Hidden Momentum and the Absence of the Gravitational Spin Hall Effect in a Uniform Field
Andrzej Czarnecki *, Ting Gao * · 2025
Read Hidden Momentum and the Absence of the Gravitational Spin Hall Effect in a Uniform Field by Andrzej Czarnecki *, Ting Gao * (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-18096.txt.
Introduction
Andrzej Czarnecki and Ting Gao revisit a claim that gravity bends spinning particles sideways as they fall. The claimed drift, a spin Hall effect for gravity, would split a falling wave packet by its spin. Their check uses a spinning mass model and the quantum Dirac equation in a flat, even gravity field.
They find the past setup hid a catch: the packet was never truly at rest, since two kinds of momentum part ways when spin is present. That hidden push, not gravity, gave the sideways drift. Prepared with care, the packet stays centered to first order, and any true spin drift waits for far smaller terms. Even fields, they conclude, do not sort spins sideways.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrzej Czarnecki *, Ting Gao * |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-18096
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hidden Momentum and the Absence of the Gravitational Spin Hall Effect in a Uniform Field Andrzej Czarnecki *, Ting Gao * Abstract We re-examine the recent claim that a Dirac particle freely falling in a uniform gravitational field exhibits a spin-dependent transverse deflection (gravitational spin Hall effect). Using a circulating mass model, we show that hidden momentum arises in uniform fields when an object carries angular momentum. On the quantum side, we analyze the Dirac Hamiltonian in a uniform potential, construct its Foldy–Wouthuysen form, and evaluate the Heisenberg evolution of spin-polarized Gaussian packets. The state used previously, with ⟨ p ⟩ = 0 \langle p\rangle=0 , is not at rest: because canonical and kinetic momenta differ, the packet carries a spin-dependent hidden momentum from t = 0 t=0 . Imposing ⟨ x ( 0 ) ⟩ = ⟨ v ( 0 ) ⟩ = 0 \langle x(0)\rangle=\langle v(0)\rangle=0 requires a compensating spin-dependent ⟨ p ( 0 ) ⟩ \langle p(0)\rangle ; with this preparation ⟨ x ( t ) ⟩ = 0 \langle x(t)\rangle=0 to leading order in the gravitational acceleration g g . Generalizing, an exact Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation (linear in g g but to all orders in 1 / c 1/c ) shows that spin-dependent transverse motion begins no earlier than at O ( g 2 ) O(g^{2}) for a broad class of wave packets. We conclude that a uniform field does not produce a gravitational spin Hall effect at linear order; the previously reported drift stems from inconsistent initial states and misinterpreting canonical momentum. keywords gravitational spin Hall effect; hidden momentum † † firstpage: 1 † † volume: 11 † † issue: 11 † † articlenumber: 365 † † year: 2025 † † copyright-year: 2025 † † external-editor: László Árpád Gergely † † received: 30 September 2025 † † revised: 3 November 2025 † † accepted: 4 November 2025 † † published: 6 November 2025 † † hreflink: https://doi.org/10.3390/ universe11110365 † † titlecitation: Hidden Momentum and the Absence of the Gravitational Spin Hall Effect in a Uniform Field † † authornames: Andrzej Czarnecki and Ting Gao † † authorcitation: Czarnecki, A.; Gao, T. † † address: Department of Physics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2E1, Canada † † corresponding: Correspondence: [email protected] (A.C.); [email protected] (T.G.) † † reftitle: References \doinum 10.3390/universe11110365 1 Introduction Spin–orbit phenomena offer a probe of how internal angular momentum couples to background fields, and gravity is no exception Mathisson 1937 ; Mathisson 2010 ; Papapetrou 1951 ; Dixon 1970 ; Obukhov 2001 ; Silenko and Teryaev 2005 : curvature (encoded via the spin connection in the curved-space Dirac equation) can imprint helicity-dependent transverse shifts—often called the gravitational spin Hall effect (SHE)—with analogues in optics Onoda et al. 2004 ; Hosten and Kwiat 2008 , whose counterpart, “spinoptics” in curved spacetime, is still under active debate Frolov 2024 ; Frolov and Shoom 2024 ; Andersson and Oancea 2023 ; Deriglazov 2021 . A gravitational SHE would test the universality of free fall for spin degrees of freedom and semiclassical wave-packet dynamics Xiao et al. 2010 ; Silenko and Teryaev 2005 ; Obukhov 2001 and would have implications for precision interferometry near Earth and for polarization-dependent lensing in astrophysics Noh et al. 2021 ; Andersson and Oancea 2023 . The uniform-field limit is the critical baseline because most laboratory settings operate there; any transverse spin drift in this limit would be both experimentally accessible and conceptually consequential. Recent claims of a linear-in-time, polarization-dependent deflection for Dirac wave packets in a uniform field therefore warrant scrutiny. A tantalizing recent paper Wang 2024 claims that a Dirac particle freely falling in a constant, uniform gravitational field (such as near the Earth’s surface) may be deflected in a horizontal direction. Specifically, as shown in Figure 1 , a particle polarized along a horizontal y -axis and falling in the positive z -direction is deflected toward the \pm x direction, depending on the sign of its polarization. ( a ) ( b ) Figure 1: Two different types of trajectories for the motion of a particle with spin in a uniform gravitational field. ( a ) Free-fall motion with an initial horizontal velocity; ( b ) motion starting from rest, with the horizontal velocity developed through the gravitational spin Hall effect. Based on Equations (22)–(24) in Ref. Wang 2024 , the particle should follow a projectile trajectory as in ( a ); however, the graphic in that work shows trajectory ( b ), contradicting those equations. Here, we expand on a comment we submitted for consideration of publication Czarnecki and Gao and discuss phenomena related to hidden momentum. In Section 2 , we summarize the reasoning presented in Wang 2024 . In Section 3 , we present a simple model of circulating masses in a uniform gravitational field. We focus on various contributions to the linear momentum. Having developed this intuition, we return to the motion of a spinning particle in Section 4 , and in Section 5 we demonstrate the absence of the gravitational spin Hall effect in a uniform field. 2 Summary of Wang’s Study of the Gravitational Spin Hall Effect The analysis presented in Ref. Wang 2024 considers a state that, at the initial time t=0 , is described by a Gaussian wave packet, \psi\left({\bm{x}},t=0\right)=\frac{1}{\left(a^{2}\pi\right)^{3/4}}\exp\left(-\frac{{\bm{x}}^{2}}{2a^{2}}\right), (1) where a is a constant characterizing the spatial extension of the initial packet. The complete wave function also contains a Dirac spinor factor describing polarization along the \pm y -axis; it remains constant during free fall, so we omit it here. The time evolution of the wave packet is governed by the Dirac Hamiltonian with a linear potential term V\left(z\right)=-mgz describing the interaction with the gravitational field. This Hamiltonian is unitarily transformed using the Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation Foldy and Wouthuysen 1950 ; Foldy 2006 . It is found that at time t>0 the expectation values of the x and z coordinates are nonzero. For the z coordinate, this is, of course, as expected for free fall, \left\langle z\left(t\right)\right\rangle_{\pm}=\frac{gt^{2}}{2}, (2) where the subscript on the LHS refers to the y -polarization state. However, the x coordinate is also found to develop a nonzero, polarization-dependent expectation value: \left\langle x\left(t\right)\right\rangle_{\pm}=\mp\frac{\hbar gt}{4mc^{2}}. (3) We use SI units rather than setting \hbar=c=1 to emphasize the order of quantum and relativistic effects. The nonzero expectation value of a horizontal deflection is interpreted as a gravitational spin Hall effect, previously established only in non-uniform fields, such as those experienced by a particle flying by a star Liberman and Zel’dovich 1992 ; Frolov 2024 ; Frolov and Shoom 2024 ; Andersson and Oancea 2023 ; Yamamoto 2018 ; Bliokh et al. 2015 ; Noh et al. 2021 . An astonishing feature of Equation ( 3 ) is that the expectation value grows linearly with time. In other words, the x -component of velocity seems to be independent of time; it is nonzero even at t=0 when the wave packet is released. This contradicts the graphic in Ref. Wang 2024 . A motion with a constant horizontal velocity corresponds to a projectile trajectory depicted in Figure 1 a. However, for a phenomenon to be interpreted as a Hall effect, the particle should develop the transverse component