigma}\sqrt{B}. (3) with the n_{\sigma} accuracy. Given a sufficient set of experimental parameters, all contributions to S and B are known. Therefore, equation ( 2 ) allows us to make quantitative predictions about the detectability of an ETPA signature. II.1 Rate estimations To calculate the TPA rates the pair \phi_{pair} and single-photon \phi_{s,i} fluxes at the absorber are needed. Therefore, we assume an ideal (non-degenerate) PDC source that produces N_{P} correlated photon pairs per pump pulse. Since any experiment will involve optical losses between the source and the absorber, which will break the pair correlations, we describe these losses using the transmission coefficients \eta_{s,i} of signal and idler beams respectively. Using the photon creation \hat{a}^{\dagger}_{s,i} and annihilation operators \hat{a}_{s,i} for the signal and idler beam at the sample position, the single-photo flux can be written as \displaystyle\phi_{s,i}=\frac{\expectationvalue{\hat{a}^\dagger_{s,i} \hat{a}_{s,i}}}{A_{s,i}T_{s,i}}=\frac{\eta_{s,i}N_{P}}{A_{s,i}T_{s,i}}, (4) with A_{s,i} and T_{s,i} denoting the cross-sectional area and temporal duration of the wave packets at the sample position. As previously mentioned, the absorber can be excited by two uncorrelated photons 9 . This classical TPA rate can be written as: \displaystyle f_{c}=\sigma_{c}N_{t}\phi_{s}\phi_{i}=\epsilon_{c}\eta_{s}\eta_{i}N_{P}^{2}. (5) with the number of illuminated molecules N_{t} , and the classical two-photon absorption coefficient \displaystyle\epsilon_{c}=\frac{N_{t}\sigma_{c}}{A^{2}T^{2}}, (6) assuming both beams have the same spatial A_{s}=A_{i}=A and temporal T_{s}=T_{i}=T shape, ensuring maximal overlap and therefore maximising the TPA yield. In PDC, the photon pair is defined by the properties of the pump beam and phase patching of the nonlinear medium, resulting in spatial, spectral, and temporal correlations between the signal and idler photons. We model these quantum correlations by introducing the entanglement area A_{e} and the entanglement time T_{e} . These represent the conditioned spatial and temporal distributions of the idler photon, upon the detection of the signal photon 14 ; 2 ; 15 ; 18 ; 17 .

Read the complete text