On Efficient Adjustment for Micro Causal Effects in Summary Causal Graphs

Isabela Belciug, Simon Ferreira, Charles K. Assaad · 2025

Read On Efficient Adjustment for Micro Causal Effects in Summary Causal Graphs by Isabela Belciug, Simon Ferreira, Charles K. Assaad (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18315.txt.

Introduction

Isabela Belciug, Simon Ferreira, and Charles K. Assaad simplify how to adjust for background traits in summary causal graphs. Such graphs compress a whole time series into one node, which suits dynamic systems but breaks the classic rules for picking a fair comparison set. Recent work gave full conditions for when a small scale effect can be read off by adjustment, yet the rules were heavy and yielded just two valid sets.

Their restatement puts those conditions in a lighter form, and a new test certifies many more valid adjustment sets than the old rules allowed. Among the valid sets they single out the near best one, whose effect estimate wobbles least over large samples. The plainer rules also skip the slow path counting the first version needed.

Catalog record

CREATORIsabela Belciug, Simon Ferreira, Charles K. Assaad
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18315

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On Efficient Adjustment for Micro Causal Effects in Summary Causal Graphs Isabela Belciug, Simon Ferreira, Charles K. Assaad Abstract Observational studies in fields such as epidemiology often rely on covariate adjustment to estimate causal effects. Classical graphical criteria, like the back-door criterion and the generalized adjustment criterion, are powerful tools for identifying valid adjustment sets in directed acyclic graphs (DAGs). However, these criteria are not directly applicable to summary causal graphs (SCGs), which are abstractions of DAGs commonly used in dynamic systems. In SCGs, each node typically represents an entire time series and may involve cycles, making classical criteria inapplicable for identifying causal effects. Recent work established complete conditions for determining whether the micro causal effect of a treatment or an exposure X t − γ X_{t-\gamma} on an outcome Y t Y_{t} is identifiable via covariate adjustment in SCGs, under the assumption of no hidden confounding. However, these identifiability conditions have two main limitations. First, they are complex, relying on cumbersome definitions and requiring the enumeration of multiple paths in the SCG, which can be computationally expensive. Second, when these conditions are satisfied, they only provide two valid adjustment sets, limiting flexibility in practical applications. In this paper, we propose an equivalent but simpler formulation of those identifiability conditions and introduce a new criterion that identifies a broader class of valid adjustment sets in SCGs. Additionally, we characterize the quasi-optimal adjustment set among these, i.e., the one that minimizes the asymptotic variance of the causal effect estimator. Our contributions offer both theoretical advancement and practical tools for more flexible and efficient causal inference in abstracted causal graphs. 1 Introduction Understanding causal relationships is a central goal in many scientific disciplines, such as epidemiology [ 13 , 11 ] , economics [ 14 ] , climate science 23 , and industry [ 4 ] . Causal inference from observational data, in particular, poses fundamental challenges due to the presence of confounding bias. A widely used framework for representing and reasoning about causal relationships is based on Structural Causal Models (SCM) [ 18 ] . An SCM is a set of structural equations that define how each observed variable is generated from its causes, thereby specifying a causal data-generating process. Usually, the SCM is supposed to be unknown, but the Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) it induces—representing the qualitative causal structure among variables—is known. In the induced DAG, nodes represent variables and directed edges denote direct causal influences. These graphs provide a powerful language for articulating causal assumptions and determining whether a given causal effect is identifiable from observational data. There exist several tools for identifying (i.e., removing confounding bias without adding new biases) a causal effect of interest in DAGs among which the do-calculus—a set of three rules that, when applied iteratively,—form a sound and complete tool for causal effect identification in non-parametric settings. However, while powerful in theory, the do-calculus [ 18 ] can be highly complex to apply in practice today. Even when identification is possible, the resulting formulas (e.g., the front-door formula [ 18 ] [ 21 ] ) may not be compatible with standard estimators such as ordinary least squares regression or propensity score methods. As a result, researchers often prefer simpler graphical criteria like the back-door criterion [ 18 ] or the generalized adjustment criterion [ 20 ] , which offer intuitive graphical tests to identify causal effects by covariate adjustment which is compatible with standard estimators. However, in complex systems with high-dimensional data or partial observability, specifying the DAG is often infeasible or undesirable due to uncertainty, noise, or computational cost. To address these challenges, researchers have proposed various abstractions of DAGs that simplify or summarize the underlying causal structure [ 20 , 7 , 1 , 4 , 2 , 10 ] . These abstractions are particularly valuable in fields like epidemiology, where large-scale longitudinal studies often involve repeated measurements over time and many partially observed variables. One such abstraction is the cluster graph [ 1 , 4 , 2 , 10 ] , which groups variables into clusters. A notable and particularly useful instance of this is the summary causal graph (SCG) [ 4 , 2 , 10 ] , where each node represents a time series. SCGs are especially well-suited for applications involving time series or cohort data, where variables are naturally organized over time. These graphs preserve causal relations between time series while abstracting away the time. While adjustment criteria for causal inference have been well-studied in the context of DAGs—notably the back-door criterion [ 17 ] and its extensions to the generalized adjustment criterion [ 19 , 20 ] —the theory of adjustment in SCGs remains comparatively underdeveloped. SCGs pose two additional challenges: they may contain cycles, and a single node can represent an entire cluster of variables, both of which complicate the identification of valid adjustment sets. In recent years, a significant advancement was made for identifying causal effects in SCGs 4 , 2 , 10 . In particular, 2 provided sound complete [ 28 ] graphical conditions for identifying by covariate adjustment the causal effect of one timepoint X_{t-\gamma} on another timepoint Y_{t} —known as a micro causal effect and denoted as {\Pr}(y_{t}\mid\text{do}(x_{t-\gamma})) [ 10 ] —in SCGs under the assumption of no hidden confounding. However, in 2 only two valid unpracticable adjustment sets were presented for any identifiable micro causal effect. This stands in contrast to the tools developed for DAGs—like the back-door criterion—which gives, whenever a causal effect is identifiable by adjustment, multiple valid adjustment sets, each of which is theoretically correct but may differ significantly in practical properties such as statistical efficiency. In particular, while all valid sets remove confounding bias, they can vary widely in terms of how they impact the variance of the estimated effect 22 , 27 , 25 , 24 , 12 . Therefore, being able to search over adjustment sets to identify the one that yields the most precise estimate (i.e., minimal variance) is critical in real-world applications. In this paper, we start by simplifying the conditions given in 2 to identify {\Pr}(y_{t}\mid\text{do}(x_{t-\gamma})) ; then we present the SCG-back-door criterion, an extension of the back-door criterion to SCGs, which provides, whenever {\Pr}(y_{t}\mid\text{do}(x_{t-\gamma})) is identifiable by adjustment in SCGs using the conditions given in 2 , a rich collection of valid adjustment sets. Furthermore, we identify the quasi-optimal adjustment set among this collection, defined as the one that minimizes the asymptotic variance of the causal effect estimator under standard assumptions in at least some distribution compatible with the SCG; it is also the smallest set among all valid adjustment that contains as much as possible of all sets that minimize the asymptotic variance of the causal effect estimator in every distribution compatible with the SCG. We emphasize that this set is not necessary the smallest set. Our results bridge a critical gap in the theory of causal inference from abstracted graphical models and open new directions for variance-aware causal effect estimation in SCGs. The remaining of the paper is as follows: Section 2 introduces needed preliminaries and terminologies. Section 3 simplifies the results given in 2 and introduces the SCG-back-door criterion. Section 4 shows which of the set given by the

Read the complete text