Towards an agnostic algorithm for sampling empirical structure models

Stefano Wirth, Luca Morf, Ravit Helled · 2025

Read Towards an agnostic algorithm for sampling empirical structure models by Stefano Wirth, Luca Morf, Ravit Helled (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16995.txt.

Introduction

Stefano Wirth, Luca Morf, and Ravit Helled present an algorithm that samples the full range of interior density profiles for planets, with as few baked-in beliefs as possible. Uranus and Neptune serve as test cases, since their inner makeup is still poorly pinned.

Instead of Markov chain sampling, the method uses gradient-descent optimization built for speed. It returns density and pressure profiles that match each planet mass, radius, and gravity moments. Past studies agree broadly but miss parts of the solution space. The authors give rules for layered models, and find density jumps, if present, cluster near 0.65 of the radius for Uranus and 0.7 for Neptune.

Catalog record

CREATORStefano Wirth, Luca Morf, Ravit Helled
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16995

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards an agnostic algorithm for sampling empirical structure models Stefano Wirth, Luca Morf, Ravit Helled Abstract We present an algorithm to efficiently sample the full space of planetary interior density profiles. Our approach uses as few assumptions as possible to pursue an agnostic algorithm. The algorithm avoids the common Markov chain Monte Carlo method and instead uses an optimisation-based gradient-descent approach designed for computational efficiency. In this work, we use Uranus and Neptune as test cases and obtain empirical models that provide density and pressure profiles consistent with the observed physical properties (total mass, radius, and gravitational moments). We compared our findings to other work and find that while other studies are generally in line with our findings, they do not cover the entire space of solutions faithfully. Furthermore, we present guidance for modellers that construct Uranus or Neptune interior models with a fixed number of layers. We provide a statistical relation between the steepness classifying a density discontinuity and the resulting number of discontinuities to be expected. For example, if one classifies a discontinuity as a density gradient larger than 0.02 kg m -4 , then most solutions should have at most one such discontinuity. Finally, we find that discontinuities, if present, are concentrated around a planetary normalised radius of 0.65 for Uranus and 0.7 for Neptune. Our algorithm to efficiently and faithfully investigate the full space of possible interior density profiles can be used to study all planetary objects with gravitational field data. The case of Uranus and Neptune 1 Introduction Uranus and Neptune have always been key to understanding the formation and evolution history of the Solar System. As the investigation of our own planetary system continues to expand, the study of exoplanets is gaining more attention. Although the characterisation of exoplanets remains limited, it is now clear that in terms of mass and size, many exoplanets in the galaxy resemble Uranus and Neptune ( Zhu & Dong 2021 ) . By revealing the internal structures of Uranus and Neptune, we can improve our knowledge of these two planetary objects in our own neighbourhood and the many observed intermediate-mass exoplanets orbiting distant stars. To study the internal structure of a planet, we need to know its density profile. In the absence of direct measurements, the profile can be inferred from other observations. Density profiles can be inferred by varying all values constituting a profile until the result matches the available observational data (for example total mass, radius, and the gravitational field). The number of such observational parameters is typically small; for Uranus and Neptune, there are fewer than ten. In contrast, density profiles typically consist of orders of magnitude more data points. Inferring density profiles is therefore severely degenerate, as many density profiles can fit the same observational data. To address this problem, one can simplify the approach used to infer density profiles by relying on a multitude of assumptions. However, caution must be taken. Making unsound simplifying assumptions could exclude a large portion (or all) of the valid density profiles. Therefore, obtaining a complete overview of all possible solutions is paramount before simplifications are even considered. To gain such an overview, we must sample profiles with an approach that is as unbiased as possible. This kind of unbiased investigation is called empirical structure modelling. Empirical structure modelling has been used before to investigate the internal structure of Uranus and Neptune. The approach harkens back to earlier foundational works such as Marley et al. 1995 and Podolak et al. 2000 . More recently, Neuenschwander & Helled 2022 presented empirical structure models parametrised by polytropes that directly relate density to interior pressure. In comparison, Movshovitz & Fortney 2022 used models that employed a combination of polynomials and sigmoid functions. The current numerical method of choice for empirical structure modelling is often the Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method ( Marley et al. 1995 ; Movshovitz & Fortney 2022 , for example) . The MCMC approach starts by generating initial density profiles and then randomly alters their parameters until they fit the observational data. This poses challenges due to the aforementioned large number of data points that make up a density profile. Therefore, one must either tolerate the slow convergence of the MCMC method when handling countless parameters or reduce the dimensionality of the parameter space to accelerate the search. Previous studies have taken the latter route by parametrising density profiles with polytropes, polynomials, or sigmoid functions. This reduces the number of parameters to an order of magnitude comparable to the number of observational parameters, but it can introduce biases, which is precisely what we aim to avoid here. We replace the common MCMC method with a new optimisation-based approach that uses an algorithm to efficiently investigate the full space of possible interior density profiles that fit the known observational data of a planet. The assumptions made for the profiles are reduced to an absolute minimum: We only require that there are no density plateaus or inversions and that the maximal density does not exceed the density of any feasible material. Otherwise, (with a resolution of N=1024 ) the N density values are all allowed to change freely. Because we treat all N density values as free parameters, the method avoids biases introduced by the parametrisations of previous MCMC studies. However, this alone does not ensure that the results are free from bias. We must further ensure that the generation of starting profiles is unbiased, and — because we no longer use an MCMC algorithm — we must additionally ensure that the way we find the density profiles is unbiased. For the first point, if the generation of starting profiles favours certain types of density profiles, for instance, by initially under-representing profiles with sharp density discontinuities, an adjustment that increases the sampling of such profiles is required. For the second point, we need to verify that our optimisation approach does not overlook harder-to-find local solutions in favour of dominant global ones that are easily spotted. Our paper is structured as follows. Section 2 provides an overview of the algorithm. In Section 3 we present and interpret the results. In Section 4 we discuss the results, highlight caveats, and provide an outlook for future work. Section 5 presents a summary of the key findings of this study. We note that our methodology is based on the theory of figures ( Zharkov & Trubitsyn 1978 , ToF,) . For the purposes of notation, we follow the elaboration presented in Appendix A of Morf et al. 2024 . We employed the open-source code PyToF 1 1 1 See https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17592269 ( Morf 2025 ) to implement the ToF numerically. 2 Methods 2.1 Algorithm Planets are flattened due to their rotation. Surfaces of both constant density and potential are not spherical shells defined by a single radius, r , but are rather spheroidal in shape. Spheroidal surfaces are described by a function, r_{l}(\vartheta) , that depends on the polar angle, \vartheta . The variable l uniquely identifies a spheroid and represents its volumetric mean radius: \frac{4\pi}{3}l^{3}=2\pi\int_{-1}^{1}\mathrm{d}\cos\vartheta\int_{0}^{r_{l}(\vartheta)}{r^{\prime}}^{2}\mathrm{d}r^{\prime}. (1) We also refer to l as the level surface of a spheroid. A planet with such a spheroidal structure has a multipolar (non-spherical) external gravity field V_{\text{ext}}(r,\vartheta)=\frac{Gm}{r}\left(1-\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\left(\frac{R_{\text{ref}}}{r}\right)^{2n}J_{2n}P_{2n}\left(\cos\vartheta\right)\right),

Read the complete text