On extremal black holes
Chiara Coviello, Ruth Gregory · 2025
Read On extremal black holes by Chiara Coviello, Ruth Gregory (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01898.txt.
Introduction
Extremal black holes sit at the edge of what physics allows, carrying the largest charge or spin possible for their mass. Chiara Coviello and Ruth Gregory take a fresh look in 2025 at whether such objects could really exist within ordinary, non-supersymmetric low-energy physics.
A charged black hole can shed its charge by creating particle pairs, a process called Schwinger discharge. By including prefactors and volume effects that earlier estimates skipped, the authors show this discharge in charge-neutral surroundings is far more efficient than commonly assumed. That efficiency tightens the case about which extremal black holes nature could actually sustain.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chiara Coviello, Ruth Gregory |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01898
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On extremal black holes Chiara Coviello, Ruth Gregory Abstract We take a fresh look at the viability of physically realistic extremal black holes within our (non-supersymmetric) low energy physics. By incorporating prefactors and volume effects, we show that Schwinger discharge in charge neutral environments is far more efficient than commonly assumed. Using ionization estimates for neutral hydrogen, we obtain a new and robust lower bound on the mass of an extremal electrically charged black hole, exceeding 10 14 M ⊙ 10^{14}M_{\odot} . For magnetic black holes, we compute the Lee-Nair-Weinberg instability and revisit early universe pair creation rates, including singular instantons that substantially enhance production, to demonstrate that the extreme charges required for stability are cosmologically implausible. Finally, we suggest that an extremal Kerr black hole could shed angular momentum via superradiant scattering from the stochastic gravitational wave background. Taken together, our results provide a unified picture that extremal black holes of any type are unlikely to persist in our universe. I Introduction Extremal black holes remain among the most perplexing solutions in classical general relativity. They often sit at the boundary between naked singularities and well-behaved spacetimes, challenge our understanding of black hole thermodynamics, and yet we do not even know if they exist beyond our mathematical expressions. In these objects, inner and outer horizons coincide, and they reach the maximum charge/angular momentum allowed for a black hole. Their vanishing Hawking temperature suggests a connection to the ill-understood third law of black hole thermodynamics, whereas their finite area raises puzzles with the conventional interpretation of entropy as a counting of microstates. It is precisely their unique thermodynamic character, as well as their threshold nature in terms of cosmic censorship that makes them so compelling a study. In a recent essay, Dafermos Dafermos 2025 reflects on these aspects of extremality, both discussing the historical development of our understanding as well as how and why that understanding was incomplete. The third law of black hole thermodynamics, as conjectured in Bardeen et al. 1973 , simply asserted that it should be impossible to reduce the surface gravity of a black hole to zero in a finite sequence of operations – such a law would not only keep the thermodynamical analogy for black holes intact, but also would ensure that one could not, in a finite set of steps, push a black hole beyond extremality, rendering it a naked singularity. In 1986, Israel Israel 1986 , provided a definitive formulation of this third law, then presented a proof that there was no continuous process in which the black hole could be rendered extremal while maintaining the weak energy condition. However, the results of Sorce and Wald Sorce and Wald 2017 , while focused on proving that no gedanken experiment can succeed in overcharging or overspinning a Kerr-Newman black hole,suggest that an extremal black hole can be reached from a near-extremal one via carefully tuned perturbations, assuming only the null energy condition. Indeed recently, Kehle and Unger Kehle and Unger 2025 have shown how to form an extremal Reissner-Nordström black hole through gravitational collapse in Einstein-Maxwell-charged scalar field theory – we refer the reader to Dafermos 2025 for a comprehensive yet concise critical evaluation of these results and how Israel’s original proof is evaded. Beyond their thermodynamic peculiarities, extremal black holes play a key role in fundamental high-energy physics. They often emerge as supersymmetric gravitational solutions in string theory Gibbons and Hull 1982 ; Horowitz and Strominger 1991 . Indeed, a recent tantalising result of Brown et al. Brown et al. 2024 explores the partition function of near extremal black holes and, via an exact computation in JT gravity, argue that as one approaches extremality, quantum gravitational effects strongly modify the partition function, suppressing the entropy. This would appear to resolve the puzzle of an extremal black hole having finite area yet being at zero temperature that was debated some years ago in the literature (see e.g. Hawking et al. 1995 ; Ghosh and Mitra 1997 ). The notion that an extremal, or near extremal, black hole should receive strong quantum corrections then raises the question of whether these modifications could be observable, and indeed could provide a clear signal of these corrections Emparan 2025 ; Emparan and Trezzi 2025 – a tantalising prospect indeed! The discussion of Dafermos (and indeed many explorations of over-charging or spinning black holes such as Wald 1974 ; Hubeny 1999 ; Sorce and Wald 2017 ) all treat the black hole in splendid isolation – the spacetime is determined by classical general relativity with test particles or Maxwell fields. In our universe however, black holes are not isolated systems, therefore we critically re-examine the question: can extremal black holes exist in our universe? This is a crucial question, as the answer determines whether such geometries can serve as a potential testing ground for quantum gravity and black hole thermodynamics, or whether extremality is inherently unreachable, with black holes naturally evolving away from it, rendering these spacetimes inaccessible and ultimately unobservable. The possibility of long-lived electrically charged black holes is often dismissed on the grounds that the Coulomb force vastly exceeds gravity, implying that charged particles in any surrounding plasma would rapidly neutralize the black hole Eardley and Press 1975 . Here we consider the viability of physically realistic charged extremal black holes immersed in a neutral environment (the QED vacuum and neutral hydrogen). We first revisit the Gibbons Gibbons 1975 Schwinger discharge process, re-evaluating the probability of discharge including 1-loop effects and a proper consideration of the probability of discharge. We then derive an even stronger constraint from the ionization of matter in the local environment. In both cases, the impact of the prefactor and volume in which electric discharge occurs is extremely significant. We then evaluate the likelihood of extremal magnetic black holes, that might be expected to be stable to any pair production decay, computing the details of the linear instability first argued by Lee, Nair and Weinberg Lee et al. 1992a . We also revisit arguments on black hole creation during inflation, noting a broader range of instantons than previously considered. We conclude with remarks on Kerr extremality. A remark on units Throughout our discussion, we will, in the main, use natural units as is standard convention in GR literature, i.e. \hbar=c=4\pi\epsilon_{0}=1 . We will also use the standard (as opposed to reduced) definitions of Planck units, setting G=1 . However when discussing the details of physical processes, where scales and numerical estimates are relevant, we restore these constants in the presentation of results, using SI units. II Electrically charged extremal black holes We first discuss the feasibility of an extremal electrically charged black hole. A classic result by Gibbons Gibbons 1975 calculated how the electrostatic field of an electrically charged black hole can induce Schwinger pair production, leading to charge depletion. The essence of this effect is that the energy of an electric field is proportional to |{\bf E}|^{2} , thus the stronger the electric field, the greater the drop in energy if the field discharges an amount \delta{\bf E} . Meanwhile, to create an electron/positron pair, we require (at minimum) a rest mass energy of 2m_{e}c^{2} . An estimate of the drop