LSTM-MDNz: Estimating Quasar Photometric Redshifts with an LSTM-Augmented Mixture Density Network

Jianzhen Chen, Zhijian Luo, Liping Fu, Zhu Chen, Hubing Xiao, Shaohua Zhang, Chenggang Shu · 2025

Read LSTM-MDNz: Estimating Quasar Photometric Redshifts with an LSTM-Augmented Mixture Density Network by Jianzhen Chen, Zhijian Luo, Liping Fu, Zhu Chen, Hubing Xiao, Shaohua Zhang, Chenggang Shu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16010.txt.

Introduction

Jianzhen Chen and six co-authors tackle a measurement problem in astronomy in an arXiv paper posted in 2025. Quasars are brilliant distant objects, and knowing their redshifts is key for mapping the universe. Yet their colors can look alike at very different distances, which confuses methods that rely on images alone rather than full spectra.

The team built LSTM-MDNz, a deep learning model that reads multi-band brightness values in wavelength order. It was trained on more than 550,000 quasars with known redshifts, using 14 bands from four sky surveys. With all bands it reached a scatter measure of 0.037 and an outlier rate of 3.5 percent. That cuts errors by 29 percent and outliers by 56 percent versus the usual band set.

Catalog record

CREATORJianzhen Chen, Zhijian Luo, Liping Fu, Zhu Chen, Hubing Xiao, Shaohua Zhang, Chenggang Shu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16010

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

LSTM-MDNz: Estimating Quasar Photometric Redshifts with an LSTM-Augmented Mixture Density Network Jianzhen Chen, Zhijian Luo, Liping Fu, Zhu Chen, Hubing Xiao, Shaohua Zhang, Chenggang Shu Abstract Quasar photometric redshifts are essential for studying cosmology and large-scale structures. However, their complex spectral energy distributions cause significant redshift–color degeneracy, limiting the accuracy of traditional methods. To overcome this, we introduce LSTM-MDNz, a novel end-to-end deep learning model combining long short-term memory networks (LSTM) with mixture density networks (MDN). The model directly uses multi-band photometric fluxes and associated errors as wavelength-ordered sequential inputs, eliminating the need for manual feature engineering while enabling simultaneous point estimation and probability distribution function (PDF) prediction of quasar redshifts. We integrate data from four major sky surveys—SDSS, DESI-LS, WISE, and GALEX—to assemble a sample of over 550,000 spectroscopically confirmed quasars ( 0 ≤ z spec ≤ 5 0\leq z_{\mathrm{spec}}\leq 5 ) across 14 ultraviolet to infrared bands for model training and testing. Experimental results show that using all 14 bands yields optimal performance, with a normalized median absolute deviation ( σ NMAD \sigma_{\mathrm{NMAD}} ) of 0.037 and an outlier rate ( f out f_{\mathrm{out}} ) of 3.5% on the test set. These values represent reductions of 29% and 56%, respectively, compared to the commonly adopted SDSS+WISE band set. Probability integral transform ( PIT \mathrm{PIT} ) and continuous ranked probability score ( CRPS \mathrm{CRPS} ) analyses confirm that the predicted PDFs align closely with the true redshift distribution. Band-ablation experiments further highlight the essential role of ultraviolet and infrared data in alleviating color degeneracy and reducing systematic bias. This study demonstrates the effectiveness of multi-band fusion in improving quasar photo-z accuracy and offers a ready-to-use estimation framework for future surveys like LSST, CSST, and Euclid. show][email protected] I Introduction Quasars, the most energetically luminous active galactic nuclei in the universe, serve as vital probes for investigating the large-scale structure of the universe, galaxy evolution, and the growth of supermassive black holes ( 66 ; 38 ; 45 ) . They also play a crucial role in elucidating the nature of dark energy and understanding the epoch of cosmic reionization ( 23 ; 79 ; 58 ) . The advent of next-generation large-scale photometric surveys, such as the Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST), the Chinese Space Station Survey Telescope (CSST), and the Euclid space telescope, is expected to discover and identify tens of millions of quasars ( 43 ; 30 ; 21 ) . However, obtaining precise spectroscopic redshifts ( z_{\mathrm{spec}} ) for such a vast sample is observationally expensive and time-consuming, making spectroscopic confirmation impractical for the majority of sources. Consequently, efficient estimation of quasar photometric redshifts ( z_{\mathrm{phot}} ) using readily available multi-band photometric data has become an indispensable approach for statistical studies of large samples ( 67 ; 80 ) . Photometric redshift estimation refers to the technique of inferring cosmological redshifts from multi-band photometric measurements (e.g., magnitudes and colors) without requiring spectroscopic observations. This method enables the rapid acquisition of three-dimensional spatial distributions for large samples, expanding the scale of observable universe studies by orders of magnitude compared to spectroscopic samples, thereby enhancing the statistical power of cosmological measurements ( 35 ) . Nearly all current and upcoming large-scale survey projects—including the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS; 27 ; 82 ), the Dark Energy Survey (DES; 17 ; 1 ), the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS; 19 ), LSST ( 52 ; 43 ) , the Euclid Space Telescope ( 48 ) , the Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope or Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (WFIRST; 33 ; 71 ; 3 ), and the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program (HSC-SSP; 2 )—rely heavily on photometric redshifts to achieve their core scientific objectives. Current photometric redshift estimation methods are broadly categorized into two types: template-fitting methods and machine learning methods. Template-fitting techniques such as HyperZ ( 10 ) , BPZ ( 7 ) , EAZY ( 13 ) , and Le Phare ( 5 ) derive redshifts by fitting photometric data with spectral energy distribution (SED) templates ( 47 ; 24 ; 9 ; 55 ) . Although this approach has a clear theoretical foundation, its accuracy heavily depends on the completeness and accuracy of the template library. In contrast, machine learning (or training-set) methods learn the complex mapping between photometric features and redshifts from large spectroscopic training samples, employing a wide variety of models. Commonly used techniques include artificial neural networks (ANN; 25 ; 15 ; 68 ), support vector machines (SVM; 76 ), self-organizing maps ( 77 ; 28 ) , Gaussian process regression ( 78 ) , k-nearest neighbors (kNN; 6 ), boosted decision trees ( 29 ) , random forests (RF; 14 ; 65 ; 59 ; 53 ), and sparse Gaussian frameworks ( 4 ) . More recently, deep learning approaches such as multi-layer perceptrons (MLP; 86 ), convolutional neural networks (CNN; 39 ; 20 ; 62 ), and Bayesian neural networks (BNN; 85 ) have also been widely applied in photo‑ z estimation. When sufficient training samples are available, machine learning methods often achieve higher accuracy. In recent years, with the growing volume of astronomical data and advances in computational capabilities, machine learning methods have been widely applied to photometric redshift estimation, delivering impressive results across various surveys. For instance, in galaxy photometric redshifts, 59 used DES data and the COSMOS2015 catalog to show that random forest algorithms yield robust redshift estimates even with limited photometric bands. The Euclid team ( 22 ) systematically evaluated 9 different machine learning methods on simulated galaxy data and found that most can provide reliable redshift estimates. To further improve performance, 54 proposed an LSTM-based model for the CSST survey, which captures sequential correlations in multi-band data and uses Monte Carlo dropout to generate probability distribution functions (PDFs), thereby enhancing reliability. Additionally, studies by 85 and 34 demonstrated that multimodal approaches combining photometric and image data (e.g., hybrid MLP-CNN models) can further refine redshift and PDF estimation accuracy. However, research on quasar photometric redshift estimation remains relatively limited. Compared to galaxies, quasar photometric redshifts generally exhibit lower accuracy and reliability, primarily due to their distinctive physical characteristics: quasar SEDs arise from a combination of power-law continuum emission, broad-line region clouds, dusty tori, and host galaxy light, leading to complex spectral shapes. Moreover, quasars lack pronounced features such as the Balmer break, the 4000Å break, or the Lyman break that characterize galaxy SEDs. These factors result in a highly nonlinear and non-monotonic relationship between quasar colors and redshifts—a phenomenon known as “redshift–color degeneracy” ( 67 ; 61 ) . Consequently, methods that perform well for galaxy redshifts often show significantly reduced effectiveness when applied directly to quasars, facing limitations in both accuracy and robustness. To improve quasar redshift estimation, researchers have explored diverse machine learning strategies. For example, 49 developed models using XGBoost, CatBoost, and Random Forest, finding that a two-step strategy—separating quasars into high- and low-redshift subsets before prediction—outperformed single-model approaches. Their subsequent studies ( 50 ; 51 ) further indicated that these methods generally achieve higher accuracy for galaxies than for quasars. 16 evaluated deep learning (DL), k-nearest neighbors (kNN), and decision tree regression (DTR) for quasar redshift estimation, concluding that kNN and DL delivered

Read the complete text