Generalized CP from non-invertible selection rules Preprint: EPHOU-25-019 KYUSHU-HET-345

Tatsuo Kobayashi 1 and, Hajime Otsuka 2,3 · 2025

Read Generalized CP from non-invertible selection rules Preprint: EPHOU-25-019 KYUSHU-HET-345 by Tatsuo Kobayashi 1 and, Hajime Otsuka 2,3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16376.txt.

Introduction

Tatsuo Kobayashi and Hajime Otsuka extend symmetry physics in an arXiv paper released in 2025. Particle theories use selection rules to say which interactions may occur. Non-invertible rules, built from fusion algebras where combining charges need not be reversible, are a modern generalization now drawing intense study.

The authors label fields by conjugacy classes of a finite group rather than by its standard representations. When the fusion rules carry a twofold symmetry matching charge conjugation, a consistent CP symmetry, the mirror symmetry between matter and antimatter, can be defined alongside parity. Mixing group flavor symmetries with CP then forces a generalized CP transformation. The framework even allows spontaneous CP violation, where the symmetry breaks by itself, with consequences for Yukawa textures, the pattern of fermion masses and mixings.

Catalog record

CREATORTatsuo Kobayashi 1 and, Hajime Otsuka 2,3
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16376

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Generalized CP from non-invertible selection rules Preprint: EPHOU-25-019 KYUSHU-HET-345 Tatsuo Kobayashi 1 and, Hajime Otsuka 2,3 Abstract We study a framework in which fields are labeled by basis elements of a fusion algebra with non-invertible fusion rules. In particular, we consider the case where fields are labeled by conjugacy classes of a finite group rather than its irreducible representations. When the fusion rules possess a ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry identified with charge conjugation, a CP-invariant system can be consistently defined together with parity transformation. Furthermore, it is found that combining group-based flavor symmetries underlying non-invertible selection rules with CP symmetry naturally leads to a generalized CP transformation. We also demonstrate the possibility of spontaneous CP violation in this framework and discuss its implications for Yukawa textures. 1 Introduction The flavor structure of quarks and leptons remains unexplained in the Standard Model of particle physics. So far, flavor symmetries, in particular discrete flavor symmetries, have been extensively studied to address the peculiar pattern of fermion masses and mixings (see, e.g., Refs. Altarelli:2010gt ; Ishimori:2010au ; Hernandez:2012ra ; King:2013eh ; King:2014nza ; Tanimoto:2015nfa ; King:2017guk ; Petcov:2017ggy ; Feruglio:2019ybq ; Kobayashi:2022moq for reviews). Furthermore, some of the discrete flavor symmetries can be compatible with the generalized CP symmetry Holthausen:2012dk ; Chen:2014tpa , leading to an enlarged symmetry group of the form G_{f}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{\mathrm{CP}} Feruglio:2012cw . Since the model parameters are restricted to take real numbers, this framework yields testable predictions (see, e.g., Refs. Holthausen:2012dk ; Ding:2013bpa , for the A_{4} case). Recently, an alternative approach has been explored to understand the origin of flavor structure of quarks and leptons. In the conventional approach based on group-based symmetries, the fields are assumed to transform as some irreducible representations of a given group. However, it has been recently proposed that fields are labeled by basis elements of a fusion algebra endowed with an associative multiplication law: \displaystyle ab=\sum_{c\in A}N_{ab}^{c}c. (1.1) Here, A=\{e,a,b,...\} represents a finite set of basis elements with e being the unit, and the coefficients N_{ab}^{c} are taken to be non-negative integers. In the context of field theory and string theory, this setup will correspond to the situation in which fields are labeled by conjugacy classes of a group rather than by its representations. Since fusion rules generically yield multiple terms in the product of two basis elements, the associated selection rules for fields labeled by these elements exhibit a non-invertible structure. For instance, a scattering process involving fields \phi_{a} and \phi_{b} , labeled by the elements a and b , is governed by the coefficient N_{ab}^{c} in the fusion algebra. These non-invertible selection rules lead to a structure that is richer than that of ordinary group-based symmetries. It was known that these fusion rules are compatible with field theory and string theory (see, e.g., Ref. Kaidi:2024wio ). For instance, non-invertible selection rules can be realized on toroidal orbifolds in heterotic string theory Kobayashi:2025ocp and type II D-brane models Kobayashi:2024yqq ; Funakoshi:2024uvy , where topological operators generate non-invertible symmetries together with the corresponding non-invertible selection rules. In the context of field theory, the non-invertible structure plays a significant role in particle phenomenology such as the realization of tiny neutrino mass Cordova:2022fhg ; Kobayashi:2025cwx , and new Yukawa textures for quarks Kobayashi:2025znw and leptons Kobayashi:2025ldi . These non-invertible selection rules arising from fusion algebras may contain group-like symmetries, such as \mathbb{Z}_{N} , which may remain stable under quantum corrections. The existence of such group-like symmetries has been demonstrated for fusion rules associated with the conjugacy classes of various groups Dong:2025jra , and further supported through spurion analysis Suzuki:2025bxg ; Suzuki:2025kxz . It naturally raises the question of whether a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry appearing in the non-invertible selection rules can be identified with charge conjugation. However, the relation between the CP transformation and non-invertible selection rules has not been fully clarified yet. This motivates us to construct a CP-invariant framework in which fields are labeled by specific basis elements of a fusion algebra that admits a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry. In this paper, we identify a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry underlying certain non-invertible selection rules with the charge conjugation, where the charge conjugate of a field \phi is likewise labeled by an element of the fusion algebra. By combining the charge conjugation with the parity transformation, one can realize the four-dimensional CP transformation. Furthermore, some fusion algebras admit additional group-based symmetries G_{f} . When fields are labeled to irreducible representations of G_{f} in a manner consistent with CP, the full symmetry of this system is described by G_{f}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{2}^{\mathrm{CP}} . Hence, the generalized CP symmetry can be formulated in theories whose non-invertible selection rules are governed by fusion algebras. This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 , we formulate the generalized CP for fusion rules of conjugacy classes of a group which admits the group-based flavor symmetries and the charge conjugation. It leads to the condition for couplings of fields consistent with the generalized CP. In Sec. 3 , we explicitly demonstrate the generalized CP for concrete conjugacy classes of groups. When we combine two fusion algebras, one can realize the texture zero of Yukawa couplings in the context of generalized CP, as discussed in Sec. 4 . Furthermore, the spontaneous CP violation is explicitly demonstrated in Sec. 5 . We demonstrate that the three-zero textures still hold even after the spontaneous CP violation. Finally, Sec. 6 is devoted to the conclusions. 2 Formulations We formulate a generalized CP transformation underlying non-invertible selection rule in Sec. 2.1 and its implications for couplings in Sec. 2.2 2.1 Generalized CP symmetry Let us suppose that a field in four-dimensional quantum field theory is labeled by a conjugacy class [g] of a finite group G rather than its representations. The conjugate \phi^{\ast} is then labeled by a class \overline{[g]}=[g^{-1}] . Here and in what follows, we omit Lorentz indices unless explicitly specified. When the fields \phi_{i} are labeled by the conjugacy class [g_{i}] , their selection rules are governed by a hypergroup. In particular, the conjugacy classes form a commutative fusion algebra with fusion rules: \displaystyle[g_{i}]\cdot[g_{j}]=\sum_{k}N_{ij}^{k}[g_{k}], (2.1) with N_{ij}^{k} being non-negative integers. Note that when we take [g_{j}] as [g_{i}^{-1}] in the left-handed side, the identity class [e] appears on the right-handed side, i.e., [g_{i}]\cdot[g_{i}^{-1}]=[e]+\dots . * * * Here, we normalize the conjugacy classes such that N_{[g_{i}],[g_{i}^{-1}]}^{[e]}=1 . With this structure, the bare interaction \phi_{1}\phi_{2}\cdots\phi_{n} is allowed if and only if there exist representatives \tilde{g}_{i}\in[g_{i}] whose product contains the identity element e\in G : \displaystyle\tilde{g}_{1}\tilde{g}_{2}\cdots\tilde{g}_{n}=e. (2.2) It was known that the selection rules associated with the conjugacy class are often non-invertible, while nevertheless include group-like symmetries at tree and/or loop-levels Heckman:2024obe ; Kaidi:2024wio ; Kobayashi:2024yqq . As an illustrative example, let us suppose that the selection rules enjoy the following symmetry based on a finite group G_{f} , under which the conjugacy classes transform as \displaystyle[g_{i}]\rightarrow\rho(g)_{ij}[g_{j}], (2.3) where \rho(g) denotes a representation matrix of G_{f} for an element g\in G_{f} . It means that the fusion algebra ( 2.1 ) is invariant under G_{f} provided that \displaystyle\rho(g)_{i\ell}\rho(g)_{jm}N_{lm}^{k}=N_{ij}^{k} (2.4) holds for all g\in G_{f} . In this case, a four-dimensional field \phi labeled by [g_{i}] transforms in the same way as the corresponding class: \displaystyle\phi_{i}\xrightarrow{g}\rho(g)_{ij}\phi_{j}. (2.5) It is nothing but a flavor

Read the complete text