Bridging Data and Physics: A Graph Neural Network–Based Hybrid Twin Framework
M. Gorpinich, B. Moya, S. Rodriguez, F. Meraghni, Y. Jaafra, A. Briot, M. Henner, R. Leon, F. Chinesta · 2025
Read Bridging Data and Physics: A Graph Neural Network–Based Hybrid Twin Framework by M. Gorpinich, B. Moya, S. Rodriguez, F. Meraghni, Y. Jaafra, A. Briot, M. Henner, R. Leon, F. Chinesta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-15767.txt.
Introduction
M. Gorpinich and co authors present a graph neural network based hybrid twin framework in a 2025 paper, dated December 12. Physics simulations, such as finite element models, miss real effects through simplifications, leaving an ignorance gap. Pure data driven models could fill it, but they demand dense data that real settings rarely provide.
The hybrid twin models only the ignorance part, which is simpler than the full response. A graph neural network learns its spatial pattern from sparse measurement points and varied geometries. Tests on nonlinear heat transfer across meshes, shapes, and load positions show the network generalizes corrections well. Simulation accuracy and interpretability improve while data needs stay low.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Gorpinich, B. Moya, S. Rodriguez, F. Meraghni, Y. Jaafra, A. Briot, M. Henner, R. Leon, F. Chinesta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-15767
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bridging Data and Physics: A Graph Neural Network–Based Hybrid Twin Framework M. Gorpinich, B. Moya, S. Rodriguez, F. Meraghni, Y. Jaafra, A. Briot, M. Henner, R. Leon, F. Chinesta Abstract Simulating complex unsteady physical phenomena relies on detailed mathematical models, simulated for instance by using the Finite Element Method (FEM). However, these models often exhibit discrepancies from the reality due to unmodeled effects or simplifying assumptions. We refer to this gap as the ignorance model. While purely data-driven approaches attempt to learn full system behavior from measurements, they require large amounts of high-quality data across the entire spatial and temporal domain. In many real-world scenarios, such information is unavailable as physical quantities are measurable only at limited points, making full data-driven modeling unreliable. To overcome this limitation, a hybrid twin approach is required. Instead of simulating phenomena from scratch, here we focus on the modeling of the ignorance component. Since physics-based models approximate the overall behavior of the phenomena, the remaining ignorance is typically lower in complexity than the full physical response, therefore, it can be learned with significantly fewer data. A key difficulty, however, is that spatial measurements are sparse, and even more, obtaining data measuring the same phenomenon for different spatial configurations — system’s domain, external load, etc. — is challenging in practice. Our contribution is to overcome this limitation by using Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) to represent the ignorance model. GNNs inherently handle geometric structures, making them compatible with any approximation technique, for instance, FEM. They learn the spatial pattern of the missing physics even when the number of measurement locations is limited. This allows us to enrich the physics-based model with data-driven corrections without requiring dense spatial, temporal and parametric data. To showcase the performance of the proposed methodology, we evaluate this GNN-based hybrid twin on nonlinear heat transfer problems across different meshes, geometries, and load positions. Results show that the GNN successfully captures the ignorance and generalizes corrections across domain geometries and mesh discretizations, improving simulation accuracy and interpretability, while minimizing data requirements. 1 Introduction High-fidelity simulations of complex systems, such as those that exhibit a strongly nonlinear behaviour — turbulent fluid flows, structural deformations under large loads, or architectured materials, to name a few — are crucial for design, safety assessment, and performance optimization. The representation of their behaviour leads to the resolution of complex and expensive models for their approximation. However, in most cases, the considered models does not accurately represent reality. This is due to physical biases or simplifications in the models, or to inherent errors when discretizing the corresponding Partial Differential Equations (PDEs) using, for instance, the Finite Elements Method [ 51 ] . Therefore, in these scenarios, a gap between the prediction and the reality is perceived [ 39 ] . In order to address this limitation, an extension of classical Digital twins was proposed, called hybrid twins [ 9 ] . The main idea consists in learning this ignorance by a data-driven model, usually constructed using model-order reduction [ 46 , 44 , 43 ] as the sparse Proper Generalized Decomposition or deep learning techniques [ 37 , 38 , 18 , 27 ] . In the field of hybrid modeling, the main challenges lie in the ability to generalize, adapt, and integrate seamlessly with the underlying physics-based model [ 57 ] . The main advantage of combining a physics-based with a data-based model for the ignorance is reducing the need for experimental data, as long as the physical model represents reality up to some degree. This is an appealing property at the industrial level, where experimental data is limited due to its deployment costs. Several deep learning techniques have been used to build this ignorance model. Among them, one can mention the use of LSTMs (Long short-term memory) or ResNet (Residual Network) architectures [ 17 ] , which have a major impact in learning dynamical systems. This is possible because, although measurements can only be taken at a few spatial locations, temporal sampling can be performed without limitation, allowing the acquisition of rich and detailed time-series data. However, constructing an ignorance model capable of providing corrections across the entire spatial domain remains challenging, because the sparsity of spatial measurements makes it difficult for these models to infer accurate corrections in unobserved regions of the domain. An attractive alternative to overcome this spatial correction limitation is the use of Graph Neural Networks [ 47 ] . The main advantage of these networks consists in their capability of learning inherent spatial geometric relations of the dataset, being able to produce predictions for different geometric domains. This technique has proven effective for learning full models of the prediction of complex systems, given known initial conditions [ 40 ] . Nevertheless, these models have some drawbacks when the dataset is not expressive enough for the phenomenon to be learnt [ 23 ] . However, in the field of hybrid twinning, since the main objective corresponds to the construction of the ignorance model, the use of GNNs for the best adapted ignorance spatial construction seems appealing. Therefore, the novelty of this work is the implementation of a hybrid twin using GNNs to achieve a spatial correction, given by the ignorance model, when considering sparse data points for its construction. To illustrate this idea, we consider synthetic data to present the methodology. The reference problem is the enrichment of a linear heat transfer simulation in order to predict a nonlinear counterpart response, unknown. These simulations are obtained using the FEM. Here, the ignorance model is learnt using GNNs with a graph representation derived from the FEM discretization. GNNs offer the ability to capture a generalized representation of corrections across different scenarios (domain geometry or load position variations) and discretization levels, while requiring less data due to the imposition of geometric biases, thereby enhancing the efficiency of learning the ignorance model. We show proof of the efficiency of the hybrid framework under different domains and conditions, showcasing the stability, error reduction, and generalization capability compared to baseline, fully data-driven GNNs. The paper is organised as follows. Section 2 exposes the state-of-the-art and makes an overview of the common approaches applied to the problem under consideration. Section 3 describes the model architecture details. Following, Section 4 presents the configurations of the test use cases. Section 5 analyses the results, and finally Section 6 concludes the paper, explores possible perspectives of the research and summarizes the findings. 2 Related works Physics-based models have been traditionally used for the approximation of physical phenomena of interest. These ensure both interpretability and expressivity, as they have been developed in accordance with physical laws [ 41 ] . However, they are sometimes limited by poor modeling and mathematical assumptions that do not capture the whole complexity of the problem [ 9 ] . This issue can arise from a wrongly chosen time or space discretization [ 49 ] , or possibly due to missing or incorrect information in the mathematical approximation [ 37 ] , such as, for instance, assuming an incorrect non-linearity term [ 19 ] or simplified physics contributions. Hence, representations of the physics problem deviate from reality, compromising their use in real applications [ 39 ] . These