A Descriptive Model for Modelling Attacker Decision-Making in Cyber-Deception. Journal: Journal of Information Security and Applications

B.R. Turner, O. Guidetti, N.M. Karie, R. Ryan, Y. Yan · 2025

Read A Descriptive Model for Modelling Attacker Decision-Making in Cyber-Deception. Journal: Journal of Information Security and Applications by B.R. Turner, O. Guidetti, N.M. Karie, R. Ryan, Y. Yan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-03641.txt.

Introduction

B Turner and co-authors model the moment a hacker decides whether a deceptive system is worth taking on. Cyber-deception plants fake targets and false clues, but most formal models start after the attacker has already bitten. Their 2025 model moves the lens to that first judgment call.

Five parts shape the call in their framework: belief, scepticism, deception fidelity, reconnaissance, and experience. Together they describe how attackers read fake cues and price staying in. The authors have planned Capture the Flag contests, tracking moves and body signals, to test the model. No results are claimed yet; what the paper adds is the framework and the test plan.

Catalog record

CREATORB.R. Turner, O. Guidetti, N.M. Karie, R. Ryan, Y. Yan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-03641

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Descriptive Model for Modelling Attacker Decision-Making in Cyber-Deception. Journal: Journal of Information Security and Applications B.R. Turner, O. Guidetti, N.M. Karie, R. Ryan, Y. Yan Abstract Cyber-deception has become a critical strategy in cybersecurity, influencing adversarial decision-making through controlled misinformation, uncertainty, and misdirection. While existing models, including game-theoretic, Bayesian, Markov decision processes, and reinforcement learning approaches, have provided insight into how deception influences adversarial behaviour, these approaches primarily assume that an attacker has already committed to engagement. Although these models provide valuable insights into deception strategies, they often overlook the cognitive and perceptual factors influencing an attacker’s initial decision to engage or disengage. This paper introduces a descriptive model that accounts for the psychological and strategic elements that affect an attacker’s decision-making process. The model defines five core components: belief ( B ) (B) , scepticism ( S ) (S) , deception fidelity ( D ) (D) , reconnaissance ( R ) (R) , and experience ( E ) (E) which interact to describe how adversaries evaluate deception and determine whether to proceed with engagement. The model offers a systematic approach to analysing engagement decisions in cyber-deception scenarios by structuring these elements within a flexible framework. A series of Capture the Flag experiments will be conducted to evaluate this model, which incorporates varying levels of deception. These experiments will integrate behavioural observations and biometric indicators to provide a multidimensional analysis of adversarial responses to deception. The findings will contribute to a deeper understanding of the factors influencing engagement decisions and refine the model’s applicability to real-world cyber-deception environments. The proposed model enhances theoretical and applied understandings of deception in cybersecurity. The findings of this study will provide a foundation for refining cyber-deception strategies by integrating cognitive realism into adversarial decision-making processes. By addressing the gap in existing models that assume engagement, the proposed model enhances theoretical and applied understandings of deception in cybersecurity. 1 Introduction Cyber-deception has become a fundamental aspect of cybersecurity strategy, enabling defenders to manipulate adversarial decision-making by introducing uncertainty, misdirection, and false information into digital environments. As cyber threats evolve, deception techniques have been increasingly adopted to disrupt attackers’ situational awareness, delay malicious activities, and force adversaries to expend additional resources. However, understanding how attackers decide to engage with deceptive elements remains an open research challenge, requiring a structured approach to adversarial decision-making. Existing cyber-deception models, including game-theoretic, Bayesian, Markov decision processes (MDPs), and reinforcement learning approaches, provide valuable insights into how deception influences adversary behaviour. However, many of these models assume that an attacker has already committed to engagement, focusing on optimising deception strategies for after the decision to engage has been made, rather than examining the factors that lead to the decision to attack. In reality, adversaries rely on a combination of rational evaluation, cognitive biases, and heuristic reasoning when assessing potential targets, meaning that factors beyond cost-benefit calculations influence engagement decisions. The proposed model in this paper addresses this gap by introducing a descriptive framework that accounts for the psychological and strategic elements influencing an attacker’s engagement decision. The model defines five core components—belief (B), scepticism (S), deception fidelity (D), reconnaissance (R), and experience (E)—which interact to describe the decision-making process leading to engagement. Unlike existing models that treat deception as a static interaction, this approach recognises the fluid nature of adversarial decision-making and the evolving perception of trust, uncertainty, and deception fidelity over time. To evaluate this model, a structured series of Capture the Flag (CTF) experiments will be conducted, measuring how attackers respond to varying levels of deception. These experiments will incorporate both behavioural observations and biometric indicators to provide a multi-faceted analysis of adversarial decision-making. The results will provide empirical insights into how deception influences engagement and inform further refinements of the model. 2 Literature Review Research into cyber deception has increasingly adopted formal models to represent attacker decision-making processes. Mathematical and computational frameworks provide a structured means of examining how attackers perceive, reason, and act within deceptive environments. Among these, Bayesian inference, Markov decision processes, and reinforcement learning approaches have received particular attention, each offering unique insights into the mechanisms of attacker cognition and adaptation. While their mathematical foundations differ, these models share a common goal: to approximate rational behaviour under uncertainty and to identify the conditions under which deception may succeed or fail. Bayesian models represent attacker decisions as probabilistic reasoning under incomplete information. As new evidence becomes available, prior beliefs are updated to produce posterior probabilities that guide subsequent actions. This formulation captures the logic of belief revision and is particularly useful in settings where the attacker must infer the authenticity of targets from partial or ambiguous observations. However, while Bayesian reasoning embodies the principle of belief updating, it generally abstracts from the qualitative aspects of belief confidence and scepticism that influence engagement decisions. The present work therefore extends, rather than replaces, Bayesian perspectives by modelling these cognitive dimensions explicitly. Markov decision processes (MDPs) and their derivatives express attacker behaviour as a sequence of probabilistic state transitions governed by defined rules of motion. Such models are effective for representing the temporal and adaptive nature of attack progression, particularly where system responses can be discretised into states. Yet, MDPs typically describe transitions without representing the cognitive mechanisms that motivate them. The model proposed here complements this tradition by incorporating cognitive variables—belief, scepticism, deception fidelity, experience, and reconnaissance—that explain why an attacker may choose one transition path over another. Reinforcement learning (RL) approaches similarly represent adaptation through iterative feedback, allowing an agent to learn from environmental rewards and penalties. These models have proven effective in simulating red-team and blue-team dynamics, and in identifying strategies that maximise utility in competitive scenarios. However, they focus primarily on outcome optimisation rather than the cognitive reasoning that precedes behavioural change. The present model approaches the same problem from a complementary direction, defining engagement as a function of perceived authenticity, familiarity, and effort. In doing so, it expresses cognitive antecedents in a form that can later interface with data-driven RL or Bayesian frameworks for empirical calibration. Collectively, these prior approaches provide the empirical and theoretical basis for understanding deception within cyber operations. The model developed in this work builds upon that foundation by prioritising interpretability and conceptual clarity. It aims to describe how cognitive factors, rather than solely probabilistic or state-based dynamics, shape attacker engagement decisions. This perspective aligns behavioural modelling with the psychological context in which deception operates, offering an abstract yet adaptable framework for subsequent empirical investigation. A comparative summary of representative modelling approaches is presented in Table 1 . The table highlights the primary characteristics, modelling focus, and contextual relevance of existing frameworks that inform the development of the present model. This summary provides a concise reference for understanding how prior approaches contribute to the broader study of attacker decision-making in deceptive environments. Model & Approach Mathematical Foundation Handling of Deception Incorporation of Psychological Factors Proposed model - Linear deception function with heuristic weighting - (B-S)-R(E-D) : integrates belief ( B ), scepticism ( S ), experience ( E ), deception fidelity ( D ), and reconnaissance ( R ) - Dynamic: Outcome iterates based on real-time feedback (e.g. new reconnaissance data) - Bounded reconnaissance ( R ) scales the

Read the complete text