Capture into Apsidal Resonance and the Decimation of Planets around In-spiraling Binaries
Mohammad Farhat, Jihad Touma · 2025
Read Capture into Apsidal Resonance and the Decimation of Planets around In-spiraling Binaries by Mohammad Farhat, Jihad Touma (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-03940.txt.
Introduction
Planets orbiting two stars are strikingly rare around the tightest binaries, and Mohammad Farhat and Jihad Touma offer an explanation in a 2025 planetary science preprint. No third body is needed. Their mechanism uses a secular resonance that arises when a shrinking binary's relativistic precession matches the precession it induces in a companion planet's orbit.
Caught in that resonance, the planet steadily loses angular momentum to the binary, and its orbit stretches in eccentricity until it destabilises. The planet is then ejected or swallowed. The authors map the resonance, then run orbit-averaged simulations of many systems as their binaries tighten tidally. Eight of ten planets encountered the resonance, and three of four were destroyed, while survivors ended on distant orbits unlikely to transit. The process that creates tight binaries, they argue, clears away the planets surveys could have seen.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mohammad Farhat, Jihad Touma |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-03940
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Capture into Apsidal Resonance and the Decimation of Planets around In-spiraling Binaries Mohammad Farhat, Jihad Touma Abstract Transiting circumbinary planets (CBPs) are conspicuously rare, and entirely absent around stellar binaries with periods ≤ 7 days \leq 7~{\rm days} . Here, we exploit a secular resonance to stimulate the orbit of a CBP into strong, disruptive interactions with the host binary. The process requires no tertiary companion and is triggered when the general-relativistic precession of a tightening binary matches the Newtonian precession it induces in its companion planet. Adiabatic capture in this resonance sees the binary draining angular momentum from the CBP’s orbit which grows steadily in eccentricity until destabilization, and eventual ejection or engulfment. We map this resonance in phase space, then investigate the dynamical outcomes of encounter in the course of tidally shrinking binaries. With the help of orbit averaged simulations of a suite of systems, we find that, around tightening binaries: eight out of ten CBPs encounter and are captured in the resonance; three out of four are ‘destroyed’; and survivors lurk on remote, low-transit-probability orbits. This suggests that the very process which forms tight binaries effectively clears the region where transiting CBPs could reside. I Introduction Eclipsing binary stars (EBs) are propitious hunting grounds for transiting circumbinary planets ( Borucki 2016 , CBPs hereafter; e.g.,) . Their alignment with our line of sight, together with likely coplanar CBP formation and evolution, improves the odds of detection ( Martin & Triaud 2015 ; Kostov 2023 ) . There are complications of course with the binary’s dynamics contributing significant variations in transit timing, depth, and duration. At the same time, those same variations provide a unique observational signature which facilitates ruling out false positives and allows accurate determination of the planetary mass and radius ( Welsh & Orosz 2018 , see e.g.,) . Planet formation around binaries is not expected to be any less efficient than around single stars ( Nelson 2003 ; Thebault & Haghighipour 2015 ; Bromley & Kenyon 2015 , e.g.,) . Circumbinary discs will be left with substantial mass as the binary clears a sizable inner cavity, thus slowing down if not altogether suppressing accretion onto the stars ( Artymowicz & Lubow 1994 ; Vartanyan et al. 2016 ; Pierens & Nelson 2023 , e.g.,) . Planet formation close to the cavity’s boundary may face difficulties via both planetesimal accretion [due to high collisional velocities ( Marzari et al. 2008 ; Paardekooper et al. 2012 , e.g.,) ], and pebble accretion [due to hydrodynamic turbulence enhanced by inner disc instabilities ( Papaloizou 2005 ; Barker & Ogilvie 2014 ; Pierens et al. 2021 , e.g.,) ]. It was argued that disc self-gravity can mitigate against collisional fragmentation, in axisymmetric discs for sure, and to a lesser extent in eccentric ones ( Rafikov & Silsbee 2014 ; Silsbee & Rafikov 2014 ; Silsbee & Rafikov 2015 , e.g.,) . Suffice to say that, while formation close-in remains under discussion, planets have what it takes to form in the disc’s outskirts and migrate inwards under the disc’s torques ( Nelson 2003 ; Kley & Nelson 2012 ; Kley & Haghighipour 2015 , e.g.,) . All things considered, the occurrence rate of CBPs, particularly those detectable by Kepler, should be comparable to the occurrence rate of planets around single stars ( Martin & Triaud 2014 ; Armstrong et al. 2014 , {\sim}10\% ;) . Thus far, some 14 transiting CBPs have been detected by Kepler and TESS, occupying the short-orbital period end of a population of 47 candidates. Given a total of {\sim}~3000 EBs observed by Kepler ( Kirk et al. 2016 ) , one can safely speak of a dearth in CBP detection. The alarmingly miniscule harvest looks worst when limiting oneself to CBPs around short-period binaries as two thirds of the Kepler-detected EBs are in tight orbits with periods shorter than 7 days, while the shortest period binary observed to host a CBP is Kepler-47, with a binary orbital period of 7.45 days ( Orosz et al. 2012 ; Orosz et al. 2019 ) . Important to note that similar such negligible occurrence rate was confirmed in a CoRoT data sample of {\sim}2000 EBs ( Klagyivik et al. 2017 ) . One wonders whether these metrics are indicative of physical processes sculpting the expected distribution of CBPs, or merely the result of observational limitations/bias ( Li et al. 2016 , e.g.,) . A lack of transiting CBPs around long-period binaries is understandable: the circumbinary instability region extends to planetary periods {\sim}8 times that of the binary ( Dvorak 1986 ; Holman & Wiegert 1999 ) , with consequent decay of planetary transit probability. One would then expect observational bias to favor CBP transits around short-period binaries, making their scarcity even more intriguing. Allowing for disruptive physical processes, several studies ( Hamers et al. 2016 ; Muñoz & Lai 2015 , see e.g., ) investigated the dynamical fate of a CBP when allowing for the effect of a tertiary star, which forces the central binary to undergo Kozai-Lidov cycles then shrink under tidal friction ( Fabrycky & Tremaine 2007 ) . Others considered CBPs in isolated binary systems and explored the dynamical fate of the planet: i-when migrating toward the binary and encountering mean motion resonances ( Sutherland & Kratter 2019 ; Martin & Fitzmaurice 2022 ; Gianuzzi et al. 2023 , MMR; e.g.,) , or ii- when allowing for the tidal and magnetic evolution of the binary itself ( Fleming et al. 2018 ) . More recently, Mogan & Zanazzi 2025 investigated the likelihood of transits around tight binaries having decayed orbitally under tides, leaving the initially closer-in planets stranded on non-transiting orbits. In this Letter , we add an overlooked, and we believe critical, dynamical twist to ongoing attempts at explaining the CBP desert. We report on the sculpting of a typical CBP distribution by a secular resonance between the apsidal precession of the binary (general relativistic effects included) and that of the planet. We note that the resonance in question is natural around the birthplace of CBPs in isolated binaries (or binaries that are part of triple systems for that matter). We then show how the sweeping of the resonance in the course of typical evolutionary scenarios perturbs planetary orbits to a point that the occurrence rate of CBPs can be significantly reduced when compared to that of planets orbiting single stars. Prior studies of planet formation and evolution around tightening binaries should be revisited with this resonance explicitly taken into consideration. II Resonance Forensics We consider CBPs which are initially dynamically stable under strong three body perturbations, i.e. far enough from the binary to be safe from mean motion resonances, and yet close enough to be prone to disruption by a novel resonance which operates over longer/secular timescales, in the presence of non-conservative evolutionary processes. In other words, we will consider regimes where dynamical processes of interest operate over timescales which are long enough for them to be captured by an orbit averaged treatment 1 1 1 Planets far enough for their orbital periods to couple to long/secular timescales in the binary’s evolution are potentially prone to disruption by semi-secular resonances, evection