Artificial Intelligence Competence of K-12 Students Shapes Their AI Risk Perception: A Co-occurrence Network Analysis CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence CCS: Applied computing Education CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI)
Ville Heilala, Pieta Sikström, Mika Setälä, Tommi Kärkkäinen · 2025
Read Artificial Intelligence Competence of K-12 Students Shapes Their AI Risk Perception: A Co-occurrence Network Analysis CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence CCS: Applied computing Education CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) by Ville Heilala, Pieta Sikström, Mika Setälä, Tommi Kärkkäinen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-04115.txt.
Introduction
What Finnish teenagers fear about artificial intelligence depends, it turns out, on how competent they feel using it. Ville Heilala and colleagues survey upper secondary students in a 2025 preprint on computers and society. About one hundred sixty students rated their own AI competence and their concerns about AI across personal, institutional, and systemic domains, and the team mapped how answers co-occurred.
Students with lower self-rated competence dwelled on personal risks: shrinking creativity, weaker critical thinking, and misuse. Students who felt more competent looked upward instead, worrying about bias, inaccuracy, and cheating. The same technology thus reads as a threat to one's own learning or as a threat to institutions, depending on the reader. The authors argue schools should respond with AI literacy in the curriculum and guided teacher support. One-size teaching will miss risks that students actually perceive.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ville Heilala, Pieta Sikström, Mika Setälä, Tommi Kärkkäinen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-04115
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Artificial Intelligence Competence of K-12 Students Shapes Their AI Risk Perception: A Co-occurrence Network Analysis CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence CCS: Applied computing Education CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) Ville Heilala, Pieta Sikström, Mika Setälä, Tommi Kärkkäinen Abstract . As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly integrated into education, understanding how students perceive its risks is essential for supporting responsible and effective adoption. This research aimed to examine the relationships between perceived AI competence and risks among Finnish K-12 upper secondary students (n = 163) by utilizing a co-occurrence analysis. Students reported their self-perceived AI competence and concerns related to AI across systemic, institutional, and personal domains. The findings showed that students with lower competence emphasized personal and learning-related risks, such as reduced creativity, lack of critical thinking, and misuse, whereas higher-competence students focused more on systemic and institutional risks, including bias, inaccuracy, and cheating. These differences suggest that students’ self-reported AI competence is related to how they evaluate both the risks and opportunities associated with artificial intelligence in education (AIED). The results of this study highlight the need for educational institutions to incorporate AI literacy into their curricula, provide teacher guidance, and inform policy development to ensure personalized opportunities for utilization and equitable integration of AI into K-12 education. 1. Introduction With the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), especially generative AI (GenAI), its influence on society and education is increasingly recognized. However, the integration of artificial intelligence in education (AIED) is not straightforward; on one hand, it has been shown to improve educational outcomes 57 , but, on the other hand, there are also risks that can hinder the adoption ( 22 ; 44 ; 58 ; 16 ) . Despite the general view of AI technologies having a positive impact on student learning, their effect particularly on students’ agency and self-regulation is understudied ( 19 ) . This has raised concerns about how the integration of AI tools affects students’ learning experiences, as well as their impact on knowledge development and skill acquisition ( 59 ; 12 ) . AI is not perceived solely as harmful or beneficial, but simultaneously as both a risk and an opportunity ( 50 ) . However, perceptions and preferences regarding AI-related risks have received limited scholarly attention 61 . Thereby, the relationship between risk perceptions and individuals’ willingness to adopt AI-based applications is understudied 50 . Given that AI is affecting education and how teaching will be organized e.g., 28 , it is crucial to explore further the types of risks that might hinder the adoption of AI tools in learning ( 53 ) . Research on risk perception 52 , especially in the context of AI, is essential for designing effective strategies that support informed decision-making 37 and promote AI literacy 12 . Because "risk is relative to the observer” 35 , p. 12 , individual characteristics shape which factors are perceived as risks ( 61 ) . Thus, this exploratory study aims to answer two research questions: First, which of the factors do upper secondary K-12 students perceive as risks? And second, how do K-12 students’ self-reported AI competence shape their perceptions of potential AI-related risks? Finland has been one of the early advocates for adopting digital education solutions and practices 1 1 1 Finnish National Agency for Education: Exploring Finnish Digital Education . The same applies to AIED, as exemplified by the Finnish National Agency for Education, which has aligned new guidelines for the use of AI in teaching and learning in Spring 2025 2 2 2 Finnish National Agency for Education: Artificial intelligence in education – legislation and recommendations . AI technologies are novel to K-12 education e.g., 21 , and there is a great demand for understanding how they should be integrated in teaching and learning ( 36 ) . Thus, this research targets general upper secondary education students, as K-12 education has received limited attention in AIED research 1 ; 21 ; 28 . The results contribute to understanding the factors that upper secondary school students perceive as AI-related risks and how their self-reported AI-related competence influences these risk perceptions. 2. Background AI technologies continue to reshape digital society and teaching practices, highlighting the need to understand the factors that facilitate or hinder their use. AI systems offer many benefits, but their integration into K–12 education also poses challenges 63 . In educational settings, research on AI-related risks has gained popularity, and, for example, six major risk areas have been identified through a systematic literature review in K-12 education: i) privacy and autonomy risks, ii) AI biases, iii) accuracy and functional risks, iv) deepfakes and FATE—fairness, accountability, transparency, and ethics risks, v) social knowledge and skill-building risks, and vi) risks associated with shifting the teacher’s role 36 . From the student perspective, the issues may raise several questions, for example: What happens to my sensitive data? Can I trust AI? How capable and accessible is AI? Where and how can I use AI? Am I allowed and able to use AI? Why do we still need teachers? Risks regarding the use of AI occur at multiple levels. It entails short- and long-term risks, including technology-related risks (e.g., privacy breaches, cyber intrusions, and the inability to control malicious AI) 66 ; 40 , educational risks 66 ; 40 , economic and societal risks (e.g., job displacement) 25 ; 66 , and ethical risks (e.g., insufficient values and regulations) ( 50 ; 66 ; 16 ) . Specifically, systemic risks refer to broad issues tied to the trustworthiness and functioning of AI itself e.g., 56 ; 4 ; 36 , such as bias, inaccuracy, FATE issues 43 ; 1 ; 7 ; 66 ; 40 ; 26 ; 21 ; 36 , or resource consumption e.g., 23 . Institutional risks , in turn, pertain to rules, policies, and fairness within the educational system, including cheating with the aid of AI ( 14 ) , the unequal advantages of using AI (e.g., AI divide and digital divide) 27 ; 7 ; 66 , or inconsistent guidelines from teachers and schools regarding the use of AI 17 . The use of AI also involves personal risks that capture individual-level concerns, such as balancing between productivity and misconduct 17 ; 66 ; 40 ; 26 , dependence on AI (e.g., metacognitive laziness 20 ), addiction ( 2 ) , as well as potential negative effects on learning, creativity, critical thinking, and personal privacy ( 7 ; 66 ; 21 ; 36 ) . People’s perceptions of AI-related risks and opportunities are positively associated with their likelihood of adopting AI ( 50 ) . Risk perception refers to how individuals process information or direct observations about potential hazards and risks of a technology and form judgments and beliefs about its seriousness, likelihood, and acceptability 48 . Anticipated risks and concerns of AI use can be considered as negative outcome expectancies. An outcome expectancy "is defined as a person’s estimate that a given behavior will lead to certain outcomes” 5 , p. 193 . Negative outcome expectancies (i.e., perceived or experienced risks associated with using AI) can lead to reduced acceptance of AI technologies e.g., 64 , and initial negative experiences may