Most certainly certain? The Impact of Contract for Difference Design on Renewables’ Strike Prices and Electricity Market Risks Journal: arXiv

Silke Johanndeiter, Jonas Finke, Justus Heuer · 2025

Read Most certainly certain? The Impact of Contract for Difference Design on Renewables’ Strike Prices and Electricity Market Risks Journal: arXiv by Silke Johanndeiter, Jonas Finke, Justus Heuer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17508.txt.

Introduction

Silke Johanndeiter, Jonas Finke, and Justus Heuer compare three flavors of a policy meant to steady wind power income. A two-way Contract for Difference pays a wind farm when market prices fall below a set strike price, and claws money back when prices soar. Governments across Europe lean on such deals, yet the fine print varies, and each variant spreads risk in its own way.

The team derives ideal strike prices on paper, then replays 36 market futures in an energy model. Every design cut price swings for both shoppers and investors by a lot. Shopper prices barely differed across designs. A capacity-based design calmed investor profits most, but it also dulls the price signals that steer farms to build where the grid needs them. That trade-off is the paper's warning.

Catalog record

CREATORSilke Johanndeiter, Jonas Finke, Justus Heuer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17508

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Most certainly certain? The Impact of Contract for Difference Design on Renewables’ Strike Prices and Electricity Market Risks Journal: arXiv Silke Johanndeiter, Jonas Finke, Justus Heuer Abstract Weather, technological and regulatory uncertainties expose actors in highly renewable electricity markets to substantial price and volume risks. Two-way Contracts for Difference (CfDs) can mitigate these risks. They stipulate payments between the government and generators of renewable electricity based on the difference of a strike and a reference price, whose definition and unit of payment differ between CfD designs. We study the effect of three different CfD designs on wind power profit and consumer price volatility under the consideration of uncertain market outcomes in a highly renewable, sector-coupled electricity market. First, we analytically derive optimal strike prices under uncertainty. Second, we numerically determine optimal strike prices based on market expectations retrieved from optimising a set of 36 market scenarios in an energy system model. Third, we study the distribution of ex post market revenues, CfD payments and consumer prices across all 36 scenarios. Compared to purely market-based consumer prices and investor profits, we find all CfDs to significantly reduce volatility. For consumer prices, results show no substantial differences between CfD designs. For investor profits, we identify the highest volatility reduction under a capacity-based CfD with a reference price similar to power plants’ individual market revenues. Since such a CfD design is known to diminish the effect of price signals on investment decisions, our results reveal a trade-off between incentivising system-friendliness and reducing investor risk. † † highlights: Derivation of optimal strike prices in competitive CfD auction under uncertainty Investor expectations formed through 36 market scenarios in energy system model CfDs significantly reduce both profit and consumer price volatility CfD design affects profit volatility, but hardly consumer price volatility Reference power plant drives both profit volatility and system-friendly invest 1 Introduction The transition to a climate-neutral energy system exposes electricity market actors to significant risks. Consequences of a severe price shock in the European electricity market became evident during the energy crisis in 2022, when renewables achieved windfall profits at the expense of rising consumer bills ( 4 ) . As a response, the European Union introduced two-way Contracts for Difference (CfDs) as the mandatory support scheme for renewables due to their capability to mitigate risks for both generators and consumers of electricity ( 21 ) . They stipulate payments between the government and producers of renewable electricity defined by the difference of an ex post realised reference price and an ex ante agreed-upon strike price over a given contracting period – typically the expected plant operation time ( 56 ) . Two-way CfDs generally decrease generator revenues in times of high electricity prices, and increase them, when electricity prices are low, affecting both average revenues and revenue volatility. If CfD expenses and revenues are passed on to consumers via levies, they impact consumer prices in the opposite direction. There exist numerous design options of CfDs that affect their potential to reduce volatility of investor profits and consumer prices. Our work assesses the impact of three two-way CfD design options on these values in a highly renewable European electricity market. 1.1 Derisking and financing costs In the last decade, renewables became competitive with fossil fuels in terms of levelised cost of electricity (LCOE) ( 41 ) . Since then, the primary objective of renewable support schemes has shifted from increasing average revenues to reducing revenue uncertainty ( 6 ) . Underlying revenue risks can be split into two components ( 56 ) : 1. Volume risk: The uncertainty about the amount of generated electricity, which mainly depends on the weather and curtailment. 2. Price risk: The uncertainty about the market value of the generated electricity, which depends on overall market trends, the total fleet of generators, infrastructure constraints, and political factors. Several studies provide empirical or model-based evidence that lowering these revenue risks leads to reduced financing costs for renewable investments. For the Australian electricity market, 32 show an empirical correlation between the availability of long-term risk hedging options for renewable investments and lower LCOEs. Using a liquidity management model, 67 demonstrate how revenue stabilisation with CfDs decreases financing costs by allowing to decrease debt size. In a costly state verification framework, 58 predicts the effect of revenue variability on the default risk and, subsequently, cost of capital. 42 combine a model-based calculation of cost of debt and equity with global data on policy regimes and cost of capital across different countries to show an empirical correlation between risk reduction through policy and lower financing costs. These, in turn, have a significant positive effect on the expansion of renewable electricity generation as a capital-cost-intensive technology ( 5 ; 23 ) and thus also reduce total costs in highly renewable power system ( 34 ) . There exist private markets for long-term contracts to hedge risks. Forward and future contracts provide hedges up to 5 or even 10 years ahead of delivery ( 22 ) . In the context of renewables, the market for private power purchase agreements (PPAs) with contract durations of 15 years or more is growing ( 50 ) . However, the market for long-term private-to-private risk hedging instruments still lacks liquidity – an issue coined the missing risk market problem by 19 . Various instruments, such as market-maker obligations, can increase market liquidity ( 55 ) . Nevertheless, some scholars argue for the necessity of governmentally issued long-term contracts ( 27 ; 47 ) . In addition to addressing the lack of liquidity, they reduce price risks for household consumers, who lack access to long-term private risk-hedging instruments, such as PPAs, whose offtakers are dominated by corporate consumers ( 45 ) . 1.2 CfD design elements Two-way CfDs are such governmentally issued long-term contracts. They have two main design elements that affect their potential to reduce risk and their impact on system costs. The first element is the reference price . It is mainly determined by the length of the reference period, i.e., the time frame used to calculate it, and the selection of reference generators, i.e., whether all or only some power plants are considered. The simplest CfD types compare individual market performance in (quarter-)hourly trading windows to the strike price. Such simple CfDs entirely hedge price risks ( 64 ) . However, this also implies that they eliminate market price signals, thereby incentivising to design, site and operate a power plant in a manner that merely maximises full load hours. Conversely, more sophisticated CfDs preserve market price signals in both the investment and operational phase by decoupling individual market revenues from CfD payments. These CfD types use market revenues of a reference power plant (e.g., the market’s average) over longer periods (e.g., a month or a year) as reference price. In this case, power plants can retain market revenues above the reference price. Thus, this CfD design incentivises investments in power plants with an above-average market performance ( 57 ; 43 ; 44 ) . These power plants can be deemed more system-friendly , as higher market values typically imply a higher temporal match of a power plant’s supply and load, therefore inducing lower balancing costs ( 62 )

Read the complete text