Dynamical Love Numbers for Black Holes and Beyond from Shell Effective Field Theory

D. Kosmopoulos, D. Perrone, M. Solon · 2025

Read Dynamical Love Numbers for Black Holes and Beyond from Shell Effective Field Theory by D. Kosmopoulos, D. Perrone, M. Solon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-04002.txt.

Introduction

When a gravitational wave passes a black hole's neighbourhood, the hole deforms slightly, and Love numbers measure how much. Dimitrios Kosmopoulos, Davide Perrone, and Mikhail Solon compute dynamical versions of those numbers in a 2025 theoretical physics preprint. Standard effective field theory treatments demand higher-order calculations that grow punishingly hard.

The authors build a new effective theory around a spherical shell. The behaviour of gravitational perturbations is imported directly from known black hole solutions. The shell's finite size tames short-distance divergences, while its tidal responses are carried by higher-dimensional operators. Applying the machinery to scalar perturbations, they derive Love numbers for Schwarzschild black holes and generic compact bodies to unusually high order in Newton's constant. A surprise emerges: the scalar Love numbers arrange around values of the Riemann zeta function, a pattern the authors conjecture persists to all orders.

Catalog record

CREATORD. Kosmopoulos, D. Perrone, M. Solon
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-04002

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamical Love Numbers for Black Holes and Beyond from Shell Effective Field Theory D. Kosmopoulos, D. Perrone, M. Solon Abstract We construct a novel effective field theory for a compact body coupled to gravity, whose key feature is that the dynamics of gravitational perturbations is explicitly determined by known solutions in black hole perturbation theory in four dimensions. In this way, the physics of gravitational perturbations in curved space are already encoded in the effective field theory, thus bypassing the need for the higher-order calculations that constitute a major hurdle in standard approaches. Concretely, we model the compact body as a spherical shell, whose finite size regulates short-distance divergences in four dimensions and whose tidal responses are described by higher-dimensional operators. As an application, we consider scalar perturbations and derive new results for scalar Love numbers through 𝒪 ⁡ ( G 9 ) {\cal O}(G^{9}) for Schwarzschild black holes and for generic compact bodies. Finally, our analysis reveals an intriguing structure of the scalar black-hole Love numbers in terms of the Riemann zeta function, which we conjecture to hold to all orders. CERN-TH-2025-247 I Introduction The rapid growth of gravitational-wave astronomy in recent years has driven the development of new field-theoretic approaches for gravitational-wave physics (see, e.g., 38 ; 4 ; 32 ; 125 for reviews). While a large focus of this program is the two-body problem 53 ; 25 ; 28 ; 76 ; 77 ; 75 ; 113 ; 67 ; 109 ; 108 ; 78 ; 81 ; 79 , the same tools have now been applied for understanding properties of a single compact body, such as tidal deformability. The tidal response of a body to an external gravitational field is characterized by Love numbers 137 , and plays an essential role in determining its internal structure. Probing the nature of astrophysical compact bodies, such as black holes and neutron stars, by measuring the imprints of Love numbers on the gravitational waveform is one of the principal scientific goals of gravitational-wave astronomy (see, e.g., 83 ; 2 ). From the point of view of effective field theory (EFT), Love numbers are related to Wilson coefficients of tidal operators in the worldline effective action 87 ; 88 ; 160 ; 89 ; 157 ; 159 ; 161 ; 158 ; 132 ; 133 ; 131 ; 147 ; 112 ; 134 ; 110 ; 136 ; 64 ; 177 ; 118 ; 57 ; 140 ; 141 ; 119 ; 120 ; 135 ; 130 ; 65 ; 144 ; 143 ; 66 ; 142 ; 169 ; 98 (or in the quantum-field-theory action 37 ; 95 ; 12 ; 3 ; 55 ; 54 ; 29 ; 12 ; 11 ; 123 ; 56 ; 13 ; 14 ; 27 ; 39 ; 15 ; 96 ; 26 ; 40 ; 8 ; 34 ; 63 ; 16 ; 9 ), which systematically parametrize finite-size corrections to the point-particle limit. This provides a gauge-invariant definition of Love numbers, avoiding coordinate-dependent ambiguities (see, e.g., 153 ; 154 ; 93 ). Static Love numbers of black holes vanish at both the linear 82 ; 69 ; 31 ; 68 ; 122 ; 94 and non-linear order 59 ; 116 (see also 99 ; 126 ; 48 ; 101 ; 107 ; 106 ; 114 ; 170 ; 156 ; 46 ; 167 ; 71 ; 90 ; 115 ; 70 ), so a non-zero measurement would signal physics beyond general relativity (GR) 41 . This vanishing has also been the subject of recent studies as a testbed for our understanding of symmetry and naturalness 162 ; 47 ; 100 ; 49 ; 23 ; 166 ; 175 ; 176 ; 24 ; 138 ; 50 ; 155 . On the other hand, dynamical Love numbers are generally nonzero and can be determined by matching observables in the worldline EFT and in GR 18 ; 30 ; 104 ; 6 (see also 21 ; 35 ; 61 ; 22 ; 20 ). This matching requires high-order calculations which are quite challenging with traditional methods (see, however, recent progress in 42 ; 60 ; 121 ; 45 ). In this Letter, we address this problem by developing a new EFT for a compact body coupled to gravity, which we call Shell EFT. This approach directly leverages known solutions in black hole perturbation theory (BHPT) in four dimensions, and thus avoids the need for loop diagrams that build up effects due to the black-hole spacetime (see fig. 1 ). In essence, Shell EFT employs a synergy of tools from quantum field theory and GR, and offers a promising avenue for achieving the theoretical precession necessary for future gravitational-wave experiments. As a first application, we consider scalar perturbations and derive new results for scalar Love numbers of generic compact objects through {\cal O}(G^{9}) . For the specific case of black holes, we agree with previous results through {\cal O}(G^{7}) 42 . Moreover, our expression exhibits interesting structure in terms of the Riemann zeta function, allowing us to conjecture results to all orders. Figure 1: In the standard point-particle approach, calculating the tidal response involves loop contributions. By replacing the point particle with a shell, our EFT framework naturally incorporates known BHPT solutions in four-dimensions, thus bypassing the need for higher-order integration. Moreover, the matching to full theory is simplified since gravitational perturbations are described by the same solutions. II Shell Effective Field Theory The basic idea of Shell EFT is to describe a generic compact body as a spherical shell so that its finite radius R acts as a regulator for short-distance divergences in four dimensions. This allows us to solve for the dynamics of gravitational perturbations in terms of known solutions in BHPT in four dimensions 129 ; 128 ; 145 . The above ingredients are reflected in the background metric, which is flat inside the shell and Schwarzschild outside: \displaystyle\differential s_{+}^{2} \displaystyle=f(r)\differential t^{2}-f(r)^{-1}\differential r^{2}-r^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}\,,\quad r>R\,, \displaystyle\differential s^{2}_{-} \displaystyle=\differential\tilde{t}\hskip 0.7pt^{2}-\differential\tilde{r}^{2}-\tilde{r}^{2}\differential\Omega^{2}\,,\quad\tilde{r}<R\,, (1) where f(r)=1-R_{\text{S}}/r with R_{\text{S}}=2GM and R>R_{\text{S}} . The junction conditions \displaystyle\tilde{t}=t\sqrt{f(R)}\,,\quad\tilde{r}=R+\frac{r-R}{\sqrt{f(R)}}\,, (2) ensure continuity of the metric on the shell r=\tilde{r}=R 102 . 1 1 1 Thin shells have found many applications in GR, e.g., in modeling gravitational collapse 152 ; 103 , in the construction of traversable wormholes 179 , in the description of vacuum–decay bubbles and cosmological phase transitions 58 , as well as in the development of the membrane paradigm for black holes 139 ; 178 . For the application to Love numbers, we consider the scattering of a scalar wave \Phi with frequency \omega\ll 1/R off the shell, and model the tidal responses of the shell using higher-dimensional operators. The action for the shell is \displaystyle S_{\rm Shell}=\int\frac{\differential^{3}y\sqrt{\gamma}}{4\pi R^{2}}\left(-M+\sum_{\ell,n}\frac{\hat{c}_{\ell,n}}{\ell!}\varphi(u^{\mu}\nabla_{\mu})^{n}\mathsf{D}_{\ell}\phi\right)\,, (3) while the bulk dynamics of the scalar field are described by the Klein-Gordon action, \displaystyle S_{\rm Bulk}=\int\differential^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\,g^{\mu\nu}\partial_{\mu}\varphi\partial_{\nu}\phi\,. (4) We describe the elements entering eqs. 3 and 4 in turn. In order to account for dissipative tidal effects, we adopt the in-in or Schwinger-Keldysh formalism 174 ; 117 where the field \Phi is doubled: \Phi\rightarrow(\varphi,\phi) . The field \phi represents the classical field that we solve for while \varphi represents the fluctuations that source it. We take the

Read the complete text