Neural Networks as Physics-Consistent Surrogates: An Explainable AI Validation Framework for Learning Constitutive Relations
Chandana Pati, S. M. Mallikarjunaiah · 2025
Read Neural Networks as Physics-Consistent Surrogates: An Explainable AI Validation Framework for Learning Constitutive Relations by Chandana Pati, S. M. Mallikarjunaiah (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-02064.txt.
Introduction
Neural networks can learn how a material bends or stretches under load. But engineers hesitate to trust a model they cannot inspect. Chandana Pati and S. M. Mallikarjunaiah give a 2025 plan for checking such networks. The plan ties what the network does back to the known rules of how solids behave.
They use a suite of tools that explain a model's choices. The networks were trained on three kinds of material behavior: rubber-like stretching, plastic flow, and slow creep over time. The checks ask if the network's logic matches known physics, not just a curve fit. A fast stand-in that obeys physics could speed up design work while keeping trust.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chandana Pati, S. M. Mallikarjunaiah |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-02064
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Neural Networks as Physics-Consistent Surrogates: An Explainable AI Validation Framework for Learning Constitutive Relations Chandana Pati, S. M. Mallikarjunaiah Abstract This paper presents a Physics- Explainable AI (XAI) framework to validate and interpret neural networks for the constitutive modeling of solid materials. The study bridges the gap between data-driven models and continuum mechanics by applying a suite of explainability methods to neural networks trained on three distinct material behaviors: hyperelasticity ( Mooney-Rivlin ), elastoplasticity ( Chaboche ), and viscoelasticity ( Fractional Zener ). First, high-fidelity surrogate models, including dense feed-forward networks, LSTMs, and GRUs, are trained on synthetically generated data to accurately capture complex material responses. The core of the work then employs XAI techniques to ”open the black box” and confirm that the networks learn physically meaningful principles. For hyperelasticity, gradient-based attributions ( Grad Input (GI)) successfully match the analytical tangent modulus, proving the network learned material stiffness. For elastoplasticity, SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) demonstrate the Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) internalizes path-dependent memory, with SHAP identifying plastic strain as the dominant feature governing the stress prediction. For viscoelasticity, latent-space and wavelet analyses of the Gated Recurrent Unit. GRU layers reveal a clear temporal hierarchy, with different layers encoding instantaneous elastic response, intermediate relaxation, and long-term fractional memory. Ultimately, the study demonstrates that the XAI framework can verify that the neural networks are not merely curve-fitting but are, in fact, learning the underlying physical mechanisms of stiffness, history-dependence, and temporal damping. Keywords— Explainable AI; Constitutive Modeling; Neural Networks; Material Modeling; Hyperelasticity; Elastoplasticity; Viscoelasticity 1 Introduction The integration of machine learning (ML), particularly deep learning, is poised to revolutionize the field of computational solid mechanics [ 19 ] . For decades, the development of robust constitutive models has been a cornerstone of mechanical simulation. However, classical phenomenological models, while foundational, often require extensive and costly experimental calibration, struggle to capture extreme nonlinearities, and may fail entirely when faced with complex, non-proportional loading paths or anisotropic material evolution. Artificial neural networks (ANNs), as powerful universal function approximators [ 12 ] , offer a compelling alternative. In mechanics, this advantage is being actively explored in two primary domains. First, ANNs serve as highly efficient surrogate models for accelerating expensive, high-fidelity simulations. This includes applications in model order reduction (MOR) [ 15 ] and uncertainty quantification [ 3 ] , where thousands of simulation calls are rendered computationally feasible. Second, and perhaps more profoundly, ANNs are being used as data-driven constitutive models that can be trained to capture extraordinarily complex material behaviors directly from data [ 6 ] . Specialized architectures, such as Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) and their gated variants (LSTMs and GRUs), are particularly adept at modeling path-dependent and history-dependent phenomena. This has shown great promise for materials like elastoplastic metals [ 29 , 10 ] and viscoelastic polymers [ 8 ] . This data-driven approach promises to bypass the need for deriving complex, analytical material laws and can even bridge scales, learning continuum-level free energy functions directly from atomistic simulations [ 39 ] or modeling complex phenomena like brittle fracture [ 14 ] . This drive to capture extreme material behavior is part of a larger, long-standing challenge in computational mechanics, and it highlights a fascinating fork in the road for the research community. For decades, the primary path forward has been to build ever-more sophisticated classical models and solvers. This includes deep, foundational work on the very nature of materials, such as implicit constitutive theories [ 32 ] , the complex mechanics of mixtures [ 34 ] , and advanced nonlinear elasticity theories [ 33 ] . To actually solve these, especially for notoriously difficult problems like fracture, the community has developed a powerful arsenal of specialized numerical techniques. We see this in the development of adaptive phase-field models [ 42 ] , hp -adaptive discontinuous Galerkin methods [ 26 ] , and intricate hp -adaptive finite element (FEM) discretizations [ 23 ] . All this effort is aimed at a singular goal: accurately simulating how cracks propagate in novel nonlinear materials, such as those described by strain-limiting elastic theories [ 25 , 24 , 7 ] . But a parallel, more recent approach is emerging, one that uses deep learning not just as a material model, but as a direct solver for the governing differential equations. Instead of meticulously crafting FEM code, researchers are now using feedforward neural networks to approximate solutions for complex nonlinear ODEs [ 27 , 41 , 40 ] and even singularly perturbed delay differential equations [ 22 ] . Both of these streams—one based on refining classical methods, the other on a new computational paradigm—are ultimately trying to get to the same place: a reliable, accurate model of nonlinear physics. Despite this enormous potential, the primary barrier to the widespread adoption of ANNs in engineering and materials science remains their inherent ”black box” nature [ 4 ] . The internal parameters of a deep neural network, often numbering in the millions, are not readily interpretable in the language of physics or engineering. This opacity leads to a critical lack of trust, which is a non-starter for safety-critical applications in aerospace, biomedical engineering, and civil infrastructure. Without a clear understanding of a model’s internal reasoning, it is impossible to perform the rigorous Verification and Validation (V&V) that these fields mandate [ 1 ] . We cannot be certain whether the network has learned the correct, generalizable underlying physical laws or has simply become a ”Clever Hans” predictor, exploiting spurious correlations or dataset biases to achieve a correct answer for the wrong reasons [ 18 ] . To bridge this ”trust gap,” two complementary fields have emerged. The first is Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs) [ 31 ] , which embed a priori physical knowledge directly into the learning process. This is most often achieved by incorporating the residual of the governing partial differential equations (PDEs) as a penalty term in the network’s loss function. In this way, the network is trained not only to fit the data but also to obey fundamental physical laws, such as the conservation of momentum or energy. This approach, pioneered by [ 17 ] , has been shown to dramatically improve data efficiency and ensure the resulting model is physically plausible. It has seen widespread success in fluid dynamics, heat transfer, and increasingly in solid mechanics [ 9 , 13 ] . However, PINNs are not a silver bullet. They can struggle with stiff PDEs, complex geometries, and high-frequency or chaotic solutions. Furthermore, while they enforce physics, they do not fully solve the interpretability problem; the internal reasoning of the hidden layers, and how they combine information to satisfy the enforced laws, can remain a mystery. This is where the second, and perhaps more transformative, field of XAI provides a solution [ 28 ] . Instead of only enforcing physics a priori , XAI provides a suite of tools to interpret and explain the network’s decisions a posteriori . This facilitates a paradigm shift from ”physics-informed” to ”physics-explaining.” It allows us to ”open the black box” and perform a scientific interrogation of the model. XAI methods can be broadly categorized. Attribution methods seek to identify which