Does It Tie Out? Towards Autonomous Legal Agents in Venture Capital
Pierre Colombo, Malik Boudiaf, Allyn Sweet, Michael Desa, Hongxi Wang, Kevin Candra, Syméon del Marmol {firstname}@equall.com · 2025
Read Does It Tie Out? Towards Autonomous Legal Agents in Venture Capital by Pierre Colombo, Malik Boudiaf, Allyn Sweet, Michael Desa, Hongxi Wang, Kevin Candra, Syméon del Marmol {firstname}@equall.com (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18658.txt.
Introduction
Pierre Colombo and six coauthors examine a painstaking legal chore in this 2025 paper. Before a venture capital round closes, lawyers tie out the capitalization table. Every share, option, and warrant must be backed by documents in the data room, plus terms like vesting and transfer limits. The authors argue that this check remains out of reach for today's AI agents, since it demands reasoning across many documents, strict evidence trails, and identical outputs on repeat runs.
They frame cap table tie-out as a real-world benchmark for legal AI and compare how existing agent systems perform on it. They then propose a world model design aimed at automating the task. The goal is a base for legal tools that can prove each claim they make.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pierre Colombo, Malik Boudiaf, Allyn Sweet, Michael Desa, Hongxi Wang, Kevin Candra, Syméon del Marmol {firstname}@equall.com |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18658
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Does It Tie Out? Towards Autonomous Legal Agents in Venture Capital Pierre Colombo, Malik Boudiaf, Allyn Sweet, Michael Desa, Hongxi Wang, Kevin Candra, Syméon del Marmol {firstname}@equall.com Abstract Before closing venture capital financing rounds, lawyers conduct diligence that includes tying out the capitalization table: verifying that every security (e.g., shares, options, warrants) and issuance term (e.g., vesting schedules, acceleration triggers, transfer restrictions) is supported by large sets of underlying legal documentation. While LLMs continue to improve on legal benchmarks, specialized legal workflows, such as capitalization tie-out, remain out of reach even for strong agentic systems: the task requires multi-document reasoning, strict evidence traceability, and deterministic outputs that current approaches fail to reliably deliver. We characterize capitalization tie-out as an instance of real-world benchmark for legal AI, analyze and compare the performance of existing agentic systems, and propose a world model architecture towards tie-out automation—and more broadly as a foundation for applied legal intelligence. 1 1 footnotetext: Equal contributions 1 Introduction Verifying legal ownership of a company is a bottleneck in private market transactions, from venture financings to M&A deals. Before a deal closes, lawyers must manually reconcile thousands of pages against ownership records, a process commonly referred to as cap table tie-out or capitalization due diligence. This work is critical to confirm financial allocations up to and arising from the transaction, while also tedious, error-prone, and typically performed under capped fees that compress margins. Large language models have shown impressive capabilities on legal reasoning benchmarks [ 7 , 5 , 6 , 11 , 10 ] and contract analysis tasks [ 14 , 1 ] , yet this recurring verification workflow remains categorically manual. This paper investigates why and what is required to bridge the gap. In any financing or acquisition the disbursing party must verify all ownership claims, contractual obligations, potential liabilities, and regulatory risks before funds change hands [ 2 ] . This legal risk assessment centers on the dataroom , a repository containing the company’s legal and financial history: incorporation filings, stock purchase agreements, option grants, convertible instruments, board consents, and their amendments. Market data shows over 25,000 venture capital financings per year, with circa 15,000 originating in the US alone. Routine Seed and Series A rounds generate datarooms with thousands of pages, and Series B and after often reach tens of thousands of pages. Tie-out is the core verification task to reconcile legal ownership and related positions. Each entry in the capitalization table, such as share issuances, option grants, and SAFE conversions must trace to signed agreements, board approvals, and payment records. As shown in Figure 1 , tie-out transforms a heterogeneous document collection into verified ownership records while surfacing discrepancies for legal review. The task is combinatorial: a single stock grant may depend on the original equity plan, a board consent, the signed option agreement, and subsequent amendments. Errors propagate, and even a single missed cancelation or overlooked amendment can misstate ownership across dozens of stakeholders. Why LLMs alone are not enough. Tie-out exposes limitations that legal AI benchmarks do not test. Unlike single-document question answering [ 16 , 4 , 8 ] or clause extraction [ 9 ] , tie-out requires multi-document reasoning combining information scattered across dozens of files. It demands strict traceability in that every claim must link to source evidence. And it requires consistency : the same document processed twice must yield identical outputs. These requirements challenge the dominant agentic LLM paradigm, where performance excels at fluent extraction and summarization but struggles with combinatorial verification and reproducibility at scale [ 3 ] . This paper examines how LLMs can be effectively applied to capitalization tie-out, characterizing the complexity of the task and the architectural requirements for its reliable automation. Figure 1: The tie-out workflow . Lawyers review and cross-reference heterogeneous dataroom documents—one or more capitalization tables, and supporting legal documentation (e.g., SAFEs, option agreements, amendments, cancellations, etc.)—to understand the legal reality of the company and ensure the capitalization table is accurate by comparing it against the non-cap table documents, which provide the ground truth. The output : verified legal positions with document traceability, and flags for discrepancies requiring further review and/or action. Figure 2: Document category. Red dashed lines indicate Zipf’s law fits ( R^{2}\sim 1 is perfect fit). 2 Background and Formulation This section describes the capitalization due diligence context, introduces the dataroom and its core artifact—the cap table—and formally defines the tie-out problem. 2.1 The Dataroom In any financing or M&A transaction, the dataroom is a repository containing the company’s legal and financial history. We represent it as \mathcal{D}=\{D_{1},\dots,D_{N}\} , where each document D_{i} encodes partial, overlapping, or sometimes conflicting information about ownership, rights, and past transactions. Documents vary widely in formats, from contracts, registers, notices, certificates to spreadsheets. But each belongs to a functional category with a distinct role in verification (Table 1 ). As shown in Figure 5 , the distribution follows Zipf’s law: a small number of categories (e.g. board consents, SPA) account for the majority of documents, while a long tail of specialized instruments appears infrequently but remains critical when present [ 13 , 12 ] . 2.2 The Capitalization Table The capitalization table (cap table), denoted \mathcal{C} , plays a central role in the tie-out. It provides a consolidated snapshot of all outstanding securities—common stock, preferred shares, options, SAFEs—along with their holders and ownership percentages. It typically takes the form of an Excel spreadsheet, with each tab (or ledger ) detailing the current ownership for one specific class of shares. An example of such ledger is provided in Appendix A . In the tie-out problem, the ledgers from the cap table functions as the master claims ledger : every entry must trace to authoritative source documents in the dataroom. The goal is not to reconstruct the company’s full legal history but to confirm that each line is supported by controlling evidence—and to flag where it is not. Table 1: Document categories for capitalization tie-out in venture financings Document Type Role in Tie-Out Capitalization Table (Cap Table) Records ownership of Company stock, convertible securities, and purchase rights; used as the purported ”correct” representation of the Company’s ownership against which non-cap table documents are compared. Stock Purchase Agreements Document purchases of Company stock by stockholders; used to verify stock ownership and contractual rights. Convertible Securities Document purchases of convertible securities (e.g., SAFEs, convertible notes) by investors; used to verify convertible securities ownership and conversion rights. Employment Contracts Document equity ownership promised by the Company to employees, contractors, and advisors; used to verify that there are no promised equity unrepresented on the cap table. Amendments Modify prior agreement terms (e.g., vesting schedule, acceleration terms); used to reconcile historical changes in ownership and document terms. Certificates of Incorporation / Bylaws Establish the Company’s legal existence, share class structure, and governance rules; used to verify issued securities comply with legal limit of authorized shares. Board and Shareholder Consents Approve corporate actions (e.g., stock issuances, amendments, or corporate actions); used to validate formal board and/or stockholder authorization of transactions. Term Sheets Outline terms of proposed financing; used to cross-check final agreements and conversion terms. Ancillary Equity Agreements (e.g., Option Exercise, Repurchase, and Transfer) Document additional equity-related events; used to ensure