Note on bulk viscosity as an alternative to dark energy

P. P. Avelino, A. R. Gomes, D. A. Tamayo · 2025

Read Note on bulk viscosity as an alternative to dark energy by P. P. Avelino, A. R. Gomes, D. A. Tamayo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-15633.txt.

Introduction

P. P. Avelino, A. R. Gomes, and D. A. Tamayo examine bulk viscosity as an alternative to dark energy in a 2025 paper. Bulk viscosity is a fluid's resistance to volume change, and it has been proposed to drive the speed up of cosmic expansion, both early and late. The authors test two physical origins for the effect.

One origin is nonminimal interaction between two fluids, the other is elastic collisions in an ideal gas. In the first case, getting the standard viscous tensor costs violation of all classical energy conditions. In the second, pressure stays non negative, too weak to drive acceleration. The results expose physical hurdles for viscous dark energy models.

Catalog record

CREATORP. P. Avelino, A. R. Gomes, D. A. Tamayo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-15633

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Note on bulk viscosity as an alternative to dark energy P. P. Avelino, A. R. Gomes, D. A. Tamayo Abstract Bulk viscosity, which characterizes the irreversible dissipative resistance of a fluid to volume changes, has been proposed as a potential mechanism for explaining both early- and late-time accelerated expansion of the Universe. In this work, we investigate two distinct physical scenarios for the origin of bulk viscosity: (1) nonminimal interactions between two fluids, and (2) elastic collisions in an ideal gas. In both cases, we demonstrate that while the associated energy–momentum exchange can significantly influence fluid dynamics, overall energy–momentum conservation precludes such exchange from having any direct gravitational effect in the context of General Relativity. In case (1), we show that the standard bulk viscous energy–momentum tensor can be obtained for the two-fluid system only at the cost of the violation of all classical energy conditions: null, weak, dominant, and strong. In case (2), we consider a single fluid composed of point particles undergoing instantaneous, energy- and momentum-conserving collisions, and find that the proper pressure remains strictly non-negative, with the equation-of-state parameter confined to the interval [ 0 , 1 / 3 ] [0,1/3] . In both scenarios, achieving a sufficiently negative effective pressure to drive cosmic acceleration requires assumptions that compromise the physical viability of the model. Our results highlight some of the key physical challenges involved in modeling dark energy through bulk viscous effects. I Introduction Viscosity plays a crucial role in many physical phenomena, especially in relativistic astrophysical environments characterized by extreme conditions, such as the regions around black holes or neutron stars. In these gravitationally dominated systems, it is essential to account for dissipative effects in the hydrodynamic equations. While classical descriptions of viscous fluids Landau and Lifschits 1980 are sufficient for many scenarios, they become inadequate in regimes involving strong gravity or relativistic velocities. In such cases, a fully relativistic treatment of fluid dynamics is required Weinberg 1972 (see also Maartens 1996 ; Andersson and Comer 2007 ). A natural extension of this idea has led several authors to explore the potential role of dissipative fluids in cosmology. In the context of a perfectly homogeneous and isotropic universe described by the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) metric, the spacetime symmetries imply the absence of shear viscosity and heat conduction. For this reason, the exploration of the potential role of dissipative processes on the dynamics of the Universe has been mostly focused on relativistic bulk viscosity Maartens 1995 ; Maartens 1996 ; Zimdahl 1996 . This has motivated its study as a possible driver of accelerated cosmic expansion at both early Zimdahl et al. 1997 ; Chimento et al. 1997 ; Mimoso et al. 2006 ; Sawyer 2006 ; Tawfik et al. 2010 ; Bamba and Odintsov 2016 ; Haro and Pan 2018 and late times Fabris et al. 2006 ; Meng et al. 2007 ; Meng and Dou 2009 ; Avelino and Nucamendi 2009 ; Li and Barrow 2009 ; Avelino and Nucamendi 2010 ; Piattella et al. 2011 ; Gagnon and Lesgourgues 2011 ; Velten et al. 2013 ; Floerchinger et al. 2015 ; Brevik et al. 2015 ; Wang et al. 2017 ; Yang et al. 2019 ; Odintsov et al. 2020 ; Tamayo 2022 . These studies generally adopt a phenomenological framework in which a single fluid is modeled with a covariantly conserved energy–momentum tensor, corresponding to that of a perfect fluid with an additional term a proper pressure contribution associated with bulk viscosity. While such phenomenological approaches may be sufficient for an effective description within classical fluid dynamics, they fail to provide a comprehensive and fully consistent physical framework for the underlying mechanisms responsible for the emergence of bulk viscosity. In Eckart’s theory Eckart 1940 , bulk viscous pressure is treated as a small perturbation to the equilibrium pressure. The Israel–Stewart theory Israel and Stewart 1979 avoids the acausal propagation of perturbations inherent to Eckart’s formulation, but it remains perturbative despite incorporating higher-order terms. Regardless of these limitations, any significant cosmological impact of bulk viscosity should ultimately arise from far-from-equilibrium physics. Indeed, if bulk viscosity is proposed as an explanation for dark energy, its contribution must dominate the total pressure. This requirement renders a perturbative description of bulk viscosity inadequate for such a role. Thus, in contrast to the standard assumption that the fluid’s true energy–momentum tensor is that of a perfect fluid supplemented by an ad hoc bulk-viscous term, here we adopt a different perspective. Specifically, we consider two distinct physical scenarios for the origin of bulk viscosity: (i) nonminimal interactions between two different fluids, and (ii) elastic collisions in an ideal gas. We then examine the potential cosmological implications of these scenarios, with particular emphasis on their viability as potential dark energy mechanisms. Previous studies Li and Barrow 2009 ; Velten and Schwarz 2011 ; Giovannini 2015 ; Barbosa et al. 2017 have already identified problems with the hypothesis that bulk pressure alone can drive the late-time acceleration of the Universe, suggesting that an additional dark energy component remains necessary. In most cases, these issues arise at the perturbative level rather than in the background evolution. In contrast, this study explores more fundamental physical limitations of attributing late-time cosmic acceleration solely to a bulk viscous fluid. The outline of this paper is as follows. In Sec. II, we consider nonrelativistic bulk viscosity and demonstrate that its impact on the dynamics of the Universe is negligible. In Sec. III, we explore a relativistic scenario where bulk viscosity arises from nonminimal interactions between two fluids, critically examining its potential effects on the accelerated expansion of the Universe. In Sec. IV, we analyze the case of an idealized single-fluid model composed of point particles interacting microscopically conserving energy and momentum. Finally, our conclusions are presented in Sec. V. Throughout this work, we adopt the metric signature [-,+,+,+] and use natural units where c=1 . II Nonrelativistic bulk viscosity Bulk viscosity characterizes the irreversible response of a fluid to changes in volume and may be associated with an effective pressure experienced by the fluid that differs from its true proper pressure. Here, we consider a fluid without shear viscosity or heat flux, composed of stable, nonrelativistic particles, and assume that this pressure difference corresponds to the bulk viscous pressure: \Pi=p_{\rm eff}-p=-\zeta\nabla\cdot\vec{v}\,, (1) where \nabla\cdot\vec{v} is the divergence of the fluid’s 3-velocity field, and \zeta>0 is the bulk viscosity coefficient. This coefficient generally depends on the fluid’s microscopic properties, which may vary with time and position. In a nonrelativistic regime, the internal energy of the fluid is approximately conserved, which implies that the continuity equation \frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\rho\vec{v})=\frac{d\rho}{dt}+\rho\,\nabla\cdot\vec{v}=0 (2) holds to first order in |\vec{v}| . When combined with Eq. ( 1 ), this yields \Pi=\zeta\frac{d\ln\rho}{dt}\,. (3) The energy density of a homogeneous volume element V containing a fixed number N of nonrelativistic particles of constant proper mass m is approximately given by \rho=\frac{mN}{V}\,. (4) Combining Eqs. ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) we obtain an approximate relation between the bulk viscous pressure and the volume change \Pi=-\zeta\frac{1}{V}\frac{dV}{dt}\,. (5) The work done by the bulk viscous pressure in an expanding system is then given approximately by W_{\Pi}=\int_{V_{i}}^{V_{f}}\Pi dV=-\int_{V_{i}}^{V_{f}}\zeta\frac{dV}{dt}\frac{dV}{V}<0\,. (6) The negative sign indicates that the work done

Read the complete text