GW231123: Overlapping Gravitational Wave Signals?
Qian Hu, Harsh Narola, Jef Heynen, Mick Wright, John Veitch, Justin Janquart, Chris Van Den Broeck · 2025
Read GW231123: Overlapping Gravitational Wave Signals? by Qian Hu, Harsh Narola, Jef Heynen, Mick Wright, John Veitch, Justin Janquart, Chris Van Den Broeck (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17550.txt.
Introduction
Qian Hu and coauthors reanalyze GW231123, a gravitational wave signal read as a merger of two black holes. Their total mass comes to 190 to 265 solar masses, the heaviest merger yet detected. Waveform models of the signal disagree about the source, and the paper asks whether the data hide something more complex.
The team finds that a model with two overlapping signals fits far better, with Bayes factors around 100 to 10,000 in its favor. That reading also largely removes the clashes between waveform models. They also check the earlier event GW190521 and find no sign of the same effect there. The work warns that the loudest, heaviest signals may blend two events into one, which would change how their masses and spins are read.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Qian Hu, Harsh Narola, Jef Heynen, Mick Wright, John Veitch, Justin Janquart, Chris Van Den Broeck |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17550
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
GW231123: Overlapping Gravitational Wave Signals? Qian Hu, Harsh Narola, Jef Heynen, Mick Wright, John Veitch, Justin Janquart, Chris Van Den Broeck Abstract The recently discovered gravitational wave event GW231123 was interpreted as the merger of two black holes with a total mass of 190-265 M ⊙ M_{\odot} , making it the heaviest such merger detected to date. Whilst much of the post-discovery literature has focused on its astrophysical origins, primary analyses have exhibited considerable discrepancies in the measurement of source properties between waveform models, which cannot reliably be reproduced by simulations. Such discrepancies may arise when an unaccounted overlapping signal is present in the data, or from phenomena that produce similar effects, such as gravitational lensing or overlapping noise artifacts. In this work, we analyse GW231123 using a flexible model that allows for two overlapping signals, and find that it is favoured over the isolated signal model with Bayes factors of ∼ 10 2 − 10 4 \sim 10^{2}-10^{4} , depending on the waveform model. These values lie within the top few per cent of the background distribution. Similar effects are not observed in GW190521, another high-mass event. Under the overlapping signals model, discrepancies in the measurement of source properties between waveform models are largely mitigated, and the two recovered sources show similar properties. Additionally, we find that neglecting an additional signal in overlapping-signal data can lead to discrepancies in the estimated source properties resembling those reported in GW231123. I Introduction The LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA collaboration 1 ; 9 ; 10 recently reported the detection of the gravitational wave (GW) signal, GW231123_135430 (hereafter referred to as GW231123), from the merger of a binary black hole (BBH) system 2 . With an estimated total mass of 190-265 M_{\odot} , it became the heaviest BBH system detected to date, surpassing GW190521 8 , whose total mass was 126-170 M_{\odot} . The individual black hole masses of GW231123 lie within or above the pair-instability black hole mass gap predicted by standard stellar evolution theory 23 ; 24 , making the event particularly intriguing from an astrophysical perspective. Several formation scenarios have been proposed, including hierarchical mergers 49 ; 34 ; 33 , mergers in active galactic nucleus disks 14 ; 21 , primordial black holes 58 ; 20 , cosmic strings 19 , and evolution of massive stars under specific conditions such as low-metallicity 26 ; 51 , moderate magnetic fields 26 , and high spins 18 ; 38 . Constraints on fundamental physics are also made based on the parameter estimation of GW231123 15 ; 12 ; 56 . Determining the formation channel of a BBH depends on its source properties, i.e., masses, distance, spins, and such. Measuring these properties for an unusual system such as GW231123 is also a challenging task which heavily relies on how accurately we can model the signal. In this scenario, these are known as waveform models which describe the evolution of spacetime 39 ; 54 ; 22 ; 52 . For GW231123, the measured source properties using different waveform models show significant discrepancies 2 , which cannot be reliably reproduced by the simulations. The scale of discrepancies appears to be larger compared to the expected statistical fluctuations and also larger compared to the systematic differences between the waveform models. This behaviour may be attributed to, but not limited to, inaccuracy of the waveform models, missing physical effects, or noise fluctuations in the data 41 ; 47 ; 44 . An additional source for such discrepancies may be the presence of overlapping signals 37 ; 28 ; 45 ; 43 ; 29 ; 31 ; 57 ; 32 ; 13 , i.e., signals arriving at the detectors close to each other in time. Since GW detection rate estimates disfavour such scenarios 3 , the state-of-the-art parameter estimation pipelines do not account for overlapping signals 11 . However, when not accounted for, they may bias the measurements of source properties such as masses, distance, and spins 45 ; 43 ; 30 . The fainter overlapping signal may be fitted differently by different waveforms, leading to waveform systematics which cannot be reproduced in simulations accounting for only one isolated signal. This seems to be the case for GW231123, i.e., the estimated source properties using different waveform models do not agree, raising the question: could there be an additional signal overlapping with the GW231123? To address this question, we analyse GW231123 with a flexible signal model that accounts for two independent overlapping signals. In principle, such a model could also fit the faint noise artefacts if they are overlapping with the signal 41 . Significant interest in determining the presence of an additional signal near GW231123 is generated by the recent gravitational lensing interpretation of the event 46 ; 27 ; 35 ; 4 . Specifically, the scenario where a gravitational wave signal is lensed by a massive object in its path 50 , and the two images produced by lensing are not well-separated in time, they can imitate the features of two overlapping signals 36 . This lensing scenario may be viewed as a specific sub-case of our overlapping signal case of more generalised overlapping signal analysis, and may affect the significance of its lensing interpretation 40 . To make a confident detection of a lensed gravitational wave signal, it would be crucial to rule out the possibility of coincidental overlap of signals. II Bayesian model selection We employ the Bayesian model selection technique to determine which model, two overlapping signals or the isolated signal, fits better to the data corresponding to GW231123. Specifically, we compute the Bayesian evidence \mathcal{Z} , \mathcal{Z}=\int\mathrm{d}\vec{\theta}~\pi(\vec{\theta})~\mathcal{L}(\vec{d}|\vec{\theta}), (1) for each model. In Eq. ( 1 ), \vec{\theta} denotes the model parameters, \vec{d} denotes the detector strain, \pi(\vec{\theta}) denotes the prior on \vec{\theta} and \mathcal{L}(\vec{d}|\vec{\theta}) denotes the likelihood of \vec{d} given \vec{\theta} . For stationary Gaussian noise, the log-likelihood function for N signals can be written as 55 ; 45 , \ln{\mathcal{L}(\vec{d}|\vec{\theta})}\propto-\frac{1}{2}\left<\vec{d}-\sum_{i=1}^{N}\vec{h}_{i}(\vec{\theta})\right|\left.\vec{d}-\sum_{i=1}^{N}\vec{h}_{i}(\vec{\theta})\right>, (2) where <\cdot|\cdot> denotes the noise-weighted inner product 25 and \vec{h}(\vec{\theta}) denotes the signal model. The detector strains and the noise power spectral densities for were obtained from the publicly available data release corresponding to GW231123 16 . We analyse a 4 seconds long segment centred at the trigger time of the event. The frequency range of our analysis is [20,448] Hz. We adopt the prior distributions from the public data release 16 , with the exceptions that the chirp mass and luminosity distance priors are extended to 250 M_{\odot} and 12 Gpc respectively. We restrict our analysis to two overlapping signals owing to the computation cost and the lower odds of more than two signals overlapping. When using the overlapping signals model, the prior on each signal is identical to the isolated signal model. Hence, the prior volume for the overlapping signals model is the square of the one for the isolated signal. We do not include detector calibration uncertainties since calibration envelopes are mostly consistent with zero 6 . We use the Bilby codebase (v2.6.0) in combination with the Dynesty sampler (v2.1.5) to compute the evidence 11 ; 48 . XPHM NRSur TPHM XO4a \log_{10}\mathcal{Z}_{\mathcal{S}} -3774.14 -3771.68 -3769.88 -3767.95 \log_{10}\mathcal{Z}_{\mathcal{OS}} -3769.92 -3769.72 -3768.21 -3767.74 \log_{10}\mathcal{B}^{\mathcal{OS}}_{\mathcal{S}} 4.22 1.96 0.79 0.21 Table 1: Bayesian evidence