A solution to the problem of the existence of a dense plastic subset X โ โ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐ |X|<\mathfrak{c}
Wojciech Bielas ยท 2025
Read A solution to the problem of the existence of a dense plastic subset X โ โ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐ |X|<\mathfrak{c} by Wojciech Bielas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18948.txt.
Introduction
Wojciech Bielas answers a question in set-theoretic topology from a recent arXiv paper, its Problem 1. Can the real line contain a dense plastic subset smaller than the continuum? His short paper, posted to arXiv in December 2025, works under one assumption: the continuum is at least omega-2. Under it, he constructs exactly such a set. The set X is dense and plastic, and its cardinality is strictly less than c. The example settles the existence problem in the affirmative.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wojciech Bielas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 10 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18948
Browse the full library ยท About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A solution to the problem of the existence of a dense plastic subset X โ โ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐ |X|<\mathfrak{c}
Wojciech Bielas
Abstract
. Under the assumption ๐ โฉพ ฯ 2 \mathfrak{c}\geqslant\omega_{2} , we give an example of a dense plastic subset X โ โ X\subseteq\mathbb{R} of cardinality | X | < ๐ |X|<\mathfrak{c} . This answers Problem 1 of [ 1 ] .
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification
Primary 54E40; Secondary 03E50
1.
Introduction
For a metric space
(X,d)
, we say that
f\colon X\to X
is
non-expansive
if
d(f(x),f(y))\leqslant d(x,y)
for all
x,y\in X
.
A metric space
X
is
plastic
if its every non-expansive bijection
f\colon X\to X
is an isometry.
A subset
Y
of a metric space is
plastic
if it is plastic as a subspace.
In
[
1
]
Authors have proved, among others, that every countable dense subspace of a normed space is not plastic.
This implies that, under the Continuum Hypothesis, every dense subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|<\mathfrak{c}
is not plastic.
In Problem 1 of
[
1
]
, Authors ask whether the Continuum Hypothesis is a necessary assumption.
Under the assumption
\mathfrak{c}\geqslant\omega_{2}
, we construct a dense plastic subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|=\omega_{1}
.
The subset
X
has a stronger property: the identity map is its only non-expansive bijection.
2.
The construction
Let
\mathcal{R}=\{[a_{n},b_{n}]\colon n<\omega\}
be a pairwise disjoint family of intervals of
\mathbb{R}
such that for every
m,n<\omega
:
(i)
a_{n},b_{n}\in\mathbb{Q}
,
(ii)
2(b_{n+1}-a_{n+1})<b_{n}-a_{n}
,
(iii)
if
b_{m}<a_{n}
, then
a_{n}-b_{m}>b_{0}-a_{0}
,
(iv)
a_{0}<a_{1}
,
(v)
for every
x\in\mathbb{R}
there exist
k
and
l
such that
b_{k}<x<a_{l}
.
Condition (ii) says that the distance between different intervals of
\mathcal{R}
is at least
b_{0}-a_{0}
.
It follows that for each
n
there exists a unique
m
such that:
โข
for every
x\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
and
y\in[a_{m},b_{m}]
we have
x<y
,
โข
(b_{n},a_{m})\cap\bigcup\mathcal{R}=\emptyset
.
In that case let
A_{n}\subseteq(b_{n},a_{m})
be such that
|A_{n}\cap U|=\omega_{1}
for every non-empty open
U\subseteq(b_{n},a_{m})
.
We define
X=\bigcup_{n<\omega}((\mathbb{Q}\cap[a_{n},b_{n}])\cup A_{n}).
3.
Basic properties of the set
X
For the rest of this section we fix a non-expansive bijection
f\colon X\to X
and define for every
n<\omega
:
\delta_{n}=b_{n}-a_{n},\quad a^{\prime}_{n}=a_{n}+\delta_{n+1},\quad b^{\prime}_{n}=b_{n}-\delta_{n+1}.
Let us recall that
x\in\mathbb{R}
is a
condensation
point of a subset
A\subseteq\mathbb{R}
if
|A\cap U|\geqslant\omega_{1}
for every open neighborhood
U
of
x
.
Thus, if
x
is a condensation point of
X
, then
f(x)
is also a condensation point of
X
.
From now on, when we say a condensation point, we will mean a condensation point of
X
.
Observe that for every
n<\omega
:
โข
a_{n}
and
b_{n}
are condensation points,
โข
there is no condensation point
x
such that
|x-a^{\prime}_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
or
|x-b^{\prime}_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
,
โข
neither
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
nor
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})
is a condensation point.
Lemma 1
.
For every
n<\omega
, if
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}],
then
\{f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\}=\{b^{\prime}_{n},a^{\prime}_{n}\}.
Proof.
Points
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
and
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})
belong to the interval
[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
of length
b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}
, hence
|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}.
Since
f
is non-expansive,
b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}=|a^{\prime}_{n}-b^{\prime}_{n}|\leqslant|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})|.
Thus the distance between points
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
and
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})
equals
b_{n}-a_{n}-2\delta_{n+1}
but the interval
[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
contains only one such pair:
\{a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}\}
.
โ
Lemma 2
.
For every
n<\omega
, if
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=a^{\prime}_{n}
, then
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
and
f(b_{n})=b_{n}
, but if
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=b^{\prime}_{n}
, then
f(a_{n})=b_{n}
and
f(b_{n})=a_{n}
.
Proof.
Assume
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=a^{\prime}_{n}
.
We have
|a_{n}-a^{\prime}_{n}|=\delta_{n+1}
, hence
|f(a_{n})-f(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\delta_{n+1}
.
Since
a_{n}
is a condensation point, so is
f(a_{n})
, but there is only one condensation point
x
such that
|x-a^{\prime}_{n}|\leqslant\delta_{n+1}
, namely,
x=a_{n}
.
Thus
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
.
From
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=a^{\prime}_{n}
it follows that
f(b^{\prime}_{n})=b^{\prime}_{n}
and we show similarly that
f(b_{n})=b_{n}
.
The case
f(a^{\prime}_{n})=b^{\prime}_{n}
is analogous.
โ
Lemma 3
.
For every
n<\omega
, if
\{f(a_{n}),f(b_{n})\}=\{a_{n},b_{n}\}
, then
f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.
Proof.
Since
\{f(a_{n}),f(b_{n})\}=\{a_{n},b_{n}\}
, for any
t\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, the system of inequalities
(*)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|f(a_{n})-x|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|,\\
|f(b_{n})-x|&\leqslant&|b_{n}-t|\\
\end{array}\right.
has a unique solution, which is
t
, if
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
, and
x=a_{n}+b_{n}-t
, if
f(a_{n})=b_{n}
.
On the other hand, since
f
is non-expansive, we have
(**)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|f(a_{n})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|,\\
|f(b_{n})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|b_{n}-t|.\\
\end{array}\right.
Thus
f(t)
is the only solution of
(*)
, hence
f(t)=t
for all
t\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, if
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
, or
f(t)=a_{n}+b_{n}-t
for all
t\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, if
f(a_{n})=b_{n}
.
โ
Lemma 4
.
For every
n<\omega
,
f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.
Proof.
Fix
n
and assume that the hypothesis holds for
k<n
.
We will show that
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}].
Suppose that
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\notin[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
.
By the inductive assumption,
f[[a_{k},b_{k}]\cap X]=[a_{k},b_{k}]\cap X
for
k<n
.
Since
f(f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}))=a^{\prime}_{n}\in[a_{n},b_{n}]
, we have
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\notin\bigcup_{k<n}[a_{k},b_{k}]
.
Thus either
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in X\setminus\bigcup_{k<\omega}[a_{k},b_{k}]
, which means that
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})
is a condensation point and this is a contradiction, or
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in[a_{m},b_{m}]\cap X
for some
m\geqslant n
.
Since
a_{m}
is a condensation point, so is
f(a_{m})
.
Now, if
m=n
, then
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\notin[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
implies that
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in[a_{n},a^{\prime}_{n})\cup(b^{\prime}_{n},b_{n}],
which means that
\min\{|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-a_{n}|,|b_{n}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\}<\delta_{n+1}.
If
|f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})-a_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
, then
|f(a_{n})-a^{\prime}_{n}|=|f(a_{n})-f(f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}))|\leqslant|a_{n}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|<\delta_{n+1},
but there is no condensation point
x
such that
|x-a^{\prime}_{n}|<\delta_{n+1}
; a contradiction.
The case
|b_{n}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|<\delta_{n+1}
is analogous.
If
m>n
, then
\textstyle\min\{|a_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|,|b_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\}\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}.
If
|a_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}
, then
\textstyle|f(a_{m})-a^{\prime}_{n}|=|f(a_{m})-f(f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}))|\leqslant|a_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}<\delta_{n+1};
a contradiction.
The case
|b_{m}-f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})|\leqslant\frac{1}{2}\delta_{m}
is analogous.
Finally,
f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
and the fact that
f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\in[a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}]
is proved similarly.
From Lemma
1
it follows that
\{f^{-1}(a^{\prime}_{n}),f^{-1}(b^{\prime}_{n})\}=\{a^{\prime}_{n},b^{\prime}_{n}\}
.
By Lemma
2
, we have
\{f(a_{n}),f(b_{n})\}=\{a_{n},b_{n}\}
.
Then, by Lemma
3
,
f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.
โ
4.
The main theorem
Theorem 5
.
The set
X
is plastic.
Proof.
Fix a bijection
f\colon X\to X
which is non-expansive.
By Lemma
4
, for every
n<\omega
the restriction
f|_{[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X}
is an isometry onto
[a_{n},b_{n}]\cap X
.
If
f(b_{0})=a_{0}
and
f(b_{1})=a_{1}
, then
|f(b_{1})-f(b_{0})|=a_{1}-a_{0}=(a_{1}-b_{0})+(b_{0}-a_{0})>(a_{1}-b_{0})+(b_{1}-a_{1})=b_{1}-b_{0};
a contradiction.
If
f(b_{0})=a_{0}
and
f(b_{1})=b_{1}
, then
|f(b_{1})-f(b_{0})|=b_{1}-a_{0}>b_{1}-b_{0};
a contradiction.
Thus
f(b_{0})=b_{0}
, hence
f(a_{0})=a_{0}
.
Fix
1\leqslant n<\omega
and assume that
f(a_{k})=a_{k}
and
f(b_{k})=b_{k}
for
k<n
.
Suppose that
f(b_{n+1})=a_{n+1}
.
If
a_{n}<a_{n+1}
, then
b_{n}<a_{n+1}
and
b_{n+1}-b_{n}=f(a_{n+1})-f(b_{n})\leqslant a_{n+1}-b_{n}<b_{n+1}-b_{n};
a contradiction.
If
a_{n+1}<a_{n}
, then
b_{n+1}<a_{n}
and
a_{n}-a_{n+1}=f(a_{n})-f(b_{n+1})\leqslant a_{n}-b_{n+1}<a_{n+1}-a_{n};
a contradiction.
Thus
f(b_{n+1})=b_{n+1}
, hence
f(a_{n+1})=a_{n+1}
.
By induction,
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
and
f(b_{n})=b_{n}
for every
n<\omega
.
Fix
t\in X
.
There exist
m
and
n
such that
a_{m}<t<a_{n}
.
Once again,
t
is the only solution of the system of inequalities
(***)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|a_{m}-x|&\leqslant&|a_{m}-t|,\\
|a_{n}-x|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|,\\
\end{array}\right.
On the other hand, since
f
is non-expansive, we have
(**)\quad\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}|f(a_{m})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|a_{m}-t|,\\
|f(a_{n})-f(t)|&\leqslant&|a_{n}-t|.\\
\end{array}\right.
Since
f(a_{m})=a_{m}
and
f(a_{n})=a_{n}
, the value
f(t)
is the only solution of
(***)
, hence
f(t)=t
.
โ
Theorem 6
.
The Continuum Hypothesis is equivalent to the non-existence of a plastic dense subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|<\mathfrak{c}
.
Proof.
The Continuum Hypothesis and Corollary 2 from
[
1
]
imply that there is no plastic dense subset
X\subseteq\mathbb{R}
of cardinality
|X|<\mathfrak{c}
.
If we assume that
\mathfrak{c}\geqslant\omega_{2}
, then the set
X
is plastic, dense and is of cardinality
\omega_{1}<\mathfrak{c}
.