Governance by Evidence: Regulated Predictors in Decision-Tree Models
ALEXIOS VESKOUKIS, DIMITRIS KALLES · 2025
Read Governance by Evidence: Regulated Predictors in Decision-Tree Models by ALEXIOS VESKOUKIS, DIMITRIS KALLES (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-15955.txt.
Introduction
Alexios Veskoukis and Dimitris Kalles examine regulated predictors in published decision tree models in a 2025 paper. Decision trees are prized because readers can follow them, and papers using them usually list their inputs openly. Many of those predictors, such as age, diagnosis codes, and location, fall under privacy law, a link rarely checked.
The authors compile a corpus of decision tree studies, assign each reported input to a regulated data class, and link each category to passages in European Union and United States privacy laws. Many inputs prove regulated, with the largest shares in health care and clear gaps across fields. The evidence supports privacy saving methods and oversight checks in machine learning practice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | ALEXIOS VESKOUKIS, DIMITRIS KALLES |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 93 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-15955
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Governance by Evidence: Regulated Predictors in Decision-Tree Models ALEXIOS VESKOUKIS, DIMITRIS KALLES Abstract . Decision-tree methods are widely used on structured tabular data and are valued for interpretability across many industry sectors. However as published studies often list the predictors they used (for example age, diagnosis codes, location), current privacy laws increasingly lead us to raise the question of how often these reported predictors fall into legally regulated data types, and in which industries is this exposure maximum and, maybe, leading to legal risks. In this work, we use published decision-tree papers as a practical proxy for real-world use of legally governed data types. We compile a corpus of decision-tree studies and assign each explicitly reported predictor to a regulated data category (for example health data, biometric identifiers, children’s data, financial attributes, location traces, and government IDs), which we then link to the specific text excerpts in European Union/United States privacy law which covers the category or the predictor itself. Across the corpus, we observe that many reported predictors fall in regulated data categories, with the largest shares in healthcare and clear differences across industries. We analyze corpus-wide prevalence, industry composition, and temporal patterns of regulated predictors reported in decision-tree studies and we assess regulation-aligned timing by marking each framework’s reference year and summarizing cross-framework differences. This work aims to map the current use of regulated data in decision-tree models so as to motivate and orient further work on privacy-preserving methods and governance checks. Although we focus on decision-tree studies, the evidence and governance checks that we present can inform privacy-preserving machine-learning practice more broadly. This is an author version (preprint). 1. Introduction Decision-tree models are widely used in applied machine learning on tabular data across domains such as healthcare, finance, marketing, and public services. They are often chosen because their structure appears easy to inspect, yet the predictors they use describe people, organizations, and behavior in ways that privacy and sectoral laws regulate. Legal frameworks in the European Union and the United States define categories of regulated data and attach duties to their use, disclosure, and retention. These legal duties motivate a closer look at how decision-tree predictors relate to law-defined data categories across sectors and years. Our study uses the published decision-tree literature as a proxy for model use in practice. We assemble a corpus of tree-based papers from multiple sectors, identify the predictors that authors explicitly report, and align these predictors with an ontology of regulated data categories anchored in specific clauses of European Union and United States regulation. AI-assisted data extraction and human validation link predictors to paragraph-cited legal fragments. On this basis we quantify how reported predictors are distributed across sectors and regulated categories, estimate what share of them falls within law-defined categories, rank regulations by how often they govern the predictors and categories we observe, and trace how the use of regulated predictors changes over time. In this study, we first situate our work in conceptual and empirical background and related research. We then describe how we construct the dataset of decision-tree papers, extract predictors, and map them to regulated data categories and legal clauses. Next, we present our audit-based error assessment and population correction and report empirical findings on regulated predictors across sectors, regulations, and time. We conclude by summarizing our data, code, and replication resources, discussing limitations, and examining societal and policy implications. 2. Background and Related Work This section provides conceptual and empirical background for our study. We first review decision-tree models and their role in interpretable machine learning. We then define regulated data categories and the multi-class schema we use to normalize predictors, and describe how we map them to regulatory clauses. Next, we identify what existing surveys cover and what corpus-scale measurement gaps remain. Finally, we summarize the resources we provide for responsible computing. 2.1. Decision trees and interpretability Decision trees make their reasoning explicit: each split names a condition and each root–to–leaf path is a human-readable rule. This transparency supports audit and documentation. Canonical tree induction methods and widely used toolchains illustrate this transparency in practice ( Quinlan 1986 ; Quinlan 1993 ; Kalles and Morris 1996 ; Kalles and Papagelis 2000 ; Kalles and Papagelis 2009 ; Hall et al. 2009 ; Shapiro 1987 ) . Benchmark repositories and applied evaluations further motivate explicit predictor reporting in the literature ( Dua and Graff 2017 ; Kurgan et al. 2001 ) . Because published tree studies often list the exact predictors (and sometimes rules) they used, we extract the reported predictors, normalize them to a fixed attribute ontology, and anchor them to paragraph-cited legal categories. This provides a precise basis to quantify when published practice touches regulated data categories and to assess implications for disclosure, auditing, and risk across domains and time. 2.2. Privacy regulations and regulated data categories Our analysis links paper-extracted predictors to paragraph-anchored legal evidence. This design is motivated by privacy-preserving data mining work that operationalizes privacy risk and protection in terms of sensitive attributes and attribute classes ( Agrawal and Srikant 2000 ; Verykios et al. 2004 ; Kreso et al. 2020 ; Krasadakis 2020 ) . The pipeline maps each extracted decision-tree predictor to an attribute ontology and then to regulatory clauses using quoted fragments keyed to article or sections of major regulation applicable in the EU (European Union) ( European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2016 ; European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2002 ; European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2022 ; European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2015 ; European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2011 ) and the US (United States) ( United States 1996 ; United States 2009 ; United States 1999 ; Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives 2025 ; California Legislative Information 2025 ; California Secretary of State 2020 ) ; the final validator cites the exact paragraphs, enabling audit and re-checks without external knowledge. Regulated data categories are the bridge from raw mentioned predictors in scientific literature to law-defined categories. By regulated data category we mean the ontology to which category that a predictor belongs . We use a fixed, closed multi-class schema (e.g., Health_Clinical , Demographic , Behavioral , Financial , Device_OnlineID , Child_Data ) to normalize heterogeneous predictors and to aggregate legal coverage at the class level. This evidence-first linkage supports robust counts and comparisons later in the paper without inferring regulation beyond what the quoted text supports. 2.3. Prior surveys and gaps Surveys in privacy and machine learning summarize protection mechanisms for data mining and access control ( Agrawal and Srikant 2000 ; Verykios et al. 2004 ; Kreso et al. 2020 ; Krasadakis 2020 ) . In this work, we focus on corpus-scale measurement for decision-tree studies where predictors are explicitly reported and can be linked to paragraph-cited legal text. We treat these counts as an evidence-first proxy for reported practice across sectors and time. To our knowledge, corpus-scale measurement remains limited. We lack counts of how often published decision-tree papers report predictors in legally governed data types and how this varies by industry and year. Because many deployments in practice adopt methods first introduced in the