Strategic Selection of Remanufacturing Business Models: A Consumer Perception Perspective Journal: European Journal of Operational Research

Zhongxin Hu, Christina Imdahl, Zümbül Atan · 2025

Read Strategic Selection of Remanufacturing Business Models: A Consumer Perception Perspective Journal: European Journal of Operational Research by Zhongxin Hu, Christina Imdahl, Zümbül Atan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-03732.txt.

Introduction

Remanufacturing restores used products to as-new condition, cutting waste in a circular economy. Zhongxin Hu, Christina Imdahl, and Zümbül Atan ask which business model a manufacturer should choose for that work. Their 2025 preprint, also published in an operations research journal, puts consumer perception at the centre of pricing and production decisions.

Three options are compared: skipping remanufacturing, doing it in-house, or authorising an outside firm under contract. When buyers value restored products highly, in-house work wins on profit and environmental grounds, though restored goods then dominate the market. When perceived value is moderate and an outside partner raises the appeal of new products, authorised remanufacturing earns more but increases total environmental impact. The authors also find two-part contracts handle strict environmental rules better, and they assemble their findings into a step-by-step roadmap for managers.

Catalog record

CREATORZhongxin Hu, Christina Imdahl, Zümbül Atan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-03732

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Strategic Selection of Remanufacturing Business Models: A Consumer Perception Perspective Journal: European Journal of Operational Research Zhongxin Hu, Christina Imdahl, Zümbül Atan Abstract As a key circular economy strategy, remanufacturing allows original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) to reduce waste by restoring used products to “as-new” conditions. This paper investigates an OEM’s optimal remanufacturing business model by incorporating consumer perceptions into price and production quantity decisions. We analyze three alternative models: no remanufacturing, OEM in-house remanufacturing, and third-party remanufacturer (TPR) authorized remanufacturing. We extend the authorization with a two-part tariff contract and consider a stochastic market size. Through a numerical approach, we optimize price and quantity decisions based on consumer perceptions and develop a hierarchical decision roadmap to guide model selection. Our findings show that when consumer’s perceived value of remanufactured products is high, OEM in-house remanufacturing is most profitable and reduces environmental impacts, but generally leads to a market dominated by remanufactured products. In contrast, when consumer’s perceived value of remanufactured products is moderate and TPR remanufacturing significantly increases the perceived value of new products, the TPR-authorized remanufacturing is most profitable. It typically boosts total market sales, but accordingly increases environmental impacts. In addition, sensitivity analysis indicates that two-part authorization contracts are more advanced in meeting stringent environmental requirements than one-part contracts. Incorporating market size stochasticity enhances system profitability while keeping environmental impacts within a limited scope. 1 Introduction In recent years, remanufacturing has emerged as a key strategy within the circular economy, offering substantial potential for resource conservation, waste reduction, and the creation of economic value. Remanufacturing involves processes that restore used products to an “as-new” state, effectively prolonging their useful lives. Environmentally, remanufacturing reduces the need for new raw materials, decreases energy consumption and emissions compared to producing brand-new products, and minimizes waste by diverting products from landfills back into the economic cycle. 12 shows that remanufacturing in the automotive sector can decrease virgin material use by 88%, reduce energy requirements by 56%, and cut CO 2 emissions by up to 53%. Economically, it presents substantial advantages by potentially saving up to 40% - 64% of production costs compared to manufacturing new products ( 20 , 11 ) . 37 reports that the European remanufacturing market is currently valued at €31 billion and could grow to €100 billion by 2030, saving 21 megatons of CO 2 emissions. Given these advantages, a variety of remanufacturing business models have been developed, including in-house remanufacturing by the original equipment manufacturer (OEM) ( 26 , 1 ) , outsourcing to a third-party remanufacturer (TPR) ( 36 ) , and authorizing to a TPR ( 40 , 9 ) . In both OEM in-house and outsourcing models, the OEM maintains control over the sale and marketing of remanufactured products, but the authorizing model allows TPR to sell and market remanufactured products under its own brand. This distinction in branding improves the consumer’s awareness of who is responsible for the remanufactured product. The effectiveness of the three business models depends not only on operational and economic factors, but also on consumer perception ( 35 , 14 , 23 ) . Empirical evidence shows that consumers generally value remanufactured products less than new products, with a perceived value ranging between 40% and 90%, the so-called willingness-to-pay (WTP) discount factor ( 21 , 2 ) . 4 find the perceived value of new products can be significantly influenced by the identity of the remanufacturer. Specifically, for products, such as MP3 players and printers, third-party remanufacturing can increase the perceived value of new products by up to 8%, the so-called contrast effect , while OEM remanufacturing may decrease it by up to 7%, the so-called assimilation effect . Although some analytical models have partially incorporated consumer perceptions ( 5 , 16 , 25 ) , most research treats these perceptions as fixed assumptions and primarily focuses on cost analysis, assessing how cost parameters determine business model choices given a specific condition of consumer perceptions. Only a limited number of studies have systematically explored the patterns by which consumer perception influences the optimal business model. To address this research gap, we investigate the following research question: How does consumer perception affect the choice of the optimal remanufacturing business model? In this study, we compare three remanufacturing business models: no remanufacturing (Model N), OEM in-house remanufacturing (Model O), and TPR-authorized remanufacturing (Model T). The outsourcing model, in which the OEM retains control over sales and marketing, is equivalent to OEM in-house remanufacturing from a consumer perspective; thus, it is excluded from analysis. Using a numerical method, we determine unit prices and quantities of new and remanufactured products to be offered to consumers so that OEM’s profit is maximized. Subsequently, we identify the most profitable model under varying consumer perception conditions and reveal systematic patterns in model selection. Further, we assess both market and environmental outcomes under the optimal model, and discuss the assumptions of authorization contracts and market size. We contribute to the remanufacturing literature in multiple ways. First, we integrate consumer perceptions into remanufacturing business models and examine their impact on the selection of the best business model. We develop a hierarchical decision roadmap that accommodates the full spectrum of consumer perceptions. Second, we examine the market and environmental outcomes associated with optimal business model selection, thereby evaluating the extent to which remanufacturing can promote sustainability. Third, we study stochastic market size and generalize the authorization contract by a two-part tariff structure, including a one-time fixed fee and a unit fee. Our findings reveal that consumer perceptions substantially affect the OEM’s selection of the remanufacturing business model. Among perception factors, the WTP discount factor for remanufactured products exerts the strongest influence, whereas effects related to remanufacturer identity, i.e., assimilation and contrast effects, influence only under specific conditions. When consumers perceive remanufactured products as less valuable, that is, low WTP discount factors, the OEM should avoid remanufacturing. For moderate WTP discount factors, the optimal model depends on the magnitude of assimilation and contrast effects. When these effects are moderate to high, authorizing a third-party remanufacturer is the most profitable option. When consumers perceive remanufactured products as nearly equivalent to new ones, that is, high WTP discount factors, OEM in-house remanufacturing is most profitable. Based on these insights, we develop a hierarchical roadmap to guide the selection of the optimal remanufacturing business model aligned with varying consumer perception conditions. Our numerical analysis explores the market dynamics and environmental impact of selected optimal models. When the TPR-authorized remanufacturing model becomes optimal, the total product output can increase by up to 63.9% and new product output can rise by up to 14.8%, alleviating managerial concerns about cannibalization ( 21 , 7 ) . However, this substantial market expansion also increases overall consumption and emissions, outweighing the environmental benefits of remanufacturing and resulting in a higher aggregate environmental impact. Consequently, the TPR-authorized model generates a “win-win-lose” outcome: higher profits and significant market growth, but an increased environmental burden. In contrast, when the OEM in-house remanufacturing model is optimal, a “win-win-win” outcome emerges: higher profits, moderate market growth, and reduced environmental impact. In this case, remanufactured products can dominate the market when consumers perceive their value as sufficiently high, resulting in a market where only

Read the complete text