From Natural Language to Control Signals: A Conceptual Framework for Semantic Channel Finding in Complex Experimental Infrastructure

Thorsten Hellert, Nikolay Agladze, Alex Giovannone, Jan Jug, Frank Mayet, Mark Sherwin, Antonin Sulc, Chris Tennant, [1em] Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA, [0.5em] Corresponding author: [email protected] · 2025

Read From Natural Language to Control Signals: A Conceptual Framework for Semantic Channel Finding in Complex Experimental Infrastructure by Thorsten Hellert, Nikolay Agladze, Alex Giovannone, Jan Jug, Frank Mayet, Mark Sherwin, Antonin Sulc, Chris Tennant, [1em] Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA, [0.5em] Corresponding author: [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18779.txt.

Introduction

Thorsten Hellert and seven co-authors tackle a mundane problem that slows down big science: finding the right control signal. Accelerators, fusion devices, and telescopes expose hundreds of thousands of channels, named inconsistently over decades. Operators hunt them through folklore and fragmented docs. Their paper, posted to arXiv in December 2025, formalizes semantic channel finding, mapping a plain-language request to the right signal.

They propose four design paradigms, from dictionary lookup and tree navigation to exploring agents and ontology-based search, and match them to facility data conditions. Proof-of-concept systems at four working facilities, from compact free-electron lasers to large synchrotrons, answer expert-checked operational queries with 90 to 97 percent accuracy. As language models move into control rooms, a principled way to find channels becomes essential infrastructure.

Catalog record

CREATORThorsten Hellert, Nikolay Agladze, Alex Giovannone, Jan Jug, Frank Mayet, Mark Sherwin, Antonin Sulc, Chris Tennant, [1em] Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA, [0.5em] Corresponding author: [email protected]
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18779

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From Natural Language to Control Signals: A Conceptual Framework for Semantic Channel Finding in Complex Experimental Infrastructure Thorsten Hellert, Nikolay Agladze, Alex Giovannone, Jan Jug, Frank Mayet, Mark Sherwin, Antonin Sulc, Chris Tennant, [1em] Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, USA, [0.5em] Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract Modern experimental platforms such as particle accelerators, fusion devices, telescopes, and industrial process control systems expose tens to hundreds of thousands of control and diagnostic channels accumulated over decades of evolution. Operators and AI systems rely on informal expert knowledge, inconsistent naming conventions, and fragmented documentation to locate signals for monitoring, troubleshooting, and automated control, creating a persistent bottleneck for reliability, scalability, and language-model–driven interfaces. We formalize semantic channel finding-mapping natural-language intent to concrete control-system signals-as a general problem in complex experimental infrastructure, and introduce a four-paradigm framework to guide architecture selection across facility-specific data regimes. The paradigms span (i) direct in-context lookup over curated channel dictionaries, (ii) constrained hierarchical navigation through structured trees, (iii) interactive agent exploration using iterative reasoning and tool-based database queries, and (iv) ontology-grounded semantic search that decouples channel meaning from facility-specific naming conventions. We demonstrate each paradigm through proof-of-concept implementations at four operational facilities spanning two orders of magnitude in scale-from compact free-electron lasers to large synchrotron light sources-and diverse control-system architectures, from clean hierarchies to legacy environments. These implementations achieve 90–97% accuracy on expert-curated operational queries. Keywords: semantic search, control systems, large language models, particle accelerators, channel finding, natural language processing 1 Introduction Complex experimental and industrial facilities—from particle accelerators and fusion devices to telescopes, chemical plants, and power grids—are among the most intricate operational environments in modern science and engineering. A single facility may expose tens to hundreds of thousands of control and diagnostic channels accumulated over decades of hardware evolution, subsystem upgrades, and vendor integrations. High-level operational tasks such as stabilizing beam parameters, recovering from faults, optimizing process efficiency, or preparing custom configurations, ultimately require identifying and interacting with the correct process variables (PVs) or control signals under strict safety, performance, and real-time constraints. Even when operators know the physical quantity of interest, translating that intent into the relevant channel names is often nontrivial, facility-specific, and dependent on institutional knowledge. Today this mapping relies heavily on informal expert knowledge, inconsistent naming conventions, and fragmented documentation. Legacy channels often encode subsystem structure in cryptic, fixed-length identifiers shaped by decades-old software constraints, while newer subsystems introduce more descriptive conventions but rarely update older names for backward compatibility. Different subsystems like magnets, diagnostics, vacuum, RF or instrumentation, develop separate terminologies and ontologies, and descriptions are scattered across configuration files, wikis, personal notes, and undocumented tribal knowledge. As a result, knowledge of the channel space is implicitly distributed across specialists, creating steep learning curves for new operators and persistent bottlenecks for troubleshooting under time pressure. These structural issues create persistent challenges. New operators face steep learning curves; troubleshooting requires rapid channel identification under time pressure; and documentation rarely keeps pace with hardware evolution. For emerging AI-based control assistants, the bottleneck is even more acute. Language-model–driven systems cannot safely inspect machine state, retrieve history, or execute control actions unless they can reliably map natural-language intent to concrete control-system channels. Large language models (LLMs) now enable a new interaction layer in which operators and autonomous agents specify goals directly in natural language. Within this layer, semantic channel finding becomes a foundational capability: given a free-form description (for example, “orbit corrector strengths in the booster” or “temperatures near the undulator chamber”), the system must identify the corresponding PVs and related readback, setpoint, or status channels needed for safe operation. However, control systems vary widely in scale, naming conventions, and data quality, making a single universal retrieval architecture infeasible. In this work, we formalize semantic channel finding as a general architectural problem in complex experimental and industrial infrastructure; applicable not only to accelerators but also to fusion devices, telescope arrays, chemical process control, power systems, and any large-scale facility where natural-language interfaces to control systems are desired. Rather than proposing a single universal solution, we present a conceptual framework that systematically organizes the design space into four paradigms, each optimized for different facility-specific data regimes characterized by control-system scale, naming convention quality, presence of hierarchical structure, and availability of semantic metadata. Paradigm 1 ( direct in-context lookup ) is well suited to small or curated channel sets (hundreds to low thousands) where a complete dictionary fits comfortably in modern LLM context windows, enabling zero-shot semantic matching without external retrieval. Paradigm 2 ( constrained hierarchical navigation ) applies when channel organization admits a strict tree structure: agents traverse pre-defined levels with strongly typed choices at each step, eliminating hallucination while keeping computational cost linear in tree depth rather than channel count. Paradigm 3 ( interactive agent exploration ) handles large databases where structure must be discovered dynamically: ReAct-style agents reason iteratively about what information they need, call database tools to explore compositional naming schemes or middle-layer abstractions, and refine their search based on observations. Paradigm 4 ( ontology-based semantic search ) elevates reasoning to the level of device types and signal semantics, grounding devices, signals, and relationships in a shared domain model to enable portable, facility-agnostic queries at the cost of upfront ontology development and mapping effort. The framework provides actionable guidance: facilities can select paradigms based on their existing infrastructure and data quality rather than undertaking extensive architectural redesign. Building on this perspective, our contributions are threefold. First , we formalize semantic channel finding as a general architectural problem and develop a four-paradigm conceptual framework (Sections 2 , 3 , 4 , and 5 ) that enables systematic selection of appropriate architectures based on facility-specific data regimes—control-system scale, naming convention quality, hierarchical structure, and available metadata. This taxonomy provides actionable guidance for practitioners facing the channel-finding problem across diverse scientific and industrial contexts. Second , we validate the practical feasibility of each paradigm through proof-of-concept implementations at operational facilities spanning two orders of magnitude in scale and operating under fundamentally different control-system architectures: the compact Terahertz Free Electron Laser at UC Santa Barbara [ 17 ] (300 channels, flat organization), the European XFEL [ 2 , 6 ] at Deutsche Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY (compositional DOOCS naming), the Advanced Light Source (ALS) [ 13 ] at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (legacy heterogeneous conventions mediated through middle-layer abstraction), and CEBAF [ 1 ] /ALS ontology-based deployments at Jefferson Lab. Each implementation is validated on expert-curated operational queries representative of real control-room tasks, demonstrating 90–97% accuracy and establishing that the framework’s paradigms are deployable under real-world constraints. Third , we provide open-source, plug-and-play implementations of the first three paradigms (direct lookup, hierarchical navigation, and middle-layer exploration) within the Osprey framework [ 14 , 8 ] , including database-generation tools, interactive interfaces, and minimal-configuration tutorials to support adoption at other facilities without requiring custom infrastructure development. Section 6 discusses potential extensions such as hybrid pipelines, reinforcement-learning-enhanced navigation, dynamic agent memory, and cross-facility knowledge transfer built on shared ontologies. 2 Paradigm 1: Direct Lookup In control systems where the number of channels of interest is below about 1000, the most straightforward path to semantic channel finding is to treat a large language model itself as a search engine over

Read the complete text