Extended defects in hard disk system and melting criteria.
M. V. Kondrin, Y.B. Lebed, V. V. Brazhkin · 2025
Read Extended defects in hard disk system and melting criteria. by M. V. Kondrin, Y.B. Lebed, V. V. Brazhkin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-15348.txt.
Introduction
M. V. Kondrin and two coauthors derive melting criteria for the simplest possible crystal: a plane of hard disks. Hard sphere and hard disk models are the zero order picture of fluids and solids, yet few exact results exist for them. The authors study melting by tracking how extended defects of one type accumulate in the crystal, and how the disk packing jams.
Their analysis bounds the volume ratio at the melting transition between 25/21 and 5/4. In line with the celebrated BKTHNY theory, the two dimensional crystal melts first into an anisotropic liquid. A second transition, from that anisotropic liquid to a normal isotropic one, is bounded between volume ratios 5/4 and 13/9. The work adds rare analytic anchors to the theory of two dimensional melting.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. V. Kondrin, Y.B. Lebed, V. V. Brazhkin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-15348
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Extended defects in hard disk system and melting criteria. M. V. Kondrin, Y.B. Lebed, V. V. Brazhkin Abstract The hard sphere model is widely used in description of fluids and solid media as a zero approximation to real systems. Despite the uniqueness of the model, few analytical results are known for it, both for the 2D and 3D cases. In present research we have investigated melting of the hard disk system by considering accumulation of extended defects of a certain type in the crystaline phase, and jamming of the disk packing. It results in formulation of melting criteria with lower and upper bounds on volume ratio at melting transition: 25 / 21 ≤ V / V 0 ≤ 5 / 4 25/21\leq V/V_{0}\leq 5/4 . It was found that, in full agreement with the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless-Halperin-Nelson-Young theory, the 2D crystal melts into anisotropic liquid. The second transition, which is the transition between anisotropic and isotropic liquid has volume ratio 5 / 4 ≤ V / V 0 ≤ 13 / 9 5/4\leq V/V_{0}\leq 13/9 . Hard sphere model, beside being of academic interest and source of various mathematical problems, is successfully used in modeling of liquids, glasses, amorphous solids and granular materials, to name a few Stillinger and Weber 1984 ; Donev et al. 2004 ; Torquato and Stillinger 2010 . The reason of such a versatility is that the hard sphere system is a good zero approximation in perturbation theory of disordered media Kovalenko and Fisher 1973 . The idea is traced back to seminal paper of Zwanzig Zwanzig 1954 and was first successfully applied to liquids in the works of Barker and Henderson Barker and Henderson 1967a ; Barker and Henderson 1967b . Still, despite an outstanding position of this model, there are few analytical results for it, mainly obtained through computer simulations Ángel Mulero Ed. . This is true for the melting transition in the hard disk system (2D spheres) which has been modeled many times using Monte Carlo technique, since classical work of Alder and Wainwright Alder and Wainwright 1962 . In some sense 2D hard disk system is simpler, in others it is more complex than its 3D counterpart. As it was suggested by the Nobel prize-winning Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless-Halperin-Nelson-Young theory, Berezinskii 1971 ; Kosterlitz and Thouless 1973 ; Halperin and Nelson 1978 ; Nelson and Halperin 1979 ; Young 1979 the 2D isotropic liquid is expected to crystallize through a sequence of two continuous transitions – the first (high-temperature) one is transition to anisotropic liquid (analog of liquid crystal), and the second one – proper crystallization of anisotropic liquid into solid. Although, transition of anisotropic liquid into isotropic one is now believed to be first-order one Bernard and Krauth 2011 ; Qi et al. 2014 , the continuous character of the proper melting transition is never questioned. This sequence is also observed in computer experiments Mak 2006 ; Li et al. 2022 . However, simple criteria of melting in hard disk system are lacking. According to the Born criterion, the crystal melts when it can not longer maintain shear stress. So, this brings into attention certain extended defects, which could form when the crystal is subjected to shear stress. Using geometrical consideration as well as energy of formation of such defects, one could speculate about the melting temperature. Such a strategy was applied by us in a series of works where we have estimated the melting temperature of crystals with diamond structure Kondrin et al. 2020 ; Kondrin et al. 2022 ; Kondrin et al. 2023 and graphene Kondrin et al. 2021 ; Kondrin et al. 2024 using the density functional theory calculation. Our estimations mostly agree well with available experimental data. This shifts an attention from studying the liquids, which can be extremely difficult, to investigation of certain type of crystal defects. There is a subtle point here. The Born melting criterion gives the temperature of loss of stability of the crystal, i.e., the spinodal. For most crystals, no elastic moduli or phonon frequencies becomes zero before melting. In other words, for melting, as for other transitions of the first order, a region of metastable states is possible on both sides of the transition, i.e. crystal overheating is possible, which is especially easy to observe in computer modeling, since the problem of the existence of the crystal surface is removed, from where melting mainly starts. It seems that for two-dimensional case, where the transition of infinite order into anisotropic liquid exists, melting and loss of stability generally coincide. Figure 1: Extended defect (crack) separating two half planes in otherwise intact triangular crystal lattice consisting of hard disks. Yellow arrow shows the shift of blue half plane from positions in the ideal crystal. It is trivial to imagine the sort of extended defect which forms in triangular lattice (the crystal form of hard disk system) under shear stress. The sort of defects associated with stress relaxation is depicted in Fig. 1 . If we will assume that the disks have radius 1/2, such a defect (we will call it a crack) results in shifting one half plane along the other to the distance \sqrt{3}/2 along the crack and 1/2 normal to it. Using the popular notion in the close packing terminology, such a configuration is locally jammed (individual disks can not move) but not collectively jammed (two half planes can move with respect to each other). The less obvious result known from Kondrin et al. 2024 is, what such defects can cross and so can form an irregular network of extended defects. The problem is what the maximal concentration of defects in such a network is and what is the ratio V/V_{0} where V is the volume (area) of defected crystal and V_{0} that of ideal triangular lattice. Usually, when dealing with sphere packing the covering fraction \eta and density \rho are reported which are related to V/V_{0} by the equations V/V_{0}=\pi/(2\sqrt{3}\eta)=2/(\sqrt{3}\rho) valid for hard disk system. The anomaly observed on equation of state in computer simulations and associated with melting transition yields the value V/V_{0}=1.265-1.285 Li et al. 2022 . In experiments on colloid solution (few micron-sized polymeric balls in water/alcohol mixture) in slit pore slightly different results are obtained V/V_{0}=1.277-1.333 Thorneywork et al. 2017 . Figure 2: Network of extended defects (cracks) in 19-core (shown in different colors) nearly jammed configuration. Grey balls stand for corner disks. Yellow and cyan lines are construction used for calculating V/V_{0} ratio (see text). The network of cracks with their maximal concentration is depicted in Fig. 2 . Proof that the concentration is maximal will be provided below. First we will focus on calculation the ratio V/V_{0} . V_{0} is the area of yellow equilateral hexagon in Fig. 2 which is equal 21\sqrt{3}/2 . 21 is the number of disks contained in this area and it is the sum of disks strictly laying in the interior of hexagon (19 disks colored blue in Fig. 2 we will call it 19-core disks) and six disks in the corners (6 disks colored gray in Fig. 2 we will call it corner disks) which are shared between 3 hexagons meeting in the corner that is 2. The cracks area (that is V-V_{0}