DESI-DR1 3 × 2 3\times 2 -pt analysis: Consistent cosmology across weak lensing surveys ∗
A. Porredon , 1,2,3,4,∗ C. Blake , 5 J. U. Lange , 6 N. Emas, 5 J. Aguilar, 7 S. Ahlen , 8 A. Bera, 9 D. Bianchi , 10,11 D. Brooks, 12 F. J. Castander , 13,14 T. Claybaugh, 7 J. Coloma Nadal, 15 A. Cuceu , 7 K. S. Dawson , 16 A. de la Macorra , 17 Biprateep Dey , 18,19 P. Doel, 12 A. Elliott , 20,4 · 2025
Read DESI-DR1 3 × 2 3\times 2 -pt analysis: Consistent cosmology across weak lensing surveys ∗ by A. Porredon , 1,2,3,4,∗ C. Blake , 5 J. U. Lange , 6 N. Emas, 5 J. Aguilar, 7 S. Ahlen , 8 A. Bera, 9 D. Bianchi , 10,11 D. Brooks, 12 F. J. Castander , 13,14 T. Claybaugh, 7 J. Coloma Nadal, 15 A. Cuceu , 7 K. S. Dawson , 16 A. de la Macorra , 17 Biprateep Dey , 18,19 P. Doel, 12 A. Elliott , 20,4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-15960.txt.
Introduction
A. Porredon and the DESI collaboration present a joint 3 by 2 point analysis of DESI Data Release 1 with three weak lensing surveys in a 2025 paper. Combining galaxy clustering with lensing correlation functions breaks degeneracies that limit each probe alone. The lensing data come from KiDS-1000, DES Year 3, and HSC Year 3, all overlapping DESI.
The combined fits give S8 values of 0.786 with DES, 0.760 with KiDS, and 0.771 with HSC, each consistent with the others and sitting about 1.5 to 2 sigma below the Planck microwave background fit. One unified pipeline handles all surveys, with an analytic covariance matrix covering every cross covariance. A new blinding procedure guards against confirmation bias.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. Porredon , 1,2,3,4,∗ C. Blake , 5 J. U. Lange , 6 N. Emas, 5 J. Aguilar, 7 S. Ahlen , 8 A. Bera, 9 D. Bianchi , 10,11 D. Brooks, 12 F. J. Castander , 13,14 T. Claybaugh, 7 J. Coloma Nadal, 15 A. Cuceu , 7 K. S. Dawson , 16 A. de la Macorra , 17 Biprateep Dey , 18,19 P. Doel, 12 A. Elliott , 20,4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 95 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-15960
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
DESI-DR1 3 × 2 3\times 2 -pt analysis: Consistent cosmology across weak lensing surveys ∗ E-mail: [email protected] A. Porredon , 1,2,3,4,∗ C. Blake , 5 J. U. Lange , 6 N. Emas, 5 J. Aguilar, 7 S. Ahlen , 8 A. Bera, 9 D. Bianchi , 10,11 D. Brooks, 12 F. J. Castander , 13,14 T. Claybaugh, 7 J. Coloma Nadal, 15 A. Cuceu , 7 K. S. Dawson , 16 A. de la Macorra , 17 Biprateep Dey , 18,19 P. Doel, 12 A. Elliott , 20,4 S. Ferraro , 7,21 A. Font-Ribera , 22 J. E. Forero-Romero , 23,24 C. Garcia-Quintero , 25 E. Gaztañaga , 13,26,14 S. Gontcho A Gontcho , 7,27 G. Gutierrez, 28 J. Guy , 7 B. Hadzhiyska , 29,21 H. K. Herrera-Alcantar , 30,31 S. Heydenreich , 32 K. Honscheid , 33,20,4 C. Howlett , 34 D. Huterer , 35,36 M. Ishak , 9 S. Joudaki , 1 R. Joyce , 37 D. Kirkby , 38 A. Kremin , 7 A. Krolewski, 39,40,41 O. Lahav, 12 C. Lamman , 4 M. Landriau , 7 L. Le Guillou , 42 A. Leauthaud , 32,43 M. E. Levi , 7 M. Manera , 44,22 A. Meisner , 37 R. Miquel, 45,22 S. Nadathur , 26 J. A. Newman , 19 G. Niz , 46,47 N. Palanque-Delabrouille , 31,7 W. J. Percival , 39,40,41 C. Poppett, 7,48,21 F. Prada , 49 I. Pérez-Ràfols , 50 A. Robertson, 37 G. Rossi, 51 R. Ruggeri , 52 E. Sanchez , 1 C. Saulder , 53 D. Schlegel, 7 M. Schubnell, 35,36 A. Semenaite, 5 H. Seo , 54 J. Silber , 7 A. Souki, 1 D. Sprayberry, 37 G. Tarlé , 36 M. Vargas-Magaña , 17 B. A. Weaver, 37 C. Zhou, 32 R. Zhou , 7 and H. Zou 55 (DESI Collaboration) (Affiliations can be found after the references) Abstract We present a joint cosmological analysis of projected galaxy clustering observations from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument Data Release 1 (DESI-DR1), and overlapping weak gravitational lensing observations from three datasets: the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS-1000), the Dark Energy Survey (DES-Y3), and the Hyper-Suprime-Cam Survey (HSC-Y3). This combination of large-scale structure probes allows us to measure a set of 3 × 2 3\times 2 -pt correlation functions, breaking the degeneracies between parameters in cosmological fits to individual observables. We obtain mutually-consistent constraints on the parameter S 8 = σ 8 Ω m / 0.3 = 0.786 − 0.019 + 0.022 S_{8}=\sigma_{8}\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm m}/0.3}=0.786^{+0.022}_{-0.019} from the combination of DESI-DR1 and DES-Y3, S 8 = 0.760 − 0.018 + 0.020 S_{8}=0.760^{+0.020}_{-0.018} from KiDS-1000, and S 8 = 0.771 − 0.027 + 0.026 S_{8}=0.771^{+0.026}_{-0.027} from HSC-Y3. These parameter determinations are consistent with fits to the Planck Cosmic Microwave Background dataset, albeit with 1.5 − 2 σ 1.5-2\sigma lower values in the S 8 − Ω m S_{8}-\Omega_{\mathrm{m}} plane. We perform our analysis with a unified pipeline tailored to the requirements of each cosmic shear survey, which self-consistently determines cosmological and astrophysical parameters. We generate an analytical covariance matrix for the correlation data including all cross-covariances between probes, and we design a new blinding procedure to safeguard our analysis against confirmation bias, whilst leaving goodness-of-fit statistics unchanged. Our study is part of a suite of papers that present joint cosmological analyses of DESI-DR1 and weak gravitational lensing datasets. DESI-DR1 3\times 2 -pt Analysis keywords Cosmology, weak gravitational lensing, large-scale structure of Universe 1 Introduction A central goal of modern cosmology is to define and scrutinise the model that describes the composition, initial conditions and evolution of the Universe. Given a set of compelling unsolved problems, including the unknown physics represented by dark matter and dark energy, we seek new information that might refine our knowledge ( 137 ; 68 ; 102 ; 67 , for reviews, see) . As cosmological datasets continue to expand impressively, an important theme is to combine these datasets in unified analysis frameworks. Such joint analyses serve to improve the statistical precision of our cosmological parameter determinations, mitigate against key systematic errors, and stress-test the self-consistency of our model framework against the baseline established by analyses of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation ( 107 ) . Such comparisons have already revealed a variety of “tensions” and “intriguing hints” which guide future exploration: including disagreements between determinations of the local expansion rate ( 116 ; 37 ; 45 ; 117 ; 134 ) , debates over the amplitude of matter fluctuations ( 85 ; 73 ; 59 ) , and suggestions that the physics of dark energy might evolve with time ( 28 ; 27 ; 32 ) . The large-scale structure of the Universe as mapped by spectroscopic redshift surveys, and the gravitational lensing of light by this structure as probed by photometric imaging surveys, have long been seen as highly complementary cosmological probes ( 14 ; 49 ; 20 ; 76 , e.g.,) . A set of 3\times 2 -pt correlation statistics can be constructed from these datasets: cosmic shear, the correlated distortions in galaxy shapes induced by weak gravitational lensing by the cosmic web; galaxy clustering, the correlations between galaxy positions caused by gravitational physics; and galaxy-galaxy lensing, the tangential shear of background source galaxies around foreground lens galaxies. The amplitude and scale-dependence of these correlations may be accurately predicted by lensing and clustering theory, allowing us to infer the values of the cosmological parameters which control the expansion, growth and distribution of matter. However, correlations are also induced by a variety of astrophysical effects, including intrinsic alignments, unknown photometric redshift distributions, baryonic effects in the matter power spectrum, shape measurement calibrations, and the biasing of galaxies with respect to matter fluctuations. Testing the cosmological model in light of these potential complications requires us to create a joint analysis framework which can be applied across survey datasets. In this paper, we present a unified cosmology analysis of 3\times 2 -pt statistics utilising the large-scale structure dataset assembled by the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) in conjunction with three important weak lensing (WL) surveys. We hence use DESI galaxies to form the lens sample for the 3\times 2 -pt correlations, instead of photometric galaxies from the imaging surveys. DESI, which has been operating its main survey program at Kitt Peak National Observatory since 2021, has already assembled the largest existing spectroscopic redshift dataset for cosmology, exceeding previous programs by more than an order of magnitude ( 34 ; 35 ; 30 ) . Our study is based on the first substantial assembly of DESI data, compiled from the first year of operations ( 29 , Data Release 1,) . Together with DESI data, we also use publicly-available weak lensing catalogues from the Dark Energy Survey Year 3 ( 123 ; 48 , DES-Y3,) , the Kilo-Degree Survey ( 79 ; 50 , KiDS-1000,) , and the Hyper Suprime-Cam survey Year 3 ( 1 ; 88 , HSC-Y3,) . Our work builds upon a wealth of cosmological studies already presented by these collaborations ( 63 ; 24 ; 60 ; 55 ; 61 ; 59 ; 25 ; 89 ; 19 ; 138 , e.g.,) . In particular, 23 ; 47 ; 69 have previously performed analyses