Solar Vortex Detection With Velocity Field Normalisation: Eliminating False Positives

Lauren McClure, Suzana Silva, Gary Verth, Istvan Ballai, Viktor Fedun · 2025

Read Solar Vortex Detection With Velocity Field Normalisation: Eliminating False Positives by Lauren McClure, Suzana Silva, Gary Verth, Istvan Ballai, Viktor Fedun (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18876.txt.

Introduction

Lauren McClure and four co-authors clean up the hunt for tiny whirlpools on the Sun. Small vortices in the photosphere ferry mass and energy upward, but shear in the flow fools detection algorithms into reporting vortices that are not there. Their fix, posted to arXiv in December 2025 and submitted to The Astrophysical Journal, is a preprocessing step: normalize the velocity field by its magnitude before detecting anything.

Tested on high-resolution Bifrost simulations with the d-criterion as approximate truth, three standard methods produce many false positives on raw data; normalization removes most of them. The Gamma method, which underpins most observational studies, stays accurate but misses many real flows. After normalization the other methods find four to five times more vortices, suggesting the Sun's true vortex coverage is badly underestimated today.

Catalog record

CREATORLauren McClure, Suzana Silva, Gary Verth, Istvan Ballai, Viktor Fedun
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18876

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Solar Vortex Detection With Velocity Field Normalisation: Eliminating False Positives Lauren McClure, Suzana Silva, Gary Verth, Istvan Ballai, Viktor Fedun Abstract Small-scale vortices in the solar photosphere play a central role in transporting mass, energy, and momentum into the upper solar atmosphere, yet reliably detecting these structures remains rather challenging. We address this problem by introducing a simple preprocessing step that normalises the velocity field by its magnitude. Our method preserves flow topology while suppressing shear-induced artefacts that lead to spurious detections in non-uniform, high-rotation environments. For validation, we apply this approach to high-resolution Bifrost simulations and evaluate vortex detection using four commonly employed methods: IVD, the λ 2 \lambda_{2} -criterion, the Q-criterion, and the Γ \Gamma method. We assess which structures exhibit physically consistent rotation by using the d d -criterion to automatically detect rotational plasma-flow features, which we use as an approximate ground truth. We find that, in the unnormalised field, a substantial fraction of detections made by the first three methods are false positive detections. Normalisation removes most of these. The Γ \Gamma method detects true vortices but misses a large number of vortical flows. The normalisation step yields better-defined and more realistic vortex boundaries. As the Γ \Gamma method underpins most observational analyses, current studies likely capture only a subset of vortical flows. By comparison, the other three methods detect four to five times more vortices after normalisation, suggesting that the true photospheric vortex coverage may be underestimated by a similar factor. Overall, this physically motivated preprocessing step enhances the accuracy and physical realism of vortex detection and offers a practical enhancement for analysing vortical flows in turbulent flows. I Introduction Vortex tubes are ubiquitous phenomena in the solar atmosphere, where they serve as important channels for the transport of energy, mass, and momentum from the photosphere through the chromosphere and into the corona ( 27 ) . This behaviour appears consistently across multiple magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations. In essence, vortices are swirling columns of plasma, typically associated with upward flows in the chromosphere and corona, but predominantly linked to downward flows in the photosphere ( 4 ; 29 ) . By definition, from a two-dimensional identification perspective, they have high local vorticity, are bounded, persistent in time, and exhibit circular (or quasi-circular) motion. Alongside these characteristics we have a general definition for solar vortex flows proposed by 28 : “A vortex is the collective motion associated with the azimuthal component ( \varphi ) of a vector field (e.g. true velocity or magnetic field) or its observational counterparts (such as trackable motions of features associated with radiation intensity or magnetic field) about a common centre or axis.” Nevertheless, despite these recognised traits, there is still no universally accepted mathematical definition of a vortex. This has led to the development of numerous automated vortex identification methods ( 5 ) . Since the introduction of the Okubo–Weiss criterion, which evaluates whether strain or rotation dominates within a local flow region, a wide range of additional metrics have been proposed ( 19 ; 30 ) . The Q-criterion subsequently extended this approach by comparing the magnitude of rotation to that of strain, and can be generalised to three dimensions by evaluating velocity gradients through their normal components rather than eigenvalues ( 12 ) . Both the Q-criterion and the Okubo-Weiss criterion are classically regarded as effective tools for identifying regions within a flow that exhibit vortex-like behaviour. More recent methods have focused on locating a defined centre of a vortex within a flow field ( 23 ; 9 ) , with some approaches also specifying the surrounding region in which the vortical behaviour is confined. A straightforward approach to identifying a vortex centre is to search for local maxima in the vorticity magnitude ( 26 ) . While this method directly captures the “high local vorticity” characteristic, it also risks misclassifying strong shear flows as vortical structures. One widely used approach that identifies both the region of a vortex and its centre is the \Gamma method ( 9 ) . In this method, the vortex centre and boundary are defined based on the flow topology within a restricted domain by detecting regions that exhibit solid-body rotation around a central point. The LAVD (Lagrangian Averaged Vorticity Deviation) and IVD (Instantaneous Vorticity Deviation) methods (in Lagrangian and Eulerian forms, respectively), introduced by 11 , determine vortex centres by evaluating the deviation of vorticity within a domain from the mean vorticity, and locating the local minima and maxima of the resulting field. The corresponding vortex boundaries are obtained by identifying the outermost bounded isocontour that encloses these extrema, with the contours further filtered according to their convexity. A wide variety of additional vortex detection methods have been developed, most of which emphasise one or two of the recognised vortex characteristics ( 5 ; 34 ; 35 ) . In this paper, we introduce a modification to vortex detection approaches and apply our methodology to simulated vortex flows in the solar photosphere. Our focus is on finding a robust vortex detection methodology that remains reliable despite the asymmetry of rotational flows. By concentrating exclusively on the topology of the flow while disregarding its magnitude, we demonstrate a means of achieving more accurate vortex identifications, with potential applications in both terrestrial hydrodynamics and space-based magnetohydrodynamics. We illustrate the method using small-scale vortices in the solar photosphere, where asymmetric vortex flows are prevalent ( 18 ; 3 ) . II Methodology II.1 Bifrost Simulation Data All results presented in this paper are obtained using numerical simulations performed with the radiative magnetohydrodynamical code Bifrost ( 10 ) . Designed to reproduce the velocity and magnetic fields of the upper solar atmosphere with high accuracy, Bifrost enables detailed investigation of photospheric kinetic vortices. Because the photosphere is highly turbulent and dominated by numerous shear-like flows, any vortex detection method must be capable of operating reliably in turbulent conditions and of distinguishing effectively between shear and vortical motions. The specific simulation used in this study is publicly available through the Hinode Science Data Centre (SDC) as part of the IRIS project ( 6 ) . The dataset, named ch024031_by200bz005, spans a horizontal domain of 24 Mm \times 24 Mm and a non-uniform vertical extent of 17 Mm, beginning 2.5 Mm below the solar surface. For this analysis, we focus on a photospheric layer located 0.44 Mm above the solar surface. At a spatial resolution of 31km, the domain for applying the two-dimensional vortex detection methods corresponds to 768 \times 768 grid points. Figure 1: A view of the vertical component of velocity, v_{z} , over the numerical domain over which we conduct our analyses. The blue and black box represent the subdomain shown in Appendix ( the blue blox is shown in Figure ( 6 ) and the black box represents the subdomain shown in Figures ( 7 – 10 )). II.2 Normalisation of the Velocity Field The modification we propose involves normalising the velocity field within the fundamental equations of each vortex detection method. This is achieved by dividing the x - and y -components of the velocity field by the velocity magnitude. The rationale is that by focusing exclusively on the flow topology at a given time,

Read the complete text