When to compute in space
Rajiv Thummala and Gregory Falco · 2025
Read When to compute in space by Rajiv Thummala and Gregory Falco (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17054.txt.
Introduction
Rajiv Thummala and Gregory Falco ask where a spacecraft workload should run: on board, in an orbital data center, at a ground edge node, or in Earth cloud. Each tier trades latency, reliability, power, link limits, cost, and legal fit in unlike ways.
Their frame turns placement into a scored optimization. Measurable metrics are normalized, feasibility limits applied, and a single utility score ranks tiers, even when data are incomplete. Two sample workloads show how the scoring picks a home tier and why. The method gives mission designers a structured, extensible way to reason about compute placement as space architectures grow more mixed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rajiv Thummala and Gregory Falco |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17054
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When to compute in space Rajiv Thummala and Gregory Falco Abstract Spacecraft increasingly rely on heterogeneous computing resources spanning onboard flight computers, orbital data centers, ground station edge nodes, and terrestrial cloud infrastructure. Selecting where a workload should execute is a nontrivial multi objective problem driven by latency, reliability, power, communication constraints, cost, and regulatory feasibility. This paper introduces a quantitative optimization framework that formalizes compute-location selection through empirically measurable metrics, normalized scoring, feasibility constraints, and a unified utility function designed to operate under incomplete information. We evaluate the model on two representative workloads demonstrating how the framework compares compute tiers and identifies preferred deployment locations. The approach provides a structured, extensible method for mission designers to reason about compute placement in emerging space architectures. 1 Introduction Modern satellites generate unprecedented volumes of data. Historically, this data followed the simple flow of being captured through the payload, stored in onboard memory, and downlinked to ground stations for processing. This paradigm is shifting, however, as new computational paradigms and space infrastructure is enabling diverse options for where computation occurs. In the decades to come, mission architects can choose to perform computation for a spacecraft on the onboard flight computer, an orbital data center, ground station edge nodes, and terrestrial data centers. However, the decision of where to execute a computational workload in the context of space systems remains a complex multi-objective optimization problem. Each compute tier presents distinct trade-offs across latency, reliability, power consumption, communication overhead, and cost. Furthermore, regulatory considerations such as ITAR restrictions, data sovereignty requirements, and mission security policies may impose hard constraints that supersede performance considerations. Existing approaches to compute placement in distributed systems typically assume homogeneous network conditions and focus on cloud-edge trade-offs in terrestrial settings. These frameworks do not adequately capture the unique constraints of space systems such as intermittent line-of-sight communication windows, orbit-dependent propagation delays, power budgets dominated by solar panel geometry and eclipse periods, radiation effects on computational reliability, and the need to balance operational complexity against mission autonomy. This paper [ 7 ] introduces a formal optimization framework designed specifically for this heterogeneous space compute landscape, providing mission architects with a principled method to navigate these trade-offs and select the appropriate compute tier for each workload. 2 Prior Art Several studies describe the ongoing shift in how computing is conceived and implemented in the space domain. [ 6 ] outlines four principal phases in the development of space computing architectures. The first, distributed embedded systems, characterizes spacecraft composed of independent embedded units. The second, integrated electronic systems, consolidates multiple functions onto a single platform. The third, external intelligent systems, augments the integrated architecture with high performance computing modules capable of executing complex algorithms, including artificial intelligence. The fourth, integrated intelligent systems, unifies the external and integrated architectures into a single construct with reduced power consumption, smaller volume, and improved performance. Although the work provides a clear articulation of the advantages and limitations of each paradigm, it does not supply a formal decision-making construct that would allow mission engineers to determine which architecture is most appropriate for a given application. [ 4 ] similarly compares multiple space computing paradigms and examines their operational constraints, incorporating examples from real systems such as the James Webb Space Telescope. The authors argue that an orbital data center located at the Earth–Moon L1 point could support activities such as calibration, cosmic ray scrubbing, and first-order science processing by receiving raw instrument data directly from JWST. This paper, however, also stops short of offering a rigorous decision function to guide engineers in selecting an optimal computing architecture. Although academic literature on orbital data centers remains sparse, the concept of employing sun-synchronous orbits to provide large-scale AI computation and inference has gained widespread media attention. [ 1 ] highlights that orbital solar power emerges as a cost-saving cornerstone for data centers, addressing the staggering energy burdens of terrestrial facilities where electricity devours 40% to 60% of annual expenses—up to $5-10 million yearly for hyperscale operations. In sun-synchronous orbits, solar panels thrive under uninterrupted sunlight, unhindered by clouds, pollution, or atmospheric filtering, basking in an irradiance of 1,366 W/m² compared to Earth’s diluted average. For instance, deploying 1,000 kg of arrays via Falcon 9 at $2,500 per kg incurs a mere $2.5 million upfront, yielding 500 kW of capacity at roughly $5,000 per kW, which is on par with ground-based setups when amortized over extended lifecycles. This shift slashes annual operational expenditures to zero post-deployment, swaps water-guzzling cooling (4-5 million gallons daily) for efficient radiative methods, and eases regulatory hurdles from zoning and land grabs to streamlined ITU spectrum and orbital licensing. Ultimately, solar-powered orbital platforms not only eradicate millions in energy and cooling costs but also propel sustainability goals, redefining data center economics for a 10- to 20-year horizon. Several organizations have proposed architectures based on this model. Google Suncatcher [ 3 ] seeks to deploy solar-powered satellites carrying TPU accelerators, with the number and size of TPUs determined by engineering and economic constraints. Their design places satellites in a dawn–dusk sun-synchronous low Earth orbit to maximize solar power availability while keeping ground communication latency and launch costs low. Their stated rationale rests on the scale of solar output, which exceeds global human electricity consumption by more than fourteen orders of magnitude, implying that future large-scale AI workloads may be most efficiently powered by direct access to solar flux. Other entities, including Starcloud [ 2 ] and Axiom Space [ 5 ] , are developing orbital data center concepts intended for AI training workloads. Axiom Space asserts that such an architecture provides vastly greater volume, external mounting area, electrical power, and heat rejection capacity, along with a benign pressurized environment that supports commercial-grade hardware. They further argue that routine crewed and resupply missions would enable economical delivery of upgrades, maintenance, and physical commodities to LEO [ 5 ] . Taken together, these works constitute a small fraction of the emerging discourse on space-based computation, whether academic or media-driven. They nonetheless lack formal structure and do not identify the empirical metrics needed to determine when an orbital data center, rather than terrestrial infrastructure, represents the optimal solution for a given mission profile. 3 Compute-Location Optimization Model The ability for a spacecraft to offload compute to heterogeneous resources has received significant attention in recent literature. This can include the onboard computer, orbital data centers, ground station edge nodes, and terrestrial cloud infrastructure. Determining where a process should execute involves balancing competing objectives including latency, reliability, power consumption, communication overhead, cost, and regulatory feasibility. To formalize this decision process, we introduce a constrained multi criteria optimization model that evaluates various computational tiers using a unified utility function. The selected compute location is the one that maximizes the effective utility subject to the spacecraft’s mission constraints. 3.1 Variables and Notation Let j\in\{\mathrm{FC},\mathrm{ODC},\mathrm{GSE},\mathrm{TDC}\} denote a compute tier: onboard flight computer (FC), orbital data center (ODC), ground station edge (GSE), or terrestrial data center (TDC). Each tier is described by a vector of empirically measurable metrics. Let i\in I index the set of all criteria. Table 1 summarizes the variables used in the optimization formulation. Table 1: Metrics and variables used in the compute-location optimization