Simultaneous Sequential Compactness

Sirio Resteghini, Cesare Straffelini · 2025

Read Simultaneous Sequential Compactness by Sirio Resteghini, Cesare Straffelini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-15593.txt.

Introduction

Sirio Resteghini and Cesare Straffelini study simultaneous sequential compactness in a 2025 math paper. A family of sequences converges simultaneously when one infinite subset of indices works for all of them at once. The question is how large such families can be, and in which spaces the property holds.

The authors discuss simultaneous convergence in the same space and across different sequentially compact spaces, and link the two settings. They show it holds for fewer sequences than certain cardinal bounds, depending on the weight of the space, and generalize the results to Hausdorff spaces. A final part probes whether those bounds are optimal. The work sits in general topology and set theory.

Catalog record

CREATORSirio Resteghini, Cesare Straffelini
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-15593

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simultaneous Sequential Compactness Sirio Resteghini, Cesare Straffelini Abstract . A set of sequences is said to converge simultaneously if there exists an infinite subset H H of the index set ω \omega such that all sequences converge when restricted to H H . We discuss simultaneous convergence of sequences in the same or in different sequentially compact spaces; we link the results for different spaces to ones for the same space; we show that simultaneous convergence happens for less than 𝔰 \mathfrak{s} sequences in spaces with weight bounded by 𝔰 \mathfrak{s} and for less than 𝔥 \mathfrak{h} sequences in general; we show a slight generalisation of these results in the context of Hausdorff spaces; and finally we investigate their optimality. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 03E17, 54A25 (Primary) 54D10, 54D30, 54D55 (Secondary) 1. Introduction and Preliminary Results Given a topological space X and a sequence x=\langle x_{n}:n<\omega\rangle of points in X , where the index set \omega is the least infinite ordinal, we say that x converges to some point x_{\infty}\in X if, for every open neighbourhood U of x_{\infty} in X , there exists a natural number n_{U}<\omega such that x_{n}\in U for all n>n_{U} . If H is an infinite subset of \omega , we say that x converges along H if the subsequence x\upharpoonright H=\langle x_{n}:n\in H\rangle converges. Our aim is to study the following problem: given several sequences (which may take values in different topological spaces), can we find an infinite subset H of \omega such that all these sequences converge along H ? We seek an answer that may depend both on the number of sequences and on the topological properties of spaces under consideration. Let [\omega]^{\omega} denote the set of all infinite subsets of \omega . For two elements H_{0} and H_{1} in [\omega]^{\omega} , we write H_{0}=^{\ast}H_{1} if their symmetric difference is finite (i.e., they differ only on a finite set), and H_{0}\subseteq^{\ast}H_{1} if there exists H^{\prime}\subseteq H_{1} with H_{0}=^{\ast}H^{\prime} . If H_{0}=^{\ast}H_{1} , then x\upharpoonright H_{0} converges if and only if x\upharpoonright H_{1} does. On the other hand, if H_{0}\subseteq^{\ast}H_{1} , then x\upharpoonright H_{0} converges if (but not necessarily only if) x\upharpoonright H_{1} converges. Definition 1.1 . If \lambda is a cardinal, a space X is \lambda - simultaneously sequentially compact ( \lambda -ssc for short) if, whenever we are given \lambda -many sequences having values in X , we can find H\in[\omega]^{\omega} such that each of those sequences converges along H . Note that if \lambda\leqslant\kappa and a space X is \kappa -ssc, then X is \lambda -ssc. Moreover, the definition of “ 1 -ssc” coincides with the standard definition of sequential compactness. Sequential compactness already implies \aleph_{0} -simultaneous sequential compactness, a fact that can be proved via a diagonalisation argument. For sake of completeness, we provide a proof below. Lemma 1.2 . A topological space is sequentially compact if and only if it is \aleph_{0} -ssc. Proof. First, assume X is \aleph_{0} -ssc. Then it is 1 -ssc, and thus sequentially compact. Now, assume X is sequentially compact. Let x^{k} be sequences with values in X , for k<\omega . By sequential compactness, there exists H_{0}\in[\omega]^{\omega} such that x^{0}\upharpoonright H_{0} converges. Next, consider the sequence x^{1}\upharpoonright H_{1} . Since X is sequentially compact, there is H_{1}\subseteq H_{0} in [\omega]^{\omega} such that x^{1}\upharpoonright H_{1} converges. By a previous remark, we can add finitely many elements to H_{1} without losing convergence, so we assume that H_{0} and H_{1} have the same least element. Proceed by induction. Suppose we have sets H_{i} for i<k such that H_{i+1}\subseteq H_{i} , and that H_{i} and H_{i+1} agree on the first i+1 elements, with each subsequence x^{i}\upharpoonright H_{i} converging. Consider x^{k}\upharpoonright H_{k-1} . Since X is sequentially compact, there exists H_{k}\subseteq H_{k-1} such that x^{k}\upharpoonright H_{k} converges. We may assume that H_{k-1} and H_{k} agree on their first k elements. Let H:=\bigcap_{k<\omega}H_{k} . This set is infinite because for all k<\omega the first k elements of H_{k} belong to H . Since H\subseteq H_{k} for all k<\omega , every sequence x^{k}\upharpoonright H converges, as required. ∎ This work is then structured as follows. In Section 2 , we generalise a result by Andreas Blass from [ Bla10 ] , showing the first of our main results: Theorem 2.7 . If \lambda<\mathfrak{s} , any sequentially compact space X with w(X)<\mathfrak{s} is \lambda -ssc. Here, \mathfrak{s} denotes the splitting number. In Section 3 , we consider the case of Hausdorff spaces. We define a cardinal invariant, called countable Hausdorff weight ( \mathrm{cHw} ), which we use in place of the weight to improve on Theorem 2.7 : Theorem 3.5 . If \lambda<\mathfrak{s} , any sequentially compact Hausdorff space X with \mathrm{cHw}(X)<\mathfrak{s} is \lambda -ssc. In Section 4 , we address the problem of sequences in different topological spaces. There, both the general results from Section 2 and the specific results for Hausdorff spaces from Section 3 are generalised to this new context, showing that they essentially continue to hold, provided that all sequences come from spaces with comparable properties. Finally, in Section 5 we prove the following result, which does not rely on any restriction on the cardinal invariants of the space: Theorem 5.2 . If \lambda<\mathfrak{h} , any sequentially compact space X is \lambda -ssc. Here, \mathfrak{h} denotes the distributivity number. At the end, we propose some further questions regarding the optimality of some of our results. 2. Results based on the Splitting Number Lemma 1.2 provides a lower bound for the extent of simultaneous sequential compactness exhibited by a sequentially compact space. We now turn to the question of finding an upper bound, which, unlike the lower bound, will depend on additional topological properties of the space. Indeed, in the extremely trivial case where a space only has one element, it is easy to show that it is \lambda -ssc for all cardinals \lambda . Definition 2.1 . We say that a topological space X is “nontrivial enough to distinguish two points” (in the following, we just write nontrivial) if in X there are two elements a and b such that the closure of \{a\} and the closure of \{b\} are disjoint. For a nontrivial space X , there is indeed an upper bound for the possible values of \lambda for which X could be \lambda -ssc. This bound is given by the splitting number \mathfrak{s} . Definition 2.2 . A family \mathcal{S}\subseteq[\omega]^{\omega} is said to be a splitting family if for every A\in[\omega]^{\omega} there is some S\in\mathcal{S} such that both A\cap S and A-S are infinite sets. The splitting number \mathfrak{s} is then defined to be the least cardinality of a splitting family. It holds \aleph_{1}\leqslant\mathfrak{s}\leqslant 2^{\aleph_{0}} , and it is consistent relative to ZFC that \aleph_{1}<\mathfrak{s}<2^{\aleph_{0}} . For more informations about the splitting number, we refer the interested reader to Andreas Blass’s handbook chapter [ Bla10 ] . There, one may also find the proof of the statement “the discrete space \{0,1\} is not \mathfrak{s} -ssc”, which, as can be easily seen, can be readapted to prove also the apparently stronger Lemma 2.3 . Lemma 2.3 . If X is a nontrivial topological space, X is not \mathfrak{s} -ssc. Proof. Let a and b be

Read the complete text