Quantifying Systematic Age Discrepancies in Very Young Star Clusters Facilities: HST (WFPC2)

Joseph Guzman, Jeremiah W. Murphy, Emma Beasor, Julianne J. Dalcanton, Nathan Smith, Mojgan Aghakhanloo, Benjamin F. Williams, Andrés F. Barrientos · 2025

Read Quantifying Systematic Age Discrepancies in Very Young Star Clusters Facilities: HST (WFPC2) by Joseph Guzman, Jeremiah W. Murphy, Emma Beasor, Julianne J. Dalcanton, Nathan Smith, Mojgan Aghakhanloo, Benjamin F. Williams, Andrés F. Barrientos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17033.txt.

Introduction

Joseph Guzman and coauthors measure age gaps in three very young star clusters, NGC 2004, NGC 7419, and NGC 2100, using a statistical tool called Stellar Ages on their color-magnitude diagrams. Recent work hinted that ages for clusters under 50 million years clash by tracer.

Two gaps stand out. Red supergiant ages run older than bright blue star ages by 0.60 dex, a factor of about four. And low-mass main-sequence stars fall short of counts expected from a standard initial mass function, given the red supergiant and blue star tallies. The team reads both gaps as population-level clashes with single-star evolution models, unique to massive star life cycles.

Catalog record

CREATORJoseph Guzman, Jeremiah W. Murphy, Emma Beasor, Julianne J. Dalcanton, Nathan Smith, Mojgan Aghakhanloo, Benjamin F. Williams, Andrés F. Barrientos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17033

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantifying Systematic Age Discrepancies in Very Young Star Clusters Facilities: HST (WFPC2) Joseph Guzman, Jeremiah W. Murphy, Emma Beasor, Julianne J. Dalcanton, Nathan Smith, Mojgan Aghakhanloo, Benjamin F. Williams, Andrés F. Barrientos Abstract We infer the ages of three young stellar clusters—NGC 2004, NGC 7419 and NGC 2100—using Stellar Ages, a statistical algorithm designed to infer stellar population properties from color–magnitude diagrams. Recent studies have revealed emerging inconsistencies in the inferred ages of very young ( ≤ \leq 50 Myr-old) stellar clusters. Here, we identify and quantify two distinct discrepancies. First, ages inferred from red supergiants (RSGs) are systematically older—by about a factor of three—than those inferred from bright blue stars, with a median age offset of Δ ​ log 10 ⁡ ( t / yr ) = 0.55 ± 0.09 ​ dex \Delta\log_{10}(t/{\rm yr})=0.55\pm 0.09~{\rm dex} ( t B ≈ t RSG / 3.55 t_{B}\approx t_{\rm RSG}/3.55 ). Second, given the observed numbers of RSGs and bright blue stars, there is a pronounced deficit of lower-mass main-sequence stars relative to expectations from a standard initial mass function. Although these discrepancies resemble those reported for intermediate-age clusters, their magnitude and character suggest that they are unique to the evolution of massive stars. Together, these results highlight population-level inconsistencies with single-star evolutionary models and underscore the need to consider multiple evolutionary tracers when age-dating young clusters. By combining individual stellar ages with population-wide constraints, our approach refines prior work on cluster age determinations and provides new insight into massive star evolution and the interpretation of cluster demographics. show][email protected] show][email protected] ][email protected] ] ] ][email protected] ] ] I Introduction Star clusters have long served as testing grounds for stellar evolution theory, under the assumption that they form as simple stellar populations (SSPs), groups of stars with a common age and metallicity ( 69 ; 8 ) . This assumption makes them valuable benchmarks for testing stellar models. However, past work has often shown that SSP assumptions can break down ( 3 ; 60 ) . Color–magnitude diagrams (CMDs) of young and intermediate-age clusters often reveal features that are difficult to reconcile with a single-age population, including multiple main sequences, and stars more luminous than the nominal turnoff ( 47 ; 45 ) . These features complicate cluster age measurements while highlighting limitations in stellar evolution models. One example is the study of 4 , who analyzed four young clusters: NGC 2004 and NGC 2100 in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), and NGC 7419 and \chi Persei in the Milky Way. By fitting isochrones to different CMD features, they found a wide range of inferred ages, from about 7 to 23 Myr. The choice of stellar tracer strongly affected the results: lowest luminosity RSGs, main-sequence turnoff stars, and luminosity functions did not yield consistent ages. They suggested that binary interactions or mergers could produce apparently rejuvenated stars, mimicking a younger population ( 22 ; 66 ) . This tension is not unique to the Magellanic clusters. A wide body of work has shown that apparent age spreads in young clusters may reflect physical processes other than prolonged star formation. Binary interactions are now known to be common among massive stars, with multiplicity fractions exceeding 70% ( 64 ; 53 ) . These interactions can create rejuvenated mass gainers or merger products that appear as anomalously young bright blue stars, qualitatively analogous to blue stragglers in older populations ( 65 ; 33 ) . Rotation offers an additional channel for extending main-sequence lifetimes and altering luminosities ( 48 ; 28 ) . Rapid rotators, such as Be stars, are particularly prevalent in young clusters and may contribute to the observed CMD complexities ( 61 ) . These mechanisms not only complicate cluster age-dating, but also bear directly on massive star evolution. Understanding how cluster demographics are shaped by binaries and rotation therefore informs both stellar evolution modeling and confidence in mass estimates for core-collapse supernova progenitors. A variety of statistical methods have been developed for CMD analysis, ranging from isochrone fitting of individual stars to synthetic CMD approaches that reconstruct star-formation histories ( 39 ; 24 ; 19 ; 58 , e.g.,) . These frameworks have proven effective in many contexts, yet they often face challenges in young clusters where only a small number of evolved stars dominate the age signal. In such regimes, traditional CMD binning approaches can yield unstable results, while methods tailored to individual stars often neglect the population context. The Stellar Ages algorithm builds on this body of work by combining individual-star age estimates with population-wide inference, enabling consistency tests across distinct stellar tracers. In this paper, we revisit three of these clusters with a new statistical approach. We apply Stellar Ages ( 38 ) , a Bayesian algorithm designed to infer population properties directly from CMDs. Unlike traditional isochrone overlaying techniques, Stellar Ages provides posterior age distributions for both individual stars and the ensemble, enabling systematic comparisons between different stellar tracers. By testing whether populations such as RSGs, main-sequence stars, and bright blue stars yield consistent age distributions, we identify systematic discrepancies that reveal where current single-star models fail to reproduce the observed diversity in very young clusters. The paper is organized as follows: in Section II we describe the photometric datasets, sample selection, and adopted cluster parameters; Section III outlines the Stellar Ages algorithm; Section IV presents the results, including inferred age distributions, population mismatches, and the role of bright blue stars; Section V interprets these findings in the context of previous work, stellar evolution models, and binary evolution; and Section VI summarizes our conclusions. II Data and Clusters The goal of this study is to compare age estimates for distinct stellar age tracers, RSGs, main sequence (MS) stars, and bright blue stars, in three young nearby clusters. The sample consists of two clusters in the LMC (NGC 2100 and NGC 2004) and one in the Milky Way (NGC 7419). 4 also analyzed \chi Persei using the Kitt Peak photometry of 17 , but the Kitt Peak dataset differs substantially from the others in both filter coverage and depth, and does not provide a complete or homogeneous sample of massive stars. After quality cuts, the photometry of \chi Persei contained too few bright stars for a stable Stellar Ages analysis, which undercuts a meaningful comparison across our age tracers. For these reasons we did not include \chi Persei in our final sample. To ensure direct comparability, we rely, where possible, on the same archival photometric datasets used in 4 , with targeted adjustments to account for our more restrictive spatial selection criteria. These restrictions are necessary to maintain internal consistency across populations and to avoid artificially inflating number densities. II.1 Archival Photometry For the LMC clusters NGC 2100 and NGC 2004, we adopt the B- and V- band dereddened photometry from 57 , originally compiled from 7 . The Niederhofer study is based on archival imaging from the Hubble Space Telescope, obtained using the Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2). The HST WFPC2 observations underlying the photometry for NGC 2100 and NGC 2004 were obtained under HST Program 5475 (PI: Shara) and are available through the ESA Hubble Science Archive; the corresponding dataset can be accessed via https://doi.org/10.5270/esa-a431vi2

Read the complete text