The accretion of quasars at the epoch of reionisation: JWST catches the primeval monsters slowly feasting

Bartolomeo Trefoloni, Emanuele Nardini, Stefano Carniani, Elisabeta Lusso, Alessandro Marconi, Eleonora Parlanti, Andrea Sacchi, Anastasia Shlentsova, Matilde Signorini, Guido Risaliti, Sandra Zamora · 2025

Read The accretion of quasars at the epoch of reionisation: JWST catches the primeval monsters slowly feasting by Bartolomeo Trefoloni, Emanuele Nardini, Stefano Carniani, Elisabeta Lusso, Alessandro Marconi, Eleonora Parlanti, Andrea Sacchi, Anastasia Shlentsova, Matilde Signorini, Guido Risaliti, Sandra Zamora (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16981.txt.

Introduction

B. Trefoloni and coauthors use JWST NIRSpec spectra of eight bright quasars at redshift 5.9 and beyond to weigh their black holes and feeding rates. Quasars shine as gas falls onto supermassive black holes, and the most distant ones trace early black hole growth.

Fitting the rest-frame ultraviolet and optical light with accretion disc models gave black hole mass and disc brightness together, with tighter errors than standard single-epoch recipes. The mean feeding rate sits at a log Eddington ratio of minus 0.9, with small scatter. Only about 0.2 percent of such bright quasars should feed past the Eddington limit, proof that slow, sub-Eddington feeding rules even for these early monsters.

Catalog record

CREATORBartolomeo Trefoloni, Emanuele Nardini, Stefano Carniani, Elisabeta Lusso, Alessandro Marconi, Eleonora Parlanti, Andrea Sacchi, Anastasia Shlentsova, Matilde Signorini, Guido Risaliti, Sandra Zamora
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16981

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The accretion of quasars at the epoch of reionisation: JWST catches the primeval monsters slowly feasting Bartolomeo Trefoloni, Emanuele Nardini, Stefano Carniani, Elisabeta Lusso, Alessandro Marconi, Eleonora Parlanti, Andrea Sacchi, Anastasia Shlentsova, Matilde Signorini, Guido Risaliti, Sandra Zamora Abstract Quasars (QSOs) emit an enormous amount of light as a result of the accretion of gas onto supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Thanks to their luminosity, the most distant known QSOs allow us to trace the growth of SMBHs deep into the epoch of reionisation. In this work, we employed JWST /NIRSpec observations of eight luminous ( log ⁡ ( L 3000 ​ Å / ( erg ​ s − 1 ) ) \log(L_{3000\,\AA}/(\rm erg\,s^{-1})) > > 45.7) QSOs at z z ≥ \geq 5.9 to constrain their accretion properties, namely black hole mass, accretion disc (AD) luminosity, and Eddington ratio ( M BH M_{\rm BH} , L AD L_{\rm AD} , λ Edd \lambda_{\rm Edd} ), by fitting the rest-frame UV and optical emission with different AD models. This method provided self-consistent measurements of both M BH M_{\rm BH} and L AD L_{\rm AD} . The uncertainties on M BH M_{\rm BH} and L AD L_{\rm AD} , obtained within the AD-modelling framework ( σ M BH AD \sigma^{\rm AD}_{M_{\rm BH}} ∼ \sim 0.2 dex; σ L AD AD \sigma^{\rm AD}_{L_{\rm AD}} ∼ \sim 0.1 dex), are significantly smaller than the systematic uncertainties associated with single-epoch M BH M_{\rm BH} ( ∼ \sim 0.4 dex) and L AD L_{\rm AD} derived via bolometric corrections ( ∼ \sim 0.2 dex). Based on these results, in our sample we found an average Eddington ratio of ⟨ log ⁡ ( λ Edd ) ⟩ \langle\log(\lambda_{\rm Edd})\rangle = − 0.9 -0.9 , with a dispersion of ∼ \sim 0.2 dex. Assuming that our high- z z QSOs are representative of optically-selected bright blue QSOs, we derive a fraction of systems accreting above the Eddington limit of ∼ \sim 0.2%. In conclusion, this work i) demonstrates the suitability of JWST to test AD models on high-redshift ( z z ≳ \gtrsim 4) QSOs, thanks to the large NIRSpec spectral coverage; ii) shows that AD modelling can yield robust M BH M_{\rm BH} and L AD L_{\rm AD} measurements, with smaller uncertainties than the typical calibrations; and iii) provides compelling evidence for sub-Eddington accretion in bright high- z z QSOs, challenging the widespread paradigm of near- or super-Eddington accretion occurring in these sources. 1 Introduction Accretion of gas onto a supermassive black hole converts gravitational energy into radiation. If this process, occurring through an accretion disc (AD), is efficient, the huge energetic output released in the nuclear region of a galaxy gives rise to an active galactic nucleus (AGN), with quasars (QSOs) belonging to the brightest end of the AGN luminosity distribution. Because of their incidence and brightness, broad-line AGN can be observed up to extremely high redshifts ( z \geq 8.5; e.g., 65 ; 129 ; 58 ), possibly as high as z \sim 11 where the direct detection of broad lines in GN-z11 ( 85 ) is still debated. At the same time, the farthest QSOs have been detected at z \sim 7.5–7.6 ( 6 ; 140 ), when the Universe was only 0.7 Gyr old. The presence of SMBHs with masses exceeding 10^{8}\,M_{\odot} at so early cosmic times remains puzzling, as the pathway to grow such high masses in so little time is largely unclear (see, e.g., 52 ; 82 ; 36 , for recent reviews on this topic). In particular, it raises compelling questions concerning both the mechanisms at work for this early assembly of SMBHs and the reliability of their mass measurements. Reverberation mapping (RM; 14 ) is widely recognized as the benchmark technique to estimate BH masses in AGN, although other approaches have also been explored in recent years (see, e.g., 43 for a comparison). The RM method relies on the delay between the optical AD continuum emission and the response of broad emission lines (generally H \beta ; e.g., 111 ). Assuming that the clouds orbiting in the broad-line region (BLR) are virialised, it is ultimately possible to infer the BH mass based on the BLR radius and cloud velocity. However, RM is extremely time- and resource-consuming, and can only be applied to broad-line AGN with significant continuum variations on relatively short time-scales (see, e.g., 123 , and references therein). Because of these limitations, the number of AGN where RM has been successfully performed is of the order of a few hundreds (e.g., 122 ), yet many more are expected in the next years as part of the on-going ‘Black hole mapper’ programme in the recently started Sloan Digital Sky Survey V (SDSS-V; 67 ; 3 ). A more ‘economic’ BH-mass measurement method is based on the tight relation, with a scatter of < 0.2 dex ( 61 ; 11 ), between the BLR radius and the monochromatic disc luminosity (the R – L relation; 62 ). Such a discovery allowed the use of the monochromatic luminosity – or, equivalently, the line luminosity – as a proxy for the BLR radius, enabling the calibration of ‘single-epoch’ (SE) black-hole mass measurements, whereby a single spectrum can, in practice, provide an estimate of both the key ingredients to derive M_{\rm BH} , namely the BLR radius and the rotational velocity (parameterized by the second moment of the line profile or the full width at half maximum – FWHM; e.g., 139 , and references therein). Consequently, SE calibrations have been widely employed to estimate the BH masses of moderately luminous broad-line AGN, as well as of bright QSOs (e.g., 121 ; 113 ; 145 ). Despite their wide applicability and convenience, non-negligible systematic uncertainties affect the resulting BH mass estimates (see, e.g., 125 , and Appendix A for a more detailed discussion). Examples of such uncertainties are the unknown geometry of the BLR (key to reliably estimate M_{\rm BH} ), the inclination of the line of sight to the BLR, the differential line/continuum variability, and the non-Gaussianity of the line profile, just to mention some. The complicated dynamics of the BLR, possibly also affected by a non-virialised component (i.e., an outflow; 109 ), and the effect of radiation pressure on the BLR clouds (e.g., 87 ), exacerbated in the case of bright sources (e.g., 39 ), are additional reasons for concern. The combination of all these limitations led to even question the extrapolation of SE calibrations to the luminosity and redshift regimes of bright QSOs ( 13 ). While other techniques, such as dynamical methods (e.g. 37 ) are practically unfeasible for large samples at high redshift (but see also 60 for a direct BH mass measurement in an AGN at z\sim 7), accretion-disc modelling offers an alternative approach to self-consistently estimate the accretion parameters underlying the QSO emission (e.g., 86 ). Indeed, the disc steady-state spectral energy distribution (SED) is mainly governed by a few parameters, namely the black-hole mass ( M_{\rm BH} ), the accretion rate ( \dot{M} ), and the accretion efficiency ( \eta ), which is related to the spin a^{*} (e.g., 119 ; 102 ; 107 ). The combination of the latter parameters gives the AD luminosity as

Read the complete text