Comparing Homodyne and Heterodyne Tomography of Quantum States of Light
Rhea P. Fernandes, Andrew J. Pizzimenti, Christos N. Gagatsos, Joseph M. Lukens · 2025
Read Comparing Homodyne and Heterodyne Tomography of Quantum States of Light by Rhea P. Fernandes, Andrew J. Pizzimenti, Christos N. Gagatsos, Joseph M. Lukens (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17031.txt.
Introduction
Rhea P. Fernandes and coauthors compare homodyne and heterodyne tomography, two ways to rebuild quantum states of light from measurements. Non-Gaussian states are key resources for photonic quantum work, so picking the better rebuild method matters.
Mixing Fisher information math with simulated experiments, they test both methods on a range of non-Gaussian states. Homodyne tomography beat heterodyne for every state tried. Yet the gap was far narrower than the textbook Cramer-Rao bound suggests, so heterodyne stays closer than lore implies. The findings give labs a grounded rule for choosing measurement plans in continuous-variable quantum systems, where both methods are on the shelf.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rhea P. Fernandes, Andrew J. Pizzimenti, Christos N. Gagatsos, Joseph M. Lukens |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17031
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparing Homodyne and Heterodyne Tomography of Quantum States of Light Rhea P. Fernandes, Andrew J. Pizzimenti, Christos N. Gagatsos, Joseph M. Lukens Abstract Non-Gaussian quantum states are critical resources in photonic quantum information processing, rendering their generation and characterization of increasing importance in quantum optics. In this work, we theoretically and numerically analyze the relative efficiency of homodyne versus heterodyne measurements for reconstructing non-Gaussian states, a major outstanding question in continuous-variable tomography. Combining a Fisher information-based formalism with simulated experiments, we find homodyne tomography to outperform heterodyne measurements for all non-Gaussian states tested, although the separation between the two modalities proves significantly narrower than suggested by the asymptotic Cramér–Rao lower bound. Our results should find use for optimizing measurement strategies in practical continuous-variable quantum systems. I Introduction Continuous-variable (CV) quantum optics presents valuable opportunities for quantum information processing (QIP) 7 . In contrast to discrete-variable (DV) photonic quantum information, where historically the most common qubit has been a single photon spread over two modes 18 ; 19 , the fundamental units of information in CV approaches are “qumodes”—single modes that can carry many photons 4 . CV quantum systems furnish unique capabilities complementary to more established DV formalisms. In quantum communications, CV quantum key distribution can be realized with inexpensive off-the-shelf detection systems from classical coherent communications 13 ; 22 , while quantum sensors based on squeezed light enable quantum sensitivity enhancements even for extremely bright fields 48 ; 23 ; 49 . Computationally, Gaussian boson sampling (GBS) unlocks quantum advantages more readily than DV boson sampling due to deterministic state generation 15 ; 20 , while Gottesman–Knill–Preskill (GKP) encodings provide a compelling path for error correction 12 . Within this CV ecosystem, the distinction between Gaussian and non-Gaussian quantum states has proven useful both theoretically and experimentally. Defined by Wigner functions that are themselves Gaussian 58 , Gaussian states can be generated deterministically with existing technology and encompass such optical workhorses as coherent, thermal, and squeezed states. Yet Gaussian states can be efficiently simulated classically 5 , making non-Gaussian resources (either states or measurements) critical for universal QIP 25 ; 57 . Beyond arguably straightforward examples such as single-photon Fock states 27 , non-Gaussian photonic states are notoriously difficult to generate, but experimental progress is accelerating. Indeed, foundational cat state examples based on photon subtraction 34 ; 31 ; 53 ; 33 ; 46 ; 11 have recently been extended to highly multimode non-Gaussian states 39 , and GBS experiments (for which photon detection represents the needed non-Gaussian resource) 60 ; 35 ; 61 ; 3 ; 59 ; 50 —including a recent demonstration of an optical GKP qubit 21 —inspire optimism for a variety of configurations for tailored non-Gaussian state generation based on squeezed inputs, multiport interferometers, and partial mode detection 9 ; 42 ; 38 ; 45 ; 51 ; 56 ; 36 ; 37 . As such non-Gaussian CV states become increasingly common, so too does the need for their efficient characterization. Homodyne and heterodyne tomography represent natural choices—the former detecting a single field quadrature per mode per state copy, the latter detecting two quadratures in parallel. Both approaches are tomographically complete and thus guaranteed to recover the ground truth asymptotically. However, the efficiency with which they do so can depend strongly on the state in question. Although previous research has explored this question for Gaussian states 40 ; 30 ; 47 , to our knowledge no prior work has considered the general case of arbitrary CV states. Thus, there exists no answer to the question: For a given non-Gaussian state, is homodyne or heterodyne tomography more efficient? In this paper, we explore this question systematically in both theory and simulation. After deriving the classical Fisher information (CFI) associated with either homodyne or heterodyne measurements on arbitrary single-mode quantum states, we perform maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) on simulated data generated by a variety of quantum systems, including random mixed states and selected Gaussian and non-Gaussian examples up to a photon number cutoff of 10. Interestingly, while the homodyne simulations show good agreement with expectations from the Cramér–Rao lower bound (CRLB), estimation errors for the heterodyne tests deviate significantly from the CRLB even up to 10 9 state copies. Notwithstanding, for all states examined, both the CFI and empirical MLE tests convincingly highlight the effectiveness of homodyne over heterodyne measurements in CV state estimation—not just for non-Gaussian states, but also Gaussian states parametrized generically (i.e., without enforcing Gaussianity). Collectively, our results should prove useful in the continued progress of CV quantum information, furnishing important tools and insights for efficient tomographic schemes. II Theory II.1 Background CV state representations.— Quantum state tomography (QST) is the process by which a quantum state is reconstructed using measurements on a collection of identical copies 29 ; 16 . To uniquely identify the state, it is desirable for the measurements to be tomographically complete, meaning they are sensitive to all unknown parameters that describe the quantum system. In the CV regime in which the signals of interest can contain an uncertain number of photons, field quadrature measurements are often performed. The phase of this quantum measurement is set by a local oscillator (LO). For this study, we consider ground truth quantum states in a single optical mode (spatial, temporal, and polarization), each described by a density matrix in the Fock basis of the form \rho=\sum_{m=0}^{\infty}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\rho_{mn}\ket{m}\bra{n}. (1) Equivalently, \rho can be represented via quasiprobability distributions, such as the Wigner function 28 W(x,p)=\frac{1}{\pi}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dy\,\braket{x-y|\rho|x+y}e^{-2\mathrm{i}py} (2) and Husimi Q function 32 Q(\alpha)=\frac{1}{\pi}\braket{\alpha|\rho|\alpha}. (3) We adopt the \hbar=1 convention where \ket{x} is the \theta=0 version of the general quadrature eigenstate |x_{\theta}\rangle at angle \theta 28 : \braket{n|x_{\theta}}=\frac{1}{\pi^{1/4}\sqrt{2^{n}n!}}e^{\mathrm{i}n\theta}e^{-x^{2}/2}H_{n}(x), (4) with H_{n}(x) a Hermite polynomial. The coherent state \ket{\alpha} follows the standard form \braket{n|\alpha}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{n!}}e^{-|\alpha|^{2}/2}\alpha^{n}, (5) also expressed in the Fock basis. The QST problem can therefore be summarized as obtaining an estimate of any of the above equivalent state representations [Eqs. ( 1 – 3 )] through measurements on a collection of copies. Homodyne detection.— Homodyne detection directly measures the phase-dependent quadrature of the optical field by mixing the state with an LO with phase \theta on a beamsplitter 52 ; 44 ; 55 . Balanced detection is then performed on the two outputs. In the typical case, the beam splitter has a 1:1 split ratio (50% transmission and 50% reflection). Figure 1 (a) shows the basic configuration for homodyne detection, where we assume perfect matching of the spatio-polarization and temporal modes for the LO and signal. For each copy of the quantum state, this returns one measurement result x with a probability density function (PDF) 29 ; 8 \begin{split}f_{\theta}(x)&=\sum_{m=0}^{\infty}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\rho_{mn}\frac{e^{-\mathrm{i}(m-n)\theta}}{\sqrt{\pi m!n!2^{m+n}}}e^{-x^{2}}H_{m}(x)H_{n}(x)\\ &=\braket{x_{\theta}|\rho|x_{\theta}}.\end{split} (6) For \rho=\ket{0}\bra{0} , Eq. ( 6 ) reduces to a normal distribution with variance \braket{\Delta x^{2}}=\frac{1}{2} as required under the \hbar=1 convention. Significantly, the homodyne PDF is directly related to the Wigner function according to f_{\theta}(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dp\,W(x\cos\theta-p\sin\theta,x\sin\theta+p\cos\theta), (7) so that homodyne tomography can be viewed as sampling the Wigner function at angles \theta determined by the LO 28 . FIG. 1: Schematic of (a) homodyne detection and (b) heterodyne detection. Heterodyne detection.— Heterodyne detection 54 ; 8 first splits the signal in two with a 50/50 beamsplitter and then performs homodyne detection separately on the two outputs,