Rethinking Collapse: Coupling Quantum States to Classical Bits with quasi-probabilities

Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Pawel Kurzynski · 2025

Read Rethinking Collapse: Coupling Quantum States to Classical Bits with quasi-probabilities by Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Pawel Kurzynski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-03929.txt.

Introduction

Quantum measurement is usually told as a story of an apparatus that must itself be treated quantum mechanically, spawning an endless chain of couplings. Dagomir Kaszlikowski and Pawel Kurzynski cut that chain in a 2025 quantum physics preprint. In their framework, a single qubit couples directly to a classical measurement bit, with no quantum apparatus in between.

The trick lies in how states and interactions are written. The qubit becomes a positive probability distribution spread over a pair of classical bits. The apparatus is one more classical bit. The interaction between them is a map that may use negative transition probabilities, even though every state stays positive. When this process acts, it produces a collapsed state and an outcome with exactly the probabilities quantum mechanics predicts. The nonclassical character of measurement, the authors argue, lives in the interaction itself.

Catalog record

CREATORDagomir Kaszlikowski, Pawel Kurzynski
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-03929

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rethinking Collapse: Coupling Quantum States to Classical Bits with quasi-probabilities Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Pawel Kurzynski Abstract We propose a formulation of quantum measurement within a modified framework of frames , in which a quantum system—a single qubit—is directly coupled to a classical measurement bit. The qubit is represented as a positive probability distribution over two classical bits, a a and a ′ a^{\prime} , denoted by p ⁡ ( a ​ a ′ ) p(aa^{\prime}) . The measurement apparatus is described by a classical bit α = ± 1 \alpha=\pm 1 , initialized in the pure distribution p ​ ( α ) = 1 2 ​ ( 1 + α ) p(\alpha)=\frac{1}{2}(1+\alpha) . The measurement interaction is modeled by a quasi-bistochastic process S ⁡ ( b ​ b ′ ​ β ∣ a ​ a ′ ​ α ) S(bb^{\prime}\beta\mid aa^{\prime}\alpha) —a bistochastic map that may include negative transition probabilities, while acting on an entirely positive state space. When this process acts on the joint initial state p ⁡ ( a ​ a ′ ) ​ p ​ ( α ) p(aa^{\prime})p(\alpha) , it produces a collapsed state p ⁡ ( b ​ b ′ ∣ β ) p(bb^{\prime}\mid\beta) , yielding the measurement outcome β \beta with the correct quantum-mechanical probability p ⁡ ( β ) p(\beta) . This approach bypasses the von Neumann chain of infinite couplings by treating the measurement register classically, while capturing the nonclassical nature of measurement through the quasi-bistochastic structure of the interaction. 1 Introduction The quantum measurement problem has long resisted a fully satisfactory resolution. In the standard formulation introduced by von Neumann, measurement is modeled as a unitary interaction between a quantum system and an increasingly large hierarchy of measuring devices, each entangled with the next. This recursive structure leads to the well-known von Neumann chain [ 22 ] , in which the collapse of the wavefunction is never explicitly realized, but continually deferred. Numerous interpretations and frameworks have been proposed to address this issue. The Copenhagen interpretation introduces a classical/quantum boundary and postulates wavefunction collapse as an axiom when a measurement occurs, without offering a dynamical account. Decoherence-based approaches explain the suppression of interference and the appearance of classicality by tracing out environmental degrees of freedom, but they do not explain the realization of a single outcome [ 17 , 3 , 24 ] . Objective collapse models, such as Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber [ 10 ] and refined continuous spontaneous localization [ 17 ] , modify the Schrödinger equation by adding stochastic or nonlinear terms that induce spontaneous localization, at the cost of violating unitarity. In contrast, the many-worlds interpretation preserves unitarity but denies collapse entirely, positing that all outcomes occur in branching universes—raising challenges concerning probability and observer identity. Quantum Bayesianism (QBism) [ 4 ] and relational quantum mechanics shift the focus from ontic states to observer-relative information updates, reframing measurement as epistemic, though arguably at the cost of explanatory completeness. In this work, we propose a formulation of quantum measurement that bypasses the von Neumann chain by coupling a quantum system – a single qubit – to a classical measurement bit. The qubit is described as a positive probability distribution over two classical bits ( a=\pm 1,a^{\prime}=\pm 1 ), while the measurement apparatus is represented by a classical bit \alpha , initialized in the deterministic state \alpha=+1 , corresponding to p(\alpha)=\frac{1}{2}(1+\alpha ). The interaction between system and apparatus is modeled by a quasi-probabilistic process S(bb^{\prime}\beta|aa^{\prime}\alpha ), which yields both the correct quantum measurement statistics and a well-defined post-measurement state. However, the model relies on transition structures that admit negative probabilities, whose physical interpretation remains generally unresolved [ 2 , 1 , 12 , 5 , 20 , 9 , 13 ] . In what follows, we highlight several structural features of the model that will be developed in the rest of the paper. First, the appearance of negative transition weights can be traced to the combination of a three-dimensional measurement direction with a single classical bit serving as the measurement register; this geometric constraint prevents a fully positive representation of all projective measurements in this minimal setting. Second, we obtain a three-parameter family of quasi-bistochastic maps that all reproduce the correct single-shot collapse behaviour, and we identify a particularly convenient choice whose repeated application exhibits a simple cyclic structure and maintains positivity in the scenarios we analyse. Third, the deterministic preparation of the meter bit, p(\alpha)=\tfrac{1}{2}(1+\alpha) , does not arise as a symmetric informationally complete (SIC) distribution of any quantum state, so the model necessarily employs initial conditions outside the quantum state space; this makes explicit why quasi-bistochastic dynamics appear when a classical bit interacts directly with a qubit. Finally, after tracing out the meter, the resulting transformation acting on the qubit reduces exactly to the SIC representation of a Lüders projection, so the nonclassical features of the model are located in the transition map rather than in the state space. 2 Frame Representations of n -Qubit States In standard quantum mechanics, the state of an n -qubit system is represented by a 2^{n}\times 2^{n} density matrix—a positive semi-definite, trace-one operator. An alternative perspective is to express quantum states using quasi-probability distributions over a classical-like space. This is achieved by expanding the density matrix in terms of an operator frame [ 19 , 23 , 11 ] . A frame is a generalization of a basis: a spanning set that may be overcomplete but still allows for a faithful reconstruction of any operator. In this context, a frame is a set of Hermitian operators \{F_{\lambda}\} , indexed by \lambda\in\Lambda , such that any density matrix \rho admits an expansion \rho=\sum_{\lambda\in\Lambda}\mu(\lambda)F_{\lambda}, (1) where the coefficients \mu(\lambda)\in{\mathbf{R}} encode the state. The frame \{F_{\lambda}\} is typically chosen so that the map \rho\mapsto\mu(\lambda):=\operatorname{Tr}[\rho G_{\lambda}] (2) is linear and invertible, with \{G_{\lambda}\} the dual frame satisfying \sum_{\lambda\in\Lambda}\operatorname{Tr}[F_{\lambda}G_{\lambda^{\prime}}]F_{\lambda}=F_{\lambda^{\prime}}. (3) The coefficients \mu(\lambda) define a quasi-probability distribution over the index set \Lambda , meaning a real-valued function that sums to one but is not required to be nonnegative, in contrast to classical probability distributions. When \mu(\lambda)\geq 0 for all physical states \rho , we obtain a positive frame representation . In this representation, quantum channels are always realized as affine maps on the frame coefficients, implemented via quasi-stochastic matrices —real matrices whose columns sum to one, but which may contain negative entries. This is the price we always pay if we want to express quantum theory as a stochastic theory [ 6 , 7 , 21 , 8 ] . A symmetric informationally complete (SIC) frame for a qubit [ 18 ] consists of four rank-one operators \{\Pi_{\lambda}\}_{\lambda=1}^{4} such that \Pi_{\lambda}=\frac{1}{4}(1+\mathbf{n}_{\lambda}\cdot\mathbf{\sigma}) , where \mathbf{\sigma} is a vector of Pauli matrices and \mathbf{n}_{\lambda} form a three dimensional tetrahedron. These satisfy: \operatorname{Tr}[\Pi_{\lambda}\Pi_{\lambda^{\prime}}]=\begin{cases}\frac{1}{4}&\text{if }\lambda=\lambda^{\prime},\\ \frac{1}{12}&\text{if }\lambda\neq\lambda^{\prime}.\end{cases} (4) A qubit density matrix \rho can be represented by four real numbers p_{\lambda} defined by p_{\lambda}:=\operatorname{Tr}[\rho\,\Pi_{\lambda}],\qquad\text{with}\quad\sum_{\lambda}p_{\lambda}=1. (5) Each p_{\lambda} is a genuine probability: p_{\lambda}\geq 0 for all physical states \rho . The map \rho\mapsto\{p_{\lambda}\} is linear and injective, providing a positive representation of quantum states in terms of classical probability distributions. The state can be reconstructed via: \rho=\sum_{\lambda=1}^{4}\left(4p_{\lambda}-1\right)\Pi_{\lambda}. (6) Under a unitary transformation U , the SIC-represented state transforms as: \tilde{p}_{\lambda}=\sum_{\lambda^{\prime}}T(\lambda\mid\lambda^{\prime})\,p_{\lambda^{\prime}}, (7) where T(\lambda\mid\lambda^{\prime}):=\operatorname{Tr}[U\Pi_{\lambda^{\prime}}U^{\dagger}\,\Pi_{\lambda}] (8) is

Read the complete text