Humanlike AI Design Increases Anthropomorphism but Yields Divergent Outcomes on Engagement and Trust Globally
Robin Schimmelpfennig, Mark Diaz, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Aida Davani · 2025
Read Humanlike AI Design Increases Anthropomorphism but Yields Divergent Outcomes on Engagement and Trust Globally by Robin Schimmelpfennig, Mark Diaz, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Aida Davani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17898.txt.
Introduction
Robin Schimmelpfennig, Mark Díaz, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, and Aida Davani test what happens when a chatbot is made to feel more human. Over a billion people now talk with such systems, and fears about misplaced trust are common. The team ran two experiments with 3,500 people in ten countries, using live open chats.
People judged human likeness by chat flow, reply speed, and whether the bot took their view, not by deep claims about minds. Making the bot more human raised that feeling in every country, yet trust and engagement rose in some places and fell in others. Rules for such design, the authors argue, must respect local culture.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Robin Schimmelpfennig, Mark Diaz, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Aida Davani |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17898
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Humanlike AI Design Increases Anthropomorphism but Yields Divergent Outcomes on Engagement and Trust Globally Robin Schimmelpfennig, Mark Diaz, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Aida Davani Abstract Over a billion users across the globe interact with AI systems engineered with increasing sophistication to mimic human traits. This rapid adoption of humanlike AI has triggered urgent debate regarding Anthropomorphism, the attribution of human characteristics to synthetic agents, and its potential to induce misplaced trust or emotional dependency. However, the causal link between more humanlike AI design and subsequent effects on user engagement and trust has not been tested in realistic human-AI interactions with a global user pool. Prevailing safety frameworks continue to rely on theoretical assumptions derived from Western populations, overlooking the global diversity of AI users. Here, we address these gaps through two large-scale cross-national experiments (N=3,500) across 10 diverse nations, involving real-time and open-ended interactions with a state-of-the-art AI system. We find that when evaluating an AI’s human-likeness, users focus less on the kind of theoretical aspects often cited in policy (e.g., sentience or consciousness), but rather applied, interactional cues like conversation flow or understanding the user’s perspective. We also experimentally demonstrate that humanlike design levers can causally increase anthropomorphism among users; however, we do not find that humanlike design universally increases behavioral measures for user engagement and trust, as previous theoretical work suggests. Instead, part of the connection between human-likeness and behavioral outcomes is fractured by culture: specific design choices that foster self-reported trust in AI-systems in some populations (e.g., Brazil) may trigger the opposite result in others (e.g., Japan). Our findings challenge prevailing narratives of inherent risk in humanlike AI design. Instead, we identify a nuanced, culturally mediated landscape of human-AI interaction, which demands that we move beyond a one-size-fits-all approach in AI governance. 1 Introduction The rapid integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems into daily life is fundamentally shifting AI’s role from a mere technical tool to an active social partner 35 ; 14 ; 25 . Users increasingly rely on conversational agents not just for information and technical assistance, but for companionship, advice, and emotional support ( 26 ; 9 ; 41 ) . This “social leap” transforms the nature of human-technology interaction ( 19 ) , creating a critical tension in the design and governance of AI systems. On one hand, driven by intense competition for user attention and market share, commercial actors intentionally design AI systems that mimic human characteristics ( 8 ; 10 ; 34 ; 24 ) to deepen user engagement 24 . On the other, AI safety researchers and ethicists warn that exposure to increasingly humanlike systems poses significant psychological and social risks. Central to this concern is AI anthropomorphism—attributing human traits, such as intention, intelligence, and personality to these non-human agents ( 17 ; 31 ; 39 ; 11 ) . Crucially, AI anthropomorphism is hypothesized to stimulate user engagement and foster increased—and potentially misplaced—trust ( 1 ; 6 ; 45 ) . Prior work hypothesizes that such dynamics may, in turn, heighten user vulnerability to targeted persuasion, emotional attachment, and over-reliance on AI systems for high-stakes tasks for which the technology remains ill-suited ( 36 ; 30 ; 41 ; 27 ) . As the global user base of conversational AI expands ( 9 ) , reaching over a billion users on platforms such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude ( 22 ) , the urgency of understanding their psychological impact grows, particularly for more vulnerable populations 37 . In many ways, humanity is in the midst of a massive, real-time social experiment. Yet, we lack an evidence-based understanding of the role AI anthropomorphism plays in this dynamic. While theoretical frameworks have outlined potential adverse ethical and practical harms ( 44 ; 19 ) , empirical research has lagged behind. Most existing studies, with few exceptions ( 21 ) , rely on non-representative samples, correlational study designs or hypothetical vignettes that measure self-reported attitudes rather than actual behavior 15 ; 11 ; 3 . Furthermore, many studies evaluate isolated AI-generated output, stripping away the iterative nature of conversation 3 . These methodological constraints limit our ability to study AI anthropomorphism in ecologically valid settings, where perceptions are context-dependent and emerge dynamically through open-ended interaction 23 ; 19 . Compounding these limitations, existing research is overwhelmingly concentrated on Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic (WEIRD) populations 20 . This geographic bias implicitly assumes a universal AI experience, potentially overlooking the moderating role of culture in human-AI interaction 38 ; 28 . For example, Japanese culture and religious traditions that attribute spirit to non-human objects may predispose individuals to accept humanlike AI as social partners 33 . In contrast, Western traditions often maintain a sharper moral and ontological distinction between humans and machines, leading to greater skepticism toward attributing minds to artificial agents 16 ; 17 . Currently, most widely-used AI systems tend to reflect WEIRD humans and values 2 . However, with rapid AI adoption outside the US and Europe 9 and the emergence of models trained in non-Western regions 22 , a culturally inclusive research framework is no longer just an academic ideal—it is a practical and ethical imperative. Figure 1 : Two-stage experimental design for measuring AI anthropomorphism and its downstream affect across user groups. In both studies, participants first engage in an open-ended, multi-turn interaction with a chatbot (GPT-4o, August 2024), followed by questionnaires and behavioral tasks (for Study 2). To address these gaps, we conducted two large-scale experiments designed to collect causal, ecologically valid, and culturally diverse evidence on the mechanisms of AI anthropomorphism. Across both studies, 3,500 participants from 10 culturally diverse countries engaged in real-time, open-ended, and non-sensitive conversations in their native languages with a state-of-the-art chatbot (Figure 1 ). Study 1 focused on identifying the specific chatbot characteristics that trigger anthropomorphic perceptions and documenting baseline variations across sampled countries. We find that while the tendency to anthropomorphize AI varies significantly across countries and cultures, it is relatively high across most groups. Moreover, the specific cues users prioritize when evaluating human-likeness are mostly applied, such as conversation flow and latency, and deviate significantly from the abstract theoretical dimensions, such as sentience or intelligence, typically emphasized in prior literature on anthropomorphism. Building on these insights, Study 2 experimentally manipulated specific AI design aspects based on Study 1, grouping them into two treatment conditions labeled as design characteristics (DC) and conversational sociability (CS) to test their causal impact on user behavior. While these manipulations reliably increased anthropomorphism across all tested countries, the downstream effects were notably non-uniform. Contrary to prevailing assumptions, increased human-likeness and anthropomorphism often increased engagement but did not translate into a universal increase in trust across user groups. We validated this through a battery of self-reported and behavioral measures for both engagement (e.g., via analyzing chat logs) and trust (e.g., via the Trust Game 5 ). Instead, we observed heterogeneous treatment effects, where more humanlike AI systems influenced engagement and trust only within specific cultural and demographic subgroups. Our findings demonstrate that while human-like design reliably increases anthropomorphism, its effects on trust and engagement are culturally contingent—the same design choices that foster trust in some populations may undermine it in others. This challenges prevailing assumptions that human-like