A Smoluchowski equation for a sheared suspension of frictionally interacting rods
Chris Quiñones, Peter D. Olmsted · 2025
Read A Smoluchowski equation for a sheared suspension of frictionally interacting rods by Chris Quiñones, Peter D. Olmsted (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19149.txt.
Introduction
Genevieve Quiñones and Peter Olmsted derive equations for a dense suspension of rods under shear flow. Think of short fibers packed tightly and dragged sideways, rubbing as they turn. Their tool is Onsager's variational method, in the form set out by Doi for liquid crystals.
Two friction kinds get separate treatment: dry solid friction, and lubricated friction that grows with sliding speed. A mean-field step yields a dissipation function for each, and from a single Rayleighian they obtain both a Smoluchowski equation for rod directions and the stress tensor. The results appear as corrections to Doi's classic model, plus a new contact-count formula.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chris Quiñones, Peter D. Olmsted |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19149
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Smoluchowski equation for a sheared suspension of frictionally interacting rods Chris Quiñones, Peter D. Olmsted Abstract In this work we develop constitutive equations for a dense, sheared suspension of frictionally interacting rods by applying Onsager’s variational method as formulated by Doi. We treat both solid friction, of the Amontons-Coulomb form; and lubricated friction, which scales with relative tangential velocity at the contact point. Dissipation functions in terms of the rod angular velocity are derived via a mean field approach for each form of friction, and from these, a Rayleighian for dense suspensions of rigid rods under shear constructed. Derivatives of this Rayleighian with respect to rod angular velocity and velocity gradient give a Smoluchowski equation and stress tensor, respectively. We show that these are representable as perturbations to Doi’s model for a sheared liquid crystal. We also suggest a form for the average number of contacts between rods as a function of volume fraction, aspect ratio, and nematic order parameter, generalizing Philipse’s random contact equation for disordered packings. I Introduction The effects of flow on suspensions of rigid rod-like particles has been studied for more than a century Björkman 2008 . Rods are typically considered to interact through a combination of hydrodynamic forces and potential energies such as electrostatics van der Waals interactions Odijk 1977 ; Dhont and Briels 2003 . It has been suggested that particles in dense suspensions under shear come into solid contact, breaking lubrication films Fernandez et al. 2013 ; Lootens et al. 2005 to then interact through frictional forces. The presence of friction in rods undergoing shear flow prompts several questions analogous to those studied for spheres: how does friction affect the orientational state and the stress? Can these interactions lead to discontinuous shear thickening and the onset of jamming, in the fashion of the Wyart and Cates Wyart and Cates 2014 model? How many contacts are there per rod in a flowing system, compared to that found in a disordered packing Philipse 1996 , and how does this contact number depend on the degree of orientational order? These questions motivate us to develop a theoretical description of a suspension of rigid rods under flow, to explicitly account for contacts between rods. The dilute and semi-dilute regimes of suspensions of rigid rods are characterized by a volume fraction \phi and aspect ratio L/D satisfying \displaystyle\phi\frac{L^{2}}{D^{2}} \displaystyle\ll 1 (dilute) (I.1a) \displaystyle\frac{D}{L}\ll\phi\frac{L}{D} \displaystyle<1 (semi-dilute), (I.1b) where D is the rod diameter and L rod length. Various theories have successfully modeled orientational dynamics under flow for these regimes ( Jeffery 1923 , Advani and Tucker 1987 , Doi 1981 ). The dimensionless Peclet number Pe weighs the effects of hydrodynamic and Brownian forces in rod dynamics, \text{Pe}\equiv\dot{\gamma}/D_{r} , where \dot{\gamma} is the rate of shear and D_{r} the rotational diffusion constant. High Pe is often referred to as “non-Brownian”. Many studies begin with Jeffery’s Jeffery 1923 equation of motion \dot{\bm{u}}_{\text{Jeffery}} for the rotation of a single ellipsoid suspended in a Newtonian fluid in a flow field, and insert this into the continuity equation for the probability distribution of rod orientations ( II.7 ) to develop a Smoluchowski equation that accounts for the effect of rod-rod interaction. Doi Doi 1981 addressed the general Pe case, and used an expression for the excluded volume of rods as a function of volume fraction, aspect ratio, and nematic order S to calculate a dynamical equation for the \mathbf{Q} tensor, which is defined as an orientational average of particle vectors: \begin{split}Q_{\alpha\beta}&=\left\langle\hat{u}_{\alpha}\hat{u}_{\beta}-\frac{\delta_{\alpha\beta}}{3}\right\rangle\\ &=S\left(\hat{n}\hat{n}-\frac{\delta_{\alpha\beta}}{3}\right).\end{split} (I.2) Here, \hat{\bm{u}} refers to the orientation of a single particle, \hat{\bm{n}} is the director, and the second line follows for a uniaxial \mathbf{Q} . Advani and Tucker 1987 applied this method to the the non-Brownian case and including a phenomenological term proportional to the rotary diffusivity to find a dynamical equation for \mathbf{Q} similar to Doi’s. Folgar and Tucker 1984 suggested a similar form, with a rotary diffusion constant that depended on the magnitude of the symmetric velocity gradient tensor, |\dot{\gamma}| . Phan-Thien and Graham 1991 proposed a constitutive equation for spatially homogeneous fiber suspensions that expanded Ericksen’s transversely isotropic fluid model Ericksen 1960 to the semi-dilute regime and successfully modeled specific viscosity varying as volume fraction cubed. Dinh and Armstrong 1984 presented a constitutive model for the high Peclet regime that included a contribution to the stress from a given orientational state; this model was used by Tseng 2021 to calculate viscosity overshoots in fiber filled polymer melts under shear. In the concentrated regime, \phi\frac{L}{D}>1 (I.3) and rod-rod interactions dominate Doi and Edwards 1978 . For solutions with \phi L/D\gtrsim 3 , the isotropic-nematic transition occurs in Brownian suspensions Doi 2011 , leading to non-zero orientational order S>0 (see Fig. 1 ). Some theories Advani and Tucker 1987 ; Doi 1981 ; Dinh and Armstrong 1984 that successfully model the semi-dilute regime and capture orientational dynamics such as flow alignment, tumbling, and kayaking Larson and Ottinger 1991 , can extend to larger \phi L/D and also model orientational properties of dense, sheared rods. However, they can’t explain certain rheological behaviors observed in concentrated solutions of rodlike particles. These behaviors include discontinuous shear thickening (DST), where the viscosity discontinuously jumps in value with an increase in shear rate, shear jamming, a state induced in a dense system which at rest is below the jamming concentration \phi_{j} Pan et al. 2023 , ( James et al. 2019 , Tapia et al. 2017 ) and vorticity tilting ( Rathee et al. 2020 ), the observed tilt of the director into the voriticty direction (out of the shear plane) in sheared rod suspensions. Pipes et al. 1994 considered a “hyperconcentrated” regime, with highly aligned fibers of aspect ratio >100 , but only predicted shear thinning and did not address any other rheological effects. The failure of these models is due in part to their implicit assumptions, such as uncorrelated rod orientations, breaking down due to increased rod interactions at higher volume fraction and aspect ratio; but also due to the neglect of frictional inter-particle contacts Singh 2023 . Recent experimental and computational work has suggested that such unexplained rheological behaviors are indeed due to frictional contacts ( Seto et al. 2013 , Royer et al. 2016 ). For suspensions of spheres, Wyart and Cates Wyart and Cates 2014 established a theory that relates the fraction of frictional contacts to DST and shear jamming. In concentrated suspensions of large aspect ratio rods, a given rod may have many contacts and remain below the Maxwell threshold Maxwell 1864 , so frictional contacts may play an even larger role in the pre-jam dynamics of rods than in spheres. Nematic order S is also expected to affect the average number of contacts per particle, which is larger for a greater average amount of excluded volume per interacting pair Philipse 1996 . A particle less aligned with its neighbors (i.e, lower S ) has a larger average excluded volume and so more contacts. Thus nematic order, a variable not present in spherical particle suspensions, is relevant to the dynamics of dense rod suspensions and must also be accounted for. Frictional contacts have been included for rods by Sandstrom and Tucker 1993 and Toll and Månson 1994 in