Pseudospectrum and black hole total transmission mode (in)stability

Yu-Sen Zhou, Ming-Fei Ji, Liang-Bi Wu, Li-Ming Cao · 2025

Read Pseudospectrum and black hole total transmission mode (in)stability by Yu-Sen Zhou, Ming-Fei Ji, Liang-Bi Wu, Li-Ming Cao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16372.txt.

Introduction

Yu-Sen Zhou and three co-authors test the stability of exotic black hole signals in their 2025 arXiv paper, accepted by Physical Review D. Total transmission modes are waves that cross a black hole spacetime with no reflection at all. Carefully shaped incoming waves can excite them and cancel reflections entirely, an effect called virtual absorption.

Using pseudospectrum methods, which measure how much a spectrum wobbles under small disturbances, the team studied these modes around Tangherlini black holes in various dimensions. Most modes proved spectrally unstable, and higher overtones were more fragile. One purely imaginary mode stood out as far stabler in higher dimensions, with a much smaller condition number. Genuinely complex mode families appear only in eight or more dimensions. Four-dimensional results hint at instability, though norm choices limit firm conclusions.

Catalog record

CREATORYu-Sen Zhou, Ming-Fei Ji, Liang-Bi Wu, Li-Ming Cao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16372

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pseudospectrum and black hole total transmission mode (in)stability Preprint: ICTS-USTC/PCFT-25-63 Yu-Sen Zhou, Ming-Fei Ji, Liang-Bi Wu, Li-Ming Cao Abstract Total transmission modes (TTMs) are modes with complex frequencies that propagate across a black hole spacetime without reflection. Recently, it is found that suitably tailored time-dependent scattering can excite these complex modes and suppress the reflected signal for the entire duration of the process, a phenomenon referred to as virtual absorption. Motivated by this, we present the study of the spectrum stability of TTMs using pseudospectrum and condition numbers. We focus on perturbations of d d -dimensional Tangherlini black holes and recast the TTM problem as a generalized eigenvalue problem by utilizing the Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates. The results show that TTMs are generically spectrally unstable, with sensitivity increasing for higher overtones, in close analogy with quasinormal modes. A notable exception is a purely imaginary TTM whose pseudospectrum’s contours are nearly concentric and whose condition number is orders of magnitude smaller than that of the overtones, indicating enhanced spectral stability. Additionally, we confirm that purely imaginary TTMs occur only for spin s = 2 s=2 , whereas genuinely complex TTM families appear only in sufficiently high dimensions, d ⩾ 8 d\geqslant 8 , extending earlier claims that placed the onset at d ⩾ 10 d\geqslant 10 . I Introduction Linear perturbations of black holes provide a clean arena to study dissipative dynamics in general relativity. At late times, generic perturbations are dominated by the quasinormal modes (QNMs), which are defined as solutions of the homogeneous perturbation equations that satisfy purely ingoing boundary conditions at the event horizon and purely outgoing conditions at infinity. Their complex frequencies encode the characteristic ringdown signal and depend only on the parameters of the background spacetime, therefore they play a central role in gravitational wave observations and their precise measurement enables black hole spectroscopy, tests of the Kerr hypothesis, and constraints on possible deviations from general relativity 55 ; 49 ; 38 ; 7 ; 6 ; 50 ; 1 ; 43 ; 42 ; 8 . From the point of view of scattering theory, however, the QNMs are only one prominent class of modes. In addition to the QNMs, which are poles of the reflection and transmission coefficients, there is an additional mode family, known as the total transmission modes (TTMs). At a TTM frequency the reflection coefficient vanishes and an incident wave is transmitted without being reflected through the effective potential barrier 22 ; 39 ; 2 . They appear as complex-frequency solutions of the perturbation equation that behave as purely outgoing or purely ingoing plane waves at both asymptotic boundaries. Research has identified TTMs in four dimensions both analytically and numerically 9 ; 23 . For the static Schwarzschild spacetime, Andersson 2 established that the earlier derived algebraically special modes 31 ; 67 ; 21 are effectively TTMs. This connection was further elaborated by Maassen van den Brink 53 who provided an analytic treatment of gravitational waves at these algebraically special frequencies. For the rotating case, the situation becomes more complicated. Keshet and Neitzke 46 performed an asymptotic analysis of QNMs, TTMs, and total-reflection modes. A sequence of studies by Cook et al. examined purely imaginary modes and their bifurcation characteristics 28 ; 30 ; 29 , and reported a novel class of TTMs whose Schwarzschild limit counterparts appear at complex infinity 26 ; 27 , which do not satisfy the standard algebraic conditions on the Starobinsky constant 60 ; 20 . There are also interests in the (quasi-)reflectionless modes where the frequency is restricted on the real axis both in gravity theory and in other communities 25 ; 5 ; 61 ; 58 ; 57 . Similar to QNMs, TTMs are also the characteristic modes of black holes, since they depend only on the parameters of the background black hole. Therefore, TTMs can also serve as a probe of the spacetime and possibly of quantum properties of the black hole 46 ; 51 ; 52 . More recently, it has been shown that suitably tailored time-dependent initial data can selectively excite a specific TTM in such a way that the whole black hole spacetime effectively acts as a perfect absorber during the scattering 66 , a phenomenon known as virtual absorption 25 ; 5 . In this picture, TTMs appear as the characteristic virtual absorption resonances of the scattering problem and thus play a central role in finely controlled black hole scattering experiments. For example, consider a gravitational wave originating from a binary black hole merger or an artificial source scattered by a black hole. If the frequency of this wave matches one of the TTMs of the black hole, the wave will be totally absorbed, i.e., no reflected wave appears. Note that TTMs with a positive imaginary part should also be considered. This differs from the QNM case, where a positive imaginary part indicates dynamical instability. Given the importance of TTMs in scattering experiments, it is natural to inquire about the robustness of these modes under perturbations induced by the black hole’s surrounding environment. It is well known that the QNM problem is an open dissipative problem, thus its evolution operator is inherently non-Hermitian 44 . Therefore the spectral stability of QNMs is well assessed by the pseudospectrum. As for the TTM problem, the same mechanism applies: the boundaries admit net energy fluxes and therefore the evolution operator is again non-Hermitian. For these non-Hermitian systems, standard eigenvalue analysis may fail to capture the system’s dynamics. It is therefore essential to analyze the pseudospectrum, which captures both eigenvalue sensitivity and potential transient growth, rather than relying solely on the location of isolated eigenvalues 64 ; 63 ; 44 ; 45 ; 11 ; 24 . Such pseudospectrum approach has been applied to QNMs of various spacetimes 37 ; 59 ; 3 ; 32 ; 36 ; 33 ; 35 ; 10 ; 14 ; 18 ; 24 ; 40 ; 4 ; 17 ; 13 ; 34 ; 16 ; 15 , and here we present the first work to extend the pseudospectrum analysis to TTMs. It is known that there are only two pure imaginary TTM in 4 -dimensional Schwarzschild black hole for a fixed \ell 9 . This makes the 4 -dimensional case less suitable for spectrum (in)stability analyses that are expected to be generic for non-Hermitian open systems. The Tangherlini black hole, which is a simple higher dimensional generalization of the Schwarzschild black hole, possesses genuinely complex TTMs. We therefore consider perturbations of Tangherlini black holes, recast the TTM problem as a generalized eigenvalue problem on a compact domain, and define pseudospectra with respect to a physically motivated energy norm. We then compute the pseudospectra and condition numbers associated with TTMs. Our main result is that TTMs exhibit spectral instability similar to QNMs, but with a notable exception: there is a spectral stable mode for gravitational perturbation on the imaginary axis. This paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II , we review the perturbation equations for Tangherlini black holes, define TTMs in terms of their asymptotic behavior, introduce the Eddington–Finkelstein coordinates and compactified radial coordinates, and using the Chebyshev-Lobatto discretization to recast the problem into a generalized eigenvalue problem. Sec.

Read the complete text