Investigating the AGN variability timescale - black hole mass relationship with Gaia, SDSS and ZTF

Adrien Hélias, Sarah C. Gallagher, Pauline Barmby · 2025

Read Investigating the AGN variability timescale - black hole mass relationship with Gaia, SDSS and ZTF by Adrien Hélias, Sarah C. Gallagher, Pauline Barmby (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17811.txt.

Introduction

Adrien Hélias, Sarah C Gallagher, and Pauline Barmby test whether a black hole's flicker speed can weigh it. Feeding black holes in distant galaxies brighten and dim at random, and heavier holes tend to vary more slowly. If that link were tight, a light curve alone could give masses where spectra cannot, especially for small holes.

The team mined a Gaia catalog of 872,228 active galaxies, matching spectra from SDSS and light curves from the ZTF survey. Gaia's own sampling proved too sparse for reliable flicker measures outside a narrow band of timescales. ZTF's denser curves behaved. Their catalog of 127 galaxies, with both flicker fits and spectrum-based masses, confirms the timescale-mass link found before, no tighter. No low-mass holes turned up in the sample, leaving that end of the scale still uncalibrated.

Catalog record

CREATORAdrien Hélias, Sarah C. Gallagher, Pauline Barmby
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17811

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Investigating the AGN variability timescale - black hole mass relationship with Gaia, SDSS and ZTF Adrien Hélias, Sarah C. Gallagher, Pauline Barmby Abstract Active galactic nuclei (AGNs) exhibit variability in their luminosities with timescales that correlate with the mass of the black hole at the centre of the AGN. Presently, the empirical correlation lacks sufficient precision to confidently convert these timescales into black hole masses, especially at the low-mass end. To find more AGNs with timescale measurements, we study a very large catalog of AGNs from the Gaia Data Release 3 called GLEAN (Gaia variabLE AgN; 872 ​ 228 872~228 objects). We identify GLEAN objects with optical spectra from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR17 and light curves from the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) DR21. After fitting the light curves with a damped random walk model, we find that the GLEAN light curves have insufficient sampling to extract reliable amplitude and timescale measurements outside the range of 50–100 days. On the other hand, well-sampled ZTF light curves allow more accurate estimations of these parameters. The fractional variability amplitude is an effective, model-independent metric for measuring variability amplitude, but only when derived from high-quality light curves. We provide a catalog of 127 GLEAN AGNs with spectroscopic virial black hole masses, and variability amplitudes and timescales. Though we do not find any low-mass black holes in this AGN sample, we confirm a relationship between the damped random walk timescale and the black hole mass that is consistent with previous studies. I Introduction Active galactic nuclei (AGN) are growing supermassive black holes located at the centres of galaxies ( 38 ; 50 ) . They emit a considerable amount of light and may generate powerful winds and jets of matter ( 17 ; 8 , e.g.,) . Most of the optical and ultraviolet light from active galaxies does not come from the stars; it comes from the accretion disk of the supermassive black hole (SMBH) ( 55 ; 36 ; 25 ) . The entire emission of the AGN spans the electromagnetic spectrum from radio to X-ray wavelengths ( 45 , e.g.,) . All active AGNs exhibit some variability in luminosity regardless of their mass and physical size ( 57 ) . This variability arises from changes in the accretion disk continuum emission; subsequently, the fluxes of the broad emission lines in AGN spectra respond after a time lag ( 46 ) . This time delay is due primarily to the light travel time from the accretion disk to the broad-line region (BLR) ( 47 ) . A part of this time delay is due to the time for the BLR gas to respond, but this is expected to be minor compared to the light travel time delay. Optical variability is a relatively recent method used to find AGNs that is effective even for X-ray-faint AGNs. The processes driving the optical continuum variability occur on timescales of hours to years depending on the physical size of the AGN accretion disk ( 46 ) . Stochastic models applied to AGN light curves such as Continuous Auto-Regressive Moving Average (CARMA) models ( 29 ) , which include the popular damped random walk (DRW) model, have proven to be useful tools to characterize variability timescales ( 28 ; 32 ; 39 ; 30 ; 5 ; 42 ) . It has also been shown that the variability can deviate from these models ( 43 ; 65 ; 26 ; 23 ; 52 ; 53 ) . CARMA models are not physically based but are still useful empirical mathematical tools for extracting more information from the data. Furthermore, the parameters have been shown to correlate with the AGN properties. For example, several researchers have found an empirical relationship between the variability timescale and the black hole mass of the AGN ( 28 ; 39 ; 33 ; 23 ; 54 ; 9 ; 3 ; 53 ) . 9 in particular (B21 hereafter), found a positive correlation between the rest-frame DRW timescale and the black hole mass (see Figs. 1 and 3 in B21). B21 kept 67 AGNs in their final sample, with high-quality light curves and a mix of reverberation-mapped and single-epoch spectroscopic black hole masses. Most of their AGNs possess black hole masses between a few 10 7 and 10 {}^{9}~M_{\odot} . However, the slope of the correlation is primarily determined by the small batch of points located between 10 4 and 10 {}^{7}~M_{\odot} . 59 added 79 data points of AGNs located in dwarf galaxies to the B21 sample. These new points lie between 10 6 and 10 {}^{7.5}~M_{\odot} in black hole mass, and are consistent with the best-fit line of B21. Nevertheless, AGNs with a central black hole mass in the 10^{2}-10^{6}~M_{\odot} range are poorly observed and are needed to further constrain the relationship at low masses. Being able to confidently infer a black hole mass from a DRW timescale would be extremely useful, particularly in cases where AGN have weak or undetectable broad lines. This is especially the case for low-mass, low-luminosity AGNs. More data are required to confirm or contradict the full shape of the relationship. To better constrain the rest-frame DRW timescale - black hole mass correlation of B21 and 59 , we studied a very large catalog of AGNs called GLEAN (Gaia variabLE AgN; 11 ). GLEAN is the first Gaia catalog of variable AGNs, coming from the Gaia Data Release 3 (Gaia DR3; 19 ). It contains astrometric, photometric and rough spectroscopic information on 872~228 extragalactic objects, which were selected solely on Gaia variability. The GLEAN catalog includes light curves for each object, one per filter, with irregular sampling, taken over the course of 3 years. Most importantly, 11 estimated that the purity of the sample, which is the number of genuine AGNs divided by the number of objects in the catalog, is at least 95%, with conservative assumptions. This is an immense, all-sky collection of AGNs selected on variability; likely some of them are new AGN identifications. Previous studies have used Gaia DR3 to perform varstrometry – a technique to trace the apparent movement of the centroid of the total flux from a source when it exhibits variability in its light curve – to identify unresolved off-nucleus or lensed quasars on sub-kpc scales ( 12 ; 35 ) . Others have used Gaia DR3 as a secondary catalog for finding dual AGNs with the multipeak method ( 60 ) . In this work, we explore and characterize the GLEAN sample by cross-matching it with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) ( 63 ) and the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) ( 40 ) , as well as studying the correlation between the central black hole mass and the variability timescale with a subset of GLEAN AGNs. In Section II , we describe the GLEAN sample and we cross-match GLEAN with SDSS to analyze the SDSS classification of the GLEAN AGNs and their properties. In Section III , we detail the stochastic modelling performed to obtain timescales and amplitudes from light curves, and we cross-match GLEAN with ZTF to obtain well-sampled light curves for our AGNs. We calculate virial black hole masses from SDSS optical spectra, and we compare

Read the complete text