Connecting current and future dual AGN searches to LISA and PTA gravitational wave detections

Nianyi Chen, Yihao Zhou, Ekaterine Dadiani, Tiziana Di Matteo, Cici Wang, Antonella Palmese, Yue Shen, Junyao Li, Adi Foord, Simeon Bird, Yueying Ni, Yanhui Yang, Rupert Croft · 2025

Read Connecting current and future dual AGN searches to LISA and PTA gravitational wave detections by Nianyi Chen, Yihao Zhou, Ekaterine Dadiani, Tiziana Di Matteo, Cici Wang, Antonella Palmese, Yue Shen, Junyao Li, Adi Foord, Simeon Bird, Yueying Ni, Yanhui Yang, Rupert Croft (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16844.txt.

Introduction

Nianyi Chen and a large team link dual active galactic nuclei, pairs of feeding black holes in merging galaxies, to future gravitational wave finds. Using the ASTRID cosmic simulation, they build dual catalogs matched to current and planned searches.

With realistic selection rules, ASTRID copies the seen dual shares, gaps, and host traits across cosmic time. A large hidden pool of close pairs under 5 kiloparsecs should exist, missed by current surveys. Tracking pairs forward, 30 to 70 percent merge within a billion years, and many of those mergers should be heard by LISA. Duals that AXIS and Roman can see seed about 10 percent of low-redshift LISA events.

Catalog record

CREATORNianyi Chen, Yihao Zhou, Ekaterine Dadiani, Tiziana Di Matteo, Cici Wang, Antonella Palmese, Yue Shen, Junyao Li, Adi Foord, Simeon Bird, Yueying Ni, Yanhui Yang, Rupert Croft
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16844

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Connecting current and future dual AGN searches to LISA and PTA gravitational wave detections Nianyi Chen, Yihao Zhou, Ekaterine Dadiani, Tiziana Di Matteo, Cici Wang, Antonella Palmese, Yue Shen, Junyao Li, Adi Foord, Simeon Bird, Yueying Ni, Yanhui Yang, Rupert Croft Abstract Dual active galactic nuclei (DAGN) mark an observable stage of massive black hole (MBH) pairing in galaxy mergers and are precursors to the MBH binaries that generate low-frequency gravitational waves. Using the large-volume ASTRID cosmological simulation, we construct DAGN catalogs matched to current (COSMOS-Web, DESI) and forthcoming (AXIS, Roman) searches. With realistic selection functions applied, ASTRID reproduces observed dual fractions, separations, and host-galaxy properties across redshifts. We predict a substantial population of small-separation ( < 5 <5 kpc) duals that current surveys fail to capture, indicating that the apparent paucity of sub-kpc systems in COSMOS-Web is driven primarily by selection effects rather than a physical deficit. By following each simulated dual forward in time, we show that dual AGN are robust tracers of MBH mergers: ∼ \sim 30–70% coalesce within ≲ 1 \lesssim 1 Gyr, and 20–60% of these mergers produce gravitational-wave signals detectable by LISA. Duals accessible to AXIS and Roman are the progenitors of ∼ 10 \sim 10 % of low-redshift LISA events and ∼ 30 \sim 30 % of the PTA-band stochastic background. Massive green-valley galaxies with moderate-luminosity AGN, together with massive star-forming hosts containing bright quasars at z > 1 z>1 , emerge as the most likely environments for imminent MBH binaries. These results provide a unified cosmological framework linking dual AGN demographics, MBH binary formation, and gravitational-wave emission, and they identify concrete, high-priority targets for coordinated electromagnetic and GW searches in upcoming multi-messenger surveys. I Introduction Hierarchical cosmological models predict the frequent occurrence of dual active galactic nuclei (AGN) as a natural outcome of galaxy mergers, when the central supermassive black holes (SMBHs) of the progenitor galaxies sink toward the center of the merger remnant and before forming a bound pair ( 6 ; 73 , e.g.) . Dual AGN are therefore the parent population of interacting SMBHs, which will eventually coalesce and emit low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs). These GW signals are directly relevant for upcoming experiments, from the pulsar timing array (PTA) detection of the nanohertz gravitational-wave background ( 2 ; 30 , GWB, e.g.) to the future Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), which will detect SMBH binaries in the millihertz band ( 5 , e.g.) . Despite their strong theoretical and astrophysical importance, the observational census of dual active galactic nuclei (AGN) remains limited and incomplete ( 24 ; 56 , see, e.g., for recent comprehensive reviews) . To date, only a few dozen dual AGN candidates have been robustly confirmed at kiloparsec-scale separations ( \lesssim 10,{\rm kpc} ), typically through targeted X-ray imaging or detailed spectroscopic follow-up observations ( 68 ; 33 ; 46 ; 67 ; 43 ; 56 ; 55 , e.g.) . As a consequence, current samples remain too small to enable a statistically robust characterization of the fundamental properties of dual AGN systems, including their separation and mass distributions, accretion states, luminosity ratios, and host-galaxy properties. This observational limitation hinders our ability to place strong empirical constraints on theoretical models of massive black hole pairing, dynamical evolution, and merger timescales. This situation is expected to improve substantially in the near future with the advent of several new and ongoing observational programs. In particular, the Advanced X-ray Imaging Satellite (AXIS) and the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope wide-field infrared survey (Roman) will dramatically expand the discovery space for dual AGN through their combination of high sensitivity, angular resolution, and large fields of view, enabling both efficient identification and statistical characterization of dual AGN populations across cosmic time. In parallel, the ongoing Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) survey is obtaining high-quality spectra for nearly 10^{5} galaxies and quasars, providing a powerful dataset for the systematic identification of AGN pairs via spectroscopic diagnostics ( 23 , e.g.) . Together, these forthcoming and ongoing datasets bring significant advances in our understanding of the demographics and environments of dual AGN, and will play a key role in strengthening the synergy between electromagnetic observations of massive black hole binaries and gravitational-wave searches. On the theoretical side, cosmological hydrodynamical simulations have recently advanced to the point of resolving both the galaxy population and the black hole dynamics required to study dual AGN formation and evolution. Recent efforts have used state-of-the-art simulations to construct mock catalogs of dual AGN, investigate their observability, and link them to SMBH binary populations ( 74 ; 17 ; 42 ; 62 ; 58 , e.g.) . Such forward-modeling efforts are crucial for interpreting survey data, connecting electromagnetic observations to GW source populations, and predicting the multi-messenger signal of SMBH pairs. However, most of these studies use generic dual AGN selection criteria (e.g., a spatial separation below \Delta r<30\,{\rm kpc} and AGN bolometric luminosity of L_{\rm bol}>10^{43}\,{\rm erg/s} ) for dual AGN selection from the simulation. Such methods hinder direct comparison with observation catalogs or the interpretation of the comparisons, as the selection function has a large impact on the resulting dual AGN population and how they evolve into SMBH binaries. It is crucial, given the diversity of ongoing and upcoming dual AGN searches, to create simulated dual AGN catalogs tailored to each observation sample, to better understand the SMBH pairs probed by each search strategy, and to bridge the gap between the DAGN simulation and observations. In this work, we make use of the ASTRID simulation, a large-volume cosmological simulation with high spatial and mass resolution, to construct mock catalogs of dual AGN matched to the selection functions of DAGN searches using COSMOS-Web and DESI data. We also generate predictive dual AGN catalogs for upcoming observation samples from AXIS and Roman. We investigate the statistical properties of these dual AGN samples, their relation to the underlying SMBH binary population, and their predicted contribution to the PTA-band GWB and LISA-detectable GW sources. By bridging large-scale galaxy surveys and gravitational-wave astronomy, we aim to provide a coherent framework for interpreting dual AGN observations as precursors of GW events. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we briefly introduce the ASTRID simulation, with a focus on the BH modeling. Section III describes the selection criteria for generating mock catalogs tailored to each observation sample. In Section IV , we show the properties of dual AGN across redshifts and in different mock samples, with direct comparisons to the observed dual candidates. Finally, section V investigates the connection between dual AGN population and SMBH binaries in the PTA and LISA band, and the host galaxies of dual AGN mergers. II Simulation We generate dual AGN mock catalogs using the AGN population from the ASTRID simulation. ASTRID contains models for galaxy formation, including gas cooling, star formation, metal return, BH seeding, merging, and accretion as well as supernova and AGN feedback (including both thermal and kinetic modes). ASTRID is fully described in the introductory papers ( 8 ; 52 ; 19 ; 17 ; 26 ; 51 ; 80 , e.g.) . Here, we briefly introduce the basic parameters and BH modeling. ASTRID runs in a uniquely large 250\,{\rm cMpc}/h box

Read the complete text