No Love for black holes: tightest constraints on tidal Love numbers of black holes from GW250114

M. Andrés-Carcasona, G. Caneva Santoro · 2025

Read No Love for black holes: tightest constraints on tidal Love numbers of black holes from GW250114 by M. Andrés-Carcasona, G. Caneva Santoro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01918.txt.

Introduction

When two black holes spiral together, each one's gravity stretches the other, and the amount of stretch is summed up in numbers called tidal Love numbers. Classical general relativity says these numbers are exactly zero for black holes in vacuum. A 2025 paper uses the gravitational-wave event GW250114 to test that claim.

The event was recorded with an unmatched signal-to-noise ratio, giving an unusually clean test. If the numbers came out nonzero, the cause could be exotic matter nearby or a failure of general relativity itself. The authors derive the tightest constraints yet on black hole Love numbers, sharpening a precise probe of fundamental physics.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Andrés-Carcasona, G. Caneva Santoro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01918

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

No Love for black holes: tightest constraints on tidal Love numbers of black holes from GW250114 M. Andrés-Carcasona, G. Caneva Santoro Abstract Tidal Love numbers of black holes, zero in classical general relativity for Kerr black holes in vacuum, become non-vanishing in the presence of exotic matter or in alternative theories of gravity, making them a powerful probe of fundamental physics. The gravitational-wave event GW250114, observed with an unprecedented signal-to-noise ratio, provides a unique opportunity to test this prediction. By analyzing this event, we conclude that the data is consistent with the binary black hole hypothesis, and we place a 90% upper limit on the effective tidal deformability of Λ ~ < 34.8 \tilde{\Lambda}<34.8 . These bounds imply that any environment surrounding the black holes must contribute less than ∼ 7 × 10 − 3 \sim 7\times 10^{-3} of their mass, and they rule out some models of boson stars. Our findings provide the strongest observational constraints yet on black hole tidal deformability and show that the data remain fully consistent with the Kerr black hole prediction of vanishing tidal Love numbers. Introduction – The first direct detection of gravitational waves (GWs) from a binary black hole (BH) in 2015 9 opened a new era of GW astronomy, enabling precision tests of general relativity (GR) in the strong-field regime and probing the nature of compact objects. Since then, the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA (LVK) collaboration has expanded the catalog to GWTC-4, containing hundreds of compact-binary coalescences 11 ; 14 ; 17 ; 7 ; 4 ; 6 . To date, all observations are consistent with the predictions of GR, with no statistically significant deviations reported 10 ; 5 ; 2 ; 16 . Within the post-Newtonian (PN) description of the inspiral, tidal interactions appear as high-order corrections to the GW phase. Their strength is quantified by the tidal Love numbers (TLNs) 57 ; 90 ; 30 , which measure the multipolar response of a body to an external tidal field. In vacuum GR, BHs have vanishing TLNs 29 ; 64 ; 38 ; 27 ; 43 ; 41 ; 70 ; 52 , reflecting the fact that their horizons cannot sustain static tidal deformations. A robust measurement of nonzero TLNs would therefore indicate physics beyond vacuum GR, such as modified gravity, exotic compact objects (ECOs), or the presence of matter surrounding the binary 54 ; 40 ; 77 ; 74 ; 39 ; 45 ; 84 ; 37 ; 51 . Environmental effects provide one possible mechanism for inducing non-zero TLNs. For example, accretion disks, boson clouds, or dark-matter halos can imprint tidal signatures on the waveform 26 ; 54 ; 32 ; 35 ; 37 ; 36 ; 66 ; 50 ; 82 . These effects grow stronger for denser environments and may also appear at other PN orders or during the ringdown phase 25 ; 24 ; 20 ; 33 ; 69 ; 20 ; 78 ; 28 ; 71 . Neglecting such imprints can bias the recovered astrophysical parameters 33 ; 49 . Previous searches for TLNs in BBH mergers using LVK data yielded only weak constraints, due to the limited signal strength and the fact that TLNs enter the GW phase at high PN order. The first dedicated studies from Refs. 76 ; 42 found no evidence for nonzero TLNs. On 14 January 2025, during the second part of the O4 observing run (O4b), a signal was observed in the LIGO Hanford and LIGO Livingston interferometers and designated as GW250114 3 ; 1 . This event shares several properties with GW150914 but was detected with a significantly higher signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), of approximately 80, thanks to an improved detector sensitivity 34 ; 85 . The enhanced SNR allows a more detailed characterization of the source. Indeed, GW250114 has already been used to confirm Hawking’s area theorem 3 and to place the strongest constraints on GR deviations from a single GW event to date 1 . The high SNR is particularly beneficial for probing high-PN corrections in the inspiral, where tidal effects enter. While Ref. 1 performed PN deviation tests, their analysis extended only to 3.5PN and, therefore, could not access TLN contributions. In this Letter , we use data from GW250114 to place the most stringent upper limits to date on the TLNs of BHs. Throughout this work we use geometrical units ( G=c=1 ). Methods – In the adiabatic limit, an external tidal field \mathcal{E}_{ij} induces a quadrupole moment Q_{ij} in a compact object given by 57 ; 62 ; 29 ; 61 Q_{ij}=-\Lambda m^{5}\mathcal{E}_{ij},\qquad\Lambda=\frac{2}{3}k_{2}, (1) where \Lambda is the dimensionless tidal deformability, m is the mass of the object, and k_{2} the quadrupolar ( l=2 ) tidal Love number. We adopt the convention of Ref. 38 , where the object’s compactness is absorbed into the definition of k_{2} , in contrast to other conventions where it appears explicitly. The value of k_{2} depends on the internal structure of the object. For neutron stars, k_{2}\sim 210 , although its exact value depends on the equation of state 29 ; 46 ; 93 ; 21 ; 79 ; 62 . For exotic compact objects such as boson stars or wormholes k_{2} can span several orders of magnitude 38 ; 83 ; 31 ; 60 ; 55 ; 65 . Tidal deformabilities imprint a distinct effect on the gravitational-wave phase, entering at high post-Newtonian order, starting at 5PN and 6PN, where they contribute an additional phase term 57 ; 90 \delta\psi_{\mathrm{tidal}}=-\frac{3}{128\eta}\left[\frac{32}{9}\tilde{\Lambda}\,v^{5}+\frac{3115}{64}\tilde{\Lambda}\,v^{6}\right.-\\ \left.\frac{6595}{364}\delta\tilde{\Lambda}\sqrt{1-4\eta}\,v^{6}\right], (2) where v=(\pi Mf)^{1/3} , f is the GW frequency, M=m_{1}+m_{2} the total mass, and \eta=m_{1}m_{2}/M^{2} the symmetric mass ratio, \tilde{\Lambda}=\frac{8}{13}\Big[(1+7\eta-31\eta^{2})(\Lambda_{1}+\Lambda_{2})\\ +\sqrt{1-4\eta}\,(1+9\eta-11\eta^{2})(\Lambda_{1}-\Lambda_{2})\Big], (3) and \delta\tilde{\Lambda}=\frac{1}{2}\Bigg[\sqrt{1-4\eta}\left(1-\frac{13272}{1319}\eta+\frac{8944}{1319}\eta^{2}\right)(\Lambda_{1}+\Lambda_{2})\\ +\left(1-\frac{15910}{1319}\eta+\frac{32850}{1319}\eta^{2}+\frac{3380}{1319}\eta^{3}\right)(\Lambda_{1}-\Lambda_{2})\Bigg]. (4) These expressions account only for the electric TLNs associated with the mass quadrupole in Eq. ( 1 ). We neglect the magnetic TLNs, which correspond to current multipoles 18 ; 38 , as well as any higher-order electric multipoles. At the waveform level, we treat (\Lambda_{1},\Lambda_{2}) as additional intrinsic parameters. We incorporate the tidal phase correction into the phenomenological inspiral–merger–ringdown waveform IMRPhenomPv2 63 ; 68 ; 59 . The waveform is modified by adding two generic absolute dephasing corrections to the inspiral phase, \psi^{\rm tidal}(f)=\psi^{\rm vac}(f)+\sum_{j\in\{10,12\}}\frac{3}{128\eta}\,\delta\psi_{j}\,v^{\,j-5}\,. (5) The coefficients \delta\psi_{j} are obtained by matching this parameterized form to Eq. ( 2 ). This approach follows the model-agnostic framework of parameterized tests of GR 19 ; 81 ; 72 ; 75 , widely used to search for deviations at specific PN orders 10 ; 16 ; 48 ; 33 ; 12 ; 13 ; 15 . and we implement this dephasing by modifying the standard LALSuite library 92 ; 73 . Although exotic physics or environmental effects could imprint deviations also in the post-inspiral regime, previous analysis have shown that the remnant is consistent with a Kerr BH 3 ; 1 . We therefore focus our search on the inspiral phase, where tidal effects are well-modeled within the PN framework, and leave the merger–ringdown portion of the waveform unchanged. We analyze the cleaned, calibrated strain data from LIGO Hanford and Livingston, centered on the GPS trigger time t_{0}=1420878141 s and processed following Ref. 3 . For each detector, we select a segment spanning 6 s before to 2 s after the trigger,

Read the complete text