Picard Groups in Equivariant Algebra and Stable Homotopy Theory
Jesse Keyes and Jordan Sawdy · 2025
Read Picard Groups in Equivariant Algebra and Stable Homotopy Theory by Jesse Keyes and Jordan Sawdy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-16002.txt.
Introduction
Jesse Keyes and Jordan Sawdy prove results in abstract algebra and homotopy theory in a paper first posted to arXiv in 2025. Their topic is the Picard group, which collects the invertible objects in a category up to equivalence. In equivariant homotopy theory, where symmetry groups act on spaces, grading by this group is arguably more natural than older choices.
The authors prove a long-expected isomorphism linking the Picard group of the Burnside ring with that of Mackey functors, for finite groups. Building on that, they classify invertible Mackey functors when the group is finite and abelian. They also classify invertible modules over the Burnside ring in that setting. The results tidy up foundations that other homotopy theorists rely on.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jesse Keyes and Jordan Sawdy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-16002
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Picard Groups in Equivariant Algebra and Stable Homotopy Theory Jesse Keyes and Jordan Sawdy Abstract . Traditionally, homotopy groups in G G -equivariant stable homotopy theory have been graded over RO ( G ) \RO(G) , the real representation ring of G G . It is arguably more natural to grade homotopical structures over the Picard group of the equivariant stable homotopy category. Though there is a canonical map of abelian groups RO ( G ) → Pic ( Ho ( 𝒮 p G ) ) \RO(G)\rightarrow\Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) relating the two, this map is neither injective or surjective in general. Fausk, Lewis, and May give an algebraic expression of Pic ( Ho ( 𝒮 p G ) ) \Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) in terms of the Picard group of the Burnside ring A ( G ) A(G) , and this work suggests a folklore isomorphism between Pic ( A ( G ) ) \Pic(A(G)) and Pic ( ℳ ack G ) \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) . We prove the existence of this folklore isomorphism in the setting of finite groups, then leverage our analysis to prove a classification of invertible Mackey functors in the setting of finite abelian groups. As a consequence, we furnish a classification of invertible A ( G ) A(G) -modules again for G G a finite abelian group. 1. Introduction Constructing the G -equivariant stable homotopy category, \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) , involves inverting the real representation spheres associated to G with respect to the smash product of G -spaces. Consequently, we can consider the homotopy of any object in \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) as \RO(G) -graded. Historically, the structure of RO(G) -graded homotopy groups has been used in homological settings when a theory of Poincaré duality is desired. It is also known that RO(G) -graded homotopy groups detect weak equivalences for G=C_{2} , so often the choice to compute these groups is made to forego computing homotopy Mackey functors. On the other hand, \mathbb{Z} -graded homotopy Mackey functors detect weak equivalences by definition. There is yet another group over which we can grade homotopy groups or Mackey functors: the Picard group of \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) . Grading homotopy groups or Mackey functors over the Picard group of \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) is justified formally in that no choice is made in what invertible objects (up to isomorphism) we choose to grade homotopical structures over. Essentially, two choices are being made. The first choice is whether to regard \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) as enriched in abelian groups or in G -Mackey functors, though these are related via change of enrichment along the lax monoidal functor \ev_{G/G}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}\rightarrow{\mathscr{A}\textnormal{b}} . The second choice comes from a more general formalism discussed throughout [ 3 ] : given any additive (or {\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G} -enriched) closed symmetric monoidal category (\mathscr{C},\otimes,\mathbbm{1}) , one can define a multi-graded abelian group (respectively, G -Mackey functor) \pi_{*}(X) for any X\in\mathscr{C} . Importantly, the grading here can be over any subgroup A\leq\Pic(\mathscr{C}) , where \Pic(\mathscr{C}) denotes the Picard group of \mathscr{C} . From this, it is clear that grading over \Pic(\mathscr{C}) is a canonical choice. In [ 4 , Theorem 0.1] , Fausk, Lewis, and May give an algebraic description of \Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) as an extension of \Pic(A(G)) by some free abelian group, where A(G) is the Burnside ring for G . In particular, they prove that there is an embedding \Pic(A(G))\coloneqq\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{A(G)})\cong\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{\pi_{0}(\mathbb{S}_{G})})\hookrightarrow\Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) whose cokernel is given by some free abelian group. Further, \Pic(A(G)) is computed by tom Dieck and Petrie; see the discussion following [ 13 , Proposition 11.3] . If one regards \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) as enriched in {\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G} , the work of [ 4 ] raises the question of whether an embedding \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\cong\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{\underline{A}})\cong\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{\underline{\pi}_{0}(\mathbb{S}_{G})})\hookrightarrow\Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) with the same free cokernel exists. Such an embedding would imply an isomorphism between \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) and \Pic(A(G)) . It is folklore that there exists an isomorphism \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\rightarrow\Pic(A(G)) induced by evaluating invertible Mackey functors at level {}^{G}\!/_{\!G} . 1.1. Outline of Results The first goal of this article is to give a precise account of the folklore statement above: for G a finite group, we build an isomorphism \Pic(A(G))\to\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) . This analysis goes through \Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) along the same lines as [ 4 ] . We define a full symmetric monoidal subcategory, k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G} , of {\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G} consisting of G -Mackey functors which satisfy a finiteness condition analogous to that in [ 4 ] for Künneth objects. Theorem A . There is a split exact sequence 0\rightarrow\Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\rightarrow\Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}))\xrightarrow{\Dim}\mathbb{Z}^{r}\rightarrow 0 in which the image of \Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) in \Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) is precisely the isomorphism classes of invertible Künneth objects in \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) . In particular, we learn that \Pic(A(G)) is isomorphic to \Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) . To obtain an isomorphism \Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\cong\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) , we show that the kernel of the dimension function above contains \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) . Theorem B . There exists an embedding \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\hookrightarrow\Pic(\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G})) whose image is contained in the kernel of the dimension function. Consequently, the inclusion k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}\subseteq{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G} induces an isomorphism on Picard groups. Following this identification of \Pic(A(G)) with \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) , we build explicit representatives for the isomorphism classes of invertible Mackey functors, and our approach is largely inspired by that of [ 1 , Definition 4.5] . This classification furnishes that of invertible A(G) -modules, recovering the computation of \Pic(A(G)) given by [ 13 ] . Theorem C . There is an isomorphism T_{G}^{\mathrm{inv}}\coloneqq\prod_{H\leq G}\left({}^{\mathbb{Z}}\!/_{\![G:H]}\right)^{\times}/\{\pm 1\}\rightarrow\Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}) given by sending \alpha\in T_{G}^{\mathrm{inv}} to the corresponding twisted Burnside Mackey functor. That is, every invertible Mackey functor is isomorphic to a twisted Burnside Mackey functor. The main technical hurdle in justifying the folklore isomorphism \Pic({\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\rightarrow\Pic(A(G)) is that the functor \ev_{{}^{G}\!/_{\!G}}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}\to{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{A(G)} is not strong symmetric monoidal, so it need not send invertible objects to invertible objects in general. However, this can be rectified by restricting the domain, as shown in the following result: Theorem D . The functor \ev_{{}^{G}\!/_{\!G}}\colon k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G}\rightarrow k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{A(G)} given by evaluation at {}^{G}\!/_{\!G} is a strong symmetric monoidal equivalence of categories. That is, it induces an isomorphism \Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\cong\Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{A(G)})\cong\Pic(A(G)). We note that Künneth objects in {\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{A(G)} coincide with dualizable objects (i.e., finitely generated projective modules). Corollary . The map T_{G}^{\mathrm{inv}}\rightarrow\Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G})\xrightarrow{\ev_{{}^{G}\!/_{\!G}}}\Pic(k{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{A(G)})\cong\Pic(A(G)) sending \alpha\in T_{G}^{\mathrm{inv}} to the corresponding twisted Burnside module is an isomorphism. That is, every invertible A(G) -module is isomorphic to a twisted Burnside module. 1.2. Notation Throughout, G will denote a finite group, unless specified otherwise. Let (\mathscr{C},\otimes,\mathbbm{1}) be a symmetric monoidal category. • Categories. – {\textnormal{C}\mathscr{R}\textnormal{ing}} : commutative rings – {\mathscr{M}\textnormal{od}}_{R} : modules over a commutative monoid in some symmetric monoidal category – {\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{G} : G -Mackey functors – {\mathscr{G}\textnormal{reen}}_{G} : G -Green functors – \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}) : the stable homotopy category – \Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}) : the G -equivariant stable homotopy category – \mathscr{S}\textnormal{ym}\mathscr{M}\textnormal{on}\mathscr{C}\textnormal{at} : symmetric monoidal categories and strong symmetric monoidal functors – d\mathscr{C} : full subcategory of dualizable objects in (\mathscr{C},\otimes,\mathbbm{1}) – k\mathscr{C} : full subcategory of Künneth objects in (\mathscr{C},\otimes,\mathbbm{1}) – \textnormal{C}\mathcal{M}\textnormal{on}(\mathscr{C}) : category of commutative monoids in (\mathscr{C},\otimes,\mathbbm{1}) • Functors. Let J\leq H be finite groups and N\lhd H with q\colon G\twoheadrightarrow{}^{G}\!/_{\!N} . – \uparrow_{J}^{H}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{H}\rightarrow{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{J} : induction – \downarrow_{J}^{H}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{J}\rightarrow{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{H} : restriction – \qInd_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}}^{H}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}}\rightarrow{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{H} : induction along a quotient map – \qRes_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}}^{H}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{H}\rightarrow{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}} : restriction along a quotient map – \Inf_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}}^{H}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}}\rightarrow{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{H} : inflation – \Phi^{N}\colon{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{H}\rightarrow{\mathscr{M}\textnormal{ack}}_{{}^{H}\!/_{\!N}} : N -geometric fixed points – \Phi^{H}\colon\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}^{G}))\rightarrow\Ho(\mathscr{S}\textnormal{p}) : H -geometric fixed points – \Pic\colon\mathscr{S}\textnormal{ym}\mathscr{M}\textnormal{on}\mathscr{C}\textnormal{at}\rightarrow{\mathscr{A}\textnormal{b}} : the Picard group • Objects. – T_{G}\coloneqq\prod_{H\leq G}\mathbb{Z} – T_{G}^{\mathrm{inv}}\coloneqq\prod_{H\leq G}\left({}^{\mathbb{Z}}\!/_{\![G:H]}\right)^{\times}/\{\pm