Competing excitonic couplings as origin of mimicked phase transitions in zinc-phthalocyanine single crystals

Lisa Schraut-May, Sebastian Hammer, Luca Nils Philipp, Krzysztof Radacki, Gabriele Tauscher, Helena Hollstein, Kilian Strauß, Martin Kamp, Heinrich Schwoerer, Holger Braunschweig, Roland Mitric, Jens Pflaum · 2025

Read Competing excitonic couplings as origin of mimicked phase transitions in zinc-phthalocyanine single crystals by Lisa Schraut-May, Sebastian Hammer, Luca Nils Philipp, Krzysztof Radacki, Gabriele Tauscher, Helena Hollstein, Kilian Strauß, Martin Kamp, Heinrich Schwoerer, Holger Braunschweig, Roland Mitric, Jens Pflaum (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-02639.txt.

Introduction

Lisa Schraut-May and eleven co-authors study crystals of zinc-phthalocyanine, a light absorbing molecule. In a molecular crystal, light excites pairs of neighboring molecules together, an effect called excitonic coupling. That coupling is very sensitive to how neighbors sit, tilt, and overlap.

Small changes in packing can mimic the signs of a phase transition in optical spectra. The team traces such mimicked transitions to competing couplings between molecules. Knowing the true cause prevents false claims of new phases, and helps design organic materials whose light response is tuned on purpose. Packing rules learned here feed the design of dyes and films that drink light for work in cells.

Catalog record

CREATORLisa Schraut-May, Sebastian Hammer, Luca Nils Philipp, Krzysztof Radacki, Gabriele Tauscher, Helena Hollstein, Kilian Strauß, Martin Kamp, Heinrich Schwoerer, Holger Braunschweig, Roland Mitric, Jens Pflaum
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-02639

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Competing excitonic couplings as origin of mimicked phase transitions in zinc-phthalocyanine single crystals Lisa Schraut-May, Sebastian Hammer, Luca Nils Philipp, Krzysztof Radacki, Gabriele Tauscher, Helena Hollstein, Kilian Strauß, Martin Kamp, Heinrich Schwoerer, Holger Braunschweig, Roland Mitric, Jens Pflaum Abstract The optical properties of molecular crystals are largely determined by the excitonic coupling of neighboring molecules. This coupling is extremely sensitive to the arrangement of adjacent molecular units, as their electronic interaction is defined by the relative orientation of the individual transition dipole moments and their wave function overlap. Hence, the optical properties, such as transmission, absorption, and emission, are usually highly anisotropic and good indicators of structural changes during the variation of intensive thermodynamic parameters like temperature or pressure. Here, we discuss the peculiar though archetypical case of β \upbeta -phase zinc-phthalocyanine: In single crystalline specimen, we report a sudden change of spectral emission with temperature from a broad, unpolarized Frenkel-exciton type luminescence to a narrow, highly polarized superradiance-like fluorescence below 80 K. Surprisingly, we find that there is no sign of a discrete structural phase transition in this temperature regime. To understand this apparent contradiction, we perform polarization-, temperature- and time-dependent photoluminescence measurements along different crystallographic directions to fully map the emission characteristics of the crystal-exciton. By means of ab-initio calculations on a density functional theory level we conclude that our observations are consistent with a dimer exciton model when considering thermalized electronic states. As such, our study presents a representative case study on a well-established molecular material class demonstrating that caution is advised when attributing discrete changes in electronic observables to a structural phase transition. As we show for zinc-phthalocyanine in its β \upbeta -phase modification, a material that has received strong attention for its use in various optical and opto-electronic applications, slowly varying excitonic couplings and thermal redistribution of excitations can mimic the same signatures attributed to a structural phase transition. 1 Introduction Molecular aggregates are comprised of extended, spatially anisotropic constituents. Strong ground state associated dipole moment forces in combination with superimposed weak dispersion forces lead to crystallization of molecular single crystals in low symmetry point groups, often being monoclinic or even triclinic in nature. [ 1 ] The electronic interaction in the aggregate depends on the relative orientation of adjacent molecules and is therefore highly anisotropic as well. [ 2 ] This gives rise to complex photophysical behavior that depends on the aggregate’s underlying crystal structure and is sensitive to disruptions of the local molecular geometry. A common description of the optical properties is given in terms of exciton theory. Based on the work of Kasha and coworkers, [ 3 , 4 ] the excitonic couplings are often described by dipolar Coulomb interactions between the transition dipole moments (TDM) of adjacent molecules. In the case of one-dimensional chains this leads to the distinction of two limiting cases, the H- and J-aggregate. [ 5 ] The treatment of the neat electronic interactions can be expanded to include coupling to the nuclear coordinates to take intra- and inter-molecular vibrations into account. This results in the exciton-polaron model, which provides a much more comprehensive picture of the photo-physics of molecular aggregates, especially regarding its dependence on temperature and dynamic and static disorder. [ 2 , 6 ] These approaches have proven successful in describing the optical properties of various molecular materials and concomitant crystal structures, from one-dimensional linear [ 2 ] and helical chains [ 7 ] to the more sophisticated cases of two-dimensional brick-wall [ 8 ] or herringbone aggregates, [ 9 , 10 ] as well as excimer formation. [ 11 ] From this it is quite clear that the optical properties of a molecular aggregate can be used as indicator for the respective underlying polymorph. [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] Especially the spectral photoluminescence has been used as a non-destructive probe to study structural phase transitions of molecular crystals in-situ. [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] Here, the knowledge of the underlying crystal structure as well as the specific orientation of the molecules in the probed crystallographic facets is extremely important for the correct interpretation of the observed photoluminescence signals and their spectral distribution. The following study is motivated by the photoluminescence of \upbeta -phase zinc-phthalocyanine ( \upbeta -ZnPc) single crystals (for molecular and crystal structure c.f. Figure 1 a) and b)). ZnPc is a well-established organic material, studied for its optical properties and utilization in opto-electronic applications, like organic photovoltaic, [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] light emitting diodes [ 15 ] or even novel concepts such as plasmonic light emitting antennas. [ 22 , 23 ] Despite the broad interest in this material, its optical behavior over a wide temperature range or specifically at low temperatures was, to our knowledge, never studied in detail before. In Figure 1 c) the evolution of the photoluminescence is shown as a function of temperature. For temperatures above 150 K, the spectra represent a typical Frenkel-type exciton emission as shown exemplary in Figure 1 d) for 290 K. Cooling down further, around 100 K, the main emission peak at 1.6 eV disappears almost completely ( c.f. center of Figure 1 d)) and reappears as a narrow emission peak at low temperatures as depicted in the lower panel of Figure 1 d). The emergence of such narrow emission peaks of high intensity in the lowest emission component is known from low-temperature J-aggregates and commonly termed superradiance. To understand this behavior, we present a comprehensive study of temperature-, polarization-, and time-dependent photoluminescence on different crystallographic facets, consistently describing the complex luminescence behavior of \upbeta -ZnPc single crystals. Together with structural characterization and complementary theoretical evaluation of the corresponding excitonic coupling between neighboring molecules via time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT), we clearly demonstrate that no underlying structural phase transition is responsible for this drastic change in the emission spectra with temperature. Instead, the observed behavior can be consistently described by an elementary aggregate-exciton model if thermal population of dark and emissive states is fully taken into account. 2 Temperature dependent photoluminescence 2.1 Steady-state photoluminescence Figure 1: a) Molecular structure of ZnPc with purple arrows indicating the TDM orientation of the \text{S}_{0}\rightarrow\text{S}_{1} and \text{S}_{0}\rightarrow\text{S}_{2} calculated via TD-DFT. b) Unit cell of \upbeta -phase ZnPc with herringbone-like packing. c) Temperature dependent PL spectra measured on the ZnPc (\bar{1}01) crystal facet with a gray line as guide to the eye indicating the evolution of spectral maximum with temperature. The spectra exhibit Fabry-Pérot oscillations at lower energies being indicative for the high crystal quality. d) Luminescence spectra measured at exemplary temperatures of 290 K, 110 K and 6 K. We first turn to the temperature dependent fluorescence spectra of the investigated \upbeta -ZnPc and their detailed description. The measurements were conducted via micro-photoluminescence on \upbeta -ZnPc single crystals grown via horizontal vapor deposition ( c.f. Methods section for details). The emission spectra are shown in Figure 1 c) for the temperature range from 6 K to 300 K. The probed crystallographic facet was identified by X-ray diffraction as the (\bar{1}01) bulk crystal facet. The polarization direction of the depicted PL corresponds to the maximum emission, as discussed below. The emission polarization is perpendicular to the crystallographic b-axis which

Read the complete text