Prime degree irreducible representations of simple algebraic groups and finite simple groups of Lie type
D. L. Flannery, A. E. Zalesski · 2025
Read Prime degree irreducible representations of simple algebraic groups and finite simple groups of Lie type by D. L. Flannery, A. E. Zalesski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18145.txt.
Introduction
D. L. Flannery and A. E. Zalesski bound a rare class of matrix groups. Their setting is the special linear group over a finite field, with the size set by a prime degree. Inside it, some subgroups sit only in one hard class from the Aschbacher scheme, the non geometric class, which resists the usual tools.
For such groups, the authors cap the group size by a rule that depends on the degree and field power, but not on the prime itself. The count of such groups, up to a change of basis, is capped by the degree alone. The caps feed a computing version of a deep number theory result about dense subgroups, where firm bounds make searches end.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | D. L. Flannery, A. E. Zalesski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18145
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Prime degree irreducible representations of simple algebraic groups and finite simple groups of Lie type D. L. Flannery, A. E. Zalesski Abstract . We show that finite quasisimple groups of Lie type in characteristic p p with an irreducible representation of prime degree r r over a finite field of characteristic p p have orders bounded above by a function of r r , independent of p p . We also bound the number of such groups in terms of r r . Apart from being notable in their own right, these results have a significant application in a computational version of the strong approximation theorem for finitely generated Zariski-dense subgroups of S L r ( ℙ ) SL_{r}(\mathbb{P}) , where ℙ \mathbb{P} is a number field. Dedicated to the memory of Otto Kegel † † 2000 AMS Subject Classification: 20B15, 20H30 † † Keywords: Simple algebraic group, group of Lie type, Lie algebra, prime degree 1. Introduction The Aschbacher categorization of (maximal) subgroups of classical groups over finite fields divides each set of subgroups into nine classes \mathscr{C}_{i},1\leq i\leq 9 [ 1 ] . The first eight of these classes are ‘geometric’, and are defined according to how the groups act on the underlying vector space. The non-geometric (quasisimple or almost simple modulo scalars) class \mathscr{C}_{9} requires separate treatment. Our interest is in this class. Specifically, we prove the following. Theorem 1.1 . Let k>0 be an integer, r,p primes, and let G be a proper subgroup of SL_{r}(p^{k}) . Suppose that G lies in \mathscr{C}_{9} and in no other \mathscr{C}_{i} . Then (1) |G| is bounded above by a function of r , independent of the characteristic p; (2) up to conjugation in GL_{r}(p^{k}) , the number of such groups G that are quasisimple of Lie type in the defining characteristic p does not exceed (4(3r)^{1/2}+2)\cdot r^{(r^{2}+8)/2} . As we will show in Theorem 3.7 below, p<r^{r^{2}/2} . This is a key step in the proof of Theorem 1.1 . It follows that an explicit bound on |G| for r>2 and G of Lie type in characteristic p is |SL_{r}(p_{0}^{k})| , where p_{0} is the greatest prime less than r^{r^{2}/2} . Note that this order bound depends on k . We also point out that Theorem 1.1 is certainly false if r is not prime, as demonstrated, e.g., by tables in [ 4 ] . For definitions of the \mathscr{C}_{i} , see [ 4 , Chapter 2] . If G\in\mathscr{C}_{9} and G\not\in\mathscr{C}_{i} for i\neq 9 , then G has a normal absolutely irreducible quasisimple subgroup S , say, such that C_{G}(S)=Z(G) . The tensor product classes \mathscr{C}_{4} and \mathscr{C}_{7} are empty for prime degree r . Class \mathscr{C}_{5} consists of groups conjugate to subgroups of SL_{r}(p^{i}) for i properly dividing k , modulo scalars; while groups lying in \mathscr{C}_{8} normalize classical groups represented naturally in SL_{r}(p^{k}) . Theorem 1.1 expands [ 6 , Lemma 3.1] . The original proof is inadequate, due to its reliance only on the classification given by [ 24 , Theorem 1.1] of ordinary projective representations of finite quasisimple groups in prime degree. The context and motivation for Theorem 1.1 is the development of an effective computational version of the strong approximation theorem for finitely generated Zariski-dense subgroups H of SL_{r}(\mathbb{P}) , where \mathbb{P} is a number field; cf. [ 22 , Window 9] and [ 7 ] . The associated algorithm is based on elimination of each \mathscr{C}_{i} as possibly containing congruence images of H modulo maximal ideals of a finitely generated subring R\subset\mathbb{P} such that H\leq SL_{r}(R) . By this process the algorithm finds the set of primes p modulo which H does not surject onto SL_{r}(p^{k}) for relevant k\leq|\mathbb{P}:\mathbb{Q}| . The classes \mathscr{C}_{1},\allowbreak\ldots\mathscr{C}_{8} may be eliminated by straightforward methods; as usual, \mathscr{C}_{9} is the most difficult class to handle. Possible congruence images in \mathscr{C}_{9} are ruled out by means of an upper bound on the orders of groups lying solely in \mathscr{C}_{9} . For this approach to be feasible, the primary requirement of any such bound on subgroup orders in SL_{r}(p^{k}) is that it must be independent of the characteristic p . A subsequent concern is optimizing efficiency of the algorithm; this depends on improvement of the initial explicit bounds that we derive in the paper. By a powerful result of Larsen and Pink [ 19 , Theorem 0.3] , if S is a finite simple group with a faithful linear or projective representation of degree m over a field of characteristic p , then either |S| is bounded above by a function of m only, or S is of Lie type in characteristic p . By Steinberg’s theorem [ 26 , Theorem 43] , S<\mathbf{G}\leq SL_{r}(\mathbb{F}) where \mathbf{G} is a simple algebraic group of the same Lie type as S over the algebraically closed field \mathbb{F} of characteristic p . To prove Theorem 1.1 , we therefore focus on the case where S is a (quasisimple, absolutely) irreducible subgroup of a simple algebraic group \mathbf{G}<SL_{r}(\mathbb{F}) . Let V be the \mathbf{G} -module afforded by this representation of \mathbf{G} . The above observation allows us to link our problem with the theory of Weyl modules for simple algebraic groups (see, for instance, [ 13 , Section 2.1] ). This is due to the fact that for each irreducible representation of a simple Lie algebra L over \mathbb{C} , and for every prime p , there exists an indecomposable \mathbf{G} -module W in characteristic p of the universal simple algebraic group \mathbf{G} of the same Lie type as L . This \mathbf{G} -module is referred to as a Weyl module . The dimension of W is equal to the dimension of the irreducible representation of L . Moreover, V is a composition factor of W whose highest weight coincides with that of V . If W is irreducible then \dim V=\dim W , and so L has an irreducible representation of prime degree r . Such representations are determined in [ 17 ] . In this case, by Theorem 2.1 below, we conclude: \mathbf{G}\cong SL(V) or SO(V) , or \mathbf{G} is of type A_{1} , or \mathbf{G} is of type G_{2} with r=7 . (*) The hypotheses of Theorem 1.1 exclude these possibilities. Thus we can assume that W is reducible, in which case we have the following result (proved in Section 3 ). Proposition 1.2 . Let \mathbf{G} be a simple algebraic group in characteristic p>0 , V an irreducible \mathbf{G} -module of dimension d with p -restricted highest weight \omega , and W a Weyl module for \mathbf{G} of highest weight \omega . If W is reducible then p<\allowbreak\dim W<d^{d^{2}/2} . Hence, if (*) does not hold, then Proposition 1.2 bounds p in terms of d . In fact the assumptions of Theorem 1.1 lead to a stronger conclusion. They imply that (*) does not hold and G is not a subgroup of SL_{r}(p^{i}) for all i properly dividing k . It will be seen that the number of irreducible subgroups G in question is bounded by a function of r , independently of p and k . This yields Theorem 1.1 . We reiterate that group orders