Photon (Non)Conservation in the Reduced Speed of Light Approximation and How to (Almost) Fix It

Nickolay Y. Gnedin · 2025

Read Photon (Non)Conservation in the Reduced Speed of Light Approximation and How to (Almost) Fix It by Nickolay Y. Gnedin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-02094.txt.

Introduction

Simulating how light travels through the cosmos is slow, so cosmologists often cheat by slowing light itself down in the calculation. Nickolay Gnedin's 2025 paper examines a flaw in that reduced speed of light approximation: in some regimes it makes photons quietly disappear.

Gnedin shows the missing photons can be counted exactly for certain numerical schemes, turning a hidden error into a measurable one. He then explains how to almost fix the problem, restoring conservation where it matters. Radiative transfer underlies simulations of galaxy formation and cosmic reionization, so photon bookkeeping errors can distort big conclusions.

Catalog record

CREATORNickolay Y. Gnedin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-02094

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Photon (Non)Conservation in the Reduced Speed of Light Approximation and How to (Almost) Fix It Nickolay Y. Gnedin Abstract The ”Reduced Speed of Light” (RSL) approximation is commonly used to speed up radiative transfer calculations in cosmological simulations. However, it has been shown previously that the RSL approximation leads to photon non-conservation in some regimes. I show that these missing photons can be counted exactly for some numerical schemes. Adding them back into a simulation, however, is a much harder task. I show one example of such a scheme, which achieves sub-percent accuracy on simple tests. Unfortunately, the scheme performs much worse on semi-realistic simulations of cosmic reionization, leading to a faster overlap and significant errors in the point-to-point comparison of the RSL radiation field with the reference simulation that maintains the full speed of light for the radiative transfer. keywords reionization, radiative transfer, numerical methods 1 Motivation The past decade has witnessed a dramatic expansion in our observational window onto the early Universe. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has revealed a rich population of galaxies within the first few hundred million years after the Big Bang, while wide-field surveys have uncovered an increasing number of luminous quasars at redshifts beyond 7. Together, these discoveries are transforming our empirical understanding of the reionization era and providing stringent new constraints on when and how the intergalactic medium was ionized. At the same time, cosmological simulations have achieved remarkable progress in reproducing many aspects of galaxy formation and the large-scale structure of the Universe. Yet, despite these advances, our understanding of cosmic reionization remains limited by the accuracy of radiative transfer methods. As reionization is fundamentally a radiative process, even small numerical errors in photon transport can propagate into large uncertainties in key observables—from the global ionized-fraction history to the morphology of ionized regions and the mean free path of ionizing photons. This is particularly apparent in comparing two of the recent ”second-generation” simulations, ”CROC” ( Gnedin 2014 ; Gnedin & Kaurov 2014 ) , and ”THESAN” Kannan et al. 2022 ; Garaldi et al. 2022 ; Garaldi et al. 2024 . The two sets of simulations are similar in many respects (box sizes, spatial and mass resolution, modeled physical processes, numerical methods, etc). The primary difference in modeled physics between the two is the specific implementation of star formation and stellar feedback. Nevertheless, and completely unexpectedly, the power spectra of the radiation source luminosity density are similar in two simulations, while the power spectra of the actual radiation field are surprisingly different ( Gnedin 2025 ) . Moreover, the power spectra of the radiation field in CROC and THESAN can be matched on large scales if one allows the timing in two simulations to be selected independently - i.e., for each CROC snapshot, one can find a snapshot from THESAN at a different cosmic time with a similar large-scale power spectrum of the radiation field. It appears, therefore, that in two simulations, radiation sources are clustered similarly and emit photons at similar rates, but these photons propagate at different rates through the modeled IGM. When phrased in such a way, it is actually not surprising, as both simulations use a ”reduced speed of light” (RSL) approximation ( Gnedin & Abel 2001 ; Gnedin 2014 ; Kannan et al. 2019 ) in modeling radiative transfer, and the two numerical implementations are not identical. It is therefore plausible to assume that the culprit for the confusing behavior of the radiation field in two simulations (the lack of similarity at the same time and similarity on large scales at different times) is the RSL approximation. Hence, the goal of this paper is to explore further the photon conservation (or the lack thereof) in the RSL approximation. This work builds on and extends the prior work by Cain 2024 , who, to the best of my knowledge, was the first to explicitly show that the RSL approximation does not conserve photons in some limits. Even earlier, the effect was mentioned by Ocvirk et al. 2019 , although they did not interpret it as a lack of photon conservation. 2 RSL Primer The radiative transfer equation for the (monochromatic) radiation specific intensity I_{\nu}(\vec{x},\vec{n},t) in a static background reads \frac{1}{c}\frac{\partial}{\partial t}I_{\nu}+\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{j}}n^{i}I_{\nu}=-\kappa_{\nu}I_{\nu}+\frac{\dot{E}_{\nu}}{4\pi}, (1) where \kappa_{\nu}=\sum_{j}\sigma_{j}(\nu)n_{j} is the absorption coefficient per unit length, the sum is over all atomic species that absorb radiation at frequency \nu , and E_{\nu} is the monochromatic luminosity density of radiative sources. With the cosmological expansion, additional terms appear on the left-hand side, which I ignore for now, since the deliberations below apply equally to a static background and the cosmologically expanding one. These cosmological terms can always be considered as just parts of a more complex time derivative operator. For monochromatic radiation, the difference between the number density and the energy density of photons is a trivial rescaling; therefore, I will switch to the photon number density below, as it may be more familiar to the cosmological radiative transfer community. The first three moments of I_{\nu} are \displaystyle N_{\nu}(\vec{x},t) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{ch\nu}\int d\Omega\,I_{\nu}(\vec{x},\vec{n},t), (2a) \displaystyle M_{\nu}^{i}(\vec{x},t) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{ch\nu}\int d\Omega\,I_{\nu}(\vec{x},\vec{n},t)n^{i}=\langle n^{i}\rangle N_{\nu}, (2b) \displaystyle P_{\nu}^{ij}(\vec{x},t) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{ch\nu}\int d\Omega\,I_{\nu}(\vec{x},\vec{n},t)n^{i}n^{j}=\langle n^{i}n^{j}\rangle N_{\nu}. (2c) The photon number flux F^{i}\equiv cM^{i} . I will, however, use the first 1 1 1 Being a computational physicist, my counting starts at 0. moment M^{i} instead of the flux since it will be important to explicitly consider all factors of c . Hereafter, I will drop the frequency subscript for clearer notation, as all radiation moments will be monochromatic unless the frequency dependence becomes explicitly relevant (as in the calculation of the photo-ionization rate). In this notation, the equations for the first 2 moments become: \displaystyle\frac{\partial N}{\partial t}+c\frac{\partial M^{j}}{\partial x^{j}} \displaystyle=-c\kappa N+\dot{N}, (3a) \displaystyle\frac{\partial M^{i}}{\partial t}+c\frac{\partial P^{ij}}{\partial x^{j}} \displaystyle=-c\kappa M^{i}+\dot{M}^{i}, (3b) where \dot{N}\equiv\dot{E}/(h\nu) is the photon production rate density and c\dot{M}^{i} is the flux source, which vanishes for isotropic sources - the assumption I adopt hereafter (note that hereafter the dot over a symbol is not a time derivative but a part of the notation). In a quasi-steady-state ( \partial N/\partial t\rightarrow 0 ), which is equivalent to the Newtonian limit ( c\rightarrow\infty) , the radiation field can be computed in a closed form - just sum up 1/(4\pi R^{2}) from each source, N_{\rm NL}(\vec{x})=\frac{1}{4\pi c}\int d^{3}y\frac{\dot{N}(\vec{y})}{(\vec{x}-\vec{y})^{2}}e^{-\tau(\vec{x},\vec{y})}, (4) where \tau(\vec{x},\vec{y})=|\vec{x}-\vec{y}|\int_{0}^{1}\kappa\left(\alpha\vec{x}+(1-\alpha)\vec{y}\right)d\alpha is the optical depth between locations \vec{x} and \vec{y} . The well-known issue with equations ( 3 ) is that photons propagate at the speed of light, and hence any explicit numerical scheme must have the time-step smaller than the light crossing time of one resolution element (a cell on the grid for a grid code). This time-step is going to be too small for the vast majority of realistic applications. Hence, the ”Reduced Speed of Light” (or RSL) approximation is used to circumvent this numerical limitation. In order to demonstrate explicitly how the RSL is introduced, Equation ( 3 a) can be written in an equivalent form, where I explicitly label two places where the speed of light enters: \frac{1}{c_{a}}\frac{\partial N}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial M^{j}}{\partial x^{j}}=-\kappa N+\frac{\dot{N}}{c_{b}}. (5) Sometimes it is also useful to consider the spatially averaged version of Equation ( 3 a), \frac{1}{c_{a}}\frac{d}{dt}\langle N\rangle=-\bar{\kappa}\langle N\rangle+\frac{\langle\dot{N}\rangle}{c_{b}}, (6) where by definition \bar{\kappa}\equiv\frac{\langle\kappa N\rangle}{\langle N\rangle}.

Read the complete text