The influence of energy-containing scales on the distribution of spectral energy transfers
Arthur Couteau, Panayotis Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler, Patrick Jenny · 2025
Read The influence of energy-containing scales on the distribution of spectral energy transfers by Arthur Couteau, Panayotis Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler, Patrick Jenny (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17804.txt.
Introduction
Arthur Couteau, Panayotis Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler, and Patrick Jenny audit turbulence's energy economy transfer by transfer. In stirred fluid, big eddies hand their energy to smaller ones in a cascade, but the bookkeeping between individual wave modes was usually blurred into group averages. Their simulations itemize every exchange within each interacting trio of modes.
A simple potential, built from the modes' own energy content, predicts where the fiercest transfers cluster. Shifting where the stirring injects energy moves that cluster with it: the energy-rich scales, not the trio's geometry, set the map. Direct swaps with the energy-rich range are choked by the fluid's incompressibility, leaving only residue near home. A classic closure theory, EDQNM, matches the audit well. Turbulence modelers gain a sharper ledger.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arthur Couteau, Panayotis Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler, Patrick Jenny |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17804
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The influence of energy-containing scales on the distribution of spectral energy transfers Arthur Couteau, Panayotis Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler, Patrick Jenny Abstract We present computations of individual mode-to-mode energy transfers from direct numerical simulations of homogeneous isotropic turbulence. Unlike previous approaches based on shell-filtered velocity fields, this method distinguishes between the energy exchanged by each pair of modes within a triad. We introduce a potential function based on the energy content of the modes involved and show that it predicts the distribution of intense energy transfers in the vicinity of the sampling mode considered. By performing simulations with forcing applied at intermediate wavenumbers, we demonstrate that the region of most intense transfers is determined by the spectral location of the energy-containing scales rather than by the local or nonlocal character of the triad. Direct energy exchanges with the energy-containing range are suppressed by geometric constraints from the divergence-free condition, but persist as residuals when the sampling mode is close to the energy-containing scales. The comparison with an estimator derived from EDQNM theory shows good agreement and recovers the forward, scale-local nature of energy transfer consistent with the cascade picture. 1 Introduction The energy cascade has been a cornerstone concept in turbulence theory, where energy is supplied to the system at large scales and dissipated at small scales. The classical Kolmogorov picture (K41) says that between those two ends of the spectrum, the energy is transported locally from scale to scale. As the energy travels from the large scales, where it is created to the small scales, where it is dissipated, the information contained about the large scale flow eventually gets lost and the statistics become isotropic (Kolmogorov’s local isotropy hypothesis). In spectral space, the mode-to-mode energy transfer between two modes \bm{\kappa} and \bm{\kappa^{\prime}} implies a third mode, \bm{\kappa}-\bm{\kappa^{\prime}} , such that they form a triangle called a triad interaction. As the idea of scale locality of energy transfer is that only scales similar to a given scale contribute to energy transfer across the latter, it is expected that energy transfer occurs due to local triads, where |\bm{\kappa}|\approx|\bm{\kappa^{\prime}}|\approx|\bm{\kappa}-\bm{\kappa^{\prime}}| . An early investigation of spectral locality came from Kraichnan ( 20 ) . The introduction of a parameter v , measuring the ratio of the smallest to the middle wavenumber in a triad, in the Direct Interaction Approximation ( 19 ) closure lead to the discovery that a significant part of the energy transfer is due to interactions in which v<0.5 . While this may seem contradictory, the locality of a triad, satisfied for |\bm{\kappa}|\approx|\bm{\kappa^{\prime}}|\approx|\bm{\kappa}-\bm{\kappa^{\prime}}| , is not to be confused with the locality of energy transfer, which states that energy transfer should be high between neighbouring scales |\bm{\kappa}|\approx|\bm{\kappa^{\prime}}| . Indeed, these early results suggested that nonlocal triads consisting of two neighbouring scales and a large scale (small wavenumber) are crucial for energy transfer. Domaradzki and coworkers ( 9 ; 10 ; 30 ; 12 ; 25 ) explicitly calculated band to band energy transfer functions using filtered velocity fields obtained from Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS). They showed that the most intense energy transfers occurred between neighbouring wavenumbers, mediated by a small wavenumber, thus establishing the concept of “local energy transfer in nonlocal triad interaction”. While it is in agreement with the classical picture of the energy cascade with local transfers, this point of view clashes with another assumption of the Kolmogorov framework, that is the universality of small scales. Indeed, the statistical independence of small scales from large scale flow is questioned by the fact that the most intense triad interactions include the large scales. Subsequent studies ( 29 ; 31 ; 32 ) , while confirming the predominance of nonlocal triads in the energy flux, argued that the mode-to-mode energy transfers are not the appropriate quantities to determine the locality of energy transfer. Instead, integrated quantities like the shell-to-shell energy transfer functions should be investigated. In this aggregate function, the influence of the nonlocal interactions producing intense local energy transfers diminishes. Indeed, there is a fixed number of nonlocal interactions compared to the total number of interactions, and further cancellations due to sign definite regions are expected. 14 ; 15 introduced another definition of local flux to show that local interactions do dominate in the limit of high Reynolds number, in order to justify unversality of small scale statistics. Later, they extended the previous work for non-sharp filters and obtained bounds on the contribution of nonlocal interactions to the local energy flux ( 16 ; 13 ; 2 ) . Following works ( 1 ; 23 ; 8 ; 7 ; 11 ) continue to support the “local energy transfer in nonlocal triad interaction” perspective via higher Reynolds number simulations, while showing a weakening, but non-vanishing, of these interactions as the Re is growing ( 24 ) . With the use again of statistics based on spectral band-truncated velocity fields, they showed the coexistence of nonlocal interactions and local energy cascade. Furthermore, they highlighted that the extent of locality, that is the number of bands involved in intense local energy transfers, is dependent on the numerical forcing conditions. Furthermore, while not directly looking at the locality question, recent studies ( 18 ; 28 ) investigate the “path” of energy across spectral modes and show that phase correlation in phase space is also local, suggesting that energy is transferred locally between neighbouring modes. While the locality of energy transfer is established in all works mentioned above, there is controversy about which triad interactions are responsible for it, the main question being “are the large scales involved in energy transfer at any other scale?”. We would like to put this question in the general context of the statistical independence of small scales, as assumed by Kolmogorov theory for large enough Re . In this regard, there are still ongoing discussions about deviations from the expected behaviour of universal small scale statistics. For example, a slower return to isotropy or even a persistence of anisotropy at small scales from large scale forcing was observed numerically ( 3 ; 4 ) and experimentally ( 5 ; 6 ) . These are usually attributed to moderate Reynolds number effects, see 17 for a discussion on the topic. In the present work, we compute individual mode-to-mode energy transfers directly from DNS, which allows us to distinguish between the energy exchanged by each pair of modes within a triad. We introduce a potential function based on the energy content of the modes involved and show that it predicts the distribution of intense energy transfers. By performing simulations with forcing applied at intermediate wavenumbers, we demonstrate that the most intense transfers are determined by the spectral location of the energy-containing range rather than by the local or nonlocal character of the interaction. The methodology and definitions are presented in Sec. 2 , followed by results for classical large-scale forcing in Sec. 3 and for shifted forcing configurations in Sec. 4 . 2 Methodology 2.1 Incompressible flow in spectral space The Navier-Stokes equations for an incompressible flow are given by \displaystyle\partial_{t}u_{j}+u_{l}\frac{\partial u_{j}}{\partial x_{l}}=-\frac{\partial p}{\partial x_{j}}+\nu\frac{\partial^{2}u_{j}}{\partial x_{l}\partial x_{l}}\quad\mathrm{and} (1) \displaystyle\frac{\partial u_{j}}{\partial x_{j}}=0. (2) Using the Fourier series representation of the velocity field u_{j}(\bm{x}) as u_{j}(\bm{x})=\sum_{\bm{\kappa}}\hat{u}_{j}(\bm{\kappa})e^{i\bm{\kappa}\cdot\bm{x}}, (3) the Navier-Stokes equations are transformed to