New Method for Investigating the Presence of Extragalactic Magnetic Fields

B. Stern, I. Tkachev · 2025

Read New Method for Investigating the Presence of Extragalactic Magnetic Fields by B. Stern, I. Tkachev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-03192.txt.

Introduction

Magnetic fields between galaxies are nearly impossible to see directly. B. Stern and I. Tkachev present a new way to hunt for them in this 2025 work. High-energy photons from distant sources can start cascades as they cross space.

A field would bend those cascades, causing a time delay and a faint halo of gamma rays around the source. Astronomers look for those signs. The authors' method aims to sharpen that search. Finding such fields would reveal how magnetism arose and shaped the cosmos. Gamma-ray telescopes already gather the data such a search needs, if analysis is sharp enough.

Catalog record

CREATORB. Stern, I. Tkachev
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-03192

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

New Method for Investigating the Presence of Extragalactic Magnetic Fields B. Stern, I. Tkachev Abstract The extragalactic magnetic field could be detected by searching for signatures of the electromagnetic cascade initiated by high-energy photons on the intergalactic radiation and deflected by the field. This process produces a time delay and an extended gamma-ray halo around the source, which are looked for. We propose a new signature of electromagnetic echoes: the asymmetry of the gamma-ray distribution around blazars. As a measure of asymmetry, we use the offset of the gamma-ray distribution to the location of the blazar. This offset is due to the tilt of the jet of the blazar relative to the line of sight. Using a subsample of the 10 brightest BL Lacs, we exclude the range of extragalactic magnetic fields from 10 − 16 10^{-16} to 10 − 14 10^{-14} G, assuming that these objects have maintained a constant average luminosity over hundreds of thousands of years. , I Introduction There is no theoretical consensus on the origin and likely values of the extragalactic magnetic field (EGMF), for an overview see 12 . There is a well-established upper limit on its value of \sim 10^{-9} G, obtained from Faraday rotation measurements (see, e.g., 24 ), and a number of papers proclaiming lower limits. Two approaches are used to test EGMF and establish lower limits. Both are associated with the \gamma -ray echo caused by electromagnetic cascades initiated by multi-TeV photons on extragalactic background light. The first one is to search for delayed photons after gamma-ray flares of blazars or GRBs. This approach was suggested by 22 and developed by 20 ; 10 . The lower limit set by this method is of the order of 10^{-17} G 16 ; 14 ; 2 ; 27 . The second approach is to search for extended halos around the blazar’s gamma-ray images due to angular spread caused by the same process 23 ; 5 . Most studies of this effect report the absence of angular spreading and put a lower limit on the EGMF value at the level 10^{-15} G ( 21 ; 13 ; 28 ; 4 ; 6 ). We stress that these bounds depend on the \gamma -ray energy and EGMF correlation length, see e.g. 2 . Comprehensive reviews with theoretical background can be found in 19 ; 7 . There are several reports of observations of extended gamma-ray halos around BL Lacs, for example, a signal in stacked images of a sample of active galactic nuclei was detected in 8 . However, Ref. 18 demonstrated, and 3 confirmed, that this was merely an underestimation of the telescope’s point spread function (PSF) width. Then, in the paper 9 an interesting hint of image broadening was found in a stacked sample of high synchrotron-peaked BL Lacs. This paper presents a new method for detecting the presence of EGMF. It is based on the asymmetry of the blazar image rather than its extent, and is sensitive enough to give a significant signal from an individual object. We limit the present study to Fermi LAT data and one simple characterization of image asymmetry. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II we formulate the problem and describe the Monte-Carlo model. In Section III we present the results of numerical simulations and describe the expected signal for different model parameters. In Section IV , we describe how we formed our sample of BL Lac objects and discuss the challenge of non-unique definition of their locations. Further in this section we put the constraints on the extragalactic magnetic field using the brightest part of the sample. In Section V we discuss the advantages of the method and perspectives of further efforts in this direction. Additional technical information is provided in the Appendix. II The method and the model Astrophysical high-energy photons are converted into e^{+}e^{-} pairs by interacting with the extragalactic background light, which is optically thick for photons in the TeV range at distances of hundreds of Mpc. In modelling this process, we use an estimate of the spectral density of infrared-optical photons in intergalactic space from 15 . The produced pairs subsequently comptonize CMB photons up to the GeV energy range covered by the gamma-ray telescopes. The path length of an electron before it can Comptonize the relic radiation is about 10 kpc, which is negligible compared to the distance to the source. This cooling distance limits the range of magnetic field values that can be detected using this technique to 10^{-16}-10^{-14} G. A weaker field is unable to deflect the electrons by an angle sufficient to distort the blazar’s image; a stronger field will deflect them so that the Comptonized photons will lose their connection with the source and contribute to the isotropic gamma-ray background. The process in this range extends a blazar image, producing a halo. Figure 1: Diagram illustrating the formation of a ”cascade echo”. The primary TeV radiation in the jet creates e^{+}e^{-} pairs in the intergalactic background light; e^{+}e^{-} pairs deflected by EGMF create secondary GeV photons when interacting with the cosmic microwave background radiation. The resulting GeV halo is shifted towards the jet inclination. The central point of the new method we propose is that the halo must be asymmetric, since the blazar jets are not directed precisely at us, see Fig. 1 . We suggest that halo asymmetry may be a more efficient indicator of the intergalactic field than the image extent above the PSF. In particular, the new approach does not rely on the perhaps poorly known energy-dependent PSF. We derive the expected properties of the asymmetric halo using Monte Carlo simulations. To do this, we first need a blazar model. We make the following assumptions: i) The blazar jet has a Lorentz factor of 20. This is a typical value estimated from the superluminal motion ( 17 ). ii) The jet is strongly collimated. The angular distribution of photons results from the isotropic motion of emitted particles in the comoving reference frame of the jet. iii) The spectral energy distribution is a flat power law, i.e, the photon number index is \Gamma=-2 . This is a typical feature of BL Lacs. Some objects (e.g. Mkn 421) have harder spectra in the 1 GeV - 1 TeV range, while others (e.g. BL Lac) are softer. Flat spectrum is a good compromise. iv) The maximum photon energy is 10 TeV in the jet comoving frame. v) We model the EGMF in the following way. From birth until the loss (due to cooling) of the ability to produce Compton photons with energy greater than GeV, each electron moves in a field with an initially randomly oriented but then constant transverse component H with a given amplitude. This modeling scheme corresponds to a correlation length \gtrsim Mpc. A shorter correlation length will reduce the effect we are looking for if the field is in the range of 10^{-16}-10^{-15} G, and will enhance it in a stronger field. Items iii and iv imply low external radiation density at the source, this condition is natural for BL-Lacs. This basic model does not cover the entire variety of BL-Lacs and EGMF, but it is quite sufficient for studying

Read the complete text