Algorithmic UDAP DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX XXX-XXX-XXX CCS: Social and professional topics Computing / technology policy CCS: Human-centered computing
Talia Gillis, Riley Stacy, Sam Brumer, Emily Black · 2025
Read Algorithmic UDAP DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX XXX-XXX-XXX CCS: Social and professional topics Computing / technology policy CCS: Human-centered computing by Talia Gillis, Riley Stacy, Sam Brumer, Emily Black (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-17007.txt.
Introduction
Talia Gillis and coauthors compare two US legal tools for judging algorithmic bias in lending: disparate impact doctrine and UDAP, the ban on unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices. Disparate impact has long grounded fair lending law, while regulators now test UDAP as a second path.
The team formalizes both doctrines and runs them in a simulated lending market. They argue UDAP is not a copy of disparate impact but a distinct frame. Its unfairness prong adds tests of avoidable harm and balance of harms and gains, and its deception and abuse prongs can catch harms the older doctrine misses. Gaps remain, so the authors call for clearer regulatory guidance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Talia Gillis, Riley Stacy, Sam Brumer, Emily Black |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-17007
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Algorithmic UDAP DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX XXX-XXX-XXX CCS: Social and professional topics Computing / technology policy CCS: Human-centered computing Talia Gillis, Riley Stacy, Sam Brumer, Emily Black Abstract . This paper compares two legal frameworks—disparate impact (DI) and unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices (UDAP)—as tools for evaluating algorithmic discrimination, focusing on the example of fair lending. While DI has traditionally served as the foundation of fair lending law, recent regulatory efforts have invoked UDAP, a doctrine rooted in consumer protection, as an alternative means to address algorithmic discrimination harms. We formalize and operationalize both doctrines in a simulated lending setting to assess how they evaluate algorithmic disparities. While some regulatory interpretations treat UDAP as operating similarly to DI, we argue it is an independent and analytically distinct framework. In particular, UDAP’s “unfairness” prong introduces elements such as avoidability of harm and proportionality balancing, while its “deceptive” and “abusive” standards may capture forms of algorithmic harm that elude DI analysis. At the same time, translating UDAP into algorithmic settings exposes unresolved ambiguities, underscoring the need for further regulatory guidance if it is to serve as a workable standard. 1. Introduction For decades, the disparate impact (DI) doctrine has served as the cornerstone of fair lending law, providing a framework for identifying and remedying discriminatory practices that disproportionately affect protected groups, even in the absence of intentional discrimination. Under statutes like the Fair Housing Act (FHA) and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), the DI framework follows a well-established three-part burden-shifting test: plaintiffs must first demonstrate that a facially neutral practice produces disparate outcomes for protected groups; defendants can then assert a business justification for the practice; and finally, plaintiffs may show that the same business interest could be served by a less discriminatory alternative ( 12 ; 45 ; 47 ) . Recent regulatory developments have reshaped the legal landscape for addressing algorithmic discrimination. Under the Biden administration, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) advanced the idea that the prohibition on unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices (UDAP), 1 1 1 As will be explained below, Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act ( 43 ) prohibits unfair and deceptive acts or practices and is typically referred to as “UDAP”. Section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act ( 21 ) , prohibits unfair, deceptive, and/or abusive acts or practices and is typically referred to as “UDAAP”. Because this article focuses primarily on the “unfairness” prong, for simplicity, we use the term “UDAP” to refer collectively to the FTC Act and Dodd-Frank provisions, even though Dodd-Frank’s provision includes an “abusive” prong. When discussing Dodd-frank specifically we may refer to the provision as “UDAAP”. originally rooted in consumer protection law, could serve as an additional tool for addressing discrimination, including algorithmic discrimination in lending. By contrast, the current Trump administration has signaled growing skepticism toward disparate impact liability 2 2 2 See recent Executive Order, 88 . In the first Trump administration, there were also attempts to pull back on DI enforcement. See then-Acting Director Mick Mulvaney’s statement that the CFPB will reexamine its guidance on disparate impact liability under the ECOA ( 14 ) . and toward expansive uses of UDAP in the anti-discrimination context. Together, these shifts point in divergent directions, creating uncertainty about which legal framework will guide the evaluation of algorithmic lending practices and underscoring the need to clarify how DI and UDAP differ in structure, scope, and normative foundation. These developments raise fundamental questions about the relationship between UDAP and DI. While some regulatory interpretations treat UDAP as operating similarly to DI, we argue that the underlying structure and normative foundations of these frameworks differ. UDAP’s “unfairness” prong requires showing that a practice causes substantial injury that is not reasonably avoidable and is not outweighed by countervailing benefits—elements that differ from traditional DI analysis. Meanwhile, UDAP’s “deceptive” and “abusive” standards may capture forms of algorithmic harm that fall outside the scope of DI entirely. Although UDAP has been identified as a possible tool against algorithmic discrimination ( 52 ; 77 ) , its practical implications remain largely unexplored, particularly in contexts where machine learning’s complexity intersects with shifting legal standards. As lenders increasingly deploy sophisticated algorithms for credit decisions, understanding how different legal frameworks would evaluate the same algorithmic system becomes crucial for both compliance and policy development. Yet the technical operationalization of these legal standards—translating abstract legal concepts into concrete, measurable criteria—has received limited attention in existing scholarship. These doctrinal differences are particularly important in the context of algorithmic lending. As financial institutions increasingly deploy complex machine learning models for credit decisions, the question is how legal standards can be translated into workable criteria for evaluating these systems. Yet the technical operationalization of doctrines such as disparate impact and UDAP—translating abstract legal concepts into concrete, measurable criteria—has received limited attention in existing scholarship. This paper addresses this gap by providing the first technical comparison of DI and UDAP as frameworks for evaluating algorithmic discrimination in lending. We make several key contributions. First, we formalize both legal doctrines in technical terms, creating operational criteria that can be applied to algorithmic systems. Second, we demonstrate through simulation how these frameworks would evaluate the same lending algorithm, revealing where they converge and diverge in their assessment of algorithmic practices. Third, we identify critical ambiguities and open questions that must be resolved through regulatory guidance to make UDAP a workable standard for algorithmic governance. Our analysis reveals that while UDAP and DI may sometimes reach similar conclusions about particular algorithmic practices, they reflect fundamentally different approaches to evaluating potential harms. UDAP’s incorporation of proportionality analysis through its requirement that harms not be outweighed by countervailing benefits introduces a form of cost-benefit balancing that is largely absent from traditional DI doctrine. This difference has significant implications for how algorithmic systems are evaluated and what kinds of justifications are deemed acceptable for practices that produce disparate outcomes. Moreover, our technical implementation highlights numerous areas where existing UDAP guidance provides insufficient clarity for algorithmic applications. Questions such as what constitutes “substantial injury” in the context of algorithmic lending decisions, how to assess whether discriminatory harms are “reasonably avoidable,” and how to weigh business benefits against discriminatory costs under the “unfairness” prong of UDAP remain largely unresolved. These ambiguities create significant uncertainty for both regulated entities seeking to ensure compliance and enforcers attempting to apply the doctrine consistently. Our focus on better understanding the UDAP framework as a tool for addressing discriminatory conduct is particularly timely. Decades of regulatory enforcement and case law have recognized DI under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) and the Fair Housing Act (FHA), but its legal foundation has recently come under sustained challenge, raising doubts about its continued robustness. In this environment, exploring UDAP not merely as a substitute but as a complementary doctrinal foundation helps identify paths for sustained fair lending enforcement. These developments suggest that fair lending protections may benefit from being grounded in multiple legal bases to ensure continued enforcement against discriminatory practices. In addition, many states have their own statutes prohibiting unfair and deceptive conduct, which grant them enforcement discretion beyond federal oversight. As a result, much of the