AI-Driven Cybersecurity Testbed for Nuclear Infrastructure: Comprehensive Evaluation Using METL Operational Data

Benjamin Blakely, Yeni Li, Akshay Dave, Derek Kultgen, and Rick Vilim · 2025

Read AI-Driven Cybersecurity Testbed for Nuclear Infrastructure: Comprehensive Evaluation Using METL Operational Data by Benjamin Blakely, Yeni Li, Akshay Dave, Derek Kultgen, and Rick Vilim (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01727.txt.

Introduction

Benjamin Blakely and co-authors evaluate AI cybersecurity for nuclear infrastructure on real plant data. Advanced reactors face attackers who exploit cyber-physical links. They can twist control systems while dodging classic IT guards. Testbeds must reflect that real risk.

Their testbed uses operational data from Argonne's engineering test loop. AI methods are scored on that live-like data. Scores show which detectors catch stealthy attacks. Nuclear sites need that proof before any AI guard can be trusted near reactor controls. Operational data keeps the test honest, since lab-made attacks often miss the noise and quirks of a working test loop's traffic.

Catalog record

CREATORBenjamin Blakely, Yeni Li, Akshay Dave, Derek Kultgen, and Rick Vilim
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01727

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI-Driven Cybersecurity Testbed for Nuclear Infrastructure: Comprehensive Evaluation Using METL Operational Data Benjamin Blakely, Yeni Li, Akshay Dave, Derek Kultgen, and Rick Vilim Abstract Advanced nuclear reactor systems face increasing cybersecurity threats as sophisticated attackers exploit cyber-physical interfaces to manipulate control systems while evading traditional IT security measures. This research presents a comprehensive evaluation of artificial intelligence approaches for cybersecurity protection in nuclear infrastructure, using Argonne National Laboratory’s Mechanisms Engineering Test Loop (METL) as an experimental platform. We developed a systematic evaluation framework encompassing four machine learning detection paradigms: Change Point Detection, LSTM-based Anomaly Detection, Dependency Violation analysis, and Autoencoder reconstruction methods. Our comprehensive attack taxonomy includes 15 distinct scenarios targeting reactor control systems, each implemented across five severity tiers to evaluate detection performance under varying attack intensities. The experimental evaluation encompassed 300 rigorous experiments using realistic METL operational data. Change Point Detection emerged as the leading approach with mean AUC performance of 0.785, followed by LSTM Anomaly Detection (0.636), Dependency Violation (0.621), and Autoencoder methods (0.580). Attack detectability varied significantly, with multi-site coordinated attacks proving most detectable (AUC = 0.739) while precision trust decay attacks presented the greatest detection challenge (AUC = 0.592). This work delivers practical performance benchmarks and reference architecture that advance AI-based cybersecurity capabilities for critical nuclear infrastructure, providing essential foundations for operational deployment and enhanced threat response in cyber-physical systems. 1 Introduction Modern nuclear facilities face escalating cybersecurity challenges as operational technology (OT) and information technology (IT) systems become increasingly interconnected. Unlike traditional IT security threats, cyber attacks targeting nuclear infrastructure can manipulate physical processes through sensor spoofing, control system interference, and data integrity compromises that evade conventional network-based detection methods. The complexity of these threats demands novel approaches that leverage both artificial intelligence capabilities and deep understanding of nuclear system physics. Historical incidents in critical infrastructure have demonstrated the vulnerability of industrial control systems to sophisticated adversaries capable of leveraging cyber-physical attack vectors. The 2010 Stuxnet attack on Iranian nuclear facilities exemplified how malware could target programmable logic controllers to cause physical damage while remaining undetected for extended periods. Subsequent attacks on power grids, water treatment facilities, and manufacturing systems have highlighted the urgent need for robust, AI-driven detection capabilities specifically designed for cyber-physical environments. Current cybersecurity approaches in nuclear facilities rely primarily on network perimeter defenses, signature-based detection, and air-gapped architectures. However, these traditional methods prove insufficient against advanced persistent threats that exploit legitimate system access, utilize zero-day vulnerabilities, or employ living-off-the-land techniques. The integration of machine learning for anomaly detection in nuclear systems presents both significant opportunities and unique challenges, requiring careful consideration of safety implications, regulatory requirements, and operational constraints. Our research addresses this critical gap by developing and systematically evaluating AI-driven cybersecurity approaches using the Mechanisms Engineering Test Loop (METL) at Argonne National Laboratory as a realistic experimental platform [ 1 ] . Building upon previous work in nuclear anomaly detection [ 2 , 5 ] and cyber-physical security [ 3 ] , this study provides the first comprehensive, multi-paradigm evaluation of machine learning detection capabilities under realistic nuclear operational conditions. The key contributions of this work include: (1) a systematic evaluation framework for AI-based cybersecurity in nuclear environments, (2) comprehensive performance benchmarks across four detection paradigms and twelve attack scenarios, (3) quantitative analysis of attack detectability patterns and deployment implications, and (4) practical guidance for operational implementation in advanced reactor systems. This research establishes essential foundations for evidence-based cybersecurity decision-making in critical nuclear infrastructure. 2 Methodology 2.1 Research Environment The Mechanisms Engineering Test Loop (METL) at Argonne National Laboratory is an experimental facility designed to replicate key operational characteristics of sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) while providing a realistic operational environment absent of radiological components. METL features integrated test vessels operating at temperatures up to 1,200 degrees F, electromagnetic pumps, and comprehensive instrumentation and control (I&C) systems including Emerson/NI cRIO devices and industrial controllers. This architecture provides authentic thermal-hydraulic conditions and sensor networks for developing AI-driven anomaly detection and cyber-physical security models. METL’s segmented operational technology (OT) and information technology (IT) networks, combined with detailed temperature profiles, flow measurements, and sodium handling procedures, enable realistic simulation of cyber attack scenarios targeting critical reactor operations. The METL sensor architecture captures the complex interdependencies and correlation patterns essential for validating AI-based detection methods under realistic operational conditions. Our experiments utilized 214 sensors and setpoints selected from 11,899 total data points for cybersecurity evaluation, providing comprehensive coverage of thermal-hydraulic parameters, electromagnetic pump operations, and cold trap purification system dynamics. 2.2 Data Architecture and Processing Pipeline The experimental framework establishes a comprehensive cybersecurity testbed that spans the complete data lifecycle from operational sensor collection through machine learning evaluation. This testbed architecture enables systematic analysis of attack detection capabilities under realistic conditions while maintaining complete experimental control and reproducibility. The pipeline consists of four integrated stages: operational data collection from METL facility systems, attack scenario injection through configurable transformation engines, multi-paradigm detection analysis, and statistical evaluation with confidence assessment. Data was collected from the METL facility via a REST API that provides instantaneous values for all or a subset of values when queried. Our fetching script was configured to normally pull data at 1 minute intervals, but when a particular damper was opened (as indicated by a setpoint value), we assumed maintenance was ongoing and switched to a 1Hz sampling rate. This approach captured more dynamic sensor activity during maintenance periods compared to steady state periods. We captured this data over several months, and ultimately selected a 30-day period where we had the most consistent data collection - other periods had larger gaps due to system outages. The ARSS Data Proxy system architecture implements a transformation engine capable of real-time and offline data manipulation across multiple attack vectors simultaneously. The system utilizes Apache Parquet columnar storage format for efficient data processing, enabling high-performance analytics across the 214-sensor dataset while maintaining temporal fidelity essential for time-series analysis. Data ingestion pipelines support both streaming (MQTT-based) and batch processing modes. For the purposes of this analysis, batch processing was used as only offline analysis was needed and the streaming engine could not process our selected transformations in real-time. To prepare sensor and setpoint data for machine learning analysis, standardized preprocessing algorithms were applied across all experimental conditions. The preprocessing pipeline addressed three primary challenges: temporal alignment across heterogeneous sensor networks and feature standardization for cross-paradigm evaluation. Data normalization employed min-max scaling to preserve the original data distribution characteristics while ensuring numerical stability across machine learning algorithms. Each sensor signal was independently scaled to the range [0,1] based on historical operational bounds observed during the 30-day baseline period. This approach maintained the relative magnitude relationships between different sensor types while preventing numerical overflow in gradient-based optimization algorithms. Feature engineering focused on temporal alignment and sampling rate harmonization across the heterogeneous sensor network. Raw sensor data collected at varying frequencies (1 Hz during maintenance, 1-minute intervals during steady-state) was resampled to a uniform 30-second interval using linear interpolation. 1/60 Hz data was forward filled as necessary to meet the 1/30 Hz rate. This downsampling strategy balanced computational efficiency with temporal resolution requirements for attack signature detection while maintaining sufficient granularity for machine learning analysis. 2.3 Data Perturbation Techniques Our research

Read the complete text