Predicted white-light solar flare emission from the F-CHROMA grid of models
S. Ornig ,, M. Carlsson , · 2025
Read Predicted white-light solar flare emission from the F-CHROMA grid of models by S. Ornig ,, M. Carlsson , (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01717.txt.
Introduction
Ornig and Carlsson predict white-light flare emission from a grid of models. Much of a solar flare's energy may leave as continuum light. White light can be seen from the ground, which makes it prized. Its prevalence in flares is still not settled.
The F-CHROMA grid models flares driven by electron beams alone. The pair ask which runs emit white light and why. Traits that switch emission on or off are mapped. Ground observers can then use white-light rates to infer beam traits in real flares. Ground-based white-light patrols run nightly, so model rates translate at once into how many flares those patrols should log each season.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Ornig ,, M. Carlsson , |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01717
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Predicted white-light solar flare emission from the F-CHROMA grid of models S. Ornig ,, M. Carlsson , Abstract Context. Much of a solar flare’s energy is thought to be released in the continuum. The optical continuum (white light) is of special interest due to the ability to observe it from the ground. Aims. We aim to investigate the prevalence of white-light (WL) emissions in simulations of purely electron beam-driven solar flares, what determines the occurrence of these enhancements, and the underlying causes. Methods. We utilized the F-CHROMA grid of flare simulations created using the radiative hydrodynamics code RADYN . We probed the spectral index, total energy, and low-energy cutoff to draw conclusions about their relationships to the white-light intensity. Furthermore, we calculated the 6684 Å continuum intensities, the Balmer, and the Paschen ratios. Finally, we analyzed two particular cases, one with high 6684 Å intensity and one with a large Balmer ratio, to determine the dominant mechanisms in these simulations. Results. 33 of the 84 flares included in the F-CHROMA grid show white-light intensity enhancements that exceed 0.1% relative to the pre-flare level. We conclude that, with the parameters presented in the F-CHROMA grid, purely electron beam-driven simulations of solar flares are not able to reproduce observed WL enhancements, as the maximum enhancements in the grid are below 4%, which is significantly lower than observational values. The total energy (which is correlated with the maximum beam flux) is the main factor for deciding whether excess white-light emissions will be detectable or not. There is a linear relationship between the Balmer (and Paschen) ratio and the relative continuum increase. Both case studies show that during the time of maximum WL excess, hydrogen ionization and subsequent recombination in an optically thin medium is the dominant mechanism for WL continuum emission enhancements in these electron beam-driven atmospheres. Increased H - emission in the photosphere as a result of radiative backwarming becomes dominant during the declining phase of WL emissions in both case studies. We confirm the inability to reproduce the characteristics of type II WL flares, namely the appearance of photospheric continuum enhancements without prior chromospheric emission increases and the lack of a clear Balmer jump, with the F-CHROMA grid. 1 Introduction Flares are sudden local brightenings that appear throughout the electromagnetic (EM) spectrum over a timespan of minutes to hours ( 3 ) . They can accelerate particles to high energies, heat the ambient plasma, and be accompanied by coronal mass ejections ( 47 ) . To explain the observations, the so-called CSHKP model (or Standard Flare Model; named after 11 , 50 , 24 , 30 ) was developed. A large magnetic loop rises up to coronal heights due to an instability in the system and gets pinched at its legs. Where the anti-parallel magnetic field lines meet, magnetic reconnection sets in and releases the built-up energy. Charged particles (electrons and ions) are accelerated and move along the magnetic loop toward the chromosphere. There, the density is high enough that the energetic particles can lose their energy through Coulomb collisions, thereby heating the ambient plasma. Since the plasma pressure is dependent on the temperature, the heated plasma expands and fills the magnetic loop in a process known as chromospheric evaporation ( 21 ) . Along the way, it emits radiation in the soft X-ray (SXR) and extreme ultraviolet (EUV) parts of the EM spectrum ( 3 ) . The first observations of solar flares were conducted in the optical part of the EM spectrum ( 12 ) . Here, especially the Balmer and Ca II K lines have become increasingly popular ( 34 ) . However, spectral lines are not the only parts of the spectrum that contribute to optical emissions. The continuum has arguably received less attention due to the short duration and poor contrast of its intensities ( 25 ; 22 ) . It was postulated that emissions in the optical continuum, known as white-light (WL) emissions, not only occur in certain conditions, but rather could be general features of flares ( 26 ) . In a statistical analysis, 52 found WL emission in half of a sample of 100 M- and X-class flares observed by Hinode/SOT. Another, more recent study by 4 randomly selected a set of flares from the flare list in 36 (and added 6 X-class flares on their own). Using a revised method of identification applied to SDO/HMI continuum observations, they found WL emission in 30% of the 30 C-class flares they studied, with an even higher proportion for M- and X-class flares. Similar values have been reported by 48 using observations taken from space (by SDO/HMI) and the ground (by the Optical and Near-infrared Solar Eruption Tracer, ONSET), although the differentiation between C- and M-class flares was not considered. 13 report comparable percentages for M- and X-class flares, but lower ( \approx 10 % ) for C-class events; results that match those for circular-ribbon flares in 49 . A concise summary of statistics on WL flare occurrences across several studies can be found in 13 . In WL flares, the optical continuum contains a significant portion of the total radiated energy and may even play the dominant role overall. 43 suggested that WL intensity enhancements may account for up to 90% of the total energy emitted from the flare region. This is supported by findings in Sun-as-a-star observations by 34 , who found that about two-thirds of the radiated flare energy is contained in WL. On the other hand, more recent statistical investigations found that the relative enhancement of the optical continuum at 360 nm during WL flares is less than 30% in most cases ( 27 ) , with a mean of approximately 19%. This seems to be strongly dependent on the resolution of the instrument, as 26 found enhancements of up to 300% in localized regions. As for the origin of WL emissions, the mechanisms are still poorly understood. The theories can be divided mainly into two categories ( 15 ) : The first, where the emission comes from regions that emit at the same wavelengths in the quiet Sun, i.e., the photosphere ( 28 ) , and the second, where the emission comes from higher up, i.e., the chromosphere. In the former, the energy needs to be transported to the photosphere by high-energy electron beams ( 19 ; 44 ) , Alfvén waves ( 45 ) or radiative backwarming ( 39 ; 40 ) . In the latter, WL emission is characterized by optically thin recombination radiation, mainly in hydrogen continua ( 17 ) . A more detailed discussion of possible WL emission mechanisms can be found in 41 . Following these two theories, WL flares can then be broadly classified into two groups depending on their spectral properties, as well as the relation between intensity enhancements of the WL and that of hard X-rays (HXR) or microwaves ( 38 ) . Type I WL flare spectra show a Balmer jump and strong Balmer line intensities. WL emission of type I WL flares generally coincides in time with HXR or microwave enhancements ( 20 ; 35 ) , and is believed to be caused by hydrogen recombination in the chromosphere (