Magnetic field spreading from stellar and galactic dynamos into the exterior

Axel Brandenburg, Oindrila Ghosh, Franco Vazza, Andrii Neronov · 2025

Read Magnetic field spreading from stellar and galactic dynamos into the exterior by Axel Brandenburg, Oindrila Ghosh, Franco Vazza, Andrii Neronov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17770.txt.

Introduction

Axel Brandenburg and three co-authors rethink how a star's or galaxy's magnetism leaks into the space around it. Textbooks cap a dynamo with a tidy current-free field, in which the dipole pattern fades slowest with distance. Real exteriors are turbulent and conduct poorly, so the field does not settle tidily; it diffuses outward instead.

Under diffusion, the ordering flips: a quadrupole pattern can grow a toroidal part that fades even more slowly than the dipole. The field still dies off fast beyond a magnetosphere boundary. That kills one hopeful idea, that galaxies collectively seeded the magnetism found in cosmic voids; those void fields must be primordial leftovers. Radio telescopes may test the picture, since quadrupole glow should ring evenly around its galaxy.

Catalog record

CREATORAxel Brandenburg, Oindrila Ghosh, Franco Vazza, Andrii Neronov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17770

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Magnetic field spreading from stellar and galactic dynamos into the exterior Axel Brandenburg, Oindrila Ghosh, Franco Vazza, Andrii Neronov Abstract The exteriors of stellar and galactic dynamos are usually modeled as a current-free potential field. A more realistic description might be that of a force-free magnetic field. Here, we suggest that, in the absence of outflows, neither of those reflect the actual behavior when the magnetic field spreads diffusively into a more poorly conducting turbulent exterior outside dynamo. In particular, we show that the usual ordering of the dipole magnetic field being the most slowly decaying one is altered, and that the quadrupole can develop a toroidal component that decays even more slowly with radial distance. This behavior is best seen for spherical dynamo volumes and becomes more complicated for oblate ones. In either case, however, those fields are confined within a magnetosphere beyond which the field drops exponentially. The magnetosphere expands ballistically (i.e., linearly in time t t ) during the exponential growth phase of the dynamo, but diffusively proportional to t 1 / 2 t^{1/2} during the saturated phase. We demonstrate that the Faraday displacement current, which plays a role in a vacuum, can safely be neglected in all cases. For quadrupolar configurations, the synchrotron emission from the magnetosphere is found to be constant along concentric rings. The total and the polarized radio emissions from the dipolar or the quadrupolar configurations display large scale radial trends that are potentially distinguishable with existing radio telescopes. The superposition of magnetic fields from galaxies in the outskirts of the voids between galaxy clusters can therefore not explain the void magnetization of the intergalactic medium, reinforcing the conventional expectation that those fields are of primordial origin. I Introduction The magnetic fields in stars and galaxies can be explained by dynamo action converting the kinetic energy in the turbulence and the differential rotation into magnetic energy. Such systems are traditionally computed by assuming that the magnetic field outside the dynamo domain continues as a current-free potential field. Mathematically, this can be formulated as a suitable boundary condition applied on the outer radius of a spherical ( Steenbeck & Krause 1969 ) or an ellipsoidal domain ( Stix 1975 ) . In cylindrical and several other coordinate systems, on the other hand, there exists no method to apply a potential field boundary condition. One possibility is then to adopt a perfectly conducting boundary condition ( Meinel et al. 1990 ) . However, a more physical procedure might be to embed the galaxy in a poorly conducting exterior ( Elstner et al. 1990 ; Brandenburg et al. 1990 ) , because this would approximate a vacuum in the limit of zero conductivity. The assumption of a vacuum outside the dynamo was never thought to be more than just a mathematically convenient construct. However, in recent work of Garg et al. 2025 , a vacuum was assumed to exist even in the far-field of galaxies. Their study, which does not involve outflows or winds of any type, spawned subsequent investigations that addressed the question what the nature of the magnetic field in the far-field of galaxies actually is ( Seller & Sigl 2025 ; Ghosh et al. 2025 ) . The present paper is a follow-up of our earlier work ( Ghosh et al. 2025 ) . Here, we focus on a more detailed numerical study, approach in some cases the limit of extremely poor conductivity, and make contact with possible measurements of synchrotron emission. It is commonly assumed that a more realistic boundary condition corresponds to an electrically conducting exterior, although not necessarily to a perfectly conducting one. In addition, if the density of the exterior is low and the exterior is at rest, the magnetic field would be force-free, i.e., the cross product of current density and magnetic field vanishes. Since in MHD, the current density is proportional to the curl of the magnetic field, both fields must then be parallel to each other. Such fields would therefore be eigenfunctions of the curl operator and are also known as Chandrasekhar-Kendall functions ( Chandrasekhar & Kendall 1957 , after the early paper by) . Adopting a perfectly force-free magnetic field is generally problematic because it might topologically not be realizable and it would also take some time to establish such a field in the vast exterior of a dynamo. Therefore, to alleviate this problem, a commonly used approach in solar physics is the magneto-frictional one ( Yang et al. 1986 ) . Here, the Lorentz force is allowed to drive flows through a friction term. These flows tend to relax the field until the force is minimized. In a similar approach, we study here the spreading of galactic magnetic fields into intergalactic space by solving the mean-field momentum equation and modeling the dynamo exterior as a medium with a certain viscosity and electric conductivity. A vacuum would correspond to the limit of very small conductivity or very large magnetic diffusivity. A large effective magnetic diffusivity emerges in a turbulent environment when modelling the large-scale field as an average or mean field, {\overline{\bm{B}}} , where the overbar denotes some suitable averaging. However, as we explain below, the diffusivity needed to reproduce the electric properties of a vacuum would be at least eight orders of magnitude larger than what can be explained by turbulence. It is useful to represent the resulting magnetic field as a multipole expansion with terms proportional to Y_{\ell}^{m}(\theta,\phi) , where \ell and m are the spherical harmonic degree and order, respectively. For a vacuum, the magnetic field decays with radius r like r^{-(\ell+2)} . The lowest multiple is the dipole with \ell=1 , so the field decays like r^{-3} , while for a quadrupole, \ell=2 , so the field decays like r^{-4} . In an electrically conducting environment, magnetic fields are expected to be close to force-free and can then decay differently. If the gas pressure is negligible, force-free magnetic fields obey {\overline{\bm{J}}}\times{\overline{\bm{B}}}=0 , i.e., the current density {\overline{\bm{J}}}={\bm{\nabla}}\times{\overline{\bm{B}}}/\mu_{0} with \mu_{0} being the vacuum permeability, is parallel to {\overline{\bm{B}}} . This means that {\bm{\nabla}}\times{\overline{\bm{B}}}=\alpha_{\mathrm{ff}}{\overline{\bm{B}}} , where \alpha_{\mathrm{ff}} is a coefficient that must be constant along the magnetic field line, but it can vary perpendicular to it ( Priest 1982 ) . To explain the toroidal magnetic fields observed around solar-type stars, Bonanno 2016 and Bonanno & Del Sordo 2017 considered force-free magnetic fields in mean-field dynamo exteriors. They assumed the coronal magnetic field of those stars to be harmonic, but they did not consider the question how such magnetic field configurations can be achieved in a finite time. Here, we show that such fields can only be produced within a slowly expanding, but finite magnetosphere around the dynamo. This also has applications to galactic dynamos and the question whether such magnetic fields can explain the magnetic field in the voids between galaxy clusters ( Garg et al. 2025 ; Seller & Sigl 2025 ; Ghosh et al. 2025 ) . II Our model II.1 Basic equations We solve the mean-field dynamo equations using spherical coordinates, (r,\theta,\phi) . We refer to earlier work by Jabbari et al. 2013 and Jakab & Brandenburg 2021 for a similar treatment. To quantify the difference between a poorly

Read the complete text