Phantom Menace in general Palatini f ( R , ϕ ) f(R,\phi) theories
Rahul Thakur, Abhijith Ajith, Sukanta Panda, Archit Vidyarthi · 2025
Read Phantom Menace in general Palatini f ( R , ϕ ) f(R,\phi) theories by Rahul Thakur, Abhijith Ajith, Sukanta Panda, Archit Vidyarthi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16256.txt.
Introduction
Rahul Thakur and three co-authors test modified gravity in their 2025 arXiv paper. They study f(R, phi) theories in the Palatini formalism, where curvature and a scalar field jointly drive cosmic expansion. The goal is one model that covers both the early inflation era and today's accelerating universe.
Assuming the curvature part behaves like Starobinsky gravity, they check stability after inflation and find two fixed points that give a stable, accelerating late universe. Data from the DESI survey, cosmic chronometers, and supernovae tighten the picture further. One surviving fixed point has expansion driven by a phantom scalar field, which acts more strongly than a cosmological constant. Timescale arguments suggest that point may be temporary, with the universe later settling into potential-driven expansion.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rahul Thakur, Abhijith Ajith, Sukanta Panda, Archit Vidyarthi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16256
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Phantom Menace in general Palatini f ( R , ϕ ) f(R,\phi) theories Rahul Thakur, Abhijith Ajith, Sukanta Panda, Archit Vidyarthi Abstract We study general f ( R , ϕ ) f(R,\phi) theories in Palatini formalism and attempt to constrain the behavior of ones that could support both inflationary and late-time expansion era in a unified model. In particular, we find conditions for which the theories remain consistent in weak gravity regimes as well as cosmic expansion eras in both early and late universe. Assuming that the curvature part of the f ( R , ϕ ) f(R,\phi) behaves as Starobinsky gravity, we assess post-inflation dynamical stability of the theory in Einstein frame and proceed to isolate two distinct fixed points that provide a stable late-time accelerating universe. Comparison with DESI, Cosmic Chronometers, and SNeIa datasets adds more stringent constraints to the behavior of the theory near the present epoch, giving us one stable fixed point where expansion is driven by a phantom scalar field. However, time scales of the two fixed points suggest that this fixed point may be transient and may eventually evolve toward a stable expansion stage driven potential domination in the distant future of the universe. I INTRODUCTION The universe is currently experiencing an epoch of accelerated expansion, a phenomenon that has been documented over the past century through various observational efforts. Among the recent key sources of evidence are the measurements of luminosity distance and redshift of Type Ia supernovae 77 ; 76 ; 79 , which have played a central role in this discovery. Other important observations, such as the cosmic microwave background radiation 43 , baryon acoustic oscillations 29 ; 75 , and the determination of the Hubble constant 78 , have further contributed to our understanding of this accelerated phase. Due to sheer lack of any information about what’s driving this late-time expansion, cosmologists have attributed it to the mysterious dark energy which exerts a large negative pressure to counteract gravitational collapse. Although many theoretical models have been proposed, the true nature of dark energy is still unknown. One of the first and most widely studied models is the \Lambda CDM model, which includes the cosmological constant ( \Lambda ) and cold dark matter. This model has been popular, especially among the particle physics community. However, the severe fine-tuning associated with the observed value of \Lambda , along with the coincidence problem 91 ; 68 , suggests that a dynamical mechanism may be responsible for cosmic acceleration. This has driven interest in exploring dynamical dark energy models based on scalar fields, where a scalar field is responsible for generating negative pressure, leading to the accelerated expansion of the universe at late times. Depending on the form of the Lagrangian, there are mainly two types of scalar field models studied so far: the quintessence models 95 ; 73 ; 41 ; 74 ; 61 ; 37 ; 38 ; 13 ; 17 ; 24 ; 47 ; 46 ; 72 ; 81 ; 93 ; 56 and the k -essence models 7 ; 42 ; 9 ; 8 ; 22 ; 23 ; 82 ; 20 ; 12 . Another promising direction involves modifying the gravitational sector itself. Among such theories, f(R) gravity, which generalizes the Einstein-Hilbert action by promoting the Ricci scalar R to a function f(R) , has attracted considerable interest 15 ; 14 ; 16 ; 62 ; 28 ; 35 ; 84 ; 36 . These models can naturally drive late-time acceleration without introducing exotic matter components. However, pure f(R) models have their limitations. In particular, they often face challenges in fitting both cosmological and local gravitational tests simultaneously, and they may lack the flexibility needed to reproduce a wide range of cosmological behaviors 26 . To overcome these shortcomings, an extended class of theories has been proposed in which a scalar field \phi is explicitly coupled to the curvature, leading to models of the form f(R,\phi) 51 ; 11 ; 69 ; 33 ; 64 . These models merge the advantages of both scalar field dynamics and modified gravity, offering a richer framework to explore dark energy and late-time acceleration. More recently, certain classes of f(R,\phi) inflation models have also been shown to produce a slightly enhanced scalar spectral index corresponding to the recent results from Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT). The latest ACT data release has disfavored long-standing inflationary paradigms such as Higgs inflation and Starobinsky inflation, though there have been efforts to show that modified dynamics may be able to restore these models to within the acceptable range 94 ; 44 ; 27 ; 6 ; 45 ; 66 ; 63 ; 92 ; 4 . More importantly, it has been highlighted by some authors that the non-minimal coupling \phi R is well-suited to produce the required enhancement in the scalar spectral index. An important subtlety in studying f(R,\phi) models lies in the choice of variational principle. In the metric formalism, the action is varied with respect to the metric, and the connection is taken to be Levi Civita. In contrast, the Palatini formalism treats the metric and affine connection as independent variables 85 ; 67 ; 71 . The resulting equations of motion are second order in derivatives, thereby avoiding the instabilities that typically emerge in higher derivative metric gravity theories. Furthermore, the Palatini approach often leads to new scalar tensor equivalences that are not present in the metric formulation, making it a compelling framework for exploring modified gravity. A standard technique for revealing the effective degrees of freedom is the application of a Weyl transformation which maps the Jordan frame action into its equivalent Einstein frame counterpart (wherein gravitational sector resembles GR and the modifications are absorbed into scalar field terms with non standard kinetic and potential structures) 34 ; 39 . In the case of f(R,\phi) models in Palatini formalism, the transformed action exhibits a particularly novel structure: the scalar sector acquires a higher order kinetic interaction term and an effective potential 25 . The appearance of higher order kinetic terms places the model within the broad class of k -essence theories 9 ; 21 . These models are known to produce rich cosmological behavior, including dynamical dark energy with varying equation of state, attractor solutions, and even phantom like regimes without introducing ghosts 90 . In this paper, we investigate the cosmological behavior of a class of Palatini f(R,\phi) gravity models in the Einstein frame and examine their viability as an explanation for the observed acceleration of the universe. Our goal is to determine whether such models can provide an improved or complementary description to \Lambda CDM while remaining consistent with current observational data. We perform a dynamical system analysis of cosmological evolution which provides a systematic way to classify possible asymptotic states of the Universe by converting the cosmological equations into an autonomous system of differential equations 24 ; 10 . Our main goal is to identify conditions under which such models admit stable accelerated attractors at late times and thus providing a framework for dynamical dark energy. In addition, we highlight the role of the induced quartic kinetic interaction term in driving acceleration. The paper is organized as