How large can lepton mixing be?
J. de Blas, C. Giuliano, G. Guedes, R. Sánchez López, J. Santiago · 2025
Read How large can lepton mixing be? by J. de Blas, C. Giuliano, G. Guedes, R. Sánchez López, J. Santiago (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-04148.txt.
Introduction
Charged leptons like the electron are usually assumed to barely mix with heavy fermions. J. de Blas and colleagues show the mixing could reach twenty percent without breaking any rule, in a 2025 preprint. The loophole sits in effective field theory. When mixing effects cancel at tree level in the leading operators, or are suppressed by tiny lepton masses, experiments lose their grip.
Using a model that realises this scenario naturally through symmetries, the authors check every current direct and indirect constraint. The limits turn out so mild that, given the present lower bound on heavy fermion masses, theory itself supplies the strongest restrictions on the mixing. They then forecast future sensitivity at the high-luminosity LHC and the proposed FCC colliders. Hadron machines leave theory in charge, but FCC precision could finally measure the mixing squared to per-mille accuracy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. de Blas, C. Giuliano, G. Guedes, R. Sánchez López, J. Santiago |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-04148
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How large can lepton mixing be? J. de Blas, C. Giuliano, G. Guedes, R. Sánchez López, J. Santiago Abstract We show that, contrary to common expectations, the observed charged leptons can have a substantial mixing with new heavier fermions, at the level of 20 % \% . This can happen, in the language of effective theories, when the effect of mixing with heavier fermions vanishes at tree level in operators of mass-dimension 6 (or it is suppressed by the small charged lepton masses), a cancellation that can be naturally ensured by symmetries. Using a model that realizes this scenario we consider all current direct and indirect constraints and show that experimental constraints on the mixing are so mild that, given the current direct limit on the mass of the heavy fermions, theoretical considerations become the leading current constraints on the mixing. We also estimate the sensitivity to the mixing at future experiments, including the high-luminosity phase of the LHC and, most notably, the FCC-ee, and FCC-hh. We find a pattern in which the reach of direct searches in hadron machines makes theoretical considerations lead the limits while the precision of lepton machines can beat these theoretical considerations. We find that the FCC can finally reach per mille precision in the mixing squared of the charged leptons. CERN-TH-2025-248 1 Introduction The properties of the charged leptons have been measured to an excellent experimental precision, agreeing with the Standard Model (SM) predictions to a striking better than per mille accuracy ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk . The common lore dictates that the observed charged leptons cannot have a significant mixing with new fermions. However, this statement is implicitly based on the assumption that fermion mixing necessarily induces tree-level corrections to the gauge couplings of the SM fermions suppressed, at most, by two powers of the heavy fermion mass. In the language of effective field theories, this corresponds to a tree-level contribution to operators of mass dimension 6 of the generic form \phi^{\dagger}\mathrm{i}\overleftrightarrow{D}_{\mu}\phi\overline{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\psi . Indeed, this is true in the case of mixing with a single heavy fermion delAguila:1982fs ; delAguila:2000aa , resulting in very stringent constraints on the allowed fermion mixing deBlas:2013gla . However, mixing with several different heavy fermions can induce cancellations that make this leading effects vanish 1 1 1 See Chala:2025utt for a recent study of models that generate other flat directions in electroweak (EW) precision data, even at the one-loop level. . These cancellations can be ensured by a subset of custodial symmetry Agashe:2006at , common in realistic composite Higgs models Anastasiou:2009rv . The phenomenological implications at colliders of the corresponding sizeable mixing have been explored, for quarks in Atre:2008iu ; Atre:2011ae and for tau leptons in delAguila:2010es ; Carmona:2013cq . However, how large this mixing can be is a question that has not been properly addressed thus far. The goal of the present work is to give a quantitative answer to this question, using all relevant current experimental data, as well as an estimation of the constraints that future colliders will put on this mixing. In order to do this we consider a degenerate bi-doublet model that realizes the corresponding symmetry at tree level, ensuring the cancellation of the Wilson coefficients (WCs) of the dangerous dimension-6 operators at this order. The only remaining tree-level generated operator is suppressed by the charged lepton Yukawa couplings and, in practice, only modifies the lepton couplings to the Higgs boson. As we will see, this effect sets the most stringent, although still relatively mild, experimental bound on the allowed tau mixing while being irrelevant for the first two families. In the absence of significant tree level, dimension 6 contributions, experimental constraints arise from tree-level generated dimension 8 operators or one-loop generated dimension 6 ones. In both cases the extra suppression results in milder bounds on the allowed mixing. The effective field theory (EFT) framework allows us to explore the indirect constraints from electroweak precision observables (EWPO), Higgs measurements, anomalous magnetic moments and flavor observables on this model. We also consider direct collider bounds on the model arising from pair- and single-production channels. The main result is that, with current data, the right-handed (RH) electron could have a non-singlet component as large as 20\% (in a sense that will be made explicit below) without any conflict with current experimental measurements. The corresponding numbers for the muon and tau are 18\% and 16\% , respectively. These bounds are so mild that, when combined with direct searches for the new fermions, result in regions of the parameter space that are excluded on theoretical grounds, such as the requirement of the scalar potential stability. This condition strengthens the limits to 14\% , 13\% and 16\% for mixing with the e , \mu , and \tau leptons, respectively. Despite the extra suppression in this model, flavor constraints do prevent a sizable simultaneous mixing of the vector-like leptons (VLLs) with two different SM charged leptons. Measurements at future collider experiments will put more stringent limits on this mixing. By the end of the high-luminosity phase of the Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC), the corresponding numbers will be 8\% , 6\% , and 5\% for mixing with e , \mu , and \tau , respectively, if we do not include theoretical considerations, going down to 5\% for the case of the electron and muon, and to 4\% for the case of the tau, if we include them. The electron–positron Future Circular Collider (FCC-ee) will improve the precision of EWPOs and Higgs measurements to the point that indirect bounds will surpass the theoretical constraints. Under conservative (aggressive) assumptions for the theoretical uncertainties of the observables, the expected upper bounds decrease to 1.7\% , 1.7\% , and 0.7\% ( 0.3\% , 0.3\% , and 0.4\% ) for mixing with e , \mu , and \tau , respectively. Theoretical considerations do not strenghten these bounds in this case. Finally, the hadron–hadron Future Circular Collider (FCC-hh), with its significantly enhanced center of mass energy, will further tighten the direct searches constraints. In this regime, theoretical bounds once again dominate, and the projected upper limits are expected to reach roughly 0.2\% for all mixing cases. While this paper performs a complete phenomenological analysis of a particular model, its conclusions should serve a broader purpose. First, it shows how symmetry considerations in the UV theory can have drastic consequences in the low-energy SMEFT interpretation, which are not captured if only one field extensions are considered; second, it shows the relevance of performing loop-level analysis, and how the extreme precision at the FCC-ee can even probe these symmetry-protected models. The rest of this article is organized as follows. We describe the details of the model in Section 2 . Current constraints from direct searches are discussed in Section 3 , while the indirect limits on the model are studied in Section 4 . Having covered the different sources of experimental constraints, we discuss in Section 5 a series of bounds on the model arising from theoretical considerations. Section 6 is devoted to the combination of all current constraints, and Section 7 to the estimation of expected future limits from the HL-LHC, FCC-ee and FCC-hh. We conclude in Section 8 . We also include four appendices where we describe some of