Entanglement Detection with Rotationally Covariant Measurements – From Compton Scattering to Lemonade
Marlene Funck, Ilija Funk, Tizian Schmidt, René Schwonnek · 2025
Read Entanglement Detection with Rotationally Covariant Measurements – From Compton Scattering to Lemonade by Marlene Funck, Ilija Funk, Tizian Schmidt, René Schwonnek (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-03984.txt.
Introduction
Tests for entanglement usually assume the measuring device can point its settings anywhere, but some detectors are stuck with rotational symmetry. Marlene Funck, Ilija Funk, Tizian Schmidt, and René Schwonnek study that restricted case in a 2025 quantum physics preprint. Their test particles are polarised photons, and their devices are rotationally covariant, treating every direction alike.
The authors derive the allowed measurements explicitly: each is fixed by a single measurable parameter. One derivation recasts the classic Klein-Nishina formula for Compton scattering in this language. They add a semidefinite-programming method certifying it from full statistics, including partly untrusted devices. Two such settings can never violate a Bell inequality, they show. Yet EPR steering remains certifiable when it is imposed on one side only. As a showcase, they analyse such tests using polarised light scattered in soft drinks, lemonade included.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marlene Funck, Ilija Funk, Tizian Schmidt, René Schwonnek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-03984
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Entanglement Detection with Rotationally Covariant Measurements – From Compton Scattering to Lemonade Marlene Funck, Ilija Funk, Tizian Schmidt, René Schwonnek Abstract The accurate and efficient detection of quantum entanglement remains a central challenge in quantum information science. In this work, we study the detection of entanglement of polarized photons for measurement devices that are solely specified by rotational symmetry. We derive explicit positive operator valued measures (POVMs) showing that from a quantum information perspective any such setting is classified by one real measurable parameter r r . In Particular, we give a POVM formulation of the Klein–Nishina formula for Compton scattering of polarized photons. We provide an SDP-based entanglement certification method that operates on the full measured statistics and gives tight bounds, also considering semi-device independent scenarios. Furthermore, we show that, while Bell violations are impossible with rotationally covariant measurements, EPR steering can still be certified under one-sided symmetry constraints. Finally, we present a rotationally covariant showcase experiment, analyzing the scattering of polarized optical light in a selection of soft drinks. Our results suggest that lemonade-based detectors are suitable for entanglement detection. I Introduction Entanglement is the central phenomenon that separates quantum theory from a classical description of our world. Beyond this fundamental significance, it is also an essential resource for quantum technologies. This not only includes widely popular fields like quantum computing and cryptography, but also a less often highlighted medical application, positron emission tomography (PET) Caradonna et al. 2019 ; Caradonna et al. 2024 ; Caradonna 2025 ; Hiesmayr and Moskal 2019 ; Watts et al. 2021 ; Abdurashitov et al. 2022 ; Zaidi and Koral 2004 ; Romanchek et al. 2023 ; Romanchek et al. 2024a ; Kim et al. 2023 ; Eslami and Mohamadian 2024 ; Moskal et al. 2025a ; McNamara et al. 2014 , which is one of the possible practical applications of the theory developed in this work. Tackling the task of detecting and quantifying entanglement in a real-world experiment, one faces a fundamental challenge of theoretical physics: finding a model that is mathematically manageable and enables nontrivial conclusions, while not diverging (at least not significantly) from reality. For entanglement mediated by polarized photons, those models span a wide spectrum, ranging from minimal assumptions, like device-independent tests of Bell inequalities Clauser et al. 1969 , to assuming idealized pure states and projective measurements Cohen-Tannoudji et al. 2019 . While the first comes with very demanding technological requirements for any positive result Giustina et al. 2013 ; Gühne 2004 ; Giustina et al. 2015 ; Shalm et al. 2015 ; Hensen et al. 2015 , the latter will almost certainly fail to describe realistic experiments with unavoidable imperfections. In this work, we develop and study a model at a useful middle ground: detecting entanglement of two polarized photons using measurement devices specified solely by rotational covariance, which can be found (or created) in a variety of settings (see Fig. 1 ). Figure 1: a) Rotationally covariant measurement. Measurement data is 2\pi -invariant. Rotating the preparation system (i.e. process before detection) or the detector are equivalent in description. b) Compton scattering process. Polarized photons scatter from electrons into angles, \theta and \varphi . It is rotationally covariant w.r.t. \varphi . c) The lemonade experiment. The polarization of photons is rotated by a half-wave plate. Photons scattered in the lemonade are detected at a fixed angle. The primordial motivation of this work stems from Compton scattering experiments, used to detect correlations in \gamma -quanta. This mechanism was used in the very first quantum correlation experiments in the late 40’s Wu and Shaknov 1950 , is today used to enhance PET scanners Caradonna et al. 2019 ; Caradonna et al. 2024 ; Caradonna 2025 ; Hiesmayr and Moskal 2019 ; Watts et al. 2021 ; Abdurashitov et al. 2022 ; Zaidi and Koral 2004 ; Romanchek et al. 2023 ; Romanchek et al. 2024a ; Kim et al. 2023 ; Eslami and Mohamadian 2024 ; Moskal et al. 2025a , and sparked a recent debate among theorists regarding the distinguishability of entangled and separable photon states in Compton scattering setups Hiesmayr and Moskal 2019 ; Caradonna et al. 2019 ; Ivashkin et al. 2023 . This is hopefully resolved now, as this paper shows that they can indeed be distinguished. Beyond this, rotational covariance can also be found in the mechanism that underpins the recent verification of entanglement at the LHC Afik and de Nova 2021 . Since highly radioactive material or sufficiently large hadron colliders are rarely found in a standard laboratory for quantum optics, we introduce an easy-to-perform experiment analyzing scattering of photons with optical wavelengths (see Fig. 1 c and Fig. 4 ). We measure the polarization dependent scattering distributions of a selection of soft drinks, and analyze them as rotational covariant detectors in our framework. Our results suggest that apple lemonade is suitable for detecting entanglement. In fact, the detection contrast obtained using lemonade-based detectors exceeds the known limit for Compton scattering of electron–positron annihilation photons. A fully conclusive experiment, however, demands entangled photon pairs and high sample sizes, which is why we leave it for a future publication. Beyond serving as a neat showcase and potential student experiment, studying detectors based on soft drinks illustrates a conceptually central aspect of our work: It is unrealistic to find an exact model for a glass of lemonade, reflecting all relevant specifics and imperfections. Nevertheless, by reducing our description to a macroscopically implemented rotational symmetry, we are able to make a comprehensive analysis of the setup. II Background and Setting Historically, the investigation of entanglement originates in the well-known Gedankenexperiment of Einstein, Podolski, Rosen Einstein et al. 1935 and Schrödinger Schrödinger 1935 , which predicted that quantum theory allows for correlations that cannot be explained classically. Already in 1950, Wu et al. Wu and Shaknov 1950 performed an experiment on Compton scattering of annihilation photons, which was recognized to be a proof of these correlations by Bohm and Aharonov Bohm and Aharonov 1957 in 1957. Although their findings predated the more widely known Bell-type (CHSH: Clauser et al. 1969 ) photon experiments by over a decade, they are rarely discussed in textbooks. One reason might be that the quantum information description of their setting is more subtle. In contrast to the CHSH setting, the Compton scattering measurement cannot be described by projective measurements typically used for discussing correlation tests. In fact, they are a prototype example of a joint measurement, where the traditional textbook postulate of a projection onto eigenstates fails. However, the language of quantum information has been developed further over the past decades Werner 1989a ; Ludwig 2012 ; Kraus et al. 1983 and provides the right tool for describing this setting: Quantum states are modeled by density operators \rho , which are positive unit trace operators acting on a Hilbert space \mathcal{H} . Measurement devices with outcomes in a measurable outcome set \Omega are modeled by positive operator-valued measures (POVMs), which assign a positive operator \mathsf{M}[\omega] to every measurable subset \omega\subseteq\Omega with normalization \mathsf{M}[\Omega]=1 such that \omega\mapsto\operatorname{tr}[\rho\,\mathsf{M}[\omega]] is a probability measure for every state \rho Heinosaari and Ziman 2011 . In the case of a bipartite setting, the Hilbert space factorizes: \mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_{\text{A}}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{\text{B}}