A solution to the problem of the existence of a dense plastic subset X โІ โ„ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐”  |X|<\mathfrak{c}

Wojciech Bielas ยท 2025

Read A solution to the problem of the existence of a dense plastic subset X โІ โ„ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐”  |X|<\mathfrak{c} by Wojciech Bielas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18948.txt.

Introduction

Wojciech Bielas answers a question in set-theoretic topology from a recent arXiv paper, its Problem 1. Can the real line contain a dense plastic subset smaller than the continuum? His short paper, posted to arXiv in December 2025, works under one assumption: the continuum is at least omega-2. Under it, he constructs exactly such a set. The set X is dense and plastic, and its cardinality is strictly less than c. The example settles the existence problem in the affirmative.

Catalog record

CREATORWojciech Bielas
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE10 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18948

Browse the full library ยท About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A solution to the problem of the existence of a dense plastic subset X โІ โ„ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐”  |X|<\mathfrak{c}
Wojciech Bielas

Abstract
. Under the assumption ๐”  โฉพ ฯ‰ 2 \mathfrak{c}\geqslant\omega_{2} , we give an example of a dense plastic subset X โІ โ„ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐”  |X|<\mathfrak{c} . This answers Problem 1 of [ 1 ] .



2020 Mathematics Subject Classification
Primary 54E40; Secondary 03E50

1.
Introduction

For a metric space
(X,d)
, we say that
f\colon X\to X
is
non-expansive
if
d(f(x),f(y))\leqslant d(x,y)
for all
x,y\in X
.
A metric space
X
is
plastic
if its every non-expansive bijection

f\colon X\to X
is an isometry.
A subset
Y
of a metric space is
plastic
if it is plastic as a subspace.

In
[
1
]
Authors have proved, among others, that every countable dense subspace of a normed space is not plastic.
This implies that, under the Continuum Hypothesis, every dense subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|<\mathfrak{c}
is not plastic.
In Problem 1 of
[
1
]
, Authors ask whether the Continuum Hypothesis is a necessary assumption.
Under the assumption
\mathfrak{c}\geqslant\omega_{2}
, we construct a dense plastic subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|=\omega_{1}
.
The subset
X
has a stronger property: the identity map is its only non-expansive bijection.

2.
The construction

Let
\mathcal{R}=\{[a_{n},b_{n}]\colon n<\omega\}
be a pairwise disjoint family of intervals of
\mathbb{R}
such that for every
m,n<\omega
:

(i)

a_{n},b_{n}\in\mathbb{Q}
,

(ii)

2(b_{n+1}-a_{n+1})<b_{n}-a_{n}
,

(iii)

if
b_{m}<a_{n}
, then
a_{n}-b_{m}>b_{0}-a_{0}
,

(iv)

a_{0}<a_{1}
,

(v)

for every
x\in\mathbb{R}
there exist
k
and
l
such that
b_{k}<x<a_{l}
.

Condition (ii) says that the distance between different intervals of
\mathcal{R}
is at least
b_{0}-a_{0}
.
It follows that for each
n
there exists a unique
m
such that:

โ€ข

for every
x\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
and
y\in[a_{m},b_{m}]
we have
x<y
,

โ€ข

(b_{n},a_{m})\cap\bigcup\mathcal{R}=\emptyset
.

In that case let
A_{n}\subseteq(b_{n},a_{m})
be such that
|A_{n}\cap U|=\omega_{1}
for every non-empty open
U\subseteq(b_{n},a_{m})
.
We define

X=\bigcup_{n<\omega}((\mathbb{Q}\cap[a_{n},b_{n}])\cup A_{n}).

3.
Basic properties of the set
X

For the rest of this section we fix a non-expansive bijection
f\colon X\to X
and define for every
n<\omega
:

\delta_{n}=b_{n}-a_{n},\quad a^{\prime}_{n}=a_{n}+\delta_{n+1},\quad b^{\prime}_{n}=b_{n}-\delta_{n+1}.

Let us recall that
x\in\mathbb{R}
is a
condensation
point of a subset
A\subseteq\mathbb{R}
if
|A\cap U|\geqslant\omega_{1}
for every open neighborhood
U
of
x
.
Thus, if
x
is a condensation point of
X
, then
f(x)
is also a condensation point of
X
.
From now on, when we say a condensation point, we will mean a condensation point of
X
.
Observe that for every
n<\omega
:

โ€ข

a_{n}
and
b_{n}
are condensation points,

โ€ข

there is no condensation point
x
such that
|x-a^{\prime}_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
or
|x-b^{\prime}_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
,

โ€ข

neither
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
nor
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})
is a condensation point.

Lemma 1
.

For every
n<\omega
, if
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}],

then

\{f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\}=\{b^{\prime}_{n},a^{\prime}_{n}\}.

Proof.

Points
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
and
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})
belong to the interval
[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
of length
b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}
, hence

|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}.

Since
f
is non-expansive,

b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}=|a^{\prime}_{n}-b^{\prime}_{n}|\leqslant|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})|.

Thus the distance between points
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
and
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})
equals
b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}
but the interval
[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
contains only one such pair:
\{a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}\}
.
โˆŽ

Lemma 2
.

For every
n<\omega
, if
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=a^{\prime}_{n}
, then
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
and
f(b_{n})=b_{n}
, but if

f(a^{\prime}_{n})=b^{\prime}_{n}
, then
f(a_{n})=b_{n}
and
f(b_{n})=a_{n}
.

Proof.

Assume
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=a^{\prime}_{n}
.
We have
|a_{n}-a^{\prime}_{n}|=\delta_{n+1}
, hence
|f(a_{n})-f(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\delta_{n+1}
.
Since
a_{n}
is a condensation point, so is
f(a_{n})
, but there is only one condensation point
x
such that
|x-a^{\prime}_{n}|\leqslant\delta_{n+1}
, namely,
x=a_{n}
.
Thus
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
.
From
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=a^{\prime}_{n}
it follows that
f(b^{\prime}_{n})=b^{\prime}_{n}
and we show similarly that
f(b_{n})=b_{n}
.

The case
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=b^{\prime}_{n}
is analogous.
โˆŽ

Lemma 3
.

For every
n<\omega
, if
\{f(a_{n}),f(b_{n})\}=\{a_{n},b_{n}\}
, then

f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.

Proof.

Since
\{f(a_{n}),f(b_{n})\}=\{a_{n},b_{n}\}
, for any
t\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, the system of inequalities

(*)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|f(a_{n})-x|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|,\\
|f(b_{n})-x|&\leqslant&|b_{n}-t|\\
\end{array}\right.

has a unique solution, which is
t
, if
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
, and
x=a_{n}+b_{n}-t
, if
f(a_{n})=b_{n}
.
On the other hand, since
f
is non-expansive, we have

(**)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|f(a_{n})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|,\\
|f(b_{n})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|b_{n}-t|.\\
\end{array}\right.

Thus
f(t)
is the only solution of
(*)
, hence
f(t)=t
for all
t\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, if
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
, or
f(t)=a_{n}+b_{n}-t
for all
t\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, if
f(a_{n})=b_{n}
.
โˆŽ

Lemma 4
.

For every
n<\omega
,

f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.

Proof.

Fix
n
and assume that the hypothesis holds for
k<n
.
We will show that

f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}].

Suppose that
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\notin[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
.
By the inductive assumption,

f[[a_{k},b_{k}]\cap X]=[a_{k},b_{k}]\cap X

for
k<n
.
Since
f(f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}))=a^{\prime}_{n}\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, we have
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\notin\bigcup_{k<n}[a_{k},b_{k}]
.
Thus either
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in X\setminus\bigcup_{k<\omega}[a_{k},b_{k}]
, which means that
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
is a condensation point and this is a contradiction, or
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in[a_{m},b_{m}]\cap X
for some
m\geqslant n
.
Since
a_{m}
is a condensation point, so is
f(a_{m})
.
Now, if
m=n
, then
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\notin[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
implies that

f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in[a_{n},a^{\prime}_{n})\cup(b^{\prime}_{n},b_{n}],

which means that

\min\{|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-a_{n}|,|b_{n}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\}<\delta_{n+1}.

If
|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-a_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
, then

|f(a_{n})-a^{\prime}_{n}|=|f(a_{n})-f(f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}))|\leqslant|a_{n}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|<\delta_{n+1},

but there is no condensation point
x
such that
|x-a^{\prime}_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
; a contradiction.
The case
|b_{n}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|<\delta_{n+1}
is analogous.
If
m>n
, then

\textstyle\min\{|a_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|,|b_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\}\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}.

If
|a_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}
, then

\textstyle|f(a_{m})-a^{\prime}_{n}|=|f(a_{m})-f(f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}))|\leqslant|a_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}<\delta_{n+1};

a contradiction.
The case
|b_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}
is analogous.
Finally,
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
and the fact that
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
is proved similarly.

From Lemma
1
it follows that
\{f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\}=\{a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}\}
.
By Lemma
2
, we have
\{f(a_{n}),f(b_{n})\}=\{a_{n},b_{n}\}
.
Then, by Lemma
3
,
f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.
โˆŽ

4.
The main theorem

Theorem 5
.

The set
X
is plastic.

Proof.

Fix a bijection
f\colon X\to X
which is non-expansive.
By Lemma
4
, for every
n<\omega
the restriction
f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.
If
f(b_{0})=a_{0}
and
f(b_{1})=a_{1}
, then

|f(b_{1})-f(b_{0})|=a_{1}-a_{0}=(a_{1}-b_{0})+(b_{0}-a_{0})>(a_{1}-b_{0})+(b_{1}-a_{1})=b_{1}-b_{0};

a contradiction.
If
f(b_{0})=a_{0}
and
f(b_{1})=b_{1}
, then

|f(b_{1})-f(b_{0})|=b_{1}-a_{0}>b_{1}-b_{0};

a contradiction.
Thus
f(b_{0})=b_{0}
, hence
f(a_{0})=a_{0}
.
Fix
1\leqslant n<\omega
and assume that
f(a_{k})=a_{k}
and
f(b_{k})=b_{k}
for
k<n
.
Suppose that
f(b_{n+1})=a_{n+1}
.
If
a_{n}<a_{n+1}
, then
b_{n}<a_{n+1}
and

b_{n+1}-b_{n}=f(a_{n+1})-f(b_{n})\leqslant a_{n+1}-b_{n}<b_{n+1}-b_{n};

a contradiction.
If
a_{n+1}<a_{n}
, then
b_{n+1}<a_{n}
and

a_{n}-a_{n+1}=f(a_{n})-f(b_{n+1})\leqslant a_{n}-b_{n+1}<a_{n+1}-a_{n};

a contradiction.
Thus
f(b_{n+1})=b_{n+1}
, hence
f(a_{n+1})=a_{n+1}
.
By induction,
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
and
f(b_{n})=b_{n}
for every
n<\omega
.

Fix
t\in X
.
There exist
m
and
n
such that
a_{m}<t<a_{n}
.
Once again,
t
is the only solution of the system of inequalities

(***)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|a_{m}-x|&\leqslant&|a_{m}-t|,\\
|a_{n}-x|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|,\\
\end{array}\right.

On the other hand, since
f
is non-expansive, we have

(**)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|f(a_{m})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|a_{m}-t|,\\
|f(a_{n})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|.\\
\end{array}\right.

Since
f(a_{m})=a_{m}
and
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
, the value
f(t)
is the only solution of
(***)
, hence
f(t)=t
.
โˆŽ

Theorem 6
.

The Continuum Hypothesis is equivalent to the non-existence of a plastic dense subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|<\mathfrak{c}
.

Proof.

The Continuum Hypothesis and Corollary 2 from
[
1
]
imply that there is no plastic dense subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|<\mathfrak{c}
.

If we assume that
\mathfrak{c}\geqslant\omega_{2}
, then the set
X
is plastic, dense and is of cardinality
\omega_{1}<\mathfrak{c}
.

Read the complete text